Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Low risk women/better birth facilities - unfair?

481 replies

Glassofshloer · 10/10/2021 16:45

When DD was a baby we attended a breastfeeding appointment at my local stand-alone birth centre and WOW! To say it was gorgeous is an understatement - double bed, huge whirlpool bath thing, fairy lights and bouncy balls in every room. Looked like the Ritz compared to the tiny, dimly lit room on the CDU where I gave birth. Just a bed and some wall stickers of flowers Confused

AIBU to think this is unfair on high risk/Consultant led women? And that we all deserve equal facilities, high risk or not? Fully prepared to be told IABU!

OP posts:
Hamtonn · 11/10/2021 18:35

I honestly think the first thing to campaign on is adequate staffing levels. Not the rooms.
They either need adequate staffing so every mum and baby gets decent postnatal support. Or they need rooms with an extra bed so a support person (dad, gran, friend) can stay to help with the baby while mum recovers. The room would be cheaper!

I found it very unreasonable that they expected my husband to stay and look after me and the baby while I was incapacitated, but then expected him to sleep on a hard chair for two nights with no access to facilities.

Blossomtoes · 11/10/2021 18:26

By society, I mean society. If I meant men, I’d have said that. I entirely agree that women’s rights in some areas are being eroded right now. As you say, that’s another thread. And I was hoping for an intelligent discussion of the issues, not an airy dismissal of “sexism”. 🤷‍♀️

Bookingfatigued · 11/10/2021 18:23

I don’t think maternity services were better before. In the mid eighties a close female relative was left in a room on a drip pretty much on her own, birthed the baby tearing then sewn up with no local anaesthetic.

Another relative with a breach baby in the 50s was told by a doctor not to worry if she felt a leg dangling down. Had an episiotomy and resulting stitches without local anaesthetic and told that it wouldn’t hurt if it was done straight after birth. Baby wisked away before she held it.

Don’t think our older relatives speak about it as they don’t want to scare us. But ask them. That’s enough horror stories though.

WrapAroundYourDreams · 11/10/2021 18:16

You said you 'thought it was an intelligent conversation'- don't deny your implication.

Did I say that sexism was the only reason? There are many reasons why maternity care is worse now than when I was born 33 years ago but I believe (and it really isn't a rare opinion) than sexism plays a part.

Particularly since maternity services were considerably better at a time when society was much more sexist.

Tbh- 'society'? Basically by 'society' we mean men don't we? Are men less sexist? I'm not sure about that. I don't think they can be so openly sexist in many situations. Have their views of women inherently changed? I don't think they honestly have. For some of our gains we are losing ground in others. It's a separate thread though.

Blossomtoes · 11/10/2021 18:05

[quote WrapAroundYourDreams]Wow, you're lovely aren't you @Blossomtoes, basically calling anyone with a different opinion to you thick.

It isn't lazy to consider that just maybe, some of the issues surrounding women's poor maternity care are down to inherit sexism. You've given it some thought and analysis? Believe it or not, others have, and may have come to different conclusions. Did you even read this, that I posted earlier in the thread?

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/jul/04/as-long-as-sexism-lies-at-the-heart-of-childcare-babies-and-women-will-continue-to-die[/quote]
I didn’t call anyone anything.

Lack of funding which has to be spread more thinly, staff shortages, medicalisation of childbirth are all issues here. Yes, I think dismissing it as just sexism is lazy and unhelpful. Particularly since maternity services were considerably better at a time when society was much more sexist.

Bookingfatigued · 11/10/2021 18:02

“You could give birth in the corridor with an amazing midwife who cares and looks after you amazingly and it would be a much better experience than the plush room.”

True, but do you understand the induction process that many women increasingly go through? They don’t get to 9cm at home then deliver in a couple of hours once they get to hospital. It’s an extremely long process in many cases - so environment does make a difference, especially if there’s literally no sign of baby coming and it feels like it’s being forced out of you

WrapAroundYourDreams · 11/10/2021 18:00

And this- 'patriarchal ideas of female inadequacy', as mentioned in this article, seems spot on from the experiences I love had:

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/voices/nhs-maternity-scandal-shrewsbury-telford-hospital-birth-trauma-pregnancy-a9210241.html%3famp

Glassofshloer · 11/10/2021 17:59

@Horst

I was high risk based on age nothing more.

I then had a home birth because I was treated like shit on post natal.

Then a pool birth because yet again midwifes didn’t believe I was in labour so by the time they realised I was there was no more community midwifes.

The rooms I gave birth in made not one tiny bit of difference to the labours or deliveries I had. That’s my point. It’s the midwifes and their attitudes that made the whole experience different.

I see. And what about other women sent to CDU based on age alone? Why do they not deserve a pool?

Quality of midwife care isn’t inversely proportional to how nice your room is - it’s not like having shit facilities make better midwife care more likely, why can’t we have high expectations of both?

OP posts:
WrapAroundYourDreams · 11/10/2021 17:58

Wow, you're lovely aren't you @Blossomtoes, basically calling anyone with a different opinion to you thick.

It isn't lazy to consider that just maybe, some of the issues surrounding women's poor maternity care are down to inherit sexism. You've given it some thought and analysis? Believe it or not, others have, and may have come to different conclusions. Did you even read this, that I posted earlier in the thread?

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/jul/04/as-long-as-sexism-lies-at-the-heart-of-childcare-babies-and-women-will-continue-to-die

Horst · 11/10/2021 17:52

You could have a lovely fairy tale room but if you’ve got a shitty midwife who talks to you like crap like you know nothing no matter what room you in it will be shit.

You could give birth in the corridor with an amazing midwife who cares and looks after you amazingly and it would be a much better experience than the plush room.

Blossomtoes · 11/10/2021 17:51

@WrapAroundYourDreams

You don't seem to be taking much from mine *@Blossomtoes*, to read up on women's pain not being taken seriously, and a woman who doesn't want to see the misogyny that impacts on us is more than 'disappointing' tbh.
You mean because I don’t lazily attribute the deterioration in maternity care to misogyny? Because I’ve given the issue some thought and analysis to why it’s got worse in the last few decades? OK. I thought this was an intelligent discussion.
Horst · 11/10/2021 17:50

I was high risk based on age nothing more.

I then had a home birth because I was treated like shit on post natal.

Then a pool birth because yet again midwifes didn’t believe I was in labour so by the time they realised I was there was no more community midwifes.

The rooms I gave birth in made not one tiny bit of difference to the labours or deliveries I had. That’s my point. It’s the midwifes and their attitudes that made the whole experience different.

Glassofshloer · 11/10/2021 17:48

@Horst

I didn’t have a pool for my first birth. I was high Rick consultant led who gave birth in the midwife led because there was no other rooms for me. I was actually told to go home because they didn’t believe I was in labour despite being 9cm when I appeared at triage.
Sorry your posts are quite muddled. So you had a high risk VB in the MLU, and subsequent water births? But you don’t think other high risk women (even second+ time mums, like you were when you had water births) should be entitled to a pool? Because they won’t use it properly? Hmm
OP posts:
WrapAroundYourDreams · 11/10/2021 17:46

You don't seem to be taking much from mine @Blossomtoes, to read up on women's pain not being taken seriously, and a woman who doesn't want to see the misogyny that impacts on us is more than 'disappointing' tbh.

Bookingfatigued · 11/10/2021 17:45

“Because using it for only a few Horus of relaxation stops someone using the room properly.”

The few hours of relaxation and pain relief might be the difference between a baby turning into a better position for birthing, hence avoiding epidural, episiotomy or emergency c section and avoiding a long stay on the postnatal ward.

Horst · 11/10/2021 17:45

I didn’t have a pool for my first birth. I was high Rick consultant led who gave birth in the midwife led because there was no other rooms for me. I was actually told to go home because they didn’t believe I was in labour despite being 9cm when I appeared at triage.

Blossomtoes · 11/10/2021 17:44

Was that all you took from my post @WrapAroundYourDreams? How disappointing.

Glassofshloer · 11/10/2021 17:42

@Horst

Because using it for only a few Horus of relaxation stops someone using the room properly.

On one hand we have this whole it’s what mum wants it’s her body her medical experience then in the other side it’s but I want it to look like hotel room with plush cushions and candles. Make up your mind.

Nobody has to be consultant led you can go against it. If you don’t trust them to know what’s best for you.

My pool room again looked like a standard labour but with a big bath/pool in the middle a radio and some rope light around it.

My midwife led was a room with a corner bath (not allowed to deliver in) bean bags on the floor then a full on bed with leg stirrups should they be needed.

None looked like plush hotels they look like delivery rooms.

Confused

What is ‘using it properly’? If you mean actually giving birth in water, you need to re-read the thread - nearly half of first time mums in MLUs get transferred to labour ward, so won’t be ‘using it properly’.

Overall, including second+ time mums, a quarter will be transferred to labour ward. So they won’t be ‘using it properly’.

And out of all women that give birth in an MLU that start in the pool, a third get out to deliver. So they’re not ‘using it properly’.

As a first time mum, you had less than a 50% chance of a spontaneous VB, so the odds weren’t in your favour to ‘use the pool properly’ when you got in.

So if the prerequisite of having a pool is that you definitely give birth in it, almost nobody should be offered one, including you 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
fastandthecurious · 11/10/2021 17:38

@Horst I feel like you're being deliberately obtuse. Postnatal care is still rubbish for women who deliver on CDU. The difference is you got to labour in a calm environment, most CDU do not consist of the facilities you've described while labouring, no one is trying to take them away from you, just give them to others too. Everyone deserves the same standard of health care, regardless of background and medical conditions.

WrapAroundYourDreams · 11/10/2021 17:37

I don’t have the answers but I think attributing the problem to misogyny and sexism is unhelpful because it doesn’t help us find solutions.

Even if the problem is related to sexism and misogyny?

Ignoring the reasons why women continue to receive poor care will not help find solutions either.

You say that it's difficult to say if it's true that women's pain is not taken as seriously as men- Google 'women's pain not taken seriously' and see the long list of results. I'll add just a few:

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/books/2019/sep/02/why-dont-doctors-trust-women-because-they-dont-know-much-about-us

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-9444891/amp/Womens-pain-perceived-intense-mens-pain.html

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.scotsman.com/health/insight-will-womens-health-finally-be-taken-seriously-3295608%3famp

Bookingfatigued · 11/10/2021 17:31

The point still stands, you got the pool facility, something most MLU rooms have but CDU rooms don’t - shouldn’t everyone have the options you had..? Unless they’re on a drip from the word go, there’s no reason they can’t use it for a few hours of relaxation and pain relief at least?

Agree with this. I was high risk at the very end of pregnancy due to raised blood pressure - I can’t think on what planet it would be conducive to relaxation and lowering BP to carry on blindly with an induction with a baby in no immediate danger but in back to back position (due to being in hospital night before said induction), confine the woman to her back with loads of monitors on, hardly any access to food, the additional pain of stronger closer contractions due to the induction itself, then tell her several times in established labour that an epidural was coming and then it wasn’t but then also not allow use of a pool 🤷‍♀️

Horst · 11/10/2021 17:27

Because using it for only a few Horus of relaxation stops someone using the room properly.

On one hand we have this whole it’s what mum wants it’s her body her medical experience then in the other side it’s but I want it to look like hotel room with plush cushions and candles. Make up your mind.

Nobody has to be consultant led you can go against it. If you don’t trust them to know what’s best for you.

My pool room again looked like a standard labour but with a big bath/pool in the middle a radio and some rope light around it.

My midwife led was a room with a corner bath (not allowed to deliver in) bean bags on the floor then a full on bed with leg stirrups should they be needed.

None looked like plush hotels they look like delivery rooms.

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 11/10/2021 17:24

I'm high risk and just glad that I'll be getting safe medical interventions.

Glassofshloer · 11/10/2021 17:22

@Bookingfatigued

Theres no guarantee of anything though with the current system. Even fully birthing a baby at home, you may need to go in to hospital and to the postnatal ward if there are any issues after such as issues delivering the placenta. It’s less likely but still possible. And of course you could refuse to leave your house.
Of course, my point is at least the home birther has options even if for various reasons they can’t use them - CDU mums don’t even start out with the options. It’s assumed they should just be grateful to have medical attention at all & they get shoved in a cupboard with a bed in it.
OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 11/10/2021 17:22

what do you think the reasons are for maternity care being so woefully underfunded?

The underfunding that has made the entirety of the NHS so woeful is a large factor. Medicalisation of birth is another and the wider range of antenatal care. Everything comes with a price - before scans, amniocentesis, etc became part of antenatal care all the money in maternity services was focussed on birth and postnatal care, now the money has to stretch further. Obviously you could say just put more funding in but which services do you take it from?

What do you think about women's pain not being taking as seriously as men's?

It’s very difficult to say whether this is true since there’s no directly comparable situation for men. To use your example, your brother’s GA affected only him, yours affected you and your baby. GAs are used less for everyone now, hip and knee replacements are carried out with an epidural and sedation.

The thing that would really improve women’s birth experience in my view is more midwives and HCAs to support them during and after birth. I think it’s really shocking that women have to deal with random men up close and personal when they’re at their most vulnerable because they’re expected to look after their partners. But where are those midwives going to come from when the NHS is already haemorrhaging them?

I don’t have the answers but I think attributing the problem to misogyny and sexism is unhelpful because it doesn’t help us find solutions.