Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad that I can sense that my new colleagues are disappointed in me :(

135 replies

theshyone · 09/10/2021 22:41

I started a new job at the start of September, I work from home most of the time and go into the office once a week.

I'm mid 20s and very shy and quiet. It's something I have tried and tried to get over at university and previous jobs. It is really hard for me, I naturally keep myself to myself.

I have had a few comments from colleagues and I can just tell that they are disappointed that I have been shy, and I feel really sad and anxious about it. I'm worried my manager is going to formally bring it up with me. I'm in a team of 8 and they are all really nice and welcoming and I have a lot in common with them. From my first day, I have been included and was added to their private group chats and Whats App groups and have invites for drinks and lunch etc and I have just found it a little overbearing, I need to time to warm up to people. I hate it about myself and it has caused me so much pain and loneliness throughout my life.

The kind of comments I have had are:

  • You should write more/participate more in our Whats App group
  • We are all nice/not scary, I swear!
  • I have also had several people say how many people want to work in our small team and how it's such a great team to work within (something I agree with, but it feels like a dig)
  • A position in our team is open for a role different to mine and some of the group have been sitting in interviews, they were discussing an applicant's interview and saying how they were impressed that the candidate asked about social events and how important that is for them...
  • My manager also asks me in every 1:1 whether I have been reaching out and chatting with colleagues

Please help me navigate this, I obviously need to change but I don't know how

OP posts:
BreadPita · 10/10/2021 12:48

I also hate this stuff but have found it sort of necessary at points in my career.
If you really want to stay in this particular role then try toparticipate, even when you're not inclined.
Say something just to have said something. Ask questions that you don't particularly care about the answer to, ask more questions based on their answer. This is usually enough to get you out of the "unsociable" column.
If you don't like team lunches or after work drinks, invent some sort of obligation to get out of them (say you go for a run/to the gym/to a class of some sort) but attend some of the "special occasion" socials so it's not obvious that you're avoiding them.

AliceWo · 10/10/2021 12:43

OP I think you've posted similar posts under different usernames? I'm sorry the other threads haven't helped.

If you are the same person, then take it easy on yourself. It's a PR company - they are more extrovert than most industries. For you not to immediately fit in isn't a failing on your part.

You are doing well, they have praised your work, they are trying to make you comfortable though maybe in a slightly cack-handed way as they don't understand the challenges of being really shy.

You're wfh a lot, which makes the bonding harder. You've had some good advice on this thread - try and join in the WhatsApp chat a bit and building relationships 1-1 with a couple of people to start off with.

You can't force yourself to be someone you're not so maybe this will turn out not to be the industry for you - but don't assume that now. I've a feeling you will find your niche there eventually once you are more used to the people, and they understand you better. They seem well meaning.

Kitkatbar2018 · 10/10/2021 12:26

Apologies about spelling!

Kitkatbar2018 · 10/10/2021 12:25

I think cut yourself some slack it's only been a few weeks, hard enough face to face and even more so when joining a team working remotely. Meeting the team on a 121 basis getting to know what their roles are and how you work together is a good way to ask for that 121 with each colleague in team. I set up inductions with each team member, then our heads and other teams colleagues whom they could potentially work with just 30 mins per person and that really worked. New team member now has connected with a few and really part of the team. It also helped them to be more authentic and well be themselves not feeling they needed to change. Yiu should never be made to feel you are not a right fit as that's not inclusive at all, it's about being supported to fund your space abd connections within your team so that you contribute with your unique contribution.

GoingOutOutNEVER · 10/10/2021 12:01

Work nights out are a good way to see people away from the constraints of work. Talk about the persons dress, shoes, suit to get the ball rolling, if they don’t respond to exactly the same chat to someone else. It does get easier.

nordicnorth · 10/10/2021 11:19

@questionforyouguys

Ok, as a manager myself. You need to get over any insecurities you have and put your big girl pants on and 'pretend' you give a shit. Otherwise you'll be on the sideline for too long and become way to bitter to deal with real life
What a nasty comment!
KatherineJaneway · 10/10/2021 11:12

I suspect they appreciate that you are quiet and shy but don't expect that to extend to WhatsApp.

HalzTangz · 10/10/2021 10:51

There's two things I would do.

  1. Start participating in the WhatsApp group.
  1. On your day in the office starting having lunch with one of them, build up a friendship, and do this with others as weeks go on. Once you know people a bit more individually you'll find it easier to talk more in a group
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 10/10/2021 10:32

How about - send a message, but don't put any apology or "sorry" in it. Sorry puts you on the wrong foot and tells everyone that you think you are a problem, and they will believe you.

Instead just send a message with the nice things you said in it - "hey everyone just wanted to say how nice and welcoming you've all been since I joined. I really appreciate it!"

If you want to add a little harmless personal information you could add "loved all the chat about pets, I have a rottweiler called Fred" or "I'm off to walk the West Highland Way this weekend" Or if there is something where they could genuinely help "loved all the chat about pubs, got a friend coming over, anyone have a recommendation for Camden?" - substitute reading groups, photography class, nice restaurant... whatever floats your boat. If you have things in common it shouldn't be too hard to find an overlap.

If they're planning a get-tgoether and you want to join "looking forward to seeing you all at wherever" or if you'd really rather leave it for a bit "hoping to get together with everyone at Christmas".

But these last bits are optional, don't do it if you can't think of anything. Just the friendly bit at the start will probably keep everyone happy.

ArranMumma · 10/10/2021 10:22

@Lottie2shoes yes but saying “we are nice and not scary” implies that the OP is acting as if they aren’t nice, and is acting as if she thinks they are scary people. She doesn’t think either of those things, and implying that makes the situation more awkward for her. Saying something like “I know it’s a bit scary joining a new team at first, let me know if there’s anything I can do to make you feel a bit more comfortable” would be far more helpful. It doesn’t put the blame on OP.

Lottie2shoes · 10/10/2021 10:07

@ArranMumma
May be it comes across as us and you but I think tbh they are just addressing the us collective as in they are not new vs you the new girl.
It's always hard being the new kid on the block when the rest of the group may have known each other for a long time.
Sometimes you have bitchy clique that don't want you to join in so they are showing they would like her to join and they should not be feared.
Obviously everyone sees things differently, I do tend to see positives so might just be me. Wink

drpet49 · 10/10/2021 10:04

** I don't think they sound overbearing. I think they sound like people trying very hard to make sure that your reticence isn't because they haven't welcomed you enough.

The examples you offer as evidence of their disappointment just don't read like that to me. Saying nice things about another candidate isn't a criticism of you.**

^This

Lottie2shoes · 10/10/2021 10:01

Ive not read the full thread so maybe someone has already mentioned this.
As an extrovert turned introvert myself, I know you are usually just one and that's probably the extrovert but I've found ive become more shy and second guessing meeting and chatting to new people over the years. It sounds like your colleagues know you are an introvert and may be struggling to make new friends so they are giving you openings to help you join in.
It is up to you whether you want to take them up on that offer, but it is very nice of them to offer so I would see this as a good thing.
They seem to like you and have respect too.
At this point, I'm not trying to say you are, but sometimes being shy and an introvert, some people project stand offish behaviour. As long as you aren't doing that, take your time, being involved etc will come to you. It takes some people longer to feel comfortable and warm up to people than others. There is nothing wrong with this.
I find "working" with 1 person at a time helps. So I would start off trying to be friendly with one, then slowly slowly widening the circle. That way it is not too much and your working at a comfortable stride.

Butchyrestingface · 10/10/2021 09:47

If behaving like a performing seal was more important to this outfit than your ability to do the actual job, then they should have signalled it in the ad in some way.

Even “team player” would have set me running as if from Bubonic Plague. Grin

I do think the occasional contribution to their tedious chat groups and what not would probably be expedient. And goes without saying, attendance at the Xmas bash is a must.

But otherwise, get them tae fuck.

AnnaMagnani · 10/10/2021 09:43

Are you 100% sure they are disappointed in you or has that entirely come from you?

Look at it a different way - they are a chatty, sociable team who prides themselves on being welcoming. A new staff member arrives who seems quite quiet.

They are going out of their way as a welcoming group to reach out and make sure she finds her way into their social groups as they don't want to be cliquey, say hello, make sure she is in the Whatsapp chat especially as no-one goes into the office much.

I would agree with a PP that you have automatic negative thoughts - I speak as a shy person who would have reacted much as you have.

A bit of CBT online would help you look at how you react, you can still be introverted and shy if you want to be! Just without the anxiety which is much better.

IWentAwayIStayedAway · 10/10/2021 09:36

Concentrate on job role, any kpis, etc. Thats what you are judged on

ArranMumma · 10/10/2021 09:33

Ugh comments like “ We are all nice/not scary, I swear!” are SO patronising and insensitive. It just deepens the “you” and “us” barrier even further. Honestly OP there is nothing wrong with being introverted, they’re the knob heads for not understanding that other people have different wants and needs. There’s nothing wrong with not feeling comfortable being particularly social at work - it’s not for everyone. And anyway, it’s going to be difficult for you to become comfortable when they are making it clear that they don’t feel you’ve fit in enough!
They don’t seem like a great team for you to work with but don’t worry. Accept that you’re not a good social fit but that doesn’t mean you can’t get on with your job and make the most of that. Learn what you can from the role, gain some experience then move on.

It would be helpful for you to work on your confidence though for the future. Do something like join a book club or a speakers club outside of work - something that requires you to speak in groups. This will give you more confidence in group settings.

Etinox · 10/10/2021 09:31

@AmanitaRubescens

I love my job and colleagues and am probably one of the annoying ones WhatsApping posting, chatting, ‘op have you read this paper, are you going to the xx conference

Please stop.

No. As I’ve said before, rigorously on work time via work comms, email and work phones. I felt awful when I read PP eughing at my comment but the fact that 2 ex colleagues and one current have messaged me this weekend suggests I’ve got the balance right.
Phobiaphobic · 10/10/2021 09:26

Being shy and having social anxiety is hard - I know from personal experience. The cure is to stop focussing on yourself and how you feel when you're with other people. Turn your attention to them, ask about their lives, fake interest until you genuinely are interested. This has two beneficial effects: it stops your mind obsessing about you, your performance and how other people might be judging you, while also forging real connections with people that will give them a very positive impression indeed.

TheFoundations · 10/10/2021 09:26

This is a self esteem issue, OP. It's not about what's actually happening, objectively, it's about your interpretation of what's happening. I don't mean it in a finger-pointy way, because it means you're in charge of this problem, and you're the one who can make it go away. It's good news!

You can make it go away in 2 ways:

  1. I obviously need to change but I don't know how
    The only change you need to make is to recognise and accept that you don't need to change. You are great as you are. Teams benefit from having a variety of types of people, and you're not faulty or broken, so the team will benefit from having you.

  2. You accept that you and this team are not a compatible pairing. And that's fine. Nobody is 'wrong', it's just not a bad fit. It's like with clothes. You don't go into the shop and feel like you need to change yourself if you try on a pair of trousers and they're too big for you; you just accept it, and move on (unless you are already feeling insecure about being underweight) You can plan to leave, or you can plan to stay, accepting the fact that you won't be there forever so It's just a 'make the best of it' situation.

The company has employed you. You didn't say in the interview that you were a party animal who loves social media 24/7 and whose life revolves around socialising with the office. You said you think you can do the job. Do that for a bit. Maybe they employed you because you seem quiet, and the overlords think that this team is getting a bit too wild? Recognise your power!

HelloMissus · 10/10/2021 09:20

I’m the owner of a company.
And whilst I don’t need my people to be friends I do need them to be a team. And as a creative team we need to know one another. And we can only do that if we speak and share things.
I wouldn’t want anyone on the team who avoided all interaction with the other members.

Brefugee · 10/10/2021 09:05

It sounds more like they are trying to get to know you. Teams work better when people know the others quite well.

Does your work rely on teamwork? that could be quite an important bit. My team, for eg, are scattered over about 7 different cities (even without the complication of WFH) and so we communicate a lot, officially, by Teams, email and phone calls. Inofficially we have a WhatsApp group for joking around, checking in if someone is sick (as in "hope you're ok do you need anything" rather than "when are you coming back") etc etc.

If your 1:1s have been ok, i wouldn't worry. Maybe mention to your manager what you're worrying about.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 10/10/2021 09:04

"You do not need to change. Personality wise I am very much like you and constantly would try and change myself for others who wanted me to be more outgoing. Then I thought...why? Id put myself in situations I felt anxious and unhappy to make others happier."

To be fair, op does seem to want to change. She talks about her introversion leading to a lot of unhappiness over the years.

OP, you've had some good advice here I think. Don't attach negative motives to their behaviour - you have no idea what they're all thinking snd it will further damage your self esteem.

It is possible to make small steps of change though, if you want to, whilst remaining true to yourself and largely in your comfort zone. You could try contacting some colleagues individually or taking them up on a low-stakes offer such as a coffee.

If you really are happy as you are, I do think they'll get the message shortly, that this is your preferred style and not a result of wfh and them not welcoming you enough, and then you need not give their opinion of you another thought.

branchlight · 10/10/2021 08:43

To be honest, it all sounds a bit forced in their place. Like they have decided they are the 'fun' people and this is a 'fun' team to work in. They are seeking to maintain that image by getting you to conform to being 'fun' too.

I have never worked anywhere where people are not just accepted for how they are. I find their forced conformity on their team really alien.

lnsufficientFuns · 10/10/2021 08:41

Easier thing you can do is to respond to watsapp messages actually

Even an emoticon

When participants don’t respond in my family groups. it’s like somebody is silently observing

1:1 - that’s the next easiest thing to tackle. Only you can do that.

But all the constant emphasis on being social would irritate me no end and I’m quite sociable!

Swipe left for the next trending thread