Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder what people don't like about Chris Packham?

265 replies

MRex · 10/10/2021 16:14

Obviously people actually setting fire to his gates are plain lunatics: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-58861252. The article talks about all these other online threats, dead animals and other mischief however, which implies a fair number of individuals who expend time and energy going after him. He's just an environmentalist campaigner who wants a bit more wild space, a few beavers introduced, fewer birds shot... he isn't a man of great power. So what do these people fear so much?

OP posts:
Jemimapuddleduk · 10/10/2021 22:00

I admired CP and his anti hunting stance.
However he was an ambassador for the controversial Spectrum 10k project which has recently been pulled thank god. He also
describes himself as Aspergers which many in the autistic community find controversial and upsetting.
Not linking here but all very easily google able.

Porcupineintherough · 10/10/2021 21:57

@elbea I object to pheasant shooting not because the pheasants get shot but because they are dumped in the countryside in vastly inflated numbers and do untold damage to the local ecosystem before some inadequate with a shotgun blasts them out of the sky.

HesterShaw1 · 10/10/2021 21:49

As for deer culling, that's again another issue caused by lack of wild predators. Healthy ecosystems need predators to function.

In the absence of natural predators, a cull is unfortunately necessary.

Read what happened in Yellowstone after a small pack of wolves was reintroduced.

HesterShaw1 · 10/10/2021 21:46

@elbea

His views of the countryside aren’t compatible with farming. Generally, I think people who work and manage the countryside think he’s a bit of a moron. Chris Packham’s pressure group forced the government to revoke permission for farmers to shoot birds like crows on their farms with a legal challenge. Crows rip lambs and sheep to pieces, they peck out their eyes and intestines whilst the sheep are alive and farmers could do nothing about it. They couldn’t shoot pigeons eating their crops. Natural England did a swift u-turn but it was directly Chris Packhams fault.

I have friends that shoot, hunt and fish. I can’t really understand how people can get upset about shooting pheasants that are then eaten when people eat meat. Chris Packham writes in BBC Publications about how nasty anybody who shoots or fishes is. He consistently targets people who feed this country and presents his ideas as fact to people on TV. These people then accept his views as fact when it usually isn’t the reality of farming but they then put pressure on farmers.

People who shoot pheasants and anglers don't "feed this country".

I take your point about farmers, but to be honest, much of the lack of biodiversity and environmental degradation is because of large scale agribusiness.

I know there are no easy answers, especially when you have a population who have become accustomed to really cheap food.

Just to reiterate, there are plenty of us who live in "the countryside" who think that Packham has a point, and shouldn't have to shut up just because farmers and landowners don't like what he says.

Rubyupbeat · 10/10/2021 21:43

I really dislike him. Weird thing is, I agree with most of his ideals, I just find him a total attention seeker.

MRex · 10/10/2021 21:40

It's good to see a range of opinions here. The answers have helped me to see what it is that people find challenging about him, thank you all for contributing. It's clear that a small proportion of people feel offended largely by his manner of speaking about those who pursue certain activities. I think I'd just broadly agreed with him so it hadn't occurred to me that anyone would get precious about his choice of words.

OP posts:
Griselda1 · 10/10/2021 21:39

Probably because he's uncompromising in his views and relentless at pursuing those who think it's ok to murder innocent animals.

elbea · 10/10/2021 21:36

His views of the countryside aren’t compatible with farming. Generally, I think people who work and manage the countryside think he’s a bit of a moron. Chris Packham’s pressure group forced the government to revoke permission for farmers to shoot birds like crows on their farms with a legal challenge. Crows rip lambs and sheep to pieces, they peck out their eyes and intestines whilst the sheep are alive and farmers could do nothing about it. They couldn’t shoot pigeons eating their crops. Natural England did a swift u-turn but it was directly Chris Packhams fault.

I have friends that shoot, hunt and fish. I can’t really understand how people can get upset about shooting pheasants that are then eaten when people eat meat. Chris Packham writes in BBC Publications about how nasty anybody who shoots or fishes is. He consistently targets people who feed this country and presents his ideas as fact to people on TV. These people then accept his views as fact when it usually isn’t the reality of farming but they then put pressure on farmers.

Scoutingformygirls · 10/10/2021 21:24

I grew up in the countryside, spent my whole childhood climbing haystacks, driving tractors, riding ponies, keeping poultry, helping with lambing, running free and wild and completely surrounded by farmers, small holders and villagers. No one I knew took part in blood sports nor had much interest in supporting them.

I now live in a different part of the country, in an even more deeply rural community. Again, zero support for bloodsports here.

It's such a weird way of pulling rank to suggest that all those of us who aren't keen on hunting are in someway lacking in our rural credentials.

I grew up watching The Really Wild Show and loved it. I really like CP. Even if none of the above was true, I'd still be horrified by what he has been subjected to.

CounsellorTroi · 10/10/2021 21:20

@ExtraOnions

He doesn’t hate Pandas … his point was, why have millions been spent in order to stop them going extinct, whilst at the same time hundreds of other species have gone extinct without anyone batting an eyelid. Why do we spend all that money on one species … who don’t really bring much to the planet, instead of protecting the insects that are vital for our biodiversity? It’s a good point
His point re Pandas was that they were going down an evolutionary cul de sac entirely of their own accord. Nothing to do with humans destroying their habitat or anything like that. In terms of survival of the fittest they weren’t that fit. And I think he had a point.
Porcupineintherough · 10/10/2021 21:10

He campaigns not just against blood sports but against all the hypocrisy and simple law breaking that goes along with them (the illegal persecution of raptors over grouse moors fi). So he has enemies in high places and with deep pockets.

Cluelessasacucumber · 10/10/2021 21:06

Country dweller, born, bred, work. I've met him a couple of times and a have friends/colleagues who know him better. He is kind, funny and articulate. Not everyone clicks with him but surely that's to be expected? Across the world environmentalist and conservationsist are persecuted, publically vilified and murdered. People do not like hearing they are wrong, or that they need to change, or that their power, money and influence is under threat, or having their self identity as a "good" person challenged. People are scared of the situation we are in, so they shoot the messager - it's as simple as that.

www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-58508001.amp

thingreenline.org.uk/

WeatherwaxOn · 10/10/2021 20:58

@Boood

I can’t stand him. He hates cats and pandas.

Setting fire to his property, however, is absolutely disgusting and not in any way excused because he’s unlikeable.

I don't think he hates pandas but they are a species that hasn't and cannot adapt to a fast changing environment and therefore the unpalatable truth is that it is a waste of money protecting them. As die for his views on cats, I am a cat lover but I have only ever had house cats as they're murderous bastards.

He doesn't sugar coat what he says. He is autistic. He speaks his views without any frills.
I like him. What you see is what you get.
It is rare to meet people that uphold passionate views and have the courage of their convictions.

somewhereoverthechipshop · 10/10/2021 20:52

I like him. Always fancied him!

StoneofDestiny · 10/10/2021 20:51

I'd rather live next to Packham than the vandals who attack his property and try and bully him to stop promoting his causes.
He is a good man.

birkenstuck · 10/10/2021 20:37

I love Chris. A good man.

ExtraOnions · 10/10/2021 20:32

When I worked at the BBC, I knew plenty of people on Springwatch … nobody had a bad word to say.

Also met him personally, perfectly nice

Megan2018 · 10/10/2021 20:25

[quote BeagleBeagled]@Megan2018 can you give a reason why you think he is an absolute arsehole? Do you know him well?[/quote]
My DH worked in TV production. He’s not nice to work with.

WeatherwaxLives · 10/10/2021 19:22

He's also pro badger / anti cull, which is a really really divisive topic.

Why is that such a divisive topic?

Very few people agree that a natural ancient population ( badgers) should be culled to go through the motions of protecting an artificial, inherently unstable population (cattle) - which is in fact too large, homogenous and artificial to ever be stabilised anyway-

Even people who want to kill badgers to attempt some negligible and much disputed protection to cattle can clearly see why people disagree

You'd think, wouldn't you? But in my experience many people with anything to do with the beef/dairy industry just will not apply logic and would rather badgers were completely exterminated.

I place the majority of the blame with the government (all of them, not just the current one) for completely refusing to consider alternatives to culling and the completey unreliable bTB cattle test.

In my experience anyone telling a dairy/beef farmer they're anti badger cull is treated as though they are personally infecting cattle with bTB left right and centre. It's emotive, on both sides, and that never results in civilised debate.

I genuinely never mention badgers in any social situation as it will cause arguments even between close friends.

DecadentlyDecisive · 10/10/2021 19:18

@Megan2018

He’s an absolute arsehole. But he shouldn’t have his gates set on fire for that. I disagree most of what he says, as do the majority of people that live in the countryside. He’s an extremist. He also loves the attention.
This.

He jumps on whatever platform suits him & isn't consistent....

He's quite happy for deer to be culled in Scotland, but campaigned against crows and other corvids being shot as vermin, despite the damage they wreak on songbirds and lambs.

kookplanv · 10/10/2021 19:14

I live in the countryside and I agree with him completely.

3scape · 10/10/2021 18:56

@Lonelycrab knitting used to be a sport (judged on speed accuracy and quality) I was watching a thing about it.

But bloodsports. Well they're just murderous cowardly bastards, who like to demonstrate that they are quite willing to turn on people when they don't get their way. Definitely not sporting people, they prefer unfair advantage.

ChessieFL · 10/10/2021 18:46

I like Chris. His recent programme walking along the river talking about his childhood and autism was so moving. I don’t necessarily agree with everything he says, but he doesn’t deserve attacks to his property.

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/10/2021 18:44

He hates cats and pandas.

Pandas are lazy, entitled cunts.🐼

HesterShaw1 · 10/10/2021 18:41

Apolitical to me means "doesn't publicise their party political views".

It doesn't mean "Doesn't campaign to improve nature and biodiversity".

The BBC campaigns all the time. Children in Need, Sport Relief, Comic Relief...all these could be perceived as a dig against failures in government.

Swipe left for the next trending thread