Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Low risk women/better birth facilities - unfair?

481 replies

Glassofshloer · 10/10/2021 16:45

When DD was a baby we attended a breastfeeding appointment at my local stand-alone birth centre and WOW! To say it was gorgeous is an understatement - double bed, huge whirlpool bath thing, fairy lights and bouncy balls in every room. Looked like the Ritz compared to the tiny, dimly lit room on the CDU where I gave birth. Just a bed and some wall stickers of flowers Confused

AIBU to think this is unfair on high risk/Consultant led women? And that we all deserve equal facilities, high risk or not? Fully prepared to be told IABU!

OP posts:
whichiswitch · 10/10/2021 20:16

I agree. I was high risk and didn't have the choice of the birthing centre. But luckily my local hospital has just as lovely facilities. The only difference was the type of bed. If I'd had a choice I would have chosen the hospital anyway. It's a pity that others in other parts of the country don't have as good facilities.

MrsColon · 10/10/2021 20:16

I laboured for days in a room in the consultant-led bit (induction, prem) - it was a bit boring, but I was so worried about DS that I'd have given birth in a field if it meant he'd be OK.

I think often childbirth is presented as an "experience" - when, actually, assuming you're giving birth on the NHS, the goal is to come out with both mum and baby healthy and undamaged. Twinkly lights, a birthing pool, double bed so fathers can stay are all nice to haves, but the NHS can't afford that. Safety and health must be paramount.

Hardbackwriter · 10/10/2021 20:15

I agree - they showed us both the MLU and the labour ward rooms during my antenatal class when I was pregnant with my first and it was so dispiriting since I knew I had to go to the grotty and grim one!

What really pissed me off in the end was that they had been so insistent in advance that I couldn't even think about a water birth or the MLU because I was high-risk so would need lots of extra monitoring - and then in the end they refused to believe I was in established labour, sent me home once and then when I came back left me alone in a triage ward for two hours, and only examined me and realised I was actually giving birth 30 minutes before I gave birth (90 minutes after I'd told them I needed to push), so almost the whole labour was unmonitored anyway.

I had my second in a pool in the MLU and while apparently everyone else is too high-minded to care I actually did like giving birth in a comfortable, welcoming and calm room, frivolous flibbertigibbet that I am. I liked actually receiving some care in labour even more.

Glassofshloer · 10/10/2021 20:13

@Horst

Honestly as a women who’s birthed in midwife led, homebirthed and birthed in the pool at the hospital.

I couldn’t of given a shiney shite about the lighting and radio etc that I was offered in the pool room. In fact when the midwife asked me if I would like them on I told her if she wanted them on to feel free but I didn’t care.

I’m not sure who these lights and what not are for. We go in push out a baby and go home do we really need mood like and sage flowing everywhere

But surroundings must have been a factor in you deciding to homebirth/MLU?
OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 10/10/2021 20:11

this is only because birthing centres are a relatively new concept

This time round. I gave birth in a MLU in 1975!

CarryOnNurse20 · 10/10/2021 20:11

OP I agree with you. I had an all lights on medical birth for DD1 (straightforward but on the delivery suite due to staffing on MLU). It was fine but very clinical and quite stressful.

DD2 I was on the regular labour ward (not midwife led) in a different hospital. Of the 10 rooms they had one available that they asked if I’d like. It was huge, en suite, mood lighting. They had a birthing pool that had wireless baby monitoring (I needed constant monitoring during the delivery so thought a pool wasn’t an option). It was gorgeous. It was the lovely, peaceful empowering birth everyone wants despite DC2 being ‘higher risk’ (reduced movements +++). If every room on the labour ward had been like that so many women would have had better experiences. It’s a really shame and YANBU.

mummyh2016 · 10/10/2021 20:10

[quote Glassofshloer]**@mummyh2016* yes and use of a pool/generally nicer surroundings. I know this isn’t the case for every MLU and every* room in them but overall they’re much nicer than CDU.

And I agree about the funding, I’m just talking about it in a pie-in-the-sky, nice-to-have kind of way.[/quote]
Have you checked to see if you can pay for a private room postnatal? I hope you get a birth that you feel comfortable with afterwards, maybe ask your midwife if you can take your own lighting in to make you feel more at ease. Good luck Smile

mummyh2016 · 10/10/2021 20:07

@Alleycat02

YADNBU!! I attempted first labour on the midwife-led unit in the hospital, it was very nice and then I needed more help so off to labour ward. Both subsequent births also labour ward due to risk of same complications, it was very much a clinical environment. I had to have my anti-D injection at the standalone birth centre (for what reason I don't know) and by God it was like a luxury hotel, I could have cried knowing that would never be my experience. Plenty of midwives sitting round twiddling their thumbs there too. Good question as to why those facilities clearly have more funding than the labour wards.....
They don't have more funding, if anything they have less funding due to less staff. It likely looks like they have more funding as everything normally tends to look newer on an MLU, this is only because birthing centres are a relatively new concept so they haven't been open that long. When I gave birth the midwife who delivered my baby was a community midwife - they had all had messages begging them to work on the MLU on their day off as they had no staff. I was the first birth she had done in X amount of months so understandably she was put on there rather than on the main delivery suite.
Horst · 10/10/2021 20:06

Honestly as a women who’s birthed in midwife led, homebirthed and birthed in the pool at the hospital.

I couldn’t of given a shiney shite about the lighting and radio etc that I was offered in the pool room. In fact when the midwife asked me if I would like them on I told her if she wanted them on to feel free but I didn’t care.

I’m not sure who these lights and what not are for. We go in push out a baby and go home do we really need mood like and sage flowing everywhere

Glassofshloer · 10/10/2021 20:05

@Mummyme87

Yes there is definitely an unfair gap, my trust has a lovely birth centre upstairs and delivery suite downstairs, which has been refurbished but it’s still very clinical. I always move the furniture round when I have a lady on delivery suite, make it look more welcoming, have lights turned off and lamp on, bring mat, bean bag and birthing ball in. Take unnecessary equipment such as drip stand out, can always bring in if needed.
I take it you’re a midwife @Mummyme87 and you sound a lovely one!
OP posts:
Glassofshloer · 10/10/2021 20:00

@sayanythingelse

I'd love to give birth in a MLU. I was high risk and induced with DD due to IUGR. I was pinned down to a bed, wires everywhere for 8+ hours, unable to even move an inch as the monitors would lose her heartbeat. Now I'm high risk with DD#2 as we're under the care of FMU. Even if we get signed off from them, I'm still high risk due to previous IUGR Sad. Bouncing on a ball or having a water birth in a lovely room is a distant dream for me.
I understand how you feel, I have a pre-existing condition which means I will always need inducing at max 39 weeks, so unlikely to go into spontaneous labour - and even if I did, it would be CDU for me!

I have a fantasy that my next birth will be induced by gel only enabling me to use the pool, but I’ll probably be a good girl and go for lying on the bed/wires/epidural again…

OP posts:
Alleycat02 · 10/10/2021 19:58

YADNBU!! I attempted first labour on the midwife-led unit in the hospital, it was very nice and then I needed more help so off to labour ward. Both subsequent births also labour ward due to risk of same complications, it was very much a clinical environment. I had to have my anti-D injection at the standalone birth centre (for what reason I don't know) and by God it was like a luxury hotel, I could have cried knowing that would never be my experience. Plenty of midwives sitting round twiddling their thumbs there too.
Good question as to why those facilities clearly have more funding than the labour wards.....

Glassofshloer · 10/10/2021 19:57

@mummyh2016 yes and use of a pool/generally nicer surroundings. I know this isn’t the case for every MLU and every room in them but overall they’re much nicer than CDU.

And I agree about the funding, I’m just talking about it in a pie-in-the-sky, nice-to-have kind of way.

OP posts:
Mummyme87 · 10/10/2021 19:55

Yes there is definitely an unfair gap, my trust has a lovely birth centre upstairs and delivery suite downstairs, which has been refurbished but it’s still very clinical. I always move the furniture round when I have a lady on delivery suite, make it look more welcoming, have lights turned off and lamp on, bring mat, bean bag and birthing ball in. Take unnecessary equipment such as drip stand out, can always bring in if needed.

sayanythingelse · 10/10/2021 19:55

I'd love to give birth in a MLU. I was high risk and induced with DD due to IUGR. I was pinned down to a bed, wires everywhere for 8+ hours, unable to even move an inch as the monitors would lose her heartbeat.
Now I'm high risk with DD#2 as we're under the care of FMU. Even if we get signed off from them, I'm still high risk due to previous IUGR Sad.
Bouncing on a ball or having a water birth in a lovely room is a distant dream for me.

Staryflight445 · 10/10/2021 19:51

Most of the women on the consultant led bit are either going through a rough time or have had a rough time before. I’d say it’s more important for these rooms to be as calming and look as non clinical as possible?

Staryflight445 · 10/10/2021 19:49

I know what you’re saying op and completely agree. I had a 2.1litre pph after my first and had to be consultant led the second time. I felt very stressed in the medical environment because of what happened before.
Some mood lighting and candles would’ve been great.

mummyh2016 · 10/10/2021 19:48

@Glassofshloer

Then you've posted saying some births that the NHS categorises as high risk aren't which implies to me that you think those should be allowed on an MLU, and I've advised the reason why your examples would not be allowed on an MLU

Sorry if I confused you, what I meant with my ‘GD / first time mum’ example was to show how things like birth pools can still be made good use of on the CDU as well as the MLU. If that makes sense. Plus if CDU women are in the room longer, they deserve nicer surroundings more IMO! Lol

They would only be on delivery for up to a couple of hours post birth before moving onto a ward so even if they had a double bed in there you wouldn't really benefit from it as let's be honest once you've had skin to skin and had a shower it's time to be moved. Is it more the private room you would prefer afterwards in that case rather than the big bed etc whilst you're giving birth? If it is then I get it - the only reason I went on an MLU was because I didn't want to go on a noisy ward afterwards. The trouble is though if they make every postnatal ward full of private rooms with no actual ward with bays in it will mean even less beds so hospitals would then have to accept less births. My hospital is already ridiculously busy as they closed a maternity unit at another hospital around 6 years ago, it just wouldn't work. At one point people in my area were being told to travel 20 miles to give birth despite there being 3 maternity units closer than that. I can't see any way they could make all private rooms a thing sadly.
BestZebbie · 10/10/2021 19:48

Mummyh2016 - Wow! I hallucinated on the gas and air and thought a generic painting on the wall of my magnolia hospital box room was an actual wheat field, if the room had looked like that I'd probably have thought I was being abducted by aliens! :D

Glassofshloer · 10/10/2021 19:44

Also @mummyh2016 your post explains the criteria for the MLU, but not why the facilities need to be better?

OP posts:
Barbie222 · 10/10/2021 19:37

@JoborPlay

I couldn't have given a fuck.
Me neither. Planning fairy lights and candles is a displacement activity. Better to get used to putting your own wishes at the bottom of the pile!
Glassofshloer · 10/10/2021 19:36

Then you've posted saying some births that the NHS categorises as high risk aren't which implies to me that you think those should be allowed on an MLU, and I've advised the reason why your examples would not be allowed on an MLU

Sorry if I confused you, what I meant with my ‘GD / first time mum’ example was to show how things like birth pools can still be made good use of on the CDU as well as the MLU. If that makes sense. Plus if CDU women are in the room longer, they deserve nicer surroundings more IMO! Lol

OP posts:
mummyh2016 · 10/10/2021 19:33

@Glassofshloer but you're complaining that the facilities aren't the same. I've explained in another post why they aren't the same. Then you've posted saying some births that the NHS categorises as high risk aren't which implies to me that you think those should be allowed on an MLU, and I've advised the reason why your examples would not be allowed on an MLU Confused I'm confused now!
It would be fantastic if every room on a delivery suite had all the equipment for a high risk birth as well as a double bed, mood lighting and a birth pool. Please see my earlier post regarding the lighting that was brought in at a hospital near me, it wouldn't be hard for patients to arrange that themselves if that's what they wanted. Unfortunately though if people expect a double bed and birthing pool in every room (can I add my MLU only have pools in 3 out of 5 rooms and don't actually have double beds) the rooms would need to be double the size. Which would then mean half the number of rooms - you already hear people complaining they are stuck on the labour ward when they are on the verge of pushing due to no beds, it would be horrendous if every hospital had half the number of beds they currently have.

JoborPlay · 10/10/2021 19:24

I couldn't have given a fuck.

mayblossominapril · 10/10/2021 19:23

I agree we wouldn’t need mlu if labour wards had better rooms. I didn’t mind the medical equipment and I laboured in the bed as there was no where else to go. A bigger room would have been amazing.