Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she ought to have let me have it?

835 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 11/10/2021 11:21

On my way home from town yesterday I popped into a charity shop for a browse and they had a lovely baby changing bag. I wanted to buy it but didn’t have the arm space for any more stuff and the woman who ran the shop said they couldn’t keep it for me, so I came back into town this morning to get it.
The charity shop still has a utterly daft one way system so it’s really cramped and today I had the pram. Ahead of me was a woman whose Mum (I presume) was standing next to the bags with a pram while she looked at other stuff. In front of them was someone in a wheelchair so I stood and waited until they could move so I could pick the bag up.
The woman then walks back over to her Mum, spots the bag and picks it up. I said “Oh, I was going to get that, I’ve come back into town for it.”

Now in her position, what I’d have done was said on, here you go, and handed it over. However she just shrugged and said “oh, sorry.” And took it.

AIBU to think that’s a dick move and she should have let me have it?

OP posts:
YouBelongHere · 11/10/2021 16:38

I'm a bit confused about the set-up - your arms were ladened down with bags, you desperately needed the loo, had back ache and had no money but still popped into the shop for a browse?

This reminded me of when I was queuing up at the canteen in college and the girls behind me were talking about a box of food one of them wanted and there was only one left. I was also queuing for that box so I picked it up and heard the two of them bitching about me literally behind my back. Should I really have let them have it just because I overheard that they wanted it?

I would've given you the bag but only because I wouldn't have wanted a confrontation - and then would've been miffed that you'd even asked for the rest of the day even if I didn't want the bloody bag!

TrollsAreSaddos · 11/10/2021 16:28

This is a great moral dilemma.

OP, I promise I’m a nice person and I’m definitely not a dick but I think there was nothing wrong with the woman not giving you the bag. You don’t know her situation and, for all you know, she may have been looking for a bag for ages and may be a more worthy recipient than you. Who knows?? It’s not nice that you are calling her a dick.

I’m guessing someone on this thread will be offering you a nice second hand bag soon enough though 😉

00100001 · 11/10/2021 16:25

@GreyhoundG1rl

But if I was you, I would have just said "excuse me" and reached over and grabbed the bag tbh. Oh, give over, you would not 😂
I meant instead of waiting around for them to move. I wasn't clear,sorry. :)
Franklyfrost · 11/10/2021 16:24

You went to a shop saw something, didn’t buy it, left and then someone else bought it. This is an outrage. What is the world coming to?

Malin52 · 11/10/2021 16:24

@slashlover

First come first served so fuck you, is a bit of a twatty attitude imo

So is, but I saw it first!

Ha! Exactly. Imagine a house purchase. Person 1 sees house, pretty sure they are going offer but needs to check finances so goes away to do so. Person 2 sees house and offer is accepted Person 1 bellows 'BUT I SAW IT FIRST! IVE COME HERE SPECIALLY TO BUY IT!,

This poster and the OP would believe it 'kind' for Person 2 to withdraw their offer on the strength of Person 1s demands. In reality we would all assume Person 1 to be entitled, self centred and totally unreasonable.

simitra · 11/10/2021 16:24

I can remember many years ago being at a book fair. I picked a book off the shelf and was about to buy it when another (male) customer snatched it out of my hand and said that he was about to buy it. I grabbed it back and told him that the etiquette on these occasions is that the person in whose hands it currently is has first dibs. If he had wanted the book then he should have picked it up. A row ensued and the dealer said she was not going to sell the book to either of us and put it under the counter.

Later on I passed the stand and the dealer said "Psst. If you still want the book you can have it. It was rude of him to snatch it but I didnt want to get caught in an argument."

So I got the book after all.

When an item is on display it is an "invitation to treat (or trade) " and the shopkeeper does not HAVE to sell it to anyone. However if I have the item in my hand I am considering a sale. Once I put it down I have decided not to buy and its up for grabs.

If I had wanted the bag I would have bought it, regardless if someone said they had returned/made a special journey for it. Its a tough old world out there and I buy and sell for a living.

00100001 · 11/10/2021 16:24

To clarify what I said

Is would have said excuse me and grabbed the bag INSTEAD OF waiting patiently for them to move. Not grab it from their hands!

Sorry I wasn't clear!

mumto2teenagers · 11/10/2021 16:12

YABU

First you said you offered to pay for it yesterday if they would keep it, then you said you didn't have the money to pay for it yesterday.

She got to it first, liked it and decided to buy it, therefore she is not being unreasonable at all not giving it to you.

Muchmorethan · 11/10/2021 16:12

@Cuddlyrottweiler

She was there first unfortunately. I don't understand how you didn't have the arm space for a bag? It's a bag, put your other stuff in it and put it on? Not that it matters now.
Exactly what l was going to say!!
Chartreuse45 · 11/10/2021 16:09

I think the reach over and grab meant "reach over the person blocking the aisle and get the bag BEFORE the woman picked it up". At least that was the only way it made sense to me, grabbing out of her hands in some kind of physical power struggle doesn't fit with the rest of the post.

diddl · 11/10/2021 16:08

Going into a charity shop when you can't afford/carry anything else=rookie mistake!

Frazzledmummy123 · 11/10/2021 16:07

@JamieNorthlife

I'm with you OP. I hate when this happens. I'm sure the woman did not want to buy it but because you said you wanted, she took it. I have seen this happening so many times. It's infuriating.

Don't worry about it you may find a better one soon.

So the woman bought the bag deliberately to spite her? Confused.
YourFinestPantaloons · 11/10/2021 16:06

@AngeloMysterioso

What if you had got there first, picked it up, and someone said "Oh I was going to get that, I saw it yesterday" would you have handed it over?

Honestly, yes. I’m not a dick nice like that.

Haha right-o
GreyhoundG1rl · 11/10/2021 16:06

I'm sure the woman did not want to buy it but because you said you wanted, she took it.
Absolutely, that's almost certainly why she bought it. Definitely. Wouldn't we all?

YourFinestPantaloons · 11/10/2021 16:05

@JamieNorthlife

I'm with you OP. I hate when this happens. I'm sure the woman did not want to buy it but because you said you wanted, she took it. I have seen this happening so many times. It's infuriating.

Don't worry about it you may find a better one soon.

Really Confused that exact situation with those malicious intentions?

You snooze you lose I'm afraid.

OP could have bought the bag but didn't

JudgeJ · 11/10/2021 16:04

@AngeloMysterioso

What if you had got there first, picked it up, and someone said "Oh I was going to get that, I saw it yesterday" would you have handed it over?

Honestly, yes. I’m not a dick nice like that.

Keep telling yourself that but beware, halos can cause terrible headaches.
Frazzledmummy123 · 11/10/2021 16:04

The charity shop should have probably kept it aside for you if you paid for it and a bit mean of them not to as they'd still have the money if you didn't go back for it.

However regards the girl, I think what happened was horrible and very disappointing given it was literally seconds before you got to it, but I don't think it was a dick move or she did anything wrong. It hadn't been reserved which was down to the charity shop refusing to reserve it for you, or you not taking it day before. If she had picked it up, it was hers and I know I wouldn't be handing it over to a random person who claimed they came back from yesterday for it.

JamieNorthlife · 11/10/2021 16:03

I'm with you OP. I hate when this happens. I'm sure the woman did not want to buy it but because you said you wanted, she took it.
I have seen this happening so many times. It's infuriating.

Don't worry about it you may find a better one soon.

JudgeJ · 11/10/2021 16:02

@itsgoodtobehome

Reminds me of toddler days when a child would abandon a toy, but when another picks it up they say: "I was playing with that a minute ago" so that gives them ownership rights
I was in Aldi when we were queuing down one aisle at the height of the pandemic and I walked down to the back of the queue. A minute or so later a woman poked me in the back 'Oi, there's a queue', she had been at the end of the aisle loading nappies into her trolley, about 15m from the back of the queue! I looked at the nappies, looked at her and simply said 'Of course you were in the queue deary', she looked most unhappy. Passive aggression everytime.
lynntheyresexpeople · 11/10/2021 16:02

It's weird as hell that you even attempted to try guilt her into giving you the bag - it's not her problem in the slightest. You are entirely unreasonable.

SunshineCake1 · 11/10/2021 15:58

I'm going to start trying this, wandering up to people in shops who have things I want and telling them I made a special trip to get it after seeing it the day before.

@slashlover. Why?Hmm.

DarlingFell · 11/10/2021 15:57

@AngeloMysterioso

Ok well I’ve gone from being unlucky at missing out on something that I really could have done with to rude, entitled, selfish, manipulative, calculated and god knows how many other personal attacks, so I’m going to leave this here now. I think my pride has taken enough of a beating for one day.
Aww OP don't take it to heart, AIBU is savage, you got away fairly lightly. Don't let a bunch of bored randomers ruin your day
GreyhoundG1rl · 11/10/2021 15:55

I assume the poster meant they would have said excuse me to the mother and picked it up from where it was displayed rather than waiting for her to move and thus giving the daughter the chance to spot it when she came back.
Ah yes, of course.
Well sure, I reckon that's what most people would have done, really. Shame op didn't think to.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 11/10/2021 15:51

@GreyhoundG1rl

But if I was you, I would have just said "excuse me" and reached over and grabbed the bag tbh. Oh, give over, you would not 😂
I assume the poster meant they would have said excuse me to the mother and picked it up from where it was displayed rather than waiting for her to move and thus giving the daughter the chance to spot it when she came back.

Op - I think the other customer was well within her rights in keeping the bag. You could have bought it the day before, even though you would have preferred to wait until your CB came in. You could have said excuse me to her mother and taken the bag then.

From the other customer's perspective, it quite likely appeared you were browsing and only developed an interest in the bag when she picked it up. Really, there was no reason at all that she should have given it to you unless she actually knew your circumstances (which she didn't) and decided your need was greater than hers.

Bluntness100 · 11/10/2021 15:47

@ModerateOven

OK, I work in a charity shop, and there was a lovely White Stuff top I had my eye on. We're not allowed to buy anything until it's been on the shop floor 48 hours, so I had to stand and watch a couple of people pick it up and will them to put it down. One woman looked at it for quite a long time and caught my eye and smiled and said "It's nice but I'm not sure, I'll think about it overnight"

I knew perfectly well that I was going to buy it first thing in the morning 9am on the dot. Would you have said anything?

No,,I don’t think it’s right to influence her eith r way and she’s not to know you bought it.