Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder what people don't like about Chris Packham?

265 replies

MRex · 10/10/2021 16:14

Obviously people actually setting fire to his gates are plain lunatics: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-58861252. The article talks about all these other online threats, dead animals and other mischief however, which implies a fair number of individuals who expend time and energy going after him. He's just an environmentalist campaigner who wants a bit more wild space, a few beavers introduced, fewer birds shot... he isn't a man of great power. So what do these people fear so much?

OP posts:
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 11/10/2021 14:28

The Countryside Alliance are a bunch of utterly ruthless, intimidatory thugs - thugs who often (but not always) have the power of social privilege behind them. I've seen first-hand evidence of this and can assure you they could easily put the most violent hunt saboteur in the shade (and those are people who don't exactly have a reputation for moderate views, either).

He's had death threats against himself and his family, dead animals strung up against his property, all from behind a cowardly cloak of anonymity. And still they're not going to stop him doing what he does.
He has integrity and a vast degree of courage, and insists he will not shut up no matter what they throw at him. Plus he's on the spectrum and suffers from sensory overload: he simply doesn't experience the world in the same way as neuro typical people do. He's been very eloquent in talking openly about that topic, as well, primarily I think from altruistic moments and in the hope of helping other people who might feel isolated and branded as the 'weird kid,' as he did.

I find him eloquent, intelligent, passionate, compassionate, and courageous. If the country had a few more like Chris Packham we would be doing alright.

HesterShaw1 · 11/10/2021 13:46

As for him refusing to go to Megan's graduation, I don't remember him doing so "coldly" at all. He knew how hellishly difficult that would have been for him so he said no. IIRC Megan did a degree which was very animal/wildlife focussed, and if he'd attended that he would have been mobbed by student and parent fans. Then he would have shut down and they'd all have gone away complaining about how rude Chris Packham was at their child's graduation.

Why would he have put himself through that? And if Megan didn't mind, why does some random woman on the internet?

HesterShaw1 · 11/10/2021 13:42

[quote CandidaAlbicans2]@DecadentlyDecisive, corvids are not responsible for the lack of song birds. The reasons are the destruction of habitat, lack of chick food due to pesticide use, and non-native predators such as domestic cats. Corvids and song birds have evolved together and were fine until humans fucked things up.[/quote]
Absolutely this.

Why do people think ecosystems suddenly unbalance if it's nothing to do with humans? They have predators and they have prey and they evolved alongside one another

I find it laughable the number of people who go on about "songbirds" as a reason for corvid and pigeon killing being so essential (would they be so concerned if songbirds weren't cute and made a nice noise?)

Fizbosshoes · 11/10/2021 13:31

I agree with most of what he says but I did read an interview with his once where it said we should stop chasing cures for cancer . Having seen both my parents die from cancer, and knowing that one in 2 people will get cancer sorry I can't agree with that. and he said dogs were more intelligent than cats

Otherwise I'm fairly indifferent to him.

Feelingoktoday · 11/10/2021 13:29

I never knew he is autistic. How fabulous is that. What a great role model for autistic children and adults. I think he is great. I think it is disgraceful that anyone who says anything different is now subject to hate.

Egii · 11/10/2021 13:20

I love Chris packham and I loved his program on aspergers especially as a fellow aspie. His step daughter and him have a lovely relationship they talked in that program about what an impact he had on her life. It was clear they loved each other very much, even if he couldn't do things like her graduation (or weddings with his partner) im sure he celebrated privately with her.

Eleganz · 11/10/2021 13:15

There is a reactionary wing of the national trust who presumable intersect with the countryside alliance. They are feeling quite vulnerable at the moment so think that setting fire to TV celebrities properties will win them friends.

The guy is suggesting improving habitat diversity which is the best thing we can do for our environment. A well managed moorland may be biodiverse but it isn't as biodiverse as a range of many habitats that could occupy the same space.

ancientgran · 11/10/2021 13:01

@ThePlumVan

And the way they look and interact with each, they clearly think the world of each other so I think she’s over it Grin
Well isn't he lucky that she is a kinder person than he is.
ancientgran · 11/10/2021 13:00

@Singinginshower

ancientgran There was a programme about him and she was asking, pleading with him to go to her graduation. He just coldly said he wouldn't and apparently he didn't. I can't like him after that, he was so cold and OK maybe he didn't fancy it (I've sat through so many graduations and could do with never doing it again) but he's supposed to be close to her and sometimes we do things for other people. He just seems totally selfish to me

Don't you think his diagnosis is relevant in this situation?

No. He's an adult, he goes to big events he just didn't think her graduation was important enough to him. As adults we all sometimes go and sit through things that are important to our loved ones.
ThePlumVan · 11/10/2021 10:37

And the way they look and interact with each, they clearly think the world of each other so I think she’s over it Grin

Singinginshower · 11/10/2021 10:13

ancientgran
There was a programme about him and she was asking, pleading with him to go to her graduation. He just coldly said he wouldn't and apparently he didn't. I can't like him after that, he was so cold and OK maybe he didn't fancy it (I've sat through so many graduations and could do with never doing it again) but he's supposed to be close to her and sometimes we do things for other people. He just seems totally selfish to me

Don't you think his diagnosis is relevant in this situation?

Carboncheque · 11/10/2021 09:43

The poor things have zero sense of self preservation. I’ve sat in my car on country lanes with half a dozen birds milling in the road in front of me and had to honk the horn and then wind the window down to shoo them out of the way.

QuestionEverythingBaby · 11/10/2021 09:28

And YABVU in making "habitat" into a veb.

Well I obviously meant inhabit much the same as you meant verb!
(I'd like to say I was autocorrected but I'm not sure I was 🤪)

Indecisivelurcher · 11/10/2021 09:09

The best thing for biodiversity is a mosaic of habitats, with all the little niches in between. Not a monoculture of heather managed for grouse. And not coniferous woodland either. Research shows that the habitats with highest biodiversity are also the best for carbon sequestration too. More diversity in our uplands would be great for biodiversity, carbon, and bring about more opportunities for eco tourism, diversifying the economy and increasing access to the countryside beyond a select few.

elbea · 11/10/2021 09:05

@Anycolourwilldo but heather moorlands are one of the rarest habitats in the world, why would we want to plant trees all over it? They are so special that their importance is recognised by the UN and designated as such. Although there are less insects that say woodland, heather moorland is home to very rare species that are only found there such as mountain bumblebees. Moorlands also support very specific breeds of rare birds.

But as Chris Packham has done a petition to get rid of it all, it must be a good idea.

howyalikedemapples · 11/10/2021 09:03

He knows nothing about countryside management, the fact is the most biodiverse landscape you willl find is a well managed grouse moor, by contrast the RSPB reserves have far less red listed species. And yes the RSPB carries out vermin control also. He has a personal agenda and is a very calculating man, not afraid to spread untruths and twist facts to suit his agenda.

chocolateorangeinhaler · 11/10/2021 08:41

I agree with him re the blood sports. I live rurally and the local blood sports brigade are like a bunch of lawless dads army types only fatter and stupider.
The pheasants are hand reared so therefore tame and fat so don't bother flying much. I've heard stories of birds being thrown into the air to make them fly to be shot. Call that sport eh?
The only people who it attracts are entry level middle class men and occasionally their deluded girlfriends who like to think killing hand reared defenseless animals makes them more upper class. It doesn't. It makes any pro blood sport an absolute bell end.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 11/10/2021 08:41

@WeatherwaxLives

He's also pro badger / anti cull, which is a really really divisive topic.

Why is that such a divisive topic?

Very few people agree that a natural ancient population ( badgers) should be culled to go through the motions of protecting an artificial, inherently unstable population (cattle) - which is in fact too large, homogenous and artificial to ever be stabilised anyway-

Even people who want to kill badgers to attempt some negligible and much disputed protection to cattle can clearly see why people disagree

You'd think, wouldn't you? But in my experience many people with anything to do with the beef/dairy industry just will not apply logic and would rather badgers were completely exterminated.

I place the majority of the blame with the government (all of them, not just the current one) for completely refusing to consider alternatives to culling and the completey unreliable bTB cattle test.

In my experience anyone telling a dairy/beef farmer they're anti badger cull is treated as though they are personally infecting cattle with bTB left right and centre. It's emotive, on both sides, and that never results in civilised debate.

I genuinely never mention badgers in any social situation as it will cause arguments even between close friends.

Didn't Monty Don leave Twitter as he mentioned culling and was attacked for it?
littlebilliie · 11/10/2021 08:39

'We need to stop chasing cures for cancer and things like that and start realising that the health of the planet goes beyond the health of human beings.'

This

gogohm · 11/10/2021 08:36

I like him, support him all the way. Was very nice when I met him too. He's so passionate about protecting our wildlife and diversity.

I've lived in the countryside and trust me there are many views not just those of pro hunting types

Anycolourwilldo · 11/10/2021 08:32

*rewilding 😆

Anycolourwilldo · 11/10/2021 08:30

@elbea it's not about rewinding farmland! It's about the baron moorlands where there is no farmland. If left to nature, these should be covered in trees. But the heather is burnt each year so people can hunt. They are not natural habitats.

elbea · 11/10/2021 08:18

@Mybalconyiscracking how do you anticipate that Britain will have food security and we will all eat if we rewild everything?

SaskiaRembrandt · 11/10/2021 08:06

@Pinkprawns

I think it might have something to do with being a sanctimonius prick Grin
Yes, this. I broadly agree with him but still find him insufferable.
HappyTimeTunnelDinosaur · 11/10/2021 07:52

I live in the countryside and have always thought he is brilliant.

Swipe left for the next trending thread