Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think once every 2 weeks is enough?

508 replies

naggy095 · 11/10/2021 07:21

Sorry it’s another PIL one…MIL does this passive aggressive thing of talking to 4mo DD in her baby voice about things that are directed towards me, e.g. “is your mummy anti-social? She is isn’t she!”. My favourite one so far “you’re much prettier than your mummy, aren’t you!”. 🙄

PILs have been going on since the day we got home from the hospital about looking after her overnight (no matter how many times I decline the requests keep coming), and the most recent comment to DD was “we can’t wait for you to sleep over, but you probably won’t know who we are because we don’t see you enough, do we”. We see PILs with DD at a minimum 1-2 times every 2 weeks, we spend a few hours with them each time. They see her more than anyone else on either side of the families.

AIBU to think at least once every 2 weeks is ‘enough’ for a grandchild to see their grandparents?

OP posts:
RedFlyingBeeBee · 12/10/2021 07:57

The point I'm making is that a child is not their mother's possession that can be withheld or withdrawn as a sanction.
It's not withholding as a sanction, it's staying away to protect child and mum.

Yes, practically and legally mothers often do use their children this way, giving little thought to the rights of 'their' child
Why do you put 'their' in inverted commas? Hmm Parents have legal responsibility for their offspring. Most mothers don't use their children. But with your views you are promoting using grandchildren for the self serving benefit of a toxic and dysfunctional grandparent. It's the grandmother in this scenario who is self obsessed and behaves badly not the op. Op is free to tell the horrible MIL to fuck off and she should.

Rosscameasdoody · 11/10/2021 21:27

@Zilla1. That’s the sense I had too. I think the OP would be entirely reasonable to deny access, or at the very least restrict it to when she is present. If anyone is ‘weaponising’ the child, it’s the MIL, not the OP.

Mischance · 11/10/2021 21:25

The point here is the potential for the MIL's behaviour to have detrimental effects on the child as time goes by if it continues.

OP is not using scarcer visits as a sanction, but as a means of preventing harm.

Believe me, this sort of manipulative behaviour via a child can be very damaging. The OP needs to limit contact until this is sorted out, which requires someone (OP or her OH or both) to tackle the problem.

Zilla1 · 11/10/2021 21:10

@Rosscameasdoody agreed. Until the OP's child becomes an adult then the OP is responsible for her well-being. Based on the poison that the MIL says while the OP is in the room, it appears possible the MIL will continue or amplify the poison about the child's primary caregiver hence affect the child's well-being. It is laughable to me that unless the OP absents herself then she's weaponising her DC.

Rosscameasdoody · 11/10/2021 21:05

There is no reason why the OP needs to stop her DD seeing her grandmother. She just needs to stop seeing her herself.

How badly the MIL is behaving is PRECISELY the point because she’s using the child to get at the OP. If the OP takes herself out of the equation there’s no telling what damage will be done. There needs to be some straight talking here and if the OP needs to stop access for a while, then hopefully the point will be made.

Redjumper1 · 11/10/2021 21:03

@5128gap I am not missing your point. I understood it perfectly.

You think that a grandparent should have a relationship with a grandchild irrespective of how they treat that Childs mother. The child and GP have a completely separate relationship and should the Mother try and become involved in that relationship then they are controlling and are acting as if they own the child which they do not. Is that accurate?

I think that a Mothers role is to raise their child to the best of their ability to be confident, kind and a contributing member of society . One who has good functioning relationships with friends and with their family including their extended family and will have healthy future relationships. Should the child have a GP who is critical, negative, questions the parents decisions thereby interfering in their primary relationship, stomping on boundaries and engaging in other negative behavior then i have to look at whether that relationship is for the benefit of my child. Because my role is to raise my child to the best of my ability. My role is not to sit back and completely ignore negative and damaging behaviour because the GP and the child are entitled to a relationship. They should have a relationship but not if it will damage the child. Witnessing your Mother being bullied by your Grandmother and your mother not standing up to your GM will damage the self esteem of the child and will damage the primary relationship between the parent and child which is more important than the relationship with GP which is why the Court takes the view it does re: GP rights.

My job analogy was about bullying v simply not liking someone. I think this was not understood.

We can just agree to differ. Just because I don't agree with you doesn't mean that I am missing the point.

MissConductUS · 11/10/2021 21:03

There is no reason why the OP needs to stop her DD seeing her grandmother. She just needs to stop seeing her herself.

Given that the MIL is actively disparaging OP ("is your mummy anti-social? She is isn’t she!”) to the child in an effort to alienate them, OP has a duty to prevent such behavior until the MIL stops being anti-social herself.

ReturntoSpamfritters · 11/10/2021 20:42

The MIL's nasty behaviour is the whole point of this thread. If she was nice, there wouldn't be an issue.

5128gap · 11/10/2021 20:39

[quote Redjumper1]@5128gap the OP is not writing about a MIL who does not like her and whom she does not like. Its okay to not like each other. Being very disrespectful is obviously very different which is what this thread is about.

I don't like Ann in work and so I don' t have much to do with her is not a big deal. I don't like Ann in work and so I bully her, will get me fired. Same applies here

I presume if your daughter has a good relationship with her GM that your GM did not belittle and bully you. Good for you.[/quote]
You are missing my point. Its not how badly the MIL behaves that is the point at issue. The point I'm making is that a child is not their mother's possession (or a job, to use your analogy) that can be withheld or withdrawn as a sanction. Yes, practically and legally mothers often do use their children this way, giving little thought to the rights of 'their' child, but unlike most people on here, I don't think its the only or best way. There is no reason why the OP needs to stop her DD seeing her grandmother. She just needs to stop seeing her herself.

Rosscameasdoody · 11/10/2021 20:35

I don't like Ann in work and so I don' t have much to do with her is not a big deal. I don't like Ann in work and so I bully her, will get me fired. Same applies here

This 100%

littlebilliie · 11/10/2021 20:34

@girlmom21

MIL needs to pack it in because soon enough DD will understand
Sadly this is true, the weirdness around PIL and families can be strange. I think you will have a much better relationship with them if you stand your ground now
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 11/10/2021 20:34

I agree entirely. My ex MIL disliked me intensely, and it was mutual. Her and DD have a lovely relationship and it would have been deeply unfair and spiteful of me to misuse my 'power' as mum to prevent it.

These are fair points. But the issue of concern here is the potential for parental alienation. Just reread the OP. That particular modus operandi is clearly there in the behaviour the in-laws are exhibiting, and the child is too young even to understand them yet. What about when she is?

This has the potential to drive a very nasty wedge into the family dynamic. The first point to make in relation to this is that there is no way this is in any child's interests. The second, is that as a PP points out, the rights of the child, as well as the course of action which is in the best interests of the child, are the family courts' paramount concern. It's quite telling that parental alienation is one form of behaviour the judges recognise as incredibly damaging, and they tend to take a very dim view of it indeed.

There is no love whatsoever lost between me and my MiL, and my husband solely deals with the relationship between him, her, and our child. I'm happy to let him do so, and I take a back seat and allow them to continue that relationship without my interference. I don't visit, but if she visits here and I happen to be here, I'm civil. Unfortunate though it is, I've never really known her very well and my relationship with her doesn't' go beyond this.

If she were attempting this damaging course with my child, you can bet I'd be singing a very different tune.

Rosscameasdoody · 11/10/2021 20:33

Unlike most posters on here, I didn't see the baby as my personal possession to be used as a pawn to get what I wanted. I also didn't think my sensibilities were that important in the grand scheme of my son's relationship with his grandma. In other words, it wasn't all about me.

It’s not about sensibilities, or using the baby as a pawn ffs !! It’s about setting boundaries so that the OP and her DP can get some peace as parents without having toxic in laws interfering and trying to impose their will at every turn.

Redjumper1 · 11/10/2021 20:26

@5128gap the OP is not writing about a MIL who does not like her and whom she does not like. Its okay to not like each other. Being very disrespectful is obviously very different which is what this thread is about.

I don't like Ann in work and so I don' t have much to do with her is not a big deal. I don't like Ann in work and so I bully her, will get me fired. Same applies here

I presume if your daughter has a good relationship with her GM that your GM did not belittle and bully you. Good for you.

Rosscameasdoody · 11/10/2021 20:22

Trying to take over how your DD’s room will be decorated. Expecting you to cook Xmas dinner while they look after your DD - WTF ? She’s overstepping boundaries all over the place and practically turning herself inside out trying to force a confrontation with you - and doing it indirectly through your DP to try to maximise the damage. You have to stop this, and now. Make it clear that they do not, and never will have, any input into how you decorate your baby’s room in YOUR home. You want your first Christmas with your DD to be a private affair so she needs to know that any unplanned intrusion won’t work and she won’t get over the doorstep.

Cherrysoup · 11/10/2021 20:17

Massive overstepping re decorating your dd’s room. Why the fuck does she think she can override what you want done in your house? Really weird. Also very odd that she doesn’t realise that by being rude, you are very likely to withdraw and if your dh isn’t close to them, it is highly unlikely that he’ll keep up regular contact. Very shortsighted of them.

5128gap · 11/10/2021 20:16

@Katyppp

There’s being a pain and there’s being personal, nasty and disrespectful while demanding access to a baby that’s not in the baby’s interest.

It's this weirdly faux legalese way of talking that makes me smile.

They're the baby's grandparents, for goodness sake!

Abd no to the PP, my first MIL was awful but it made no sense from a family point of view to fall out, as it would affect everybody.
Unlike most posters on here, I didn't see the baby as my personal possession to be used as a pawn to get what I wanted. I also didn't think my sensibilities were that important in the grand scheme of my son's relationship with his grandma. In other words, it wasn't all about me.

I agree entirely. My ex MIL disliked me intensely, and it was mutual. Her and DD have a lovely relationship and it would have been deeply unfair and spiteful of me to misuse my 'power' as mum to prevent it.
5128gap · 11/10/2021 20:09

@Rosscameasdoody

Your DD has her own relationship with her grandparents and she and they are entitled to pursue this, even if you don't like each other

No they’re not. Grandparents have zero rights. Even if they took legal action the courts would take the parents’ side if they have valid reasons for stopping access.

I was actually referring to the rights of the child to have a relationship with her grandparents. The MIL clearly doesn't like OP, but there's no reason to think her and DD won't be able to have a relationship. DD is a person, not the property of OP or an extension of her. Yes she's 4 months old now, but she won't always be, and unless there are reasons why a relationship with the grandparents would be bad for DD, I don't think it should be blocked by OP as revenge for rudeness.
MeridianB · 11/10/2021 19:48

Imagine going into your baby’s room in your lovely new home every day and seeing MIL’s decor.

There are million ways a parent or in-law can offer genuine support. With her it’s so obviously all about control.

Don’t let your DH be fooled by her pretence of help’.

PorkTheDork · 11/10/2021 19:06

And here I am, wishing my MIL would do something like this so I have an excuse to cut her off.

I'm sorry she's such a bitch to you, OP. I hope you find the strength to stand up to her.

Bluetrews25 · 11/10/2021 18:47

Please don't let her decorator do the room, even to your specifications. Do it yourselves, don't let her interfere. Or she will be phoning the decorator to change the colour behind your back. Or something else to put her own stamp on it. It's your house and your baby. Not hers.

MissConductUS · 11/10/2021 18:14

OP, keep in mind that you hold the power here. It's your house, your child, and your husband. She knows it too, which is why she's trying so hard to worm her way into power over you.

If she says something rude to you over the phone, hang up. Tell her that if she shows up uninvited at any time, she can't come in. Think of it like training a puppy. If she otherwise misbehaves go no contact for a month. She'll learn.

IrishMel · 11/10/2021 18:13

Just saw your update. Tell her you are decorating your baby's room as you please and can she please stop trying to control your family. Do not have them over for Christmas Day. They sound like a nightmare. Tell your husband to grow a pair and to tell them to butt out now. They are the type of inlaws that will try to turn your own daughter against you. Shocking the way she thinks she can just take over. Both of you need to stand your ground and lay down some rules when they visit and if not they are not welcome.

IrishMel · 11/10/2021 18:08

She sounds mean spirited, horrible and very nasty. You need to tell her to stop doing that as no way would my baby/toddler be staying over at their house now or ever in the future as she will be saying mean things about you. I never had my baby (he is 21 now) stay over when he was a baby and they are lucky you even let them into your house. Once a week is enough to be putting up with that crap and you need to talk to your husband and tell him calmly if she does not stop this behavior she is not welcome anymore. She sounds like she needs someone to just stand up to her. I was like you afraid to stand up for myself, but now I would call her out every time and ask her to leave if she did not change the way she acts.

TubeOfSmarties · 11/10/2021 18:04

It seems more than enough in the case of your rude and offensive MIL. And please don't be bullied / emotionally blackmailed into an overnight stay until you are ready, There will come a time you are grateful but 4 months old is probably not that!