Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's not right to charge adult children rent to live at home

822 replies

Hdhshxhs · 10/10/2021 11:50

I have a few friends who charge their adult DC rent to live at home.

I personally find this very strange, no matter their age my children will always be my children and welcome in my home without any expectation of money.

I think aswell with it being so hard for young people to get on the housing ladder these days one of the only ways they can is to live at home rent free so they can save for a deposit.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Ilovemycar77 · 13/10/2021 16:47

Totally agree in that scenario for sure!!
That’s like taking the p* ss!!

vodkaredbullgirl · 13/10/2021 16:42

Come again Daisz.

x2boys · 13/10/2021 16:41

@Daisz

I suppose the commenters on here would also see nothing wrong in charging family members for meals, such as birthdays anniversary etc special occasions. I know a few people that see nothing wrong in this despite not being charged themselves when they are invited places!
I'm not sure how this comment is at all relevant 🤔
Comedycook · 13/10/2021 16:39

@Ilovemycar77

We don’t charge our eldest who is 18 any rent. He is working full time this year to get some money behind him before heading to Uni next year. His choice to take a year out and work so is better prepared financially. The world is hard enough for youngsters as it is. I was charged by my parents from the age of 16!! I am still resentful 35years later 😂. Especially as they didn’t charge my golden balls brother a penny!!
I totally understand your situation with your ds...I probably wouldn't charge rent in that situation either.

But to those who disagree with charging their children at any point..this could theoretically mean you have a 'child' in their thirties, earning a high salary and leaving under your roof, paying nothing and therefore having zero living costs. Why would anyone accept that?!

TheBlackArt · 13/10/2021 16:39

@Daisz

I suppose the commenters on here would also see nothing wrong in charging family members for meals, such as birthdays anniversary etc special occasions. I know a few people that see nothing wrong in this despite not being charged themselves when they are invited places!
Totally different and you know it
Daisz · 13/10/2021 16:22

I suppose the commenters on here would also see nothing wrong in charging family members for meals, such as birthdays anniversary etc special occasions. I know a few people that see nothing wrong in this despite not being charged themselves when they are invited places!

Ilovemycar77 · 13/10/2021 16:16

We don’t charge our eldest who is 18 any rent.
He is working full time this year to get some money behind him before heading to Uni next year.
His choice to take a year out and work so is better prepared financially.
The world is hard enough for youngsters as it is.
I was charged by my parents from the age of 16!! I am still resentful 35years later 😂.
Especially as they didn’t charge my golden balls brother a penny!!

Cheeseplantboots · 13/10/2021 16:13

I won’t and dint charge mine because I don’t need to. My mum woukd never have charged any of us 6 kids anything and we’ve all grown into independent adults who’ve had no issues supporting ourselves. Some families may need to though.

JoborPlay · 13/10/2021 16:09

@FilthyforFirth

I personally would never do it, neither mime nor DH's parents did/would.

But I accept this comes from a place of privilege. I am not reliant upon any benefits/maintenance for my kids and they wont cost me more at 20 than they do at 18.

I will however insist they save. I was terrible with money in my 20s and I want them to avoid that.

My parents took rent from me, they didn't need to at all we were very financially secure but wanted to set me up well for when I moved out by me having to budget whilst at home.
FilthyforFirth · 13/10/2021 16:07

I personally would never do it, neither mime nor DH's parents did/would.

But I accept this comes from a place of privilege. I am not reliant upon any benefits/maintenance for my kids and they wont cost me more at 20 than they do at 18.

I will however insist they save. I was terrible with money in my 20s and I want them to avoid that.

BlueVira · 13/10/2021 15:56

I will be charging my DD if she decides to live at home after uni. Why wouldn't I charge a 22 year old? I am supporting her through uni with an expectation she will finish, get a job and become self-sufficient. I will help with house deposit.

I think NOT charging capable adult children is holding them back from becoming independent adults.

CreamSoda77 · 13/10/2021 15:45

If you are losing money when they turn 18 then not unreasonable to ask for something if they are working ft and earning, otherwise no.

x2boys · 13/10/2021 15:08

@Daisz

Dare I say it, but are working class people more prone to doing this? as they are so used to claiming benefits that suddenly stop, so are conditioned to seeing their offspring as "cash cows" I actually know someone that was turfed out on their sixteenth birthday because that is when their parents benefits stopped.
Yes those working class folk popping out kids for cash🙄 If you actually read the thread, people are saying that they expect a contribution for living expenses not using their kids as cash cows I paid my parents about £130 a month when I moved back home after I qualified as a nurse this was in the 90,s my wage was around £900 a month at the time, honestly I never had it so good, it was the only time in my life when I had loads of spare money, and guess what I still managed to save enough to get a mortgage at 27 with no help from Mummy and Daddy.
AryaStarkWolf · 13/10/2021 15:03

If the adult "child" is working full time of course they should contribute to the house they live in and the food they eat

TheBlackArt · 13/10/2021 15:02

[quote Daisz]@timetochangeagainforever finally a voice of reason. I agree with exactly this, parents are supposed to help their children move forward not hold them back.[/quote]
Please explain how that's a voice of reason 😂😂

That poster is suggesting that chikeren don't cost more to house when they turn 18. But what about those who receive maintenance/child tax? What about council tax discounts? Reasonable my arse 😂 More like privileged.

vodkaredbullgirl · 13/10/2021 14:56

Nor me Countrygirl, back in the late 80's, I gave my parents £20 a week out of my benefits.

countrygirl99 · 13/10/2021 14:54

@safariboot

Wow, this one ran.

I think, and do, that everyone bringing in money should contribute to household expenses in proportion to income. Groceries, bills, rent to a landlord, etc. (Mortgage is a maybe, since it largely benefits the owner). And every adult should also be contributing to the non-monetary aspects - chores, "life admin", that kind of stuff. Because that's what adults living together do.

But charging rent is too coldly transactional.

I think the problem is calling it rent rather than contribution to groceries etc. A rose by any other name and all that. Tbh I'd never heard the contribution a wage earner pays for their food called rent before I came on Mumsnet.
vodkaredbullgirl · 13/10/2021 14:46

I'm sure some poster who have young children, might change their minds when their lo get to adults and staying at home.

Indoctro · 13/10/2021 14:35

It's not something I would do unless they were taking the mick

EmeraldShamrock · 13/10/2021 14:23

Dare I say it, but are working class people more prone to doing this? as they are so used to claiming benefits that suddenly stop, so are conditioned to seeing their offspring as "cash cows" I actually know someone that was turfed out on their sixteenth birthday because that is when their parents benefits stopped.

Ye that is it.
WC DC are turfed out at 16 the cash stops.
Ridiculous isn't it? Your comment I meant 🙃

TheBlackArt · 13/10/2021 14:21

They don't start costing more money to house on their 18th birthday

Oh my goddddd

The naivety.

safariboot · 13/10/2021 14:19

Wow, this one ran.

I think, and do, that everyone bringing in money should contribute to household expenses in proportion to income. Groceries, bills, rent to a landlord, etc. (Mortgage is a maybe, since it largely benefits the owner). And every adult should also be contributing to the non-monetary aspects - chores, "life admin", that kind of stuff. Because that's what adults living together do.

But charging rent is too coldly transactional.

tigger1001 · 13/10/2021 14:18

@timetochangeagainforever

I agree. My parents never changed me or my sister 'rent' to stay sleeping in our bedrooms beyond 18. It enabled me to go travelling and for my sister and I to both buy houses by the time we were 25. My daughter is 22, never paid any rent and has sensibly saved hard from working since 18 and will be able to buy a flat next year. She wouldn't be able to do that for years if we charged her rent. I'll be doing the same for my 16yr oldson. They don't start costing more money to house on their 18th birthday!
That may be true for you, but as other have pointed out for some parents, it is indeed more expensive once they turn 18. Benefits/maintenance stops, and for some council tax increases too.
Daisz · 13/10/2021 14:17

@timetochangeagainforever I also bought my flat when I was 24. That would have been impossible if I also had to pay rent, and yes that would have held me back.

EmeraldShamrock · 13/10/2021 14:17

That is your choice.
I personally enjoyed handing over a percentage of my wages towards the household.
In the early days we usually borrowed it back for bus fares to work.
If my DC was saving for a house deposit while living frugally I'd allow them stay rent free.
If they buy expensive clothes, have takeaways every night and weekends on the town then I think they should contribute .