Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? BF slept with other BF ex

116 replies

katie2812 · 09/10/2021 19:06

Need advice.

I found out my best friend had slept with my other best friends ex (only broke up two months ago after 5 year relationship living together). These two are super close. Even closer than I am to these two.

I couldn't not tell my best friend so I told her that what other BF did. She was distraught and angry, said these two people were people she trusted with her life.

I told my best friend, please do not say I told you, as I want to be there for both of you and don't want to fall out but couldn't not tell her what I found out.

AIBU to expect to continue to be there for both of them, but not telling my Bf that I was the one who told other bf? Part of me is like be honest, and say if it was other way round I would have done exact same for her? Or just continue as it is and be there for her knowing I was the one who told on her?

OP posts:
shreddednips · 10/10/2021 08:39

Oh dear, this was a sticky situation for you OP. But there are so many less inflammatory ways you could have dealt with this.

For what it's worth, I don't think it's ok to sleep with your close friends' ex partners, particularly when the breakup is very fresh. Breakups are hard even when they're for the best, and it would be painful if a close friend then slept with them, especially if you'd been confiding in that friend for support (assuming this would be the case if they're best friends.)

However; you don't actually know that this is what happened. You haven't heard it from the horse's mouth. Surely the more conservative, and no less loyal, course of action would have been to speak to the friend who supposedly did the shagging, make her aware that she's the subject of workplace gossip, and then take it from there. If you all work together (do you?), even MORE reason not to be chucking fuel on the flames without even knowing the truth.

PlanDeRaccordement · 10/10/2021 08:32

@minatrina
However, I think it all depends on how you reacted to your other BF telling you that she'd slept with him. If it were me, I'd have been totally honest and told her that whilst I love her and want to be there for her, I'm disappointed in what she's done and that I couldn't keep the secret. I'd have warned her that if she didn't tell your friend then I would.

Just wanted to say that is not what happened. OP said she found out from “someone at her work” that the one friend had slept with her best friends ex. No one confessed. There is no proof. It was 3rd hand workplace gossip that alleges that her friend slept with her best friends ex.

FluffyBooBoo · 10/10/2021 08:30

So there some workplace gossip saying this happened.

I don't know about you, but I've worked on places where if you fart in the storeroom, by the time you get to the till rumor has it you shit yourself.

Yeah yeah, I know op. For some reason you absolutely know it to be true. Well, I hope it's worth losing a friend over.

PlanDeRaccordement · 10/10/2021 08:20

I’m sorry but I also think it was wrong. You have no proof, you saw nothing, that one of your friends slept with her best friend’s ex. You literally repeated gossip from “someone at her work” as if it were fact? Who does that?

And the friend who is alleged to have slept with the ex, is currently struggling with her mental health and is suicidal...but you went ahead and spread harmful gossip about her to her best friend anyway? This is reckless and cruel on your part.

Auroreforet · 10/10/2021 08:18

I wouldn’t have told your bf because it’s all secondhand gossip.
It may be true but you could have chosen not to say anything and when/if confronted could honestly state you had no proof it was true and didn’t want to potentially spread false rumours.

Unfortunately you could end up losing both friendships.

ArranMumma · 10/10/2021 08:18

You need to tell the friend who “cheated” that you’ve told your friend. Otherwise it just gets confusing and even more difficult. I think you burned your friendship with her when you told your friend what she did. Not that you were wrong for doing that but yeah.

Dozer · 10/10/2021 08:15

It’d be ‘shit stirring’ if the friend whose relationship had ended was only OP’s acquaintance.

Dozer · 10/10/2021 08:14

Not ‘shit stirring’ to tell.

KaycePollard · 10/10/2021 08:10

I couldn't not tell my best friend so I told her that what other BF did.

Ahh, but you could have.

minatrina · 10/10/2021 07:52

I completely agree that I couldn't have kept my mouth shut either in your position, OP. I couldn't not tell a best friend about something like that.

However, I think it all depends on how you reacted to your other BF telling you that she'd slept with him. If it were me, I'd have been totally honest and told her that whilst I love her and want to be there for her, I'm disappointed in what she's done and that I couldn't keep the secret. I'd have warned her that if she didn't tell your friend then I would.

She put you in a difficult position by telling you, but if you weren't honest with her about her behaviour and if you told her you'd keep it a secret, then she will be upset with you.

Sounds very messy though OP, I hope everything turns out okay and ultimately your friend deserved to know the truth Thanks

SunLovingMum · 10/10/2021 07:46

I suppose while technically it wasn’t cheating because BF1 and her boyfriend of 5 years had just Brocken up before BF2 slept with him, yeah to BF1 it is cheating and her heart /head tells her that. It’s betrayal by bit of them.

Frankly, I think I would have told BF2 to tell BF1 or that I would, then follow through

However, cat is now out of the bag. As previous poster has suggested, do tell BF2 that it was you who told BF1 became you Ely her strongly that she needed to know, that you felt morally obligated but that as a friend, you’ll be there for her too should she wish to have your help/friendship. BF2 may well feel that you betrayed her (although she was morally wrong do sleep w this guy, at least without talking to BF1 first).

We all felt it when Ross slept with a girl very quickly while on a break from Rachel. We all know it’s a no no

Percie · 10/10/2021 07:07

TBF... I think sleeping with your BestFriends Ex (5 year relationship) of 8 weeks is pretty disgusting... very low bar and shady as fuck

Why? He's an ex - who he sleeps with now is not her business. Her friend is single, who she sleeps with is none of the others business, either.

The whole OP is a bizarre and embarrassing reaction to the behaviour of single adults suggesting the emotional maturity of a teaspoon.

SequinnedShawl · 10/10/2021 05:55

And the Big Wooden Spoon award for Shit Stirring goes to...

QueenBee52 · 10/10/2021 05:06

@Bizawit

Why did you get involved in this? You’ve caused a lot of hurt and pain and potentially ruined at least two friendships. You should have stayed out of it.
Sleeping with your besties Ex of 8 weeks kinda ruined the friendship... unless of course You slept with your best mates ex and such... maybe it's normal down your way...
QueenBee52 · 10/10/2021 05:04

@DoesHePlayTheFiddle

OP, do you know the term 'shit-stirrer'? Ah yes, I see someone used it upthread. Say what you see.
TBF... I think sleeping with your BestFriends Ex (5 year relationship) of 8 weeks is pretty disgusting... very low bar and shady as fuck...

So.. the OP may well be wrong for sharing the info... but the BestFriend sleeping with this guy.... that's just gross crass and vulgar... who needs friends like that... all the men available and she sleeps with this one... after your bestie has been with him for 5 years... that's gutter behaviour right there... lowest of the low...

Real cheap ass lass that...

PixieLaLa · 10/10/2021 00:47

So just to clarify you haven’t even spoken to friend who ‘cheated’ about this? It’s workplace gossip that you thought you just HAD to pass onto your other friend…Why didn’t you speak to her first and encourage her to be honest? All sounds very high school Confused

DoesHePlayTheFiddle · 10/10/2021 00:28

OP, do you know the term 'shit-stirrer'? Ah yes, I see someone used it upthread. Say what you see.

Bizawit · 10/10/2021 00:03

Why did you get involved in this? You’ve caused a lot of hurt and pain and potentially ruined at least two friendships. You should have stayed out of it.

Leobynature · 09/10/2021 23:50

Do the three of you work together? If not, it's downright weird: one of Friend1's coworkers told you, Friend1's friend who does not work there, that Friend1's ex had slept with Friend2, and that everyone in Friend1's workplace is talking about this ... but somehow Friend1 is still clueless and the coworker thinks Friend1 should know that everyone's gossiping about her, but none of the coworkers want to tell her?

I think your next big revelation should be to Friend1's boss, who'd probably love to know why no one's getting any work done.

This is brilliant*

MushMonster · 09/10/2021 23:40

Oh dear dear. You were in a difficult position.
I do not think you have done wrong by telling your other friend, specially if others already know.
I think the friend who has transgressed will learn that it was you at some point.
Unfortunately, you are trapped in the middle of this drama.
But you would also have been when your other friend would have found out from someone else.
It is the sleeping-with-ex-friend and the ex who have created this drama. So, I would not really care that much if this one did not want to talk to me anymore.
At least you have been fair and loyal to the betrayed one, so you shall not lose that friendship.
But if you are part of a small and close group, this is going to change this group forever. You be at peace with your concience OP. You did not make the drama. It was them.

QueenBee52 · 09/10/2021 23:40

@ViperHalliwell

Do the three of you work together? If not, it's downright weird: one of Friend1's coworkers told you, Friend1's friend who does not work there, that Friend1's ex had slept with Friend2, and that everyone in Friend1's workplace is talking about this ... but somehow Friend1 is still clueless and the coworker thinks Friend1 should know that everyone's gossiping about her, but none of the coworkers want to tell her?

I think your next big revelation should be to Friend1's boss, who'd probably love to know why no one's getting any work done.

🤣😂

hellothere007 · 09/10/2021 23:28

What are you, 15?

ViperHalliwell · 09/10/2021 23:24

Do the three of you work together? If not, it's downright weird: one of Friend1's coworkers told you, Friend1's friend who does not work there, that Friend1's ex had slept with Friend2, and that everyone in Friend1's workplace is talking about this ... but somehow Friend1 is still clueless and the coworker thinks Friend1 should know that everyone's gossiping about her, but none of the coworkers want to tell her?

I think your next big revelation should be to Friend1's boss, who'd probably love to know why no one's getting any work done.

QueenBee52 · 09/10/2021 22:39

Pretty rank to be sleeping with your Best Mates ex of 8 weeks...

thats pretty telling ... what a rancid mate..

all the men in the world and she screws that one ...

TheChiefJo · 09/10/2021 22:18

@MordredsOrrery

Sums it up.