Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents who do this are hypocrites

431 replies

Cazzovuoi · 10/10/2021 16:08

I'm so sad for all the kids who will miss the magic of Santa because parents don't want to lie to their kids.

It's a bizarre concept to me that you think letting your kids believe in a wonderful magical, mythical person is lying yet, if you are religious, you actively teach them to believe in a malevolent, omnipotent, all powerful, cruel being so controlling that he takes attendance on Sunday.

At least Santa was a real person.

OP posts:
SecretGardenn · 11/10/2021 10:00

Live and let live.
Why do you go to church? From your OP you don't sound like you believe in the Christain god.
My family didn't do Santa growing up, nor do I for my own children. I don't think there's any harm in 'lying' or childhood fantasy such as the tooth fairy etc. Santa is more complicated because it's being good. Is a child whose stocking is the size of a pillow case, potentially with big gifts in better behaved than a child with a normal stocking with small gifts? Some people do all gifts from Santa. I remember an awfully disruptive and naughty child bragging about how good he was and all he got, I think in year 2. I let the cat out the bag and said something along the lines of 'if Santa were real, you'd of got coal'. I was a quiet child usually but that annoyed me massively. The whole Santa thing is problematic and I can see why people opt out of it.
Everyone comes from different religions, viewpoints, so what if Santa doesn't appeal to them. They're hardly missing out.

Halfpace · 11/10/2021 08:37

@Icecreamsoda99

My atheist friend doesn't let her children believe in Santa as she says it's the same as lying about there being a God. I also have religious relatives who don't have Santa because they want their children to believe in God and don't see how they can lie about Santa and then expect their kids to believe in what they tell them about God.

Many cultures don't have the jolly man in the red suit and perfectly happy and well adjusted.

Yes to your last sentence, and I think some of the people on here must have children in completely monocultural situations. DS was at a little village school, but there were still a significant minority of children in his class in the junior years of primary who came from Muslim, Sikh, or Orthodox Christian backgrounds who didn’t do Santa Claus/Father Christmas. He had no issue with the ‘Some people believe’ approach to both religion and SC.
NalPolishRemover · 11/10/2021 08:28

These threads appear every year & I find them totally fascinating!

I was raised in Ireland in the 70s & 80s in a practising Catholic family & Santa was a huge part of growing up for us.

I think, from what I've read here over the years, that Santa was / is far more universally accepted there than in UK.

I don't think the general population of Ireland is massively traumatised by their collective childhood belief in Santa at all.

When I was growing up We ALL believed fervently & for far longer than seems the case in the UK. I was at least 11 before one of my older cousins told me & she also told me it was our job to keep it going for our younger siblings. Which we did. We have a large age gap in our family & i was still writing letters to Santa with my youngest sibling when I was 17 & none of that bothered or traumatized me at all.

Times were hard & money was tight for a lot of people in ireland in the 70s & 80s & yet parents created this time of wonder for their children. A pp said that the excitement of the build up & the lying awake on Christmas eve in anticipation listening for sleigh bells meant even the most modest gifts were viewed through the lens of the magic of Santa & I don't ever remember being disappointed by anything I received or comparing it to what others got. And I know there must have been lean years for sure.

My dh grew up in an English home where Santa / Christmas were not really celebrated. V little effort was made at all. He didn't 'get' it when we met. He celebrated a few Christmases with my family before we had dc of our own & he was happy for us to continue my traditions & now he's the biggest fan of us all.

The traditions are more than Santa- they're the rituals we carry from year to year & give us a real sense of belonging, of family, of comfort. Our Dc love them too & even now as teens won't consider deviations.

For my dh who never had any of that growing up, it's something he cherishes & he gets quite sentimental at Christmas time.

We've never told our dc there's no Santa! We carry on every year exactly the same ad the last - stockings are hung, mince pie & whiskey is left out. Presents appear overnight & stockings get filled.

lunar1 · 11/10/2021 08:09

Your thread is really quite bigoted, people's traditions, religion and culture is unbelievably varied throughout the world.

War and hate so often stems from one group thinking their beliefs, their way of life is the correct one and everything else is wrong.

The world doesn't start and end with the things that are important to you.

Lostmarbles2021 · 11/10/2021 08:08

I always felt a bit weird lying to DC. It was a huge relief when it was finally figured out - but also a bit of sadness that the magic was over. I explained to DC why we weren’t truthful about that, the tooth fairy and easter bunny and that It felt odd lying and a relief to stop so that DC knew we weren’t in the habit of lying. I also talked about how lovely it felt to create the magic. It was a ‘both/and’ situation for me.

TheKeatingFive · 11/10/2021 08:01

in terms of myths it's a rather blunt one.

I don't agree with this at all, it's always struck me as incredibly evocative and versatile, taking many forms across the world.

Underamour · 11/10/2021 07:35

Their lives, their business. Each to their own.

Mymycherrypie · 11/10/2021 07:32

It is a weird thing people teach their kids by default - that if they're good, they'll get presents.

That is the whole concept of religion though. If you’re good, you’ll get heaven. It’s similar to the Santa myth but people don’t want to accept it because it’s one of those things that can’t be debased by comparison to a red guy in a suit who appears on a cola truck, but the essence of living a good life for reward is the same.

RedFlyingBeeBee · 11/10/2021 07:11

Plus I've always though the concept of Santa is rather creepy actually. Why should a fat guy in a weird red suit squeeze himself through chimneys to deliver gifts all night to millions of kids, in terms of myths it's a rather blunt one. Coco cola has a lot to answer for with their 80s Santa ad.

TheKeatingFive · 11/10/2021 07:11

Why should mothers toil, save, and do all the work of Christmas so a magical man in red suit who breaks into the house gets all the credit?

I find this an odd take on it all. As a mother, I don't do things to clock up 'credit'.

However, when I eventually figured out how much effort both my parents put into creating this tradition for us as children, I was really appreciative of those efforts, trust me.

Takemetothe90s · 11/10/2021 07:10

@Blackalice

Lying to your children about Santa seems a good way to break their trust in you, make a mockery of teaching them to be honest and make it hard for them to resist the bribery and threats many people use regarding Santa. My 3 kids have had wonderful and magical Christmases and all state they are glad we never lied about Santa to them (they are teens now) We also don't lie about there being gods or anything else so definitely aren't hypocritical. I think that you are being very unreasonable.
And yet so many people who’ve been “lied” to manage to have completely normal relationships with their parents. How do you manage your children to not ruin the magic for other lids? The ones who’s parents weren’t miserable twats?
RedFlyingBeeBee · 11/10/2021 07:08

Are you feeling quite well op? Why do you care so much how others parent their dc? Your rant about religion is a little ignorant, are you feeling ok?

We did do the whole mince pie and brandy for father Christmas and carrot for the reindeer thing with ours but always tongue in cheek, they knew it wasn't real but we all played along. This is what we do too.

StiggyZardust · 11/10/2021 07:08

I've never really understood the Christmas magic thing. DS is 19now, I don't remember him believing in Father Christmas. I find it all a bit daft.

NavigationCentral · 11/10/2021 06:54

Morning!

My Year 1 DS wants to be a scientist. He’s forever watching experiments, doing coding, and loves number puzzles. He’s worked out that Santa isn’t real and has told us so. Yet he will rejoice at Christmas and enjoy the lights and presents.

He’s half Indian and looks foward to Indian festivals. He doesn’t for a moment believe in any of the 180+ deities but will celebrate Diwali with great spirit.

His life is full of magic - a simple Lego marble run fills him with glee and he can spend hours watching a caterpillar wriggle around the garden - there’s no lack of magic for him Thanks.

Parker231 · 11/10/2021 06:33

@TwoMuchTwoYoung

Father Christmas is really very little to do with Christmas. Christmas is about The birth of Christ. St Nicholas Day is earlier in the month.

Completely the other way round in this house, seen as both are make believe we go with the more fun option.

Same in our house. Although we end Christmas when we go back to work after Boxing Day and have the decorations down by New Year ready to start afresh rather than drag it out to early January as some do.
Icecreamsoda99 · 11/10/2021 06:16

My atheist friend doesn't let her children believe in Santa as she says it's the same as lying about there being a God. I also have religious relatives who don't have Santa because they want their children to believe in God and don't see how they can lie about Santa and then expect their kids to believe in what they tell them about God.

Many cultures don't have the jolly man in the red suit and perfectly happy and well adjusted.

purplesequins · 11/10/2021 06:13

yabu

christmas can be magic without 'believing in santa'.

HarebrightCedarmoon · 11/10/2021 06:08

Father Christmas is really very little to do with Christmas. Christmas is about The birth of Christ. St Nicholas Day is earlier in the month

The birth of Christ is very little to do with the more ancient December winter solstice pagan festivities it piggy-backed onto. It didn't even happen in winter.

ohfook · 11/10/2021 06:07

I think this is just your specific circumstances. The ones I know who don't do Santa aren't necessarily religious.

Torvean · 11/10/2021 06:05

You were doing well til you mentioned religion.
Both my parents were Christians.
We still had Santa, the tooth fairy and the Easter bunny.

Greeneyedminx · 11/10/2021 06:02

My kids enjoyed the excitement of Christmas and Santa...however, we didn’t have the Elf and Christmas Eve boxes at that time, thankfully!!
I taught my kids that there were millions of children in the world and so “Santa” could only bring one present each for them, all other presents were from us, their aunts and uncles and grandparents etc.
That way they could thank them and enjoy knowing who had brought them whatever gift.
They were never greedy kids and knew we would try to buy them things within reason, they also knew we didn’t have lots of money, so learnt to choose what we could afford.
They have now brought their children up in similar ways with the added Elf etc that weren’t around when my children were young.
I think some people buy their children far too much and children become overwhelmed with too many presents.
Going into debt because the children “must” have the latest “whatever” isn’t good for families.
Everyone wants their family to have a brilliant time at Christmas, but it isn’t just how much is being spent on each child, but it is spending time together, having fun, playing games, relaxing and enjoying seeing relatives etc.

mathanxiety · 11/10/2021 05:42

I don't subscribe to the 'better watch out' approach to presents. Santa Claus is the embodiment of the idea of a benevolent universe.

It's a good concept to present to children, and presenting it in a way that is tangible and memorable greatly enhances the message that there is such a thing as unconditional love.

DoesHePlayTheFiddle · 11/10/2021 05:35

I hate the lies.

Bythemillpond · 11/10/2021 05:35

I actually think Santa is what Christmas is all about

I have adult children and since they found out that Santa wasn’t real Christmas it has slowly died a death in our household.
To the point that whilst we might buy a couple of random gifts and we stay in and watch tv and can’t go anywhere because there is nothing open. Like I presume a lot of people do.
It has got to be a very boring day

Usually we go away every other Christmas which does make it bearable but Covid and being stuck in this country put paid to that.

I do have a problem with parents who don’t want to do Santa because they want to make sure that their children know who bought them presents..It seems sort of off that you can’t share what you bought with a tradition

Fwiw I am from a non Christian immigrant family and I embraced doing Santa.
The rising excitement in the run up to Christmas that young dc had no matter what they were given by Santa was something no amount of expensive and wanted gifts beautifully wrapped could ever get to that level
The excitement at unwrapping anything even as simple as a Milky Way that “Santa”had delivered was something you couldn’t get from them even if it was the latest
toy they had requested and you had handed it to them

mathanxiety · 11/10/2021 05:35

Oh they are the same. I know both. Parents who tell the kids about Santa and ones who don't. All go to the same Church.

And this is therefore a Universal Truth.

Hmm