Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents who do this are hypocrites

431 replies

Cazzovuoi · 10/10/2021 16:08

I'm so sad for all the kids who will miss the magic of Santa because parents don't want to lie to their kids.

It's a bizarre concept to me that you think letting your kids believe in a wonderful magical, mythical person is lying yet, if you are religious, you actively teach them to believe in a malevolent, omnipotent, all powerful, cruel being so controlling that he takes attendance on Sunday.

At least Santa was a real person.

OP posts:
FauxPsychic · 13/10/2021 06:34

lie2
/lʌɪ/
noun
noun: lie; plural noun: lies
an intentionally false statement.
"they hint rather than tell outright lies"

Honestly people should stop with the mental gymnastics just to pretend they aren't lying. They should be proud of their lies if they truly feel they're "fun" and it means they're the most "imaginative" people ever.

A lie is simply intentionally saying something that isn't true. That's it.

Feeling judged because posters say you lied doesn't change the simple meaning of the word. I note how the defence states everything else as a lie except this one. It's not mutually exclusive for something to be both a lie and harmless or imaginative. Any lie, by its very nature, is imaginative. So you're not special for this particular lie.

Some lies are fun and harmless, others are harmful and dangerous.

Posters would sound more clever by arguing that this is a harmless lie [and in most cases, it is] than claiming it isn't a lie.

People lie about different things and this is one of them. Good god!🙄

lazylinguist · 12/10/2021 22:31

Anyone who can't tell the difference between lies and fun make-believe and stories is massively lacking in imagination. And I notice the 'I hate lies' posters have largely failed to respond to posts about the fact that parents both benignly and kindly lie to their dc and also make things up for fun all the time (unless they are pretty cruel parents).

marktayloruk · 12/10/2021 22:13

Let them work it out for themselves.

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2021 21:50

let’s not get them confused

Just what are you drawing a distinction between?

Dnaltocs · 12/10/2021 21:44

Father Christmas not Santa Clause. Christmas is a celebration of the birth of Jesus. Christ Mass.
Easy, let’s not get them confused.

NavigatingAdolescence · 12/10/2021 13:22

The ability to lie is a vital human skill. We could not function as a society without it. So I absolutely tell white lies to my daughter and expect them in return. These are lies to spare someone’s feelings - “thanks for the ornament, I love it” rather than “what the fuck is this hideous thing, take it back”; “no, your bum doesn’t look big in that” etc.

We are honest in an age appropriate way about all important matters in life, including death, what’s going on in the world, why certain people believe certain things and so on.

Santa isn’t a white lie or a fact, so we say that it’s a story some people’s I believe is true, and she’s free to believe or not, as with any other fantasy story. Presents arrive un-labelled and she can believe what she likes about where they came from. Our winter celebration is no less special for it.

SleepingStandingUp · 12/10/2021 12:59

@Tootsweets84

My typical Santa inclusive childhood Christmases were certainly not magical. Weeks spent being bullied by my narcissistic mother with 'youll be getting nothing from Santa if you don't do exactly what I want' (you'd have to be a mind reader to know what that actually was), then up at the crack of dawn to greedily wrip open a pile of presents, turkey dinner (that noone actually liked) eaten in front of the TV, at least one huge family argument and the rest of the day spent sitting about watching the same films every year. Boxing day usually involved lots of being made to feel guilty about 'everything she had done for us'. Once I twigged Santa wasn't real at about 7 even that tiny bit of 'magic' was gone. Christmas was really just a stick for her to beat us with. Then I met my Danish stepmother and discovered the real magic if Christmas - a whole month of crafts, baking, day trips to markets, singing together, chopping down and decorating a real tree, movie nights, roast duck and thoughtful gifts that I was never made to feel guilty for. My own children have an incredibly magical Christmas every year. Probably more so than many of their friends because we spend so much quality time together. We don't do Santa at all - he's just a fun story. What we do is celebrate family, food, music and the season (as has been celebrated since long before Christianity or Santa existed)
But that's a difference of parents, not what is being celebrated. I'm glad you have your step mother
SleepingStandingUp · 12/10/2021 12:56

@mustlovegin

Have you seriously never lied about how good your kids art work / singing / role play game is? About whether the dog or Granny was in pain when they died? About whether you are going to die soon toon? Or them?

A bit harsh but true

It is, but I do wonder where the "any lie to your child is wring" crew draw the line. When DS asked if Nan would die soon because X's Nan had (he's 6) I didn't promise him she'd live forever but I wasn't honest about the chance she'd die before he's grown up. And I tell him repeatedly his singing is great - a proper lie 😂😂😂
NavigatingAdolescence · 12/10/2021 10:40

@GrannyRose15

What I find sad is that anyone should object to a little story telling. Feed their imagination while you can.
We do tell the story. We don’t go all out to convince DD that it’s real.

(The DD who, aged 3, on arriving at Disneyland shouted loudly that I shouldn’t worry, the characters are just people dressed up. And who couldn’t believe that if fairies existed they would want manky baby teeth. And who clocked at 7 after an evening with Prof Brian Cox that Santa couldn’t be real because he’d have to break the speed of light to deliver presents all over the world in one night. Some kids are just too scientific.)

GrannyRose15 · 12/10/2021 10:35

What I find sad is that anyone should object to a little story telling. Feed their imagination while you can.

NavigatingAdolescence · 12/10/2021 10:20

@mustlovegin

It's only a 'Christian' holiday because it was appropriated by the church

Incorporated rather...If it hadn't been 'appropriated' by the Christians, hardly anybody would have any idea who Santa is

What a world that would be.
WalkingOnTheCracks · 12/10/2021 09:51

I think this is less AIBU than CIDSATTBTTN.

(Can I disingenuously start a thread that's bound to turn nasty)

mustlovegin · 12/10/2021 09:30

It's only a 'Christian' holiday because it was appropriated by the church

Incorporated rather...If it hadn't been 'appropriated' by the Christians, hardly anybody would have any idea who Santa is

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2021 09:24

yet obviously enjoy this Christian Holiday very much.

It's only a 'Christian' holiday because it was appropriated by the church. A yule festival has existed for many centuries before that.

mummybean84 · 12/10/2021 09:22

I can’t help but find this a little ironic. You seem to have taken issue with religion whilst simultaneously talking about the magic of a Christian Celebration. The origin of the day is quite literally the celebration of the birth of Christ. I’m not suggesting you have to be a Christian to celebrate it by any means, but I can’t help but smile at the whole idea that you find the teaching of Father Christmas hypocritical and the idea of God offensive and yet obviously enjoy this Christian Holiday very much.

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2021 09:18

Growing up in the 80's there wasn't talk of magic ... Now all this talk of 'Christmas magic' has a desperate, try hard aspect to it. Must 'make memories', people talk about their DC's last year of believing

I can't say I agree with this at all. Parents definitely talked about their DC's last year of believing in the 80s where I'm from.

And there was plenty of magic in my 80s childhood. Leaving the snacks for Santa and reindeer's, waking up to the crumbs. Soot marks on the fireplace. Listening for the sleigh bells. I loved every second. As do my own children, though we do slightly different things.

Tootsweets84 · 12/10/2021 09:15

My typical Santa inclusive childhood Christmases were certainly not magical. Weeks spent being bullied by my narcissistic mother with 'youll be getting nothing from Santa if you don't do exactly what I want' (you'd have to be a mind reader to know what that actually was), then up at the crack of dawn to greedily wrip open a pile of presents, turkey dinner (that noone actually liked) eaten in front of the TV, at least one huge family argument and the rest of the day spent sitting about watching the same films every year. Boxing day usually involved lots of being made to feel guilty about 'everything she had done for us'. Once I twigged Santa wasn't real at about 7 even that tiny bit of 'magic' was gone. Christmas was really just a stick for her to beat us with.
Then I met my Danish stepmother and discovered the real magic if Christmas - a whole month of crafts, baking, day trips to markets, singing together, chopping down and decorating a real tree, movie nights, roast duck and thoughtful gifts that I was never made to feel guilty for. My own children have an incredibly magical Christmas every year. Probably more so than many of their friends because we spend so much quality time together. We don't do Santa at all - he's just a fun story. What we do is celebrate family, food, music and the season (as has been celebrated since long before Christianity or Santa existed)

mustlovegin · 12/10/2021 09:07

Now all this talk of 'Christmas magic' has a desperate, try hard aspect to it. Must 'make memories', people talk about their DC's last year of believing. And all of it seems more about the parents rather than the kids

Yes, it's all a bit hysterical nowadays

mustlovegin · 12/10/2021 09:04

Have you seriously never lied about how good your kids art work / singing / role play game is? About whether the dog or Granny was in pain when they died? About whether you are going to die soon toon? Or them?

A bit harsh but true

jamdonut · 12/10/2021 07:07

I think I ‘believed’ in Santa tillI was about 11…then it dawned on me. I didn’t feel lied to or cheated or embarrassed, but I kept it up as I had a much younger sister and it would not have been fair to soil it for her. My own children were the same, and kept up the pretence till their younger siblings cottoned on.
At school, a year 6 boy couldn’t understand why others in his class believed in Santa. I told him he was now a keeper of the magic, and that he should try to let those that still believe continue till they figure it out and also become keepers of the magic! Well, it certainly seemed to dawn on him,and he stopped shouting others down.

I don’t see it as lying, but I do think we should go back to Santa just filling stockings and maybe one gift, rather than huge piles of presents which seems to be the norm…..unfair to children who are not from such well off homes.

Amaksy · 12/10/2021 05:40

Not really, minimal effort has been made to keep the magic alive so children work it out easily very quickly. My DS told me it’s people playing dress up 😐

mathanxiety · 12/10/2021 05:37

@Mymycherrypie

It is a weird thing people teach their kids by default - that if they're good, they'll get presents.

That is the whole concept of religion though. If you’re good, you’ll get heaven. It’s similar to the Santa myth but people don’t want to accept it because it’s one of those things that can’t be debased by comparison to a red guy in a suit who appears on a cola truck, but the essence of living a good life for reward is the same.

There is a Christian train of thought that goes contrary to those assumptions:
We are all human and therefore inextricably imperfect.
Therefore nothing we do could possibly merit eternal life in heaven.
The only way we could possibly attain eternal life is the love of God and his immense mercy.

mathanxiety · 12/10/2021 04:41

This bloody Christmas magic has a lot to answer for.

Growing up in the 80's there wasn't talk of magic, it was the getting the crappy plastic tree out, seeing the same ancient Christmas decs every year, getting presents and a selection box that was brilliant. Visitors. Parties. The sameness of it each year became a ritual, became the 'magic'. And everyone's was slightly different.

Now all this talk of 'Christmas magic' has a desperate, try hard aspect to it. Must 'make memories', people talk about their DC's last year of believing. And all of it seems more about the parents rather than the kids. I loved Christmas way beyond the age of believing - and Santa was only ever really a small part of any of it.

Excellent post @Nayday

mathanxiety · 12/10/2021 04:31

We teach our kids not to lie, then go lie to them about Santa, Tooth Fairys, Easter Bunnies etc. It is hypocritical

What's the difference between lying and throwing a surprise birthday party, lying vs. presenting a child with a surprise on Christmas morning?

mathanxiety · 12/10/2021 04:28

@Tilltheend99

St Nicholas is the ‘real’ person not ‘Santa’...
Santa Claus is derived from Sante Klaas, which means 'Saint Nicholas' in a Dutch dialect.

...but in England we don’t have ‘Santa’ we have Father Christmas.
Speak for yourself.
There are plenty of people in England who wait eagerly for Santa Claus on Christmas Eve.
Equally, there are millions around the world scanning the skies for Père Noël, Papai Noel, Pai Natal, Daidi na Nollaig.