Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think universities should allow “pro-life” groups?

395 replies

Mellowfruitfulnessy · 10/10/2021 22:51

There’s been a few incidents in the news of universities saying that “pro life” groups should be banned because they make women in campus feel “unsafe”.

There was a protest in Exeter today and there’s been similar rumblings elsewhere.

This seems odd to me: it’s fairly standard teaching in Catholicism and the students in the group largely seem to be Christian / non-UK students. Unis are saying these groups are not “inclusive” but if mainstream religious thinking isn’t allowed, isn’t this excluding free speech? Is it really making women feel “unsafe”?

AIBU to say that pro life groups should be allowed on campuses as part of free speech/thinking/religious freedom?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
IM0GEN · 10/10/2021 23:38

@SammyScrounge

Everyone has a right to express their views. Pro life is included in that. They:ll get shot down in flames, especially on campus.

I am more concerned about pRoLiferd hanging about clinics and harassing women going in for a procedure.

Indeed. But that’s not what’s being discussed here. The OP is about freedom to meet and talk on campus . The freedom to hold opinions and talk about them.

Are you going to ban Muslims and Jews from meeting up and talking or is it just Catholics?

And no I’m not Catholic but I fervently believe that they should have all the same human rights as atheists, humanists and everyone else.

HollaHolla · 10/10/2021 23:38

@titchy

Universities are private businesses, they have no obligation to entertain these people.

No they're not Hmm

They’re largely registered charities in the UK. However, most HEIs now only have about 1/2 of their income directly from public money.
GrinchTastic · 10/10/2021 23:37

No I don’t, Thekormachameleon, if “feeling safe” means never having to be confronted with an opinion or belief they disagree with or find objectionable. Which is what it increasingly seems to mean these days.

titchy · 10/10/2021 23:37

In this context 'feeling safe' is not about physical safety, or supporting someone's MH. Safe now is synonymous with 'be nice' and 'don't let me hear things that might challenge my woke bubble'.

BurntO · 10/10/2021 23:36

@Titchy
Are groups advocating against the freedom of specific races cool then or is it just woman’s bodies were are good with being up for discussion?

Sleeplessem · 10/10/2021 23:36

So @IM0GEN, there are certain schools of thought in certain religious communities that think that there should be capital punishment for homosexuality in a ‘just’ and divinely guided society. Should that be on campus? It’s freedom of speech though right?

foxgoosefinch · 10/10/2021 23:36

Universities aren’t private businesses - they’re exempt charities with clear statutory duties under the Charities Act 1993.

titchy · 10/10/2021 23:35

Anjem Choudary would go against Prevent duty.

PearLime · 10/10/2021 23:35

[quote BurntO]@PearLime have you even read the reports regarding Exeter university?? How is your comment relevant to those?[/quote]
People should be able to express opinions, irrespective of whether they cause offence and irrespective of whether they are the popular belief at the time.

Yes I have read the report.

We need to maintain free speech because it is so so important that people can express beliefs. Even ones that you happen to not agree with.

BurntO · 10/10/2021 23:35

@MurielSpriggs freedom of expression? Are groups advocating against the freedom of specific races cool then or is it just woman’s bodies were are good with being up for discussion?

Thekormachameleon · 10/10/2021 23:35

@GrinchTastic

Young women, and young men for that matter, don’t need to “feel safe” at university.
You don't think young people, many of whom will be away from home for the first time and making their own way in the world deserve to feel safe ?

What a strange opinion

titchy · 10/10/2021 23:34

Universities are private businesses, they have no obligation to entertain these people.

No they're not Hmm

Sleeplessem · 10/10/2021 23:33

[quote VeniVidiWeeWee]@sleeplessem

Of course it would apply to those groups, providing they obey actual laws, e.g. inciting violence, etc.[/quote]
So you’re telling me the likes of Anjem chowdary should be welcomed across Uni campuses under the guise of freedom of speech. Utter tosh. No one thinks that because even though that little weasel never himself incited violence his ideology was toxic.

Same with pro lifers. The ones who pray outside abortion clinics with pictures of fetuses, tormenting the women who are going inside for reasons beyond their comprehension, those who care more about the life of a 6 week old fétus than a girl/ woman. Come on. That ideology shouldn’t be given oxygen in a place of education.

MurielSpriggs · 10/10/2021 23:33

@BurntO

This is from the group’s “president”

Not sure why they are being defended

Freedom of expression.
SammyScrounge · 10/10/2021 23:33

Everyone has a right to express their views.
Pro life is included in that. They:ll get shot down in flames, especially on campus.

I am more concerned about pRoLiferd hanging about clinics and harassing women going in for a procedure.

titchy · 10/10/2021 23:32

Not sure why they are being defended

Their views AREN'T being defended.

Their right to express those views is.

owlbethere · 10/10/2021 23:32

@IM0GEN

Of course they should be allowed - we have freedom of speech in this country. It’s appalling that some people are trying to censor views that differ from their own.
Universities are private businesses, they have no obligation to entertain these people.
RobertaFirmino · 10/10/2021 23:30

Hells teeth BurntO, that is despicable.

IM0GEN · 10/10/2021 23:30

Would you say the same for other religious fundamentalists or radicals?

Unlikely

Of course I would , as long as they are not breaking the law. Who am I to decide what religious views other people can hold ?

I’m genuinely quite shocked to read how many MNers are pro censorship and anti free speech. How can you all be arguing for freedom of speech for yourself but not for others ?

Freedom of speech and religion mean nothing if it’s only for the people or belief systems that you personally like or approve of . There’s always someone who will disagree with you, so does that mean that your rights should be taken away?

I can’t decide if these posters are extremely right wing / totalitarian or just rather hard of thinking.

foxgoosefinch · 10/10/2021 23:30

@GrinchTastic

Young women, and young men for that matter, don’t need to “feel safe” at university.
^^This. It’s not a crèche. The rhetoric around “feeling safe” is ridiculous. No-one is suggesting here that harassment and intimidation or physical threat is okay. But that isn’t what the OP asked.

A stall at a university or hearing an opinion you don’t like or seeing material you disagree with (or an opinion that is against an experience you’ve had or a choice you have made), is not being “unsafe”, and it’s frankly infantilising to suggest it is.

I dislike pro-life stuff as much as anyone and will always argue against it, along with a lot of other opinions and movements that I disagree with - but would still never suggest be banned. That way is totalitarianism.

MultiStorey · 10/10/2021 23:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Movingsoon21 · 10/10/2021 23:29

Let’s call “pro-lifers” what they really are: extreme right-wing misogynistic hate groups.

Universities wouldn’t allow anti-LGBT groups or racist groups a platform so they shouldn’t allow these women-hating groups either.

Of course anyone is free to think what they like and discuss it with people in private. But no public platform for hate groups.

BurntO · 10/10/2021 23:29

This is from the group’s “president”

Not sure why they are being defended

To think universities should allow “pro-life” groups?
RobertaFirmino · 10/10/2021 23:28

Of course it gives you the right to tell lies. Have you never lied in your life? I certainly have
Of course I have lied. There's a difference between claiming 'I only ate two Kit-Kats' and saying a picture of a 5 month old foetus is actually one at 6 weeks though.

Holding meetings and saying things that you consider a lie is not a criminal offence. Otherwise we wouldn’t have a government, would we?
No, it isn't. And there would be no issue on my part if these pro-life groups simply stuck to having meetings. My issue is with their propaganda, much of which is not based on fact. It has the potential to seriously harm women and girls.

Do you want to shut down all religions that you personally don’t agree with ?
Don't be ridiculous. People should have freedom of choice as long as others will not be harmed.

Gingerkittykat · 10/10/2021 23:27

I'm 100% pro choice and I think people have the right to peacefully express themselves. People who are pro choice can debate and refute their claims.

I hate the restrictions on free speech being imposed on us right now.