Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think universities should allow “pro-life” groups?

395 replies

Mellowfruitfulnessy · 10/10/2021 22:51

There’s been a few incidents in the news of universities saying that “pro life” groups should be banned because they make women in campus feel “unsafe”.

There was a protest in Exeter today and there’s been similar rumblings elsewhere.

This seems odd to me: it’s fairly standard teaching in Catholicism and the students in the group largely seem to be Christian / non-UK students. Unis are saying these groups are not “inclusive” but if mainstream religious thinking isn’t allowed, isn’t this excluding free speech? Is it really making women feel “unsafe”?

AIBU to say that pro life groups should be allowed on campuses as part of free speech/thinking/religious freedom?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MultiStorey · 11/10/2021 10:37

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

UsedUpUsername · 11/10/2021 10:34

@Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet

There are often abortion discussions on this very website, and some of the posters are anti-abortion. I welcome that discussion, otherwise its just an echo chamber.
Yes why is Mumsnet the bastion of free speech in the UK and not universities? I mean, I really appreciate Mumsnet for this forum but …. It should really be the remit of universities. (I’m obviously referring to another topic and not this specific one)
DocAutumn · 11/10/2021 10:33

Oppressive hate groups should not be allowed anywhere.

Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 11/10/2021 10:28

There are often abortion discussions on this very website, and some of the posters are anti-abortion. I welcome that discussion, otherwise its just an echo chamber.

theAntsareMyFriends · 11/10/2021 10:27

Pro-life groups are not about debate though. They aren't suggesting adoption agencies or offering numbers of support groups for mothers they are pedalling the 'abortion is murder' line. Shock tactics and extremist views are hardly a good start for a sensible debate.

Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 11/10/2021 10:27

I have not problem with society preventing people from openly publicising incredibly hateful and harmful points of view.

And what if someone decided that your views were 'hateful and harmful', even if you thought they were perfectly reasonable? Would you be fine with not being allowed to air your views?

Mellowfruitfulnessy · 11/10/2021 10:26

@theAntsareMyFriends tbf that’s what the “pro life” people would say: the “pro choice” side have just spun their death narrative using the smokescreen of “choice” to make it seem reasonable.

Both positions are valid: it’s largely about where - from a religious perspective - human life begins and should be treated as such. A perfectly reasonable topic for disagreement.

OP posts:
BubbleCoffee · 11/10/2021 10:25

Face them up and win the* argument.*

This is the essence of free speech and should be applied to every topic that warrants discussion. No 'cancelling' of different views.

theAntsareMyFriends · 11/10/2021 10:23

@5zeds but that's not an agenda. Its giving all the options. Pushing an agenda means taking one option and putting this as more important than the rest of making it seem to be the only option. Agenda pushing and giving a choice are very different.

twelly · 11/10/2021 10:21

We need to ensure that both sides of the debate are allowed a presence, and the same rules apply ie if one is allowed to distribute literature so is the other. In a democratic society with freespeech people are allowed to have that and neither side should be hurling abuse or intimate the other side.

5zeds · 11/10/2021 10:19

because pro-choice is not about pushing a specific agenda. I don’t think that’s right. To me Pro-choice is about saying it is ok to have an abortion if you feel that is right for you. How is that not a specific agenda?Confused
I’m truly amazed that anyone should want to remove people’s right to freely express their opinion. That’s not “choice” it’s exactly the opposite.

ClareBlue · 11/10/2021 10:09

Those profiles indicate a position that can be counted easy enough. Give them a platform to allow the ridiculance of the arguments to be counteted. Don't make the debate about how hard done by they are by no platform. Face them up and win the argument. Don't make them some sort of free speech crusaders.

theAntsareMyFriends · 11/10/2021 10:07

I'm pro-choice but I would think they should also be banned if their literature was all about telling people how they must have an abortion and bandying around made-up stats about how many people die in childbirth or that children born from unplanned pregnancies are more likely to have problem in life.

Also, pro-choice is not the opposite of these groups because it is genuinely about choice not pro-abortion so we don't need 'the other side' to provide a debate because pro-choice is not about pushing a specific agenda.

ClareBlue · 11/10/2021 10:05

Surely th

DeepaBeesKit · 11/10/2021 10:04

I think the groups should be allowed to meet and speak freely but that shouldnt extend to gathering and protesting in a way that's intimidating to others. Fine to have your own views as long as not forcing them on others.

twelly · 11/10/2021 09:57

If pro-life groups are banned then pro-choice groups should be as well as should every other group that exits where anyone can hold the opposing view.

We need to allow different groups to express their views - just because some people don't agree doesn't mean we cancel them.

ShrillSiren · 11/10/2021 09:55

@SusieBob

Not really.

I have not problem with society preventing people from openly publicising incredibly hateful and harmful points of view.

Who gets to decide what is a harmful point of view? Surely a legally held view shouldn't be suppressed even though some people will disagree with it. What other perfectly legal things shouldn't be allowed?

I'm amazed you can't see the problem with it.

UsedUpUsername · 11/10/2021 09:55

I have not problem with society preventing people from openly publicising incredibly hateful and harmful points of view

Do you have the same opinion for those of us on ‘Team Terf’ (as Dave Chapelle would put it)?

BrightYellowDaffodil · 11/10/2021 09:46

Can you not see that preventing certain people you don't agree with from speaking is the beginning of the slippery slope of not allowing other people to speak and that it may include you?

Absolutely. I’ve been on the receiving end of this and it is horrific. I’m the first to say that I’ve been judgmental in the past but my experience of having friends turn on me for expressing “a wrong view” really made me understand why freedom of speech and respect for a dissenting opinion is so very important.

JumperandJacket · 11/10/2021 09:45

[quote Energy4You]@JumperandJacket the difference is that those people just have their own opinions and don’t feel the need to ram it down the throat of other people. They get on about their own business. They might have a discussion with other people about it if the subject comes up.

Thé issue here is the fact those people life groups have a long history of being disruptive and threatening. I’m not sure that saying they are ok and allowed to wait until there is an obvious issue with them is appropriate tbh.
Because that means that, in the mean time, many women will have been made at the very least uncomfortable.[/quote]
But this is exactly my point. The thread is about the existence of pro-life groups. You’re talking about people being “disruptive and threatening”. These things are not the same. There are plenty of pro-life people and organisations who find the harassment and abuse as appalling as you and I do- it’s just that one doesn’t tend to hear so much about them, for obvious reasons.

SusieBob · 11/10/2021 09:43

[quote ShrillSiren]@SusieBob

I've seen enough of these arseholes to know they shouldn't be given a breath of airtime.

And what if people with more power than you decide that you're the arsehole and shouldn't be given a breath of airtime next?

Can you not see that preventing certain people you don't agree with from speaking is the beginning of the slippery slope of not allowing other people to speak and that it may include you?[/quote]
Not really.

I have not problem with society preventing people from openly publicising incredibly hateful and harmful points of view.

Pro-lifers are arseholes whose opinions cause untold misery and thousands of deaths each year. Why should we tolerate that?

5zeds · 11/10/2021 09:43

To have a “choice” it is necessary to hear more than one view.

puffyisgood · 11/10/2021 09:35

It's not really OK, no.

It'd be fine to have, say, a 'pro life pride' march, mothers who decided to go ahead with having unwanted children marching to show their pride in their decision.

It's not OK for people [especially men] to lecture other women on what they should be doing with their bodies and lives.

ShrillSiren · 11/10/2021 09:30

@SusieBob

I've seen enough of these arseholes to know they shouldn't be given a breath of airtime.

And what if people with more power than you decide that you're the arsehole and shouldn't be given a breath of airtime next?

Can you not see that preventing certain people you don't agree with from speaking is the beginning of the slippery slope of not allowing other people to speak and that it may include you?

TeacupDrama · 11/10/2021 09:29

Many mainstream Muslim societies at university will worship with sexes segregated and preach that homosexuality is wrong they do not get bannedsome extreme ones do that encourage violence but not for just saying they believe homosexuality is wrong.it is not just catholic pro life groups that believe abortionists mostly wrong disagreeing with a groups world view is not a good enough reason for banning their right to free speech