Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Low risk women/better birth facilities - unfair?

481 replies

Glassofshloer · 10/10/2021 16:45

When DD was a baby we attended a breastfeeding appointment at my local stand-alone birth centre and WOW! To say it was gorgeous is an understatement - double bed, huge whirlpool bath thing, fairy lights and bouncy balls in every room. Looked like the Ritz compared to the tiny, dimly lit room on the CDU where I gave birth. Just a bed and some wall stickers of flowers Confused

AIBU to think this is unfair on high risk/Consultant led women? And that we all deserve equal facilities, high risk or not? Fully prepared to be told IABU!

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 11/10/2021 04:18

I am also not into fairy lights and mood music. And I'm not at all, not sure of word.

Ante natal relax low lights breathe etc. Got on my tits totally.

Horses for courses.

NiceGerbil · 11/10/2021 04:15

Hosps have limited space and resources.

If I was high risk I'd rather have the full medical shebang on hand.

I chose to go hosp.

In the end it went badly.

Midwife was totally useless.

Baby in distress, meconium, I knew it was wrong. Vomiting, pain like knives twisting inside. And worse than the pain was the intense knowing that something was just really wrong.

Eventually she got doc. One look at readouts one look at me. 2 mins. EMCS decision. 10 mins later in theatre and a good thing too.

That's just me though. I feel v comfy in hosps and trust docs generally.

Midwife was so awful it was mind boggling.

My experience others have different.

SmellyOldOwls · 11/10/2021 04:01

It is a bit shit giving birth in hospital. But it's about safety i suppose. If you're high risk you're safer on a ward where the staff can keep an eye on you post birth and I guess it's less intrusive for them to waft past your bay occasionally and discreetly look on on you both than come in and out of a side room constantly.

Your comment about the mum with GD not really being high risk doesn't make sense - mum may or may not not need interventions but with GD the baby definitely needs to have doctors on hand and blood sugar monitoring post birth at the very least.

I think most people accept that while the lovely rooms and atmosphere in MLU would be much nicer and more conducive to an easy birth, hospitals just don't have the room for all of that or the resources to staff and clean all of those individuals rooms and additional equipment.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 11/10/2021 03:57

Do fairy lights and double beds make a difference when you’re in established labour?

I gave birth in a small room on Labour ward (I wanted to be close to a theatre with doctors on hand if anything went wrong). Beyond 9cm I don’t think I registered my environment! I can’t imagine thinking about mood lighting or bouncy balls when entering transition. Maybe in the very early stages of labour those play a part (eg helping you relax, the ball stimulating contractions etc) but do women go to the birthing centre in very early labour? I thought you stay home as long as possible like consultant led?

When I had a tour of labour ward they had some rooms with water baths, some active birthing rooms with ropes and mats, mood lighting etc. But when my time came I was lucky to get a room there at all as it was full on arrival.

I had a decent sized en suite room, clean, clinical yes but then it’s a hospital! There was access to a midwife all the time, gas&air, diamorphine, the option to request an epidural. My baby was back to back and a tricky presentation so I’m glad I was in hospital not stuck in a stand alone unit waiting to be blue lighted to hospital.

Aorh · 11/10/2021 03:19

I wasn’t high risk, but after lots of losses, I ended up opting for MLU so I was close to docs if needed (no reason to think they would be. God, I wanted the local, homely maternity hospital, but I ended up deciding I wanted that safety net more. I really wish I could have had both, but I had fantastic care, which is the most important bit.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 11/10/2021 02:22

I think the “fairy lights and mood music” comments can go to hell, frankly. DD1 was MLU. This time round I gave birth (c section via induction) in delivery/wards - 12 hours ago. Having an induction absolutely set me on a track to an intervention-heavy birth. The noise, the lack of privacy, lack of space, assumption that I’d blithely agree to everything the staff suggested even though I knew statistically how it’d go. I had to fight my corner, repeatedly. The the postnatal ward - people alongside me are fairly considerate but I’m in a pool of my blood, catheter still in, buzzer responded to v slowly, not mobilised, unable to pick up my babies, tired. So much to improve upon here and fairy lights don’t crack the top 10.

inpixiehollow · 11/10/2021 02:05

I had my first daughter in a midwife led birth centre, no complications, a lovely calm water birth with just gas & air. I will say however that my birth centre didn't have proper beds and I stayed there post-natally for a night.. not great falling asleep whilst breastfeeding on a beanbag! Anyways, I'm now pregnant with baby no2 and have argued my right to birth in the birth centre even though this time I'm considered 'high risk' due to blood clotting disorder. I'm purely wanting it because of the opportunity for a calmer birth and use of the pool again, I have agreed to be transferred to maternity for careful monitoring post-natally though. My consultant has somewhat reluctantly agreed to allow me at least the opportunity to birth in the birth centre, so my advice would be to fight for it if you feel strongly that the labour ward isn't the best place for you.

chinateapot · 11/10/2021 00:07

It’s the postnatal care that gets me. For DD1 I looked round the lovely standalone MLU and heard all about the private rooms for after delivery where birthing partner could stay too and where there were more midwives available to offer support.
Thankfully I decided not to deliver there as I developed sepsis in labour, had an emergency section, baby needed resus and SCBU and I then had a 7 litre bleed and ITU admission. I was so traumatised and, once well enough, really could have done with one of those private rooms where we could have recovered and had some additional support. But no, busy ward for me and zero help.

2littleboyzmum · 11/10/2021 00:03

I got a decent sized delivery room with my first baby however I was in too much pain to care about the fact I had space or a radio or even what was on the walls as I'd arrived at 8cm's dilated didn't even get seen first just whizzed into delivery as I was trying to push then sent to theatre to get him out with a ventouse thing. The second baby It was a ga section so was in a side room on post natal with three other beds with women in and I walked up to theatre and then was wheeled back down so other than recovery I didn't see much and I felt very closed off behind a curtain compared to the side room on post natal I had to myself with my first after I'd been moved down from the delivery suite.

Hamtonn · 10/10/2021 23:44

Hamtonn then pay for a private room or private labour
Why should I when they give private rooms for free to the low risk mums.

Whstdoyouthink · 10/10/2021 23:38

@Hamtonn then pay for a private room or private labour

In the vast majority of midwife centres your transferred from that beautiful room to a labour ward post giving birth…you don’t get to stay in it as they need it for someone who is about to give birth.

MelKarnofskyCrane · 10/10/2021 23:38

Your husband doesn’t need a bed ffs.

Hamtonn · 10/10/2021 23:33

I don’t care about aesthetics either. But I do care about being taken out of a private room with a private loo and shoved in a ward with no privacy and no bed for my DH. It’s unfair - if anything I needed MORE space, privacy and support as a high risk mother, not less.

Whstdoyouthink · 10/10/2021 23:32

Right, well putting aside the fairy lights

You must surely understand the practicalities of not having a bath in a medical room or even a double bed when doctors and nurses need access to you and your baby. It sounds like you had a straight forward delivery in a labour ward, I had 7 medical staff around me at one point (very thankful there wasn’t a bath or a double bed in the way)

Glassofshloer · 10/10/2021 23:26

[quote Whstdoyouthink]@Hamtonn but in either a midwife or labour ward there should be a certain standard

The point raised by OP was the aesthetics between the two and my point is I really don’t care about aesthetics. Safe delivery of my baby I cared about not the colour of walls of lighting[/quote]
That wasn’t my point at all. My point was about the facilities, not whether the walls are painted the right colour. Of course it matters that women have equal access to good facilities to make their experience more pleasant.

OP posts:
Whstdoyouthink · 10/10/2021 23:22

@Hamtonn but in either a midwife or labour ward there should be a certain standard

The point raised by OP was the aesthetics between the two and my point is I really don’t care about aesthetics. Safe delivery of my baby I cared about not the colour of walls of lighting

Hamtonn · 10/10/2021 23:17

Meh so don’t care what it looks like as long as I have good care
But I would say having access to private facilities is part of having good care. It’s not good care if I have to walk past random blokes in a blood covered nightie today get to the loo.

Whstdoyouthink · 10/10/2021 23:15

Meh so don’t care what it looks like as long as I have good care

MelKarnofskyCrane · 10/10/2021 23:10

I was taken out of the pool in the beautiful MLU and made to go into the Labour suite when I couldn’t pee.

I was gutted. I would have clung to the door if I’d had the energy.

Hardbackwriter · 10/10/2021 22:41

In my experience most high risk moms priority is getting their baby delivered safety not the decor of the room.

That was my priority in both my births - of course it was - but I don't know why that means I have to pretend that I didn't notice that one of them took place in a much nicer and more comfortable room. You can think that the difference is a bit rubbish and unnecessary and care first and foremost about your baby's health.

Hamtonn · 10/10/2021 22:33

Oh I didn’t mind being moved to another room when I became high risk. I just think the second room should have been of the same standard. Not a tiny curtained cubicle with nowhere for my husband to sleep.

EnidFrighten · 10/10/2021 22:30

It's insane. Women's needs are made to fit around buildings and staff, not vice versa. Why can't all women give birth in rooms with nice lights, yoga balls and midwives but if something goes wrong, midwives hand over to consultants and the monitors etc come out of the cupboards? Without birthing women having to go anywhere.

Hamtonn · 10/10/2021 22:30

In my experience most high risk moms priority is getting their baby delivered safety not the decor of the room
And what about after I gave birth? I was in hospital for two days. Why couldn’t I be in a nice private room with a bed for my husband? If they can offer that to mums who’ve had a natural birth then they should offer it to everyone. There’s nothing about a c section that means you don’t need privacy or kitchen facilities or a bed for your husband. If anything you need it more!

Hamtonn · 10/10/2021 22:22

I was admitted to a lovely midwife centre with individual rooms, private shower and toilet, double bed and a sofa for guests that pulled out into a sofa bed for the father, my own tv and music system, and access to a shared kitchen with coffee facilities and free ready meals to use as required.

They rushed me out of there for a c section. After I left the theatre they put me on a ward with 15 other women and their partners, only separated by curtains. No privacy or safety. Constant noise. A single hospital bed and chair, nowhere for my husband to sleep. No tv, no music, no sofa. A single shared toilet and shower which meant I had to repeatedly make the walk of shame past strangers whilst wearing a hospital gown and leaking blood. No kitchen facilities, not even for a cuppa never mind food.

I gave birth at 1am and my husband said to the nurses if you can’t provide food and drink can you at least take me back to the midwife centre to use their kitchen and get a ready meal? They said no. He had to go out and fetch me a takeaway!

Honestly I see no reason why I couldn’t have been taken back to an equally lovely private room after my c section. I felt like a second class citizen. I’d understand if the NHS didn’t provide that level of care for anyone, but they are clearly able to offer it in the midwife centre. It’s incredibly unfair.

helpthewhos · 10/10/2021 21:46

Yep, its virtually impossible to get in my local midwife led stand alone unit, and yet there are midwives there doing nothing while you are lucky if you can find a midwife on labour ward. One of the reasons I would never have another baby is just how appalling the 'care' was after the birth of my last child. And that was pre-covid. IMO they should fully fund proper care in hospitals, but if they really can't do that, close the picture postcard stand alone MLUs and redeploy the staff where they can be more useful.