Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think universities should allow “pro-life” groups?

395 replies

Mellowfruitfulnessy · 10/10/2021 22:51

There’s been a few incidents in the news of universities saying that “pro life” groups should be banned because they make women in campus feel “unsafe”.

There was a protest in Exeter today and there’s been similar rumblings elsewhere.

This seems odd to me: it’s fairly standard teaching in Catholicism and the students in the group largely seem to be Christian / non-UK students. Unis are saying these groups are not “inclusive” but if mainstream religious thinking isn’t allowed, isn’t this excluding free speech? Is it really making women feel “unsafe”?

AIBU to say that pro life groups should be allowed on campuses as part of free speech/thinking/religious freedom?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
UsedUpUsername · 11/10/2021 13:26

Freedom of speech =/= being entitled to form groups at a particular institution, hold particular memberships, use a particular platform

The university is a place to challenge your ideas and your values, it shouldn’t be a place to simply inculcate middle class values. So yeah, not the same as the meat aisle of Tesco’s.

madisonbridges · 11/10/2021 13:25

@foxgoosefinch

And, don’t kid yourself that this is new, in the 90s there would be the pro hunt and hunt sab stalls set up opposite each other, and the antivivisectionist stalls with leaflets of horrifically damaged animals and the pro life ones and the Conservative association and the pro Hamas stalls and the Israel Society and the Alpha Course Christians opposite the LGB stall and the campus territorial army society or whatever, and somehow people managed to avoid the ones they found distasteful, and still not feel like they were “unsafe” or “triggered” or that anyone should be banned.
Oh my god. Not a Conservative association!!! How do those poor students survive university?!
foxgoosefinch · 11/10/2021 13:22

At a village hall meeting, I trust that the organisers will decide what they deem appropriate to be discussed at their meeting. Just the same as a university, no one has an automatic right to have their views platformed.

What a mangled backformed new verb “to platform” is Confused

Anyway. As lots of posters up thread, including me, have pointed out, a village hall meeting isn’t subject to the Charities Act; it doesn’t have a public sector equality duty or to comply with PREVENT or have to be mindful of ECHR guidelines. So it’s not at all the same; neither is it the same as a company; so it sounds very ill-informed to claim it is. Please do some sustained reading around this before keeping on making claims that are frankly not true. I’m a trustee of two educational charities and can tell you absolutely that what you’ve said here is rubbish.

HeyFloof · 11/10/2021 13:21

@Viviennemary

I think supporting abortion to term for any reason is vile. Far far worse than any prolifer's beliefs.
Then consider yourself incredibly lucky that you have never had to face that decision.

Terminations after the first trimester are overwhelmingly performed because the baby has severe, life limiting and often fatal fetal anomalies.

madisonbridges · 11/10/2021 13:21

@Mellowfruitfulnessy

I’m surprised that most people think IABU. I don’t see how you can want this banned from campuses but not radfem/GC groups. Surely they are two sides of the same thing I.e. a position on ideology that should be openly discussed and debated?
I think people are getting used to their ideas being shared and backed up by other people on SM etc, and they've lost the ability to deal with challenges to their thought process. So when someone has a different idea, people are scared or threatened and can become aggressive.

No one has to change their beliefs because someone else disagrees with it, but it's good to listen to what others have to say to both check the validity of what you think, as well as occasionally nuance your beliefs. If everyone had the same beliefs and were bullied into thinking the same thing, we'd still be saying the sun moved around the earth. It was only because Galileo stuck his head above the parapet that that belief changed.

I guess I'm pro-choice, although not as radically as in my younger days, but I'm happy to engage with others who think differently - how else am I going to get them to change their mind?

Sosososotired · 11/10/2021 13:14

Yabu. I am a Christian, yet am very much pro choice. As a woman I would not feel comfortable with a pro life group operating at a uni that my children, particularly my dd attend.. They usually have aggressive tactics and work through intimidation.

godmum56 · 11/10/2021 13:14

@foxgoosefinch

And, don’t kid yourself that this is new, in the 90s there would be the pro hunt and hunt sab stalls set up opposite each other, and the antivivisectionist stalls with leaflets of horrifically damaged animals and the pro life ones and the Conservative association and the pro Hamas stalls and the Israel Society and the Alpha Course Christians opposite the LGB stall and the campus territorial army society or whatever, and somehow people managed to avoid the ones they found distasteful, and still not feel like they were “unsafe” or “triggered” or that anyone should be banned.
this Mostly it didn't result in riots and fights either.
godmum56 · 11/10/2021 13:12

I think "allowing groups" is quite a nebulous concept. If you mean groups of people who meet together to discuss stuff, even scheduled public debate then yes I think it should be allowed for ANY subject that is not illegal. I think that campaigning is different and that i would not allow, not for pro life, pro choice, extinction Rebellion or any other group that's belief set seems to have a habit of meetings and campaigns ending in disarray and trouble.
Its a balance today between letting students exercise their brains and develop opinions and POV's, and allowing free for alls and the silencing of views by the most vociferous groups.

scarpa · 11/10/2021 13:08

Freedom of speech =/= being entitled to form groups at a particular institution, hold particular memberships, use a particular platform.

You are free to say that everyone who drives an Audi is a prick, but Audi are under no obligation to let you wave a banner round in their showroom saying so.

You're free to say you think meat-eating is immoral, but you don't have a right to verbally abuse people in the meat aisle of Tesco as they'll quite reasonably ask you to leave.

You're free to think abortion is wrong, and to say so to other people, but you do not have the automatic right to run a group to that effect under the banner of a university.

Of course, unis hover in a weird space between private and public sector - they both behave like private institutions while being held to similar levels of scrutiny and behaviour that public institutions are. In that sense, you could argue that because universities receive state funding, they don't have the same level of freedom to disallow groups they don't want on campus.

BubbleCoffee · 11/10/2021 13:07

I haven't seen anyone 'screeching' on here Hmm The definition of 'screech' is not 'say things with which I disagree'.

Unsure33 · 11/10/2021 13:06

I think it was reported recently that many students view their opinions as facts , rather than opinions

and that is dangerous .

Freedom of speech is slowly being eroded and that also is extremely worrying.
As long as discussions are limited to debate in a peaceful way then i think society is on a dodgy wicket to ban everything that falls outside a narrow agenda .

There are laws to prevent certain behaviours - and if a group is telling lies then that should quite rightly be proven ( easily) within debate .

Fifthtimelucky · 11/10/2021 13:06

@Libertaire

Of course ‘pro-life’ groups should be able to promote their views in universities and elsewhere, in exactly the same way as ‘pro-choice’ groups can..

Free speech is currently under attack in Britain as never before in my lifetime. This country needs to get back to “I disagree with what you say, but I will defend your right to say it”. Free speech only for people I agree with is no free speech at all.

Well said!
minatrina · 11/10/2021 13:06

@BubbleCoffee

My point is that not all arguments are academically worthy of being platformed by a university.

Who gets to decide what is 'academically worthy'? All topics can be discussed on a variety of different levels. Set up a discussion on 'Why is Mr Blobby pink?' and you could get into the depths of male privilege, racism and weight (why is fat funny)? Yes, it's a deliberately absurd example, but pretty much any subject is what you make of it.

Should debates on religion and philosophy be banned because many people are atheists and don't think science and spirituality can coexist? Should debates on gender ideology be no-platformed because 'everyone knows' XYZ? Should a debate called 'A woman's place is in the home' be banned in case women don't feel 'safe'? How about political debates when certain views are relatively unpopular in academic circles?

The answer is to stand up and defend your views, or go and do something else, not to switch other people's voices off as you would a TV programme you didn't like.

Who gets to decide? Universities. Just the same as how every other company, institution, or organisation can decide what they deem worthy of platforming.
minatrina · 11/10/2021 13:04

@UsedUpUsername

Not all viewpoints are worthy of academic debate

But the medical/philosophical ethics over abortion isn’t one of those.

That's for each individual academic institution to decide for themselves, not people screeching about "freedom of speech".
minatrina · 11/10/2021 13:02

[quote lazylinguist]**@lazylinguist at universities, or specifically events held by universities? Yes.

Why would we only be talking about universities? Do you think, then, that certain topics should be banned at university debates, but are fine for speakers in, say, a meeting at a village hall (because they don't need to be so 'intelligent' there)? Sorry, but either a topic or certain views are allowed to be addressed in public or they're not. Intelligence doesn't come into it.[/quote]
Because that's specifically what the OP was about?

At a village hall meeting, I trust that the organisers will decide what they deem appropriate to be discussed at their meeting. Just the same as a university, no one has an automatic right to have their views platformed.

BubbleCoffee · 11/10/2021 12:58

foxgoosefinch

Hear hear.

lazylinguist · 11/10/2021 12:57

@lazylinguist at universities, or specifically events held by universities? Yes.

Why would we only be talking about universities? Do you think, then, that certain topics should be banned at university debates, but are fine for speakers in, say, a meeting at a village hall (because they don't need to be so 'intelligent' there)? Sorry, but either a topic or certain views are allowed to be addressed in public or they're not. Intelligence doesn't come into it.

Viviennemary · 11/10/2021 12:55

I think supporting abortion to term for any reason is vile. Far far worse than any prolifer's beliefs.

rainbowdaz · 11/10/2021 12:52

@SusieBob

The university has every right to not allow a group to advertise, recruit and campaign on their campus.

Just like you and I have the right to do so on our property.

And that's before you get to the fact that pro-lifers are a bunch of mysoginistic, extremist fuckwits.

People on here will call anyone who doesn't agree with abortion til term a pro life or anti choicer

I think it's fine to advertise services for pregnant women as an alternative to abortion, as long as there's no harassment, accusations of murder or misrepresentation (eg graphic pictures of late fetus) - but I highly doubt that would be permitted on a campus in any context.

catgirl1976 · 11/10/2021 12:51

YANBU

I can't stand pro lifers and am pro choice to my core however people do have the right to disagree and no one has the right for their views not to be challenged. It is not "unsafe" to encounter people with different views.

I do agree with banning them from protesting outside of abortion clinics etc though as I think that crosses the line from airing your views to intimidation

foxgoosefinch · 11/10/2021 12:50

And, don’t kid yourself that this is new, in the 90s there would be the pro hunt and hunt sab stalls set up opposite each other, and the antivivisectionist stalls with leaflets of horrifically damaged animals and the pro life ones and the Conservative association and the pro Hamas stalls and the Israel Society and the Alpha Course Christians opposite the LGB stall and the campus territorial army society or whatever, and somehow people managed to avoid the ones they found distasteful, and still not feel like they were “unsafe” or “triggered” or that anyone should be banned.

Totallydefeated · 11/10/2021 12:49

[quote minatrina]@lazylinguist at universities, or specifically events held by universities? Yes. And of course we're all entitled to freedom of speech - for the record, I don't think I'm particularly intelligent so I count myself amongst the average lot. But not being given a formal spot to espouse my dim views at a university isn't a violation of my rights to free speech. I'm sorry my weeping emoticon upset you, I used it because I can't believe that people still don't understand what freedom of speech actually means.

@BrightYellowDaffodil I'm not sure I follow your logic, to be honest. Of course I don't think that everyone who disagrees with me about anything is stupid. My point is that not all arguments are academically worthy of being platformed by a university. Surely we can all cope with the knowledge that not all of our opinions are important or worthy of discussion or rebuttal by experts in the field? They have better things to be doing!

Go on your views and opinions all you like, but you don't have an automatic right to be platformed by a university, private company, website, whatever other organisation you feel owes you airtime.

@Totallydefeated I'm not in a formal debate. I'm on a mumsnet forum, so I will naturally communicate in styles commonly used online. [/quote]
Sure, just as long as you realise that others may find your pronouncements on the intelligence of others to hold less weight if you present yourself in a less intelligent way yourself.

foxgoosefinch · 11/10/2021 12:43

@SusieBob the same and much more could be said for hardcore pornography and sex work, and yet many university feminist societies are explicitly pro sex work and pro porn (the one at my university very explicitly is). Should the campus liberal feminists be banned too?

JustAnotherPoster00 · 11/10/2021 12:42

So who is the oppressive hate group in this question, and who decides that?

Society en masse decide that and eventually a law will follow, if you disagree with that what objectional views do you hold, once it was ok to question the intelligence and worthiness to equality for POC do you think that should be brought back? Whether women are intelligent enough to be academic or worthy of the vote, should we bring that back? That 'the gays' are all perverts and want access to your childrens bathrooms (wonder where weve heard that argument before)

BubbleCoffee · 11/10/2021 12:40

It's not a debate as to whether pro-life is harmful or not.

Pro-lifers argue that abortion is harmful. In an organised debate, those who are pro-choice can tell them exactly why they disagree with their stance.