Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Low risk women/better birth facilities - unfair?

481 replies

Glassofshloer · 10/10/2021 16:45

When DD was a baby we attended a breastfeeding appointment at my local stand-alone birth centre and WOW! To say it was gorgeous is an understatement - double bed, huge whirlpool bath thing, fairy lights and bouncy balls in every room. Looked like the Ritz compared to the tiny, dimly lit room on the CDU where I gave birth. Just a bed and some wall stickers of flowers Confused

AIBU to think this is unfair on high risk/Consultant led women? And that we all deserve equal facilities, high risk or not? Fully prepared to be told IABU!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LemonSwan · 14/10/2021 18:31

@gwenneh

Thanks for your insight. The private rooms sound lovely!

Sorry to hear about your experiences with DC2.

I am actually pregnant at the moment and have picked the MLU attached to the hospital. I actually designed those suites so will be interesting to test them out and I hope it all goes smoothly. I am very aware nearly 50% of FTM end up being transferred and its slightly terrifying we will be there without doctors. But equally its probably partly the doctors who rush to medicalise IYSWIM. Fingers crossed.

cabinfever102 · 14/10/2021 18:08

@GemmaRuby

I do see your point. But it’s hard to make a medicalised room look pretty without getting in the way of the wires etc. And clinical space is always sparse in hospitals so the rooms are small.

I started my labour in MLU and was transferred to labour ward just before the end. I would never give birth in a standalone MLU - it was bad enough being transferred along a corridor and up a floor - would hate to be transferred from another site.

By that point I really did not care what the room looked like.

My exact experience. I spent most of MLU time with a blanket over my head so really was not appreciating the ambience and then screamed for epidural snd they moved me down to labour ward... honestly post natal facilities bothered me more. That was hell. Especially as we couldn't get out for 5 days.
gwenneh · 14/10/2021 18:02

It would be interesting to know what the private birthing suites for high risk women are like. Do they offer all the emergency care equipment in the suite - so a combination of an MLU birthing suite and a treatment room.

I've given birth at two private hospitals under consultant-led care. Both were c-sections, one emergent after spontaneous labour and one planned. I have been classed as high risk in all of my pregnanices.

In the private hospital, the emergency care equipment is present but tucked away -- think wall port hidden behind paintings, machines in fitted cupboards, etc. There were hospital style beds, more adjustable than the NHS one but that really IS down to lottery I think. Aromatherapy options were available, the lights were controlled by a touch pad on the bed and only the lights the consultant used for examination were fluorescent. Those were only on during active examinations. Birthing balls, bands, and supports were all provided on request but admittedly I asked for an epidural quite early with my first! Private bathroom but as I wasn't going to be getting anywhere near a birthing pool at any time I did not have that suite (I don't know if they assign that particular one in high risk cases.) There was a sofa that converted to a bed for DH and several comfortable chairs, different styles, probably to help figure out the best nursing positions. The physical surroundings could not have been more different than the NHS high-risk labour room.

After the surgery DH and I were provided with a "celebratory meal for two" with champagne. I think we ordered chicken piccata. Both private hospitals had lactation consultants who came around and the first time we actually extended our hospital stay by a day to get an extra day to work with her. (I don't know if this is the case in the NHS hospital -- DS2 was in the SCBU and I was on the ward alone.) The first hospital also provided "mum's services" so post-natal massage, mani and pedi were provided.

And yes, a lot of that is "fluff", but it is fluff that is provided regardless of risk. Manicures and champagne are great but the real things I remember are not being stuck in a tiny, fluorescent lit room with no access to birthing aids during labour and then after the birth, sitting upright in a hard plastic chair in the SCBU to try to nurse a situation that made it very, very difficult to even hold my son, let alone sort out breast feeding. Having to recover on a ward is fine, but I could barely get out of bed and there was no one to even wheel me down to the SCBU to see my son. Couldn't get a breast pump. I wound up walking myself it took hours and I bled everywhere, but I was going to hold my baby. I suffered from PND quite badly with DS2, needed medication and on balance I think it changed me profoundly as a person -- things have never been quite the same since.

And I don't think it had to be that way,.

mummyh2016 · 14/10/2021 17:37

@Glassofshloer

I would hazard a guess that your birth likely cost the NHS more than mine did.

Exactly. Good facilities and lowering the chance of intervention is in everyone’s best interests in terms of cost.

I hugely doubt that being on there played any part in the cost of my birth - except maybe I would've had an epidural on the delivery suite which I obviously couldn't have on the MLU. The birthing pool did next to nothing for me, and I didn't have a double bed that you've been banging on about. But hey that doesn't suit your narrative does it Smile
LemonSwan · 14/10/2021 17:28

Sorry to ask again but presumably medical staff feel they can deal with medical emergencies in MLUs just fine?

Hi OP , sorry I was working.

I am not a doctor/ midwife so dont know exactly what emergencies they can and cant deal with.

But I do know its akin to emergency 'first aid' - the same as a midwife would do at a home birth while the ambulance comes or if in an adjoining MLU before/when you get wheeled to the adjoining labour ward.

Their are no doctors, no anaesthetists, no neonatal intensive care etc.

You can only have gas and air and opiates - no epidurals etc.

It would be interesting to know what the private birthing suites for high risk women are like. Do they offer all the emergency care equipment in the suite - so a combination of an MLU birthing suite and a treatment room.

Or are they just private MLUs and if shit hits the fan they transfer you to a hospital?

JoborPlay · 14/10/2021 16:53

@Glassofshloer

Of course *@JoborPlay*

But there seems to be a real cascade of intervention - one (reasonably minor) condition, let’s say marginally high blood pressure or asthma, leads to CDU. Which means no pool & time pressures. Which means more likely to need a theatre/instrumental delivery. Which means more likely to have PND or birth injuries. Which means more likely a repeat c-section etc. An on it goes.

Of course any woman that requests a c section should have one, I don’t think they should need to make a case for it as long as they understand the risks.

But looking back, had I been sent to the MLU after having my waters broken (or been given the same treatment as an MLU mum rather), there’s every chance I would’ve had a much better birth and taken up less NHS resources in the process.

Despite making normal and good labour progress, they decided to put me on a syntocin drip. Looking back it’s plainly obvious that they did it to speed me up because they wanted the room back (it was so busy I had to wait 3 days on the induction ward for a room to begin with!!). But the drip meant I needed an epidural, which meant I had to lie on the bed & couldn’t feel to push, a very long second stage, huge tearing where I had been forcing it, an infection, further doctor time and antibiotics to treat it etc.

Of course that may have happened had they put me in a pool and left me to it, but the facts suggest being upright & in water reduce the length of second stage and tearing etc.

The current system seems to benefit nobody, not mothers, not NHS staff and not the taxpayer.

Argh sorry, thinking back it annoys me so much!! 😆

I had the opposite experience to you, I was high risk due placenta placement but down graded to low risk after a late scan. I had a very hands off, in the pool labour and absolutely hated it. I'd done all the birth preparation, hypnobirthing stuff and was really in to having a natural delivery etc. But when it came to it, all I wanted was people telling me what to do and when! I wanted a drip, I wanted medical intervention. I felt the MLU was basically abandoning me (they weren't, they just let you get on with it and quietly observe). It was actually an extremely traumatic experience for me. With my second I opted for the most medicalised birth I could - a c section. And it was amazing!
Glassofshloer · 14/10/2021 16:22

I would hazard a guess that your birth likely cost the NHS more than mine did.

Exactly. Good facilities and lowering the chance of intervention is in everyone’s best interests in terms of cost.

OP posts:
mummyh2016 · 14/10/2021 16:16

[quote Glassofshloer]@mummyh2016

I don’t think you ever did answer when I asked if you know how it sounds when you enjoyed the MLU at all of our expense, yet dismiss this facilities as unimportant for other people?

Why is there money for your experience, but not ours?[/quote]
And in relation to your comment about there being money for my experience and not yours, I would hazard a guess that your birth likely cost the NHS more than mine did.

mummyh2016 · 14/10/2021 16:15

@Glassofshloer because writing back to you is like talking to a brick wall, it's pointless and you disregard 90% of what I put!
I wouldn't say I enjoyed it, it's a bit of a weird phrase as I doubt anyone enjoys labour. And the likelihood with this pregnancy is that I probably won't be able to use it and will have to go to the main delivery suite which is okay. In my last labour I couldn't have cared where I was, I just wanted baby out. And if I'm in the main delivery suite I get drugs so win win Wink let's see you pull this post apart now.

Glassofshloer · 14/10/2021 15:32

Of course @JoborPlay

But there seems to be a real cascade of intervention - one (reasonably minor) condition, let’s say marginally high blood pressure or asthma, leads to CDU. Which means no pool & time pressures. Which means more likely to need a theatre/instrumental delivery. Which means more likely to have PND or birth injuries. Which means more likely a repeat c-section etc. An on it goes.

Of course any woman that requests a c section should have one, I don’t think they should need to make a case for it as long as they understand the risks.

But looking back, had I been sent to the MLU after having my waters broken (or been given the same treatment as an MLU mum rather), there’s every chance I would’ve had a much better birth and taken up less NHS resources in the process.

Despite making normal and good labour progress, they decided to put me on a syntocin drip. Looking back it’s plainly obvious that they did it to speed me up because they wanted the room back (it was so busy I had to wait 3 days on the induction ward for a room to begin with!!). But the drip meant I needed an epidural, which meant I had to lie on the bed & couldn’t feel to push, a very long second stage, huge tearing where I had been forcing it, an infection, further doctor time and antibiotics to treat it etc.

Of course that may have happened had they put me in a pool and left me to it, but the facts suggest being upright & in water reduce the length of second stage and tearing etc.

The current system seems to benefit nobody, not mothers, not NHS staff and not the taxpayer.

Argh sorry, thinking back it annoys me so much!! 😆

OP posts:
JoborPlay · 14/10/2021 15:16

@Glassofshloer

Plus when you think about it, one Caesarian is very likely to lead to another, so if the first one can be avoided through better care, wouldn’t this save maternity services a shit ton of money?
Maybe. But some women want c sections, and they shouldn't be denied.

And the avoidance of a c section can lead to different complications and expenses.

Glassofshloer · 14/10/2021 14:57

Plus when you think about it, one Caesarian is very likely to lead to another, so if the first one can be avoided through better care, wouldn’t this save maternity services a shit ton of money?

OP posts:
Glassofshloer · 14/10/2021 14:54

As the op (midwife) stated, better facilities lead to better outcomes which would decrease the need for expensive theatre time. It’s just paying more later to avoid paying less now. And I refuse to believe after wasting 500 million on test & trace that there is ‘no money’ for better healthcare.

OP posts:
Bizawit · 14/10/2021 14:53

There’s all kinds of crap in hospitals. Ultimately it’s about priorities and what is seen as important and what is seen as trivial. Apparently women’s subjective well-being is a trivial and irrelevant concern to the birthing process as far as the medical establishment are concerned.

Glassofshloer · 14/10/2021 14:52

It’s amazing how women who had great facilities & experiences bang on about how there is ‘no money’ for other people’s 🙄

OP posts:
Bizawit · 14/10/2021 14:51

@LemonSwan

I used to design MLU and hospital rooms.

The design parameters are to the mm. You have more leigh way in a MLU.

No one wants a birthing ball bouncing round when someones crashing and you have a million people running round a room.

Oh give over. That’s a pathetic and thin excuse.
Glassofshloer · 14/10/2021 14:49

@mummyh2016

I don’t think you ever did answer when I asked if you know how it sounds when you enjoyed the MLU at all of our expense, yet dismiss this facilities as unimportant for other people?

Why is there money for your experience, but not ours?

OP posts:
mummyh2016 · 14/10/2021 14:00

@LemonSwan

Its not that simple.

All rooms need to be a maximum distance from a nursing station, doctors offices and other ancillary rooms - wait rooms, lounges, clean and dirty sluices etc.

You increase the sizes of rooms, and you need more additional rooms, and more staff to man those rooms.

You also need a bigger building. As you usually have room, corridor, room. So this needs to correspond with other room sizes in the hospital, as otherwise you have a floor which doesnt match the other floors.

Larger rooms in hospitals are usually the scanning rooms, so a birthing suite might fit with those, but you cant have general rooms around scanning rooms because as MRI machine can lift a small car, or decapitate someone wearing a necklace.

You would not believe the design that goes into hospitals. They are about efficiency. And no ones trying to be mean. Its not just cost efficiency, its speed efficiency - time to get people from one place to another, across a room, equipment around etc.

Quite often now they are trying to build MLUs attached to hospitals. So its best of both worlds. If you have the option I would suggest this.

You're wasting your time. I've tried explaining that to have all of these things on a delivery suite will require larger rooms, which will either mean less rooms in total or new hospitals being built. Less rooms won't work as the majority of hospitals already have too few beds and it is completely unrealistic to expect new hospitals to be built when the NHS (to put it bluntly) is fucked. There's no point in keep saying it as people on here read what they want. I am sympathetic however I'm a realist, I don't know if other posters would rather the birthing centres closed altogether and made everyone go down the main delivery suite route, as that is the only realistic way I can see the same amenities being offered to both high risk and low risk women, so rather than everyone getting double beds/birthing pools etc then no one gets it.
Glassofshloer · 14/10/2021 13:40

That said I have gained a lot of valuable information about my rights when it comes to my next birth, so I’m feeling more confident I can insist upon making my own choices (within reason). Which hopefully means a gentle induction and the pool!

OP posts:
Glassofshloer · 14/10/2021 13:37

I don’t doubt that @LemonSwan and I know it would be very expensive to put these things right. But that doesn’t stop me from wanting them to. I won’t get what I’m asking for but I can still say it’s unfair.

Sorry to ask again but presumably medical staff feel they can deal with medical emergencies in MLUs just fine?

OP posts:
LemonSwan · 14/10/2021 13:35

Its not that simple.

All rooms need to be a maximum distance from a nursing station, doctors offices and other ancillary rooms - wait rooms, lounges, clean and dirty sluices etc.

You increase the sizes of rooms, and you need more additional rooms, and more staff to man those rooms.

You also need a bigger building. As you usually have room, corridor, room. So this needs to correspond with other room sizes in the hospital, as otherwise you have a floor which doesnt match the other floors.

Larger rooms in hospitals are usually the scanning rooms, so a birthing suite might fit with those, but you cant have general rooms around scanning rooms because as MRI machine can lift a small car, or decapitate someone wearing a necklace.

You would not believe the design that goes into hospitals. They are about efficiency. And no ones trying to be mean. Its not just cost efficiency, its speed efficiency - time to get people from one place to another, across a room, equipment around etc.

Quite often now they are trying to build MLUs attached to hospitals. So its best of both worlds. If you have the option I would suggest this.

Glassofshloer · 14/10/2021 13:29

@Franca123

This was the impression I had from the obstetrician who objected to the idea candles should be on Labour wards. In an emergency they need quick access to everything. They can't have crap in the way.
Why would some battery operated tea lights on a windowsill be in the way? Confused

I will repeat, what happens in an obstetric emergency in the MLU? Placental abruption etc can happen to anyone and have presumably happened in MLUs. Did all the medical staff fall in the pool or trip over the ball trying to get to the woman?

OP posts:
Glassofshloer · 14/10/2021 13:27

@LemonSwan

I used to design MLU and hospital rooms.

The design parameters are to the mm. You have more leigh way in a MLU.

No one wants a birthing ball bouncing round when someones crashing and you have a million people running round a room.

So make the room bigger to give medics some space in case there is an emergency? It would also give the woman more space to move around during labour, so win-win. I really don’t believe that having a ball or pool in the room would result in a pile-up of medical staff if the room was sufficiently spacious with room around the bed.
OP posts:
Franca123 · 14/10/2021 13:26

This was the impression I had from the obstetrician who objected to the idea candles should be on Labour wards. In an emergency they need quick access to everything. They can't have crap in the way.

LemonSwan · 14/10/2021 13:22

I used to design MLU and hospital rooms.

The design parameters are to the mm. You have more leigh way in a MLU.

No one wants a birthing ball bouncing round when someones crashing and you have a million people running round a room.