Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents who do this are hypocrites

431 replies

Cazzovuoi · 10/10/2021 16:08

I'm so sad for all the kids who will miss the magic of Santa because parents don't want to lie to their kids.

It's a bizarre concept to me that you think letting your kids believe in a wonderful magical, mythical person is lying yet, if you are religious, you actively teach them to believe in a malevolent, omnipotent, all powerful, cruel being so controlling that he takes attendance on Sunday.

At least Santa was a real person.

OP posts:
ultra88 · 11/10/2021 20:41

[quote TReXX]@ultra88

Please don't tell me how I felt, only I can know that.[/quote]
Do you know what. You're right. I was being unkind for no reason. I'm sorry

azimuth299 · 11/10/2021 20:40

Isn't it a bit mean-spirited that people in this thread are saying that nobody could possibly be upset by finding out that their parents lied to them about Santa, and that if anyone is upset then they are ridiculous and melodramatic?

There are plenty of people on this thread who have said that they found it upsetting (as well as plenty who took it in their stride). Just because someone reacted differently than you doesn't mean that they are wrong, or pathetic. Neither reaction is wrong, just different.

LaDamaDeElche · 11/10/2021 20:34

@calvados

Meanwhile the rest of Europe celebrates the birth of Christ on Christmas Day and the presents are received from the 3 Magi / kings on January 6th. Santa is a modern concept that the UK and US have engineered to fit in with a consumerist agenda.
Totally depends on the family. In Spain loads of families give main presents on Xmas eve after dinner and just one present or sweets for the Three Kings, so 'the rest of Europe' is a bit of a stretch.
mustlovegin · 11/10/2021 20:34

People scarred by finding out about Santa

You couldn't make it up Grin

LastSummerHere · 11/10/2021 20:33

People scarred by finding out about Santa.🥴

Only on Mumsnet.

ElectriciansMate · 11/10/2021 20:32

I brought up my children, with no belief in Santa. Like the Easter bunny, the tooth fairy etc they knew it was a story. And were happy to play along. They got their pressies and decorations, advent calendars, mince pies etc. But I don’t lie to my children. Never have. They didn’t need magic. They had fun and love.

Tryagainplease · 11/10/2021 20:32

I literally cannot remember finding out that Santa wasn’t real. So it couldn’t have been that scarring.

LaDamaDeElche · 11/10/2021 20:27

@EatYourVegetables

Do you feel sad for the kids who learn at the age of 10 or so that they’ve been lied to their entire lives?
Literally don't know one child or adult who was in anyway emotionally scarred by this. Bizarre comment.
TReXX · 11/10/2021 20:18

@ultra88

Please don't tell me how I felt, only I can know that.

Sparklybanana · 11/10/2021 20:17

In our family we have good lies and bad lies. Bad lies are not nice because they can hurt someone, good lies help make people happy.
Santa is a good lie - I still remember the excitement of waking up to that sack of presents and I wouldn't deny that magic to my kids. Unless they find out at a young age that santa doesn't exist then I'm sure they'll play along in the game of "I know that you know and you know that I know you know but we're going to continue as everyone loves presents!"
I don't resent my parents for lying about santa. I resent them for lying about what the icecream van music meant..

mustlovegin · 11/10/2021 20:12

I can't believe people get so worked up about Santa TBH

ultra88 · 11/10/2021 20:10

[quote TReXX]@Takemetothe90s
Why? That's exactly what it felt like.

Excuse me for being articulate.[/quote]
I think you mean melodramatic

Aggy35 · 11/10/2021 20:08

People in general are hypocritical...so many examples out there

Aria999 · 11/10/2021 20:07

Lol.

DH and I are atheists. I was against lying to the kids about Santa for a lot of reasons but partly because I disliked the similarity to religion.

However DH (slightly to my surprise) feels that Santa is part of the magic of childhood. So I have settled for being cryptic and evasive with the DCs on the subject.

azimuth299 · 11/10/2021 20:04

@tabulahrasa

“I teach my child that no matter what she can always trust that everything I tell her is 100% true.”

Really? Everything?

So you told them that the macaroni necklace they made isn’t in fact delightful, because it’s made from pasta and you wouldn’t actually wear it?

That they don’t understand knock knock jokes yet, so they messed up the ending and the joke they told isn’t funny?

That their first attempts at handwriting aren’t in fact well done, but objectively not very good as writing goes?

A slight derail perhaps, but I thought that this was an interesting point. There are lots of ways you can encourage children with thing like this without actually lying to them.

"I love that you've made me a pasta necklace, thank you so much! I'm going to put it on my bedside table and when I see it it will make me smile!"

"Oooh are you in the mood for jokes? Let's get that joke book from your room and we'll do some together."

"Wow, I can see that you've worked really hard on this handwriting! Every time you practise you get neater and neater."

Kids often like it when you just describe what they're doing in an excited/upbeat tone: "You're drawing a dinosaur!"

It's not just a choice between lying and saying that everything the child does is objectively amazing, and coldly critiquing everything based on an adult standard.

CatsArePeople · 11/10/2021 19:54

This has been raised a few times, it's interesting.
Do children feel more let down because Santa has left their friends more/bigger toys, or because their parents provided less than than their friends parents did?

Depends if the child likes the present or not. It can be a mountain of presents and they will feel let down if its not what they were expecting.

crosstalk · 11/10/2021 19:51

Most religions have the idea of celebrating the seasons. Most early patriarchal religions have some sort of sacrificial figure who gives his life for the people. Christianity is one of the few religions where a child became a focus and even then Hillel was a Jewish teacher who informed Judaism and Christianity.

So we celebrate in Northern Europe the equinox and with German traditions like Christmas Trees, candles etc. And, like the Turkish St Nicholas, a tradition of giving and celebrating.

branchlight · 11/10/2021 19:49

I felt like an utter fool when I realised father Christmas was a lie. I still remember the sting of shame at being duped years later - so I don't see it the same way I'm afraid

This. Some kids find it really hard when they find out they have been lied to. If they really believe Santa is a real person its as painful as finding our your parents have practised any deliberate deceit on you. Kids hate being lied to.

LadyOfLittleLeisure · 11/10/2021 19:46

"with love fish for prizes" @Stompythedinosaur what is a love fish?

Parker231 · 11/10/2021 19:41

We don’t celebrate the birth of Christ or the Three Kings but love Christmas - family, parties, presents, good food and drink. Father Christmas/ Santa is a big part of it.

calvados · 11/10/2021 19:38

Meanwhile the rest of Europe celebrates the birth of Christ on Christmas Day and the presents are received from the 3 Magi / kings on January 6th. Santa is a modern concept that the UK and US have engineered to fit in with a consumerist agenda.

IndieR22 · 11/10/2021 19:30

Completely disagree. I go to church (or I did before covid, then getting pregnant during covid, then breaking my ankle, which is my current situation), but will be doing the Santa stuff for my LO.

NameChangeWithACold · 11/10/2021 19:29

(ps. When I was little, I'd pray to God and Santa at the same time whenever I needed or wanted something!!..think I was hedging my bets!! (Never got anything I asked for though!! So don't think either of them heard me, or they were busy or something!!))

NameChangeWithACold · 11/10/2021 19:26

I did the whole Santa thing when kids were little. When DS1 reached 7 he asked me if I was actually the one filling the stocking and I told him the truth! Since then he seems to have forgotton the truth and is back believing (he's 10), so I continue to go along with it!! Maybe he thinks he won't get any presents if he doesn't believe!! DS2 (now 7) has never asked for the truth, so we continue to let him think Santa is real! It's fun and magical and stockings are good fun aren't they!?

To be honest, I think they figure it out and then just play along past a certain age anyway!! I'm 42 and my mum never told me Santa wasn't real, she died with the secret this year!! Though clearly I had figured it all out for myself by age 7/8!! Grin (sorry mum!)

LisaD76 · 11/10/2021 19:25

5zeds But Jesus wasn’t born on December 25th either be… the date was used as it lined up with events on the pagan calendar…. Besides I am agnostic, while I believe he existed I don’t think he was a literal son of god and it was meant in the way that we are all children of god… his own words got taken out of context 200 years after he died and we suddenly have a new religion