Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents who do this are hypocrites

431 replies

Cazzovuoi · 10/10/2021 16:08

I'm so sad for all the kids who will miss the magic of Santa because parents don't want to lie to their kids.

It's a bizarre concept to me that you think letting your kids believe in a wonderful magical, mythical person is lying yet, if you are religious, you actively teach them to believe in a malevolent, omnipotent, all powerful, cruel being so controlling that he takes attendance on Sunday.

At least Santa was a real person.

OP posts:
Eleganz · 10/10/2021 17:13

Happy were the Christmas days of yore when we gathered around the fire to hear father's stories of jolly old st nic punching heretics. Such as shame parents aren't telling those tales anymore. Grin

People can do what they want. I personally see it as a great lesson in critical thinking and questioning authority. Most kids figure it out despite everyone they look up to telling them that Santa is real. I just wish we kept encouraging that spirit as they grow older.

JasonMomoasgirlfriend · 10/10/2021 17:13

@birdglasspen

I’m sad that I can’t do what I want with my kids for Christmas without answering all their questions when strangers ask what have you asked Santa for? Nothing! He’s 3 and sorry but he doesn’t get to ask Santa for anything! I didn’t believe in Santa growing up and Xmas was still magical!!! You do what you want and I’ll do what i want with my kids and put up with all the ridiculous questions and fake ness of Santa. I don’t believe in god FYI. I feel ridiculous lying about Santa so I won’t. Hate to tell you this but kids just want presents I doubt they care if a big hairy man delivers them or not.....
I don't understand what you mean
Anonymouseposter · 10/10/2021 17:12

Most religious parents do not encourage their children to believe in "an omnipotent, cruel being who requires attendance on Sundays". That's a silly over-simplification.
Regarding Father Christmas, I don't think going along with the story and having fun is lying to children any more than watching films and reading stories.
It would be taking it too far to insist it to be true when they begin to ask.

GreyhoundG1rl · 10/10/2021 17:11

@birdglasspen

I’m sad that I can’t do what I want with my kids for Christmas without answering all their questions when strangers ask what have you asked Santa for? Nothing! He’s 3 and sorry but he doesn’t get to ask Santa for anything! I didn’t believe in Santa growing up and Xmas was still magical!!! You do what you want and I’ll do what i want with my kids and put up with all the ridiculous questions and fake ness of Santa. I don’t believe in god FYI. I feel ridiculous lying about Santa so I won’t. Hate to tell you this but kids just want presents I doubt they care if a big hairy man delivers them or not.....
Ridiculous. You can indeed "do what you want" but bemoaning the fact that others upset the applecart by not doing similar is a bit stupid.
CuteGirlsWatchMeEatEther · 10/10/2021 17:10

Are you talking about children who still get presents and have Christmas or are you talking about families that don’t celebrate Christmas at all like Jehovah’s Witnesses?

birdglasspen · 10/10/2021 17:09

I’m sad that I can’t do what I want with my kids for Christmas without answering all their questions when strangers ask what have you asked Santa for? Nothing! He’s 3 and sorry but he doesn’t get to ask Santa for anything! I didn’t believe in Santa growing up and Xmas was still magical!!! You do what you want and I’ll do what i want with my kids and put up with all the ridiculous questions and fake ness of Santa. I don’t believe in god FYI. I feel ridiculous lying about Santa so I won’t. Hate to tell you this but kids just want presents I doubt they care if a big hairy man delivers them or not.....

Mulhollandmagoo · 10/10/2021 17:09

I believed in father Christmas as a kid, and I don't remember being upset when I realised he wasn't real, but all gifts in my house weren't from santa, they were from my parents.

The idea of santa only really makes me uneasy in terms of social disparity, it must be heartbreaking for kids of poorer families to have not really gotten many gifts compared to wealthier families if all gifts come from 'santa'

I will do santa when my daughter is old enough to understand, but he won't feature heavily, and I really won't feel bad for kids who's parents decide against it, there are so many more ways to enjoy Christmas and all families have their own traditions

FrownedUpon · 10/10/2021 17:08

You sound really ignorant to be honest. Do you not have more important things to worry about?

cantkeepawayforever · 10/10/2021 17:08

@MolkosTeenageAngst

I have a friend who never told her children Santa was real because she said the thought of lying to them seemed strange. they still did the stockings and presents etc but always knowing Santa was just a fun pretending game and their Christmases still seemed fun and magical.

Incidentally my friend is also firmly atheist and never told her children God is real either.

This is pretty much me.

I was brought up in a fiercely Christian household, but where private belief was private.

We were told the stor(ies) of Christmas from the different Gospels, and encouraged to think critically about why the different writers told them in different ways (or left them out entirely) - and about the dates that the different Gospels were written, and therefore about how likely the stories were to be literally true.

(A belief in God in three persons - Father, Son and Holy Spirit - is entirely compatible with a critical academic discussion as to whether the angels over the fields of Bethlehem were literally real, or whether the wise men from the East really were kings or not - and why Luke talks about shepherds while Matthew has wise men)

We also told stories of Father Christmas, and celebrated them as lovely stories and fantastic family traditions of make-believe (we still all have stockings as adults).

I did the same with my children - I have no personal belief but my children know the Gospel stories, and we tell the stories of Father Christmas.

We have never had to 'pretend FC is real' - do children have to 'believe' they are firemen to have huge fun going around pretending to be firemen? Do they have to believe they are a princess or fairy to spend whole days in those roles? Every child - and every parent - knows about the magic of 'make believe', and how enjoyable it is, without any need to bust a gut trying to 'prove' that 'it's real'. It's make believe. Make believe is magical, and hilarious, and timeless, and wonderful - and even better, if you never try to 'make it real' you can carry on into middle age and beyond.....

JustLyra · 10/10/2021 17:07

[quote Kanaloa]@GreyhoundG1rl

Not sure what you mean? If Santa brings gifts to children based on how good or nice they are then the nicest children should get the best gifts?

Whereas in real life richer children usually get more/better gifts while poorer kids will get less. Because their parents can’t afford as much. Of course the kids with more money will still get more than my kids, but everyone’s aware that it isn’t based on behaviour but on how much money your parents have.[/quote]
That’s exactly why my kids were always told parents have to pay for the presents Santa brings.

My eldest two were given the Santa story by their father, but he then fucked off at Christmas time. No chance I was having them worry or think that they’d been naughty because they got less than other kids.

They thought Santa was basically the delivery guy. That’s carried on with the younger kids.

TReXX · 10/10/2021 17:07

@Takemetothe90s
Why? That's exactly what it felt like.

Excuse me for being articulate.

Kanaloa · 10/10/2021 17:06

I have heard of kids being told Santa might leave a sack of coal if they've been horrendously behaved, (which I don't see as being radically different to any other consequence for bad behaviour, tbh), but no reference to the quality or quantity of the gifts they'll get for being "good".
If that's how you've spun it, you've created the situation yourself.

I haven’t ‘spun’ anything. I’ve told my kids from day dot that Santa is just a story. I’m fine with other people telling their kids Santa is real but it seems to be them that has the issue with kids missing the ‘magic.’

Takemetothe90s · 10/10/2021 17:05

@TReXX

I felt like an utter fool when I realised father Christmas was a lie.

I still remember the sting of shame at being duped years later - so I don't see it the same way I'm afraid.

We did do the whole mince pie and brandy for father Christmas and carrot for the reindeer thing with ours but always tongue in cheek, they knew it wasn't real but we all played along.

Sting of shame?? Oh for Christ sake
Cuddlyrottweiler · 10/10/2021 17:03

We will teach santa the same way we will teach God. "Some people believe...." "I don't know what I believe but Christmas does feel very magical!"

Both DH and I remember finding out santa wasn't real as being a humiliating experience. I don't remember how thinking some mythical man was breaking into our house made Christmas more exciting.

Dontforgetyourbrolly · 10/10/2021 17:03

Wow what a goady post , probably wants to get in the daily mail .

M4J4 · 10/10/2021 17:01

Surely it’s more hypocritical be atheist and yet lie to kids about Santa for years and then one day tell them ‘oh, it was all a lie’, or wait for them to realise through friends etc?

trappedsincesundaymorn · 10/10/2021 17:00

What do you think Santa means? Saint ... as in St. Nicholas

It's not St Nicholas that "lives" at the North Pole surrounded by elves and flying reindeer is it? Hence why I said that Santa was based on St Nicholas. St Nicholas lived in Turkey and I doubt very much knew anything about the Arctic Circle thus St Nicholas = real person, Santa Claus = character based on real person, but fake.

GreyhoundG1rl · 10/10/2021 16:59

@Kanaloa

Really? You’ve never heard adults say ‘ooh you better be good if you want lots of toys from Santa?’ Or teachers tell their class Santa is ‘watching’ to decide who will get lots of lovely gifts?
Honestly, no. I have heard of kids being told Santa might leave a sack of coal if they've been horrendously behaved, (which I don't see as being radically different to any other consequence for bad behaviour, tbh), but no reference to the quality or quantity of the gifts they'll get for being "good". If that's how you've spun it, you've created the situation yourself.
ABCeasyasdohrayme · 10/10/2021 16:59

I’ve never met anyone who doesn’t lie to their children, I’ve met people who say they don’t lie - but they still tell their children that the mess they painted at school is pretty or that the song they’re screeching sounds lovely...

"Mummy, mummy, do you like this picture I painted of you"

"No sweetie it's shit, my legs aren't that long, my hair isn't green, I never wear a red triangle dress and my boots haven't been that perky since 19oatcake. Do better"

😂😂😂

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 10/10/2021 16:59

@BananaPB

Equating Christmas magic with Santa is very sad
How so? I used to lie in bed and genuinely thought I heard his sleigh bells above the house one night. I imagined him going from rooftop to rooftop sliding down the chimney and delivering presents. It was magical. Why is that sad?
TableFlowerss · 10/10/2021 16:56

I agree that Santa was the magical part of Christmas for me. Yes I would have still got presents etc but it was the sheer magic of wondering whether this mythical man would leave me done presents. Absolutely made Christmas for me. Was never the same when I found out the truth. 😭

I don’t believe in god or anything of the like. Imo God is as real as Santa.

tabulahrasa · 10/10/2021 16:56

“The hypocrites are those who lie to their children about a man who brings presents for them, for no other reason other than "because I want to give you the magic of something" ; "it's because of my love for you", then teach the children that lying under any circumstance is wrong.”

I’ve never met anyone who doesn’t lie to their children, I’ve met people who say they don’t lie - but they still tell their children that the mess they painted at school is pretty or that the song they’re screeching sounds lovely...

Tilltheend99 · 10/10/2021 16:55

I think it’s hypocritical that people who hate religion insist on dictating to anyone else on how to mark religious holidays regardless of who does or doesn’t believe it ’Santa.’

And FYI

St Nicholas is the ‘real’ person not ‘Santa’ but in England we don’t have ‘Santa’ we have Father Christmas.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 10/10/2021 16:55

I have a friend who never told her children Santa was real because she said the thought of lying to them seemed strange. they still did the stockings and presents etc but always knowing Santa was just a fun pretending game and their Christmases still seemed fun and magical.

Incidentally my friend is also firmly atheist and never told her children God is real either.

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 10/10/2021 16:54

I do the santa thing, others don't.

I don't do the easter bunny thing, others do.

I have a party for the Eurovision every year and the kids get excited in the run up, other people don't.

Some people bring their children up with religion and believing in God, I don't.

Kids aren't missing out, nor is it hypocritical. We all parent the way we see fit based on things that affected us as kids and our own moral values now.

It would be a very boring world if we were all the same.

I don't believe in Santa, but I still bloody love Xmas so no magic lost here.