Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

15k loan for surgery

91 replies

HelpMeWithMyHip · 11/10/2021 12:53

Hi all

I have name changed for this as it is really outing.

More of a what would you do really. I suffer terrible RA. I am only 31 and already have my right hip replaced. I am now on list for my other hip, but due to covid this is a long time coming and I can now hardly walk (I am having both knees, shoulder and elbow replaced too as I am on the list for them but it's my hip that is the main issue with my mobility). I have been told the wait is 'ages' by the consultant. He thinks that I'll be on the NHS waiting list for 52 weeks before they then put me on the list to have it done at the private hospital , but at a cost to the NHS. This is what happened with my first hip but the waiting time was not half as long as it was almost 4 years ago. My dilemma is, should I get a 15k loan and go private? The waiting time then would be under a month and my mobility would be significantly improved to a life changing level.

There are cons.. obviously the 270 quid a month payback for the next 5 years is a big burden to bear. WWYD and AIBU to consider this.

Thanks if you've read this far.

OP posts:
ArranMumma · 11/10/2021 17:40

I think you should do it. You also might be eligible for charitable grants to pay it back - maybe an organisation like the Elizabeth Finn fund? Or you could do some fund raising yourself - I’m sure friends and family would be happy to contribute - even if you only raised £500 that’s better than nothing! X

Kissmycousinkate · 11/10/2021 17:38

Surely a further advance on your mortgage would nit be affected by you been tied in, im sure you could still borrow more, worth a check

Florence282 · 11/10/2021 17:37

HelpMeWithMyHip you need to really lay it on think when you speak to your consultant, make sure you're very clear about how desperate you are and particularly about how it's affecting your mental health.

orangejuicer · 11/10/2021 17:36

Not sure of your circumstances but could the surgery actually help you in terms of a job/better job so you might be more comfortable financially?

It sounds like you have very little quality of life at the moment OP but only you can decide.

HelpMeWithMyHip · 11/10/2021 17:32

@Zombiemum1946

If you have an existing mortgage you may be able to get a cheaper loan in terms of remortgage. You can extend the payment period of your mortgage therefore bringing down the monthly cost. We're doing this for work on the house. Even on a fixed deal this is possible. Talk to your mortgage provider and see what you can arrange.
I might call them now. Or try to. See what that say
OP posts:
HelpMeWithMyHip · 11/10/2021 17:31

@Doodar

Are you claiming everything you're entitled to OP? Sorry you're going through this xx
I am. Well I think so. I get PIP. I think we could possibly claim for I think it's attendance allowance is it? As DP or my mum have to do a lot for me.
OP posts:
Zombiemum1946 · 11/10/2021 17:28

If you have an existing mortgage you may be able to get a cheaper loan in terms of remortgage. You can extend the payment period of your mortgage therefore bringing down the monthly cost. We're doing this for work on the house. Even on a fixed deal this is possible. Talk to your mortgage provider and see what you can arrange.

Doodar · 11/10/2021 17:22

Are you claiming everything you're entitled to OP? Sorry you're going through this xx

HelpMeWithMyHip · 11/10/2021 17:07

@MatildaTheCat

I’m not sure if it’s still possible to request to go to any hospital but I saw an orthopaedic surgeon recently about a hip issue and he said the waiting list at our local (excellent) orthopaedic centre was around four months. So it might be worth calling around a bit.

However I’d take the loan if that’s not an option. Could family help at all? Even if it’s a loan the pressure on repayments wouldn’t be so scary.

That is a good shout. I don't know if you are allowed to transfer from NHS hospital to another. But it will be a question I can ask if I get a call back tomorrow.
OP posts:
HelpMeWithMyHip · 11/10/2021 17:06

@TrainforSpeed

I could cry for the fact that this is necessary, but yes, I'd do it.

I have at various times had jobs where health insurance was on offer but I've never taken it. "My health's not more important than anyone else's" and of course it still isn't, but stories like this have me seriously considering buying insurance for the first time (I no longer have that kind of job)

I'm automatically enrolled in a basic insurance plan at work and to take out the full package it is a significant cost, plus this is pre existing so they wouldn't touch me anyway sadly
OP posts:
HelpMeWithMyHip · 11/10/2021 17:05

@MissConductUS

Go for it. The cost and the interest rate are very reasonable and the RA will only get worse as you wait.

A bit off-topic, but are you on medication to slow the progression of the RA?

Yes I am on biologics. None seem to have controlled it very well. It's quite aggressive. They think as I age it will slow down but by that point I'll be bionic anyway!
OP posts:
HelpMeWithMyHip · 11/10/2021 17:04

@Xenia

3.% interest rate is more than a 1.44% house mortgage rate - if you have equity in your house it may be cheaper to remortgage the house. Have you tried publicity and your MP and that kind of thing in case there is some way to pressure them? Could you look at having it abroad for much less cost?
We are stuck in the mortgage for another 2 years so I am unsure what the pay out would be on that. I have considered go fund me. But I don't think I could do it. I'd feel like I owed people back. I my MP is a bit shit but that too is an option. I might find out his email now. Abroad, again we could look into it. I'd need to get a passport though as I haven't travelled abroad since 2009! Would insurance be really high though getting me back? And if complications did come about I think I'd prefer to be somewhere where I could access the NHS.
OP posts:
MatildaTheCat · 11/10/2021 16:57

I’m not sure if it’s still possible to request to go to any hospital but I saw an orthopaedic surgeon recently about a hip issue and he said the waiting list at our local (excellent) orthopaedic centre was around four months. So it might be worth calling around a bit.

However I’d take the loan if that’s not an option. Could family help at all? Even if it’s a loan the pressure on repayments wouldn’t be so scary.

MissConductUS · 11/10/2021 16:53

Go for it. The cost and the interest rate are very reasonable and the RA will only get worse as you wait.

A bit off-topic, but are you on medication to slow the progression of the RA?

Xenia · 11/10/2021 16:51

3.% interest rate is more than a 1.44% house mortgage rate - if you have equity in your house it may be cheaper to remortgage the house. Have you tried publicity and your MP and that kind of thing in case there is some way to pressure them? Could you look at having it abroad for much less cost?

TrainforSpeed · 11/10/2021 16:46

I could cry for the fact that this is necessary, but yes, I'd do it.

I have at various times had jobs where health insurance was on offer but I've never taken it. "My health's not more important than anyone else's" and of course it still isn't, but stories like this have me seriously considering buying insurance for the first time (I no longer have that kind of job)

HelpMeWithMyHip · 11/10/2021 16:44

So sorry for the late response. I've been in work meetings this afternoon.

Some of these comments have moved me to tears. Thank you all so much

I am going to take some of the advice. I have just left a message with my RA consultants secretary asking if he could give me a call. Just to see if he could do anything to bump me up the list. The problem I have with waiting for the NHS on top of the pain is that I am a lot further along in the process for one of my knees and I don't think I'd be able to go ahead with that without having my hip done first as my leg wouldn't be able to support me. So unless he could do something to enable me to get my hip done first I'd have to go to the back of the list with my knee as well and I don't want that either.

I will see what he says though. It's just such a hard decision to make. One I really don't think I should have to make.

Work are really understanding and have said today I can work at home for as long as I need. So complications shouldn't be a problem as I think I'd be able to work from home.

Thank you all so much. And I am sorry to see so many in the same situation

I just want my mobility back just to be able to enjoy my life again. Especially while my kids are still young enough to need me

OP posts:
user1471428785 · 11/10/2021 16:42

I have had only a fraction of your pain in my hip but worry its RA starting. In your shoes in constant pain and affecting your mental health I definitely would. I had a terrible slipped disc just after my daughter was born and was in so much pain, I could barely hold her - a newborn- or walk or sit. NHS said I'd need to wait appprox a year for an operation!! So went private and it was done 2 weeks later. Yes it was a big financial hit but I had no quality of life and it sounds like that's you. Just do it, you've likely forgotten what its like not to be in pain and the sheer relief will be worth the money. Good luck

ZealAndArdour · 11/10/2021 16:30

Just do it!

You will never regret investing in your health and well-being.

Noway100 · 11/10/2021 16:25

@trevthecat

I think if you can pay for it then definitely do it. Life is too short to suffer
This.
SueSaid · 11/10/2021 16:15

@Florence282

I work at an Orthopaedic Hospital. Does your consultant know the toll this is taking on your mental health? Does your gp even? In our department we had a patient, young lad, who was very depressed, suicidal over the pain and limits to his life. His gp wrote to the consultant and he got bumped right up the list. Sometimes you have to fight for it rather than sit back quietly and wait your turn. While everyone on these waiting lists are in pain and struggling, some are struggling more so than others so just make sure you've been heard before you take on the £15k debt.
It seems incredible that it needs pointing out, surely a 31 yr old working fulltime with a mortgage takes precedence over say, a 70yr old who may be retired and yes in pain but doesn't have to go and work 40 hrs a week.

Your consultant needs a bomb up his arse op.

Florence282 · 11/10/2021 16:06

I work at an Orthopaedic Hospital. Does your consultant know the toll this is taking on your mental health? Does your gp even? In our department we had a patient, young lad, who was very depressed, suicidal over the pain and limits to his life. His gp wrote to the consultant and he got bumped right up the list. Sometimes you have to fight for it rather than sit back quietly and wait your turn. While everyone on these waiting lists are in pain and struggling, some are struggling more so than others so just make sure you've been heard before you take on the £15k debt.

KatieB55 · 11/10/2021 15:42

There was a Panorama programme on this a few weeks ago. People used 'go fund me' and raised enough for their surgery (some went abroad). It makes me really cross that you need to pay for your treatment - you are so young and it is badly needed. Good luck OP.

guestusername · 11/10/2021 15:31

It sucks to have such reduced mobility. Your GP can and should write to your NHS consultant asking for your surgery to be expedited. The winter is fast approaching and the cold weather won’t help your situation.

Part of Nuffield Health’s joint replacement packages come with follow up appointments and x-rays included within the fee. Please do shop around though. I wish you the best of luck

SueSaid · 11/10/2021 15:04

This is shocking op. Yes anyone who needs a hip replacement will be in severe pain with limited mobility but you are so young! Surely young RA sufferers should take priority over older people with OA who may well be retired and able to cope better with reduced mobility.

I would write to your MP and ask if there is anyway your case could be expedited.

Swipe left for the next trending thread