Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder what people don't like about Chris Packham?

265 replies

MRex · 10/10/2021 16:14

Obviously people actually setting fire to his gates are plain lunatics: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-58861252. The article talks about all these other online threats, dead animals and other mischief however, which implies a fair number of individuals who expend time and energy going after him. He's just an environmentalist campaigner who wants a bit more wild space, a few beavers introduced, fewer birds shot... he isn't a man of great power. So what do these people fear so much?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Porcupineintherough · 12/10/2021 14:33

@elbea you can advance search me if you want to although why Id lie about that when there are so many more exciting fantasy careers to choose from Im not quite sure. Hmm

elbea · 12/10/2021 14:31

@Porcupineintherough I bet you are Wink

HesterShaw1 · 12/10/2021 14:23

[quote ancientgran]**@HesterShaw1* Again, why are you so bothered if Megan isn't?*

Again in case you missed it the first time. The OP asked why people disliked him. That's why I dislike him. I'm not that bothered, I've just answered people like you when they have challenged me on why I dislike him. So you might think it was fine, Megan might not be bothered, but he is someone I've never watched on TV until I saw that programme and my reaction was, "What a nasty self centred man." So I dislike him, I answered the question.

Do you want to tell us why you dislike him?[/quote]
Pretty obvious that I don't dislike him!

Or at least, I don't like or dislike him because I don't know him well. I've met him in a work capacity, but both of us were working and I wasn't thinking of whether I liked or disliked him.

I admire him. I think he's a principled man standing up to people who wish him harm, and the environment needs fearless principled people like him.

I think publicly saying you dislike a bloke you've never met based on one thing he said to his stepdaughter who clearly didn't mind herself is a bit pathetic to be honest.

Porcupineintherough · 12/10/2021 13:38

Well Im also an estate manager and know many estate managers and my experience has been quite different to yours certainly.

elbea · 12/10/2021 13:36

@Porcupineintherough anyone can write a policy, but I have managed tens of thousands of acres of the Lake District, huge swathes of Cheshire and Buckinghamshire. We implemented our policies.

My closest friends are all Estate Managers, we collectively manage tens of thousands of acres and they all have extensive environmental and land management policies that are implemented. One friend is currently overseeing the restoration of peatland moors at a huge cost to the landowner. I’m sure you know better though.

Porcupineintherough · 12/10/2021 13:16

The estates near us also have "extensive wildlife protection schemes" @elbea. Unfortunately they are not worth the paper they are written on. Anyone can write a policy.

ancientgran · 12/10/2021 13:13

@HesterShaw1 Again, why are you so bothered if Megan isn't?

Again in case you missed it the first time. The OP asked why people disliked him. That's why I dislike him. I'm not that bothered, I've just answered people like you when they have challenged me on why I dislike him. So you might think it was fine, Megan might not be bothered, but he is someone I've never watched on TV until I saw that programme and my reaction was, "What a nasty self centred man." So I dislike him, I answered the question.

Do you want to tell us why you dislike him?

flippertyop · 11/10/2021 21:29

I didn't have an opinion but now I don't like him because I love cats and pandas

elbea · 11/10/2021 21:14

@CandidaAlbicans2 I’d imagine only half go to game dealers because the rest are eaten by the estate owners, people that shoot them, estate workers, beaters, sold to locals. The beaters will often be paid in meat for the freezer - all in my first hand experience as an Estate Manager who has managed hundreds of thousands acres across the country.

You know some really shitty people because I know and have employed quite a few gamekeeper for some of the biggest estates in the country, none of them are killing birds of prey. All of the estates have quite extensive wildlife protection schemes though.

CandidaAlbicans2 · 11/10/2021 20:55

Rats are fine in their place, without human rubbish they are just another small mammal

Totally agree @Mybalconyiscracking. As per usual, rats are only a "problem" because of humans, and although the anti-ratters often mention leptospirosis as a reason to hate them it's rare in the UK. Most people recover in a few days or weeks anyway after a course of antibiotics.

I guess it’s no surprise that the kind of people who would poison hen harriers and goshawks in order to keep vast areas of moorland sterile monocultures dedicated to preserving one particular species so that the extremely rich can get their jollies by slaughtering them would resort to violence and intimidation, really

Nope, no surprises at all @crackofdoom

CandidaAlbicans2 · 11/10/2021 20:45

I have friends that shoot, hunt and fish. I can’t really understand how people can get upset about shooting pheasants that are then eaten when people eat meat

@elbea, you can’t understand why people get upset about shooting pheasants? Well, personally I object to millions of non-native, captive-bred birds being released into the countryside for starters. It’s the equivalent of releasing millions of farmed chickens which, rightly so, would be considered crazy.

Besides, they aren’t all eaten! I know someone who found a mass grave full of discarded pheasants, and it seems that’s not an isolated case:
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/abomination-of-pheasants-dumped-into-pit-by-digger-whrw935fb

raptorpersecutionscotland.wordpress.com/2018/02/06/more-shot-pheasants-dumped-west-yorkshire-this-time/

www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/news/secret-photos-released-of-dozens-of-pheasants-dumped-into-a-pit-victims-of-uk-shooting-industry-10045528.html

www.lincolnshirelive.co.uk/news/local-news/up-100-dead-pheasants-found-2481985

According to the Savills ‘Shoot Benchmarking Survey 2017/18’, on average only 48 percent of the birds shot will be taken by game dealers. With the number of pheasants being bred to be killed estimated as at least 27 million each year – though potentially much higher – the number of birds killed ‘purely for fun’ is at an alarming level.
theecologist.org/2018/oct/01/pheasant-shooting-massive-waste-life-reports-marianne-brooker

Then we have gamekeepers, whose sole purpose is to rear and protect them for shooting, often at the detriment of wildlife. I knew 2 gamekeepers and they admitted to killing anything that threatened the birds, including species they shouldn’t have. It’s a nasty business, a sick way for people to have fun, and is a world away from going out and shooting 1 for the pot. I’m not anti eating pheasant BTW (although I think it’s overrated).

Listener2021 · 11/10/2021 20:06

I've met him a couple of times. Once at an outdoor event in torrential rain where he took time to talk to everyone, smile and pose for every photo, was last to leave and completely good natured throughout.

The second time was at a talk he did in a theatre- we were clearing up and locking up afterwards. He ran over by nearly 2 hours making sure everyone who wanted signatures got them, and everyone who wanted to show him their wildlife photos was able to. He was really patient and kind. There was a teenage boy interested in a conservation career and he left him contact details.

What is there not to like about him? He's intelligent and articulate. I have lived in the countryside all my life, nearly 6 decades and I hate blood sports.

Clymene · 11/10/2021 19:56

When did he blame the arson on the countryside alliance or hunt supporters?

This is all I can find he's said. No evidence he's blamed any particular group by name:

Chris Packham: Social media stoked fire attack at my New Forest home www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-58870736

Guilty conscience?

FleasInMyKnees · 11/10/2021 19:22

Who are New Forest Information. Can you link this please.

Carboncheque · 11/10/2021 19:16

I’d imagine that if you frequently find dead animals dumped on your doorstep and you receive hate mail on a daily basis you might assume that having your gates burnt was a deliberate attack.

ChrisPackhamtellsporkies · 11/10/2021 19:06

Posted on New Forest Information ..

We are saddened and shocked to see Chris Packham blame the fire damage to his gates on Hunt Supporters or the Countryside Alliance or the shooting community.
There is absolutely no evidence whatsoever to suggest that. It was pure speculation from him and unfounded. We understand he is rightly angry but coming out all guns blazing before assessing the evidence is very unhelpful and unfair. Using it to further his campaigns is unwarranted.
It would appear there is evidence to suggest something totally different happened. The truth may be that it was a convenient, remote location for some criminals to dispose of a stolen vehicle. The stolen Land Rover was set alight, and the fire spread to the gates. On one view his gates were collateral damage only. At this point we would wish to state that we do completely condemn this criminal activity.
We are very surprised that Mr Packham did not mention that another vehicle was burnt out, on the very same night, just over a mile away across the open heath. As it is open heath you could have seen one fire from the other. We understand the police are investigating both vehicle fires as linked and appealing for information on their Facebook Page. The second vehicle was a stolen scaffolding lorry. It had been used to smash forestry gates before crashing into a Commoners Cow, killing it. It was stolen from the same builder’s yard.
This is not the first vehicle arson in this remote New Forest Area. Earlier this year [15.04.21], a stolen car was driven into the Beaulieu Road Pony Sales Yard and set on fire. The BBC reported it and we quote their headline, ‘Deliberate vehicle fire spread to wooden compound’. The Beaulieu Road pony sales yard is under a mile from Mr Packham’s gates. This is a very similar incident which clearly was not targeting Mr Packham.
The Police are investigating these incidents with crime numbers 44210403883 and 44210403698. So please make contact and quote these numbers if you have any information that will help. We hope that these criminals are brought to justice.
In the meantime, we ask Mr Packham not to accuse Country Sports people of being involved. There is no evidence of that and better still, evidence that tends to suggest something totally different. When Mr Packham considered who may have done this, he himself said, ‘I don’t know’.

ginandbearit · 11/10/2021 19:00

Simple. He relentlessly shows up the pro hunting , pro badger digging and baiting , pro trapping and releasing foxes for guaranteed sport , inbred entitled thugs of all classes who go hunting . They have limited if not risible arguments for their activities so resort to violence , lies and corruption .Good man .

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 11/10/2021 18:58

Historically hunts have tracked down and tormented militant hunt sabs so I guess that’s why his gates were set on fire; arson is a silly thing to resort to but he’s made a lot of people very angry.

And that's what I call minimizing. Arson isn't 'silly'. It's dangerous, life-threatening, and a serious criminal offence, and with good reason.

But the poor darlings had been 'made' angry?' God bless 'em, eh. That must make it alright, then! Hmm

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 11/10/2021 18:54

@crackofdoom

I guess it’s no surprise that the kind of people who would poison hen harriers and goshawks in order to keep vast areas of moorland sterile monocultures dedicated to preserving one particular species so that the extremely rich can get their jollies by slaughtering them would resort to violence and intimidation, really.
Yes. They've done it before, and in full sunlight.
Rachie1973 · 11/10/2021 18:53

@FateHasRedesignedMost

He’s anti blood sports and is trying to tighten up the anti fox hunting ban so trail hunts can’t ride over National Trust land. Being anti hunting is going to rile up a lot of powerful people, especially those who’ve had bad encounters with aggressive hunt sabs.

Historically hunts have tracked down and tormented militant hunt sabs so I guess that’s why his gates were set on fire; arson is a silly thing to resort to but he’s made a lot of people very angry.

Hunting is still a way of life for many who’ve been born and bred in the countryside. Livelihoods depend on farmers being able to cull badgers and foxes.

Hunting foxes with dogs may be officially banned but there are enough loopholes to allow many hunts to kill foxes within the law, eg by using hounds to flush out the fox, using a bird a prey, ‘accidentally’ getting onto a fox during a trail hunt. And some trail hunts operate completely legally so he’s targeting those too.

Of course that will enrage a lot of people.

I’m very anti hunt. I very much agree with his viewpoints. I come from the New Forest. A large % of us agree with him.

He’s just rude. I mentioned on another thread the other day. We shared a local pub and he told punters he wasn’t signing autographs. They’d not asked!

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 11/10/2021 18:53

Strange to discuss it in front of a camera to be broadcast then.

Granted. I know that if you put something out there in the public domain, no matter how personal, you can expect people to comment on it. I'm not saying that's necessarily unreasonable, just that I personally wasn't comfortable doing so.

crackofdoom · 11/10/2021 18:51

I guess it’s no surprise that the kind of people who would poison hen harriers and goshawks in order to keep vast areas of moorland sterile monocultures dedicated to preserving one particular species so that the extremely rich can get their jollies by slaughtering them would resort to violence and intimidation, really.

Rachie1973 · 11/10/2021 18:49

@MRex

Obviously people actually setting fire to his gates are plain lunatics: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-58861252. The article talks about all these other online threats, dead animals and other mischief however, which implies a fair number of individuals who expend time and energy going after him. He's just an environmentalist campaigner who wants a bit more wild space, a few beavers introduced, fewer birds shot... he isn't a man of great power. So what do these people fear so much?
He’s a bit of a dick in person.
ancientgran · 11/10/2021 18:35

@MarieIVanArkleStinks

Also not commenting on the thread of this conversation about his relationship with Megan. In his desire to be open about ASD he might have chosen to put this out there on a public platform; nonetheless I'd consider it their private business.
Strange to discuss it in front of a camera to be broadcast then.
ancientgran · 11/10/2021 18:34

@Frymetothemoon

For what it's worth, I am disgusted by the vile opinions of some of you on here about Chris Packham.

I won't be coming to set fire to your homes though.

Now, do you get it?

No one has said it is OK to set fire to his gates. Now do you get it?

If you have a look at the top of the thread there is a title it says AIBU to wonder what people don't like about Chris Packham? So some people have answered the question. How very dare they.