Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think universities should allow “pro-life” groups?

395 replies

Mellowfruitfulnessy · 10/10/2021 22:51

There’s been a few incidents in the news of universities saying that “pro life” groups should be banned because they make women in campus feel “unsafe”.

There was a protest in Exeter today and there’s been similar rumblings elsewhere.

This seems odd to me: it’s fairly standard teaching in Catholicism and the students in the group largely seem to be Christian / non-UK students. Unis are saying these groups are not “inclusive” but if mainstream religious thinking isn’t allowed, isn’t this excluding free speech? Is it really making women feel “unsafe”?

AIBU to say that pro life groups should be allowed on campuses as part of free speech/thinking/religious freedom?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Whstdoyouthink · 10/10/2021 23:27

Hold on though, I’ve just read the link, this isn’t a one off speech though is it. It’s about creating a society on campus with a purpose of anti abortion. This is very far from the values and beliefs of the university.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 10/10/2021 23:24

@sleeplessem

Of course it would apply to those groups, providing they obey actual laws, e.g. inciting violence, etc.

BurntO · 10/10/2021 23:24

@PearLime have you even read the reports regarding Exeter university?? How is your comment relevant to those?

BiLuminous · 10/10/2021 23:23

This seems odd to me: it’s fairly standard teaching in Catholicism and the students in the group largely seem to be Christian / non-UK students. Unis are saying these groups are not “inclusive” but if mainstream religious thinking isn’t allowed, isn’t this excluding free speech? Is it really making women feel “unsafe”?

Why not just join group based on faith then, instead of specifically abortion? They can voice their opinions in that group without trying to target people making difficult decisions

MultiStorey · 10/10/2021 23:23

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

titchy · 10/10/2021 23:22

@RealDinosaurofBarnardCastle

We’re ALL ‘pro-life’ - let’s call them what they really are which is ‘anti abortion’ - interesting how many of these are run by men.

The attack on women’s rights over their own bodies is terrifying.

I don't think anyone is disagreeing with that - try reading the thread. Hmm

But groups have a right to voice their legally held view. Who do you think you are to decide some people should have less of a voice than others. That's the reasoning of the far right.

MurielSpriggs · 10/10/2021 23:22

And if you "feel unsafe" because someone expresses a view that disagree with then the problem lies with you.

Mellowfruitfulnessy · 10/10/2021 23:21

I agree with you @Whstdoyouthink - this is such an old argument, why give it so much credence? A small group of people spouting outdated arguments really should make anyone feel unsafe.

OP posts:
PearLime · 10/10/2021 23:21

@BurntO

You can have free speech without intruding upon people’s days. Enjoy your free speech in appropriate settings or when asked for your opinions.

Free speech isn’t a free pass to be obnoxious

That's what people said to suffragettes who were protesting about votes for women.

Keep quiet. No one asked you. You can think it but don't dare say it.

chipsandgin · 10/10/2021 23:21

Nope, they shouldn’t be allowed, they should STFU - women are allowed to make autonomous decisions about their own bodies in this country, thank goodness.

FYI we also don’t like racism, homophobia or wife beating here either. Do you also believe the KKK, or ‘gay reprogramming’ groups or perhaps men who are ‘pro-violence keep women in the kitchen’ groups should be allowed too!? After all if we banned them (actually I think we have!) that would be preventing any controversial topic being discussed wouldn’t it? What a stupid question.

They are being banned because people who think the decision to not go ahead with a pregnancy should be down to them shouldn’t be allowed to voice their opinions publicly because they are deeply unpleasant views, unhelpful and go against the laws we have, for a reason, in this thankfully fairly progressive country!?

BurntO · 10/10/2021 23:21

@GrinchTastic you ok?

Sleeplessem · 10/10/2021 23:21

@IM0GEN

Of course they should be allowed - we have freedom of speech in this country. It’s appalling that some people are trying to censor views that differ from their own.
Would you say the same for other religious fundamentalists or radicals?

Unlikely

VeniVidiWeeWee · 10/10/2021 23:21

@RealDinosaurofBarnardCastle

Do you mean people exercising their right to take a view on a particular topic?

GrinchTastic · 10/10/2021 23:20

You can have free speech without intruding upon people’s days. Enjoy your free speech in appropriate settings or when asked for your opinions.

Confused
dapsnotplimsolls · 10/10/2021 23:20

It depends what they're doing. If they're not breaking the law or university regulations, then let them. I think there are times when people play the 'unsafe' card when they just don't want to hear different views.

MurielSpriggs · 10/10/2021 23:20

Are you sure this is banned? If so that's shocking.

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 10/10/2021 23:20

Exeter University does currently have an anti abortion group, one that is run by three men and one woman. It is the students, rather than the uni itself, who are protesting against them advertising to recruit new freshers.

www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/abortion-petition-letter-exeter-university-b1935005.html

www.devonlive.com/news/devon-news/tensions-mount-over-exeter-university-6039467

And I can't say I blame them. Why the fuck is there a society that is concerned about what women do with their bodies, in a UK university, in 2021?! It's a no from me.

Mellowfruitfulnessy · 10/10/2021 23:19

I was surprised at the protests - I find it weird that we have a government that is literally laundering money to its rich donors and students and protesting in their thousands about a group of probably six catholics running a stall. I guess identity politics and wrongthink are the flavour of the hour.

OP posts:
BurntO · 10/10/2021 23:19

You can have free speech without intruding upon people’s days. Enjoy your free speech in appropriate settings or when asked for your opinions.

Free speech isn’t a free pass to be obnoxious

GrinchTastic · 10/10/2021 23:18

Young women, and young men for that matter, don’t need to “feel safe” at university.

foxgoosefinch · 10/10/2021 23:17

@DrSbaitso we don’t live in the US - there are no Amendments here.

Private companies or institutions are not obliged to give a “platform” to anyone - though they are subject to equality legislation.

Universities and other charities or public institutions are in a very slightly different position. They normally have some public duty or public sector equality duties.

Nevertheless, don’t you think especially public institutions have a moral duty to uphold principles of freedom of speech? And equality law. This might, for example, include bot discriminating against religious groups with lawful beliefs you just don’t happen to like (like Catholics, for example); or political societies and movements.

Otherwise, when times change and someone in power decides they don’t like your beliefs or opinions, how can your beliefs be protected and respected?

It is exceptionally short sighted, and the mark of the very inexperienced person, not to understand that one day you might be the one with the opinions people want to ban. Whatever their shortcomings, those who grew up in the long shadow of the postwar understood this extremely well.

Whstdoyouthink · 10/10/2021 23:17

Yeap I agree with PP let’s call then anti abortion

Just seems so old fashioned. Let’s debate whether women should work or be allowed to do boxing???!! Of course we wouldn’t do why abortion

That ship has sailed what’s the point

RealDinosaurofBarnardCastle · 10/10/2021 23:17

My experience of them is middle aged and older MEN outside an abortion clinic with vile placards intimidating women who were exercising their right to legal, safe termination.

Noway100 · 10/10/2021 23:16

@IM0GEN

Of course they should be allowed - we have freedom of speech in this country. It’s appalling that some people are trying to censor views that differ from their own.
This and I am not 'pro life'. Very worrying that the voting is split and not massively in favour of the right to free speech. It shows the Government is right to be concerned about this issue at Universities.
Viviennemary · 10/10/2021 23:16

Of course they should be allowed. And not all pro life people protest outside abortion clinics.