Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - don't come on here for medical advice

63 replies

Immaculatemisconception · 10/10/2021 15:36

On the back of a few threads but not a TAAT; if you're concerned about a medical problem, particularly something a bit urgent, ring 111, go to a Walk-in-Centre, GP or A & E. Don't ask on here.

Frankly, some of the crackpot advice you'll get on here is dangerous.

OP posts:
AICM · 10/10/2021 16:45

A lot of advice on MN is crack pot and dangerous, especially medical, legal and relationship advice.

People read a tiny one-sided snippet and make relationship ending judgements almost immediately.

I'm pretty certain many relationships have been ended unjustifiably on the basis of terrible MN advice.

PikachuAndMe · 10/10/2021 16:35

Just to add that I have been sitting on the floor in A&E for almost 3 hours after 111 told me to come in at 2pm as they said I need to be seen by a doctor. At the moment I wish I had asked advice from Mumsnet before I came in as the NHS are not helping me.

Immaculatemisconception · 10/10/2021 16:32

@PikachuAndMe

111, A&E etc al are not much bloody use straight away or when you have a query. You will get a much quicker response on-line.
A quicker response perhaps but honestly, some of the crap posted on here is worse than useless, it's dangerous.
OP posts:
Immaculatemisconception · 10/10/2021 16:31

Personally, I think it's best not to say that you're a HCP. It tends to give authenticity to your posting, yet you could be absolutely anyone.

OP posts:
PikachuAndMe · 10/10/2021 16:31

111, A&E etc al are not much bloody use straight away or when you have a query. You will get a much quicker response on-line.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 10/10/2021 16:29

This is true, and I have seen threads where someone claims to be an HCP and gets pulled up on it by several other posters, but if there are a number of people on a thread claiming to be doctors or nurses and all saying the same thing as each other it’s generally clear they know what they are talking about.

Immaculatemisconception · 10/10/2021 16:25

@Babdoc

I disagree, OP. I’m a retired doctor and I have advised women on MN before now who thought they had trivial symptoms and didn’t want to bother their GP. They in fact had symptoms which we regard as cancer until proven otherwise, and they needed urgent referral. Some women are not very assertive, and need encouragement and reassurance that they would not be wasting the GP’s time.
You see, therein lies the problem. I'm a retired doctor could be said by anyone. We have no idea who is posting.
OP posts:
DDUW · 10/10/2021 16:18

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Hmumoftw0 · 10/10/2021 16:15

Last time I rang my GP, then rang 111 as her advice was well nothing, I was advised to go to A&E, were I sat for 6 hours had a blood test and was sent home to come back the next day were as if I had asked on here I would probably have been told to wait till morning and ring the EPU Blush

CovidCorvid · 10/10/2021 16:15

I’ve also seen threads on here where someone’s life has been saved. Once rather memorably in quite an acute situation where the OP went to a&e after getting good advice to go.

Kummerspeck · 10/10/2021 16:13

@Babdoc

I disagree, OP. I’m a retired doctor and I have advised women on MN before now who thought they had trivial symptoms and didn’t want to bother their GP. They in fact had symptoms which we regard as cancer until proven otherwise, and they needed urgent referral. Some women are not very assertive, and need encouragement and reassurance that they would not be wasting the GP’s time.
There is a difference though between informed advice like you mention and those posters typing "A&E NOW" for a minor ailment. I can see why the NHS is struggling when you see the expectations some posters have. I'm a HCP but I don't diagnose and, even when I think I might have an idea I know things are often more complex, so I rarely comment on threads asking for advice but am amazed at the lack of knowledge of some who do.
StrawberrySquash · 10/10/2021 16:11

We all, as non-medical-professionals sometimes need to make judgements. It can be helpful to ask others for advice to make them. Multiple times MN advice has sent someone with something they thought wasn't serious off to get much needed medical help. Obviously that's not the same as asking you to diagnose if a lump is cancer.

Angrymum22 · 10/10/2021 16:08

As a HCP I give the same advice on MM as I do in real life when asked by friends and family. Factual, generalised and always refer them to their own GP, dentist, physio etc.
Unless it’s an injury that I have witnessed where I might offer first aid or phone 999.
I have recently been diagnosed with breast cancer and it’s amazing how many people are experts on the right diet, weird treatments and mindset theories. Believe me the best advice has been from my sister who is a 20yr breast cancer survivor. Trust your medical team they know more about the disease and your unique type than an anonymous poster online.

TheVanguardSix · 10/10/2021 16:07

lockheart, whatever you say. I don’t argue on Sundays.

RavingAnnie · 10/10/2021 16:05

Well given some of the terrible and once, life threatening medical advice, I've had from various medical professionals, I'm not sure that SM is comparatively that bad. My last two conditions I've diagnosed myself (and then had confirmed), doctors themselves are often pretty useless ime. Most medicine also seems to have a large element of trial and error. Try this, no not worked, ok let's have a go at this one. Conditions, symptoms and Nice guidelines can all be looked up yourself. Every doctor I've ever seen also always had a different opinion.

I see a select few doctors (who listen and aren't completely incompetent) for advice, but that's all it. I do my own research and advocate for myself. If I am not happy with e we get one doctor says I get a second opinion.

TBF I would never go off what one person on a SM forum has said. I research everything myself and look for good evidence from reliable sources to back things up. However I think thinking that if you are I'll your only refereeing d pony should be your local surgery/hospital etc is naive and I could be dead now had I taken that approach.

ilovesooty · 10/10/2021 16:05

With a few exceptions I wouldn't get medical, employment, legal or relationship advice on here.

Babdoc · 10/10/2021 16:00

I disagree, OP. I’m a retired doctor and I have advised women on MN before now who thought they had trivial symptoms and didn’t want to bother their GP. They in fact had symptoms which we regard as cancer until proven otherwise, and they needed urgent referral.
Some women are not very assertive, and need encouragement and reassurance that they would not be wasting the GP’s time.

Lockheart · 10/10/2021 15:56

@TheVanguardSix

I think, for people who have had a certain type of cancer, a surgery, a procedure like a colonoscopy or have had MRIs and other scans, it's great to ask for a handhold and insight. For women terminating for medical reasons or terminating a pregnancy for other reasons, again an MN handhold is invaluable. For things like 'I have a thunderclap headache, just sprayed vomit everywhere, and I think I'm going to faint', I don't understand why you'd lose time posting on ANY forum, let alone MN. But 'Does this look like a bullseye rash?' is totally ok to ask here or anywhere really.
Well not really. Because you have no idea how qualified the responses will be, or what their motivations are. MN is full of less than pleasant posters who may well take delight in giving OP the worst possible scenario (or making something up entirely). Even if all you're asking is "does this look like a bullseye rash?". That's what Google is for.
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 10/10/2021 15:56

Depends if it’s a heart attack or rosacea really.

Lockheart · 10/10/2021 15:54

Couldn't agree more. Like another poster said, some of the advice (I notice this most on burns threads too) is outright dangerous.

I know people will be looking for reassurance but they will not find it on a forum full of unqualified randomers. Unless it's a specific forum for a specific condition, leave it to real life medical professionals.

TheVanguardSix · 10/10/2021 15:54

Sorry, I really worded my post poorly.

TheVanguardSix · 10/10/2021 15:52

I think, for people who have had a certain type of cancer, a surgery, a procedure like a colonoscopy or have had MRIs and other scans, it's great to ask for a handhold and insight. For women terminating for medical reasons or terminating a pregnancy for other reasons, again an MN handhold is invaluable.
For things like 'I have a thunderclap headache, just sprayed vomit everywhere, and I think I'm going to faint', I don't understand why you'd lose time posting on ANY forum, let alone MN. But 'Does this look like a bullseye rash?' is totally ok to ask here or anywhere really.

LaurieFairyCake · 10/10/2021 15:51

Well maybe the advice you get with open wounds is not great

But the 'what could this weird illness' be threads are FANTASTIC - I've seen people find out they've had all sorts of illnesses on here

Plus the 'are these levels ok' threads where people's levels are off enough to cause problems but not off enough to make the nhs do anything - hypothyroidism and vitamin B and D deficiencies are the best example

But my favourite medical threads are the ones where we all go - go and demand HRT, no you don't have to wait for blood tests - yes you will likely be SO much better in a week. I suddenly had this - sudden night heat/sudden anxiety where I've never had anxiety before/aches everywhere- 5 days of HRT all symptoms gone

AlternativePerspective · 10/10/2021 15:46

I have a serious heart condition and am on a fb support group for others with the same condition.

Even though everyone has the same condition and has experience of medical intervention and the treatments etc that are available, any posts requesting actual medical advice are deleted, and the poster is referred to either the heart failure nurse who works for the charity concerned or told to seek medical help from a medical professional. It’s written in the terms that no medical advice must be sought or given.

No-one should be being saved by posting on mumsnet. If things are that urgent they should either be in hospital or waiting on a 999 ambulance.

BIoodyStupidJohnson · 10/10/2021 15:46

The internet generally is pretty terrible for medical/health advice, to be fair.

Dr Google tends towards the horrifying -- mainly because it works based on what people are most likely to click on, rather than what's most likely to be wrong (if anything).