Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think holding children down for “educational” purposes is bad?

305 replies

MakingM2 · 09/10/2021 12:26

I watched “Don’t exclude me” last night and there were some interesting ideas but I’ll cut to the chase.

In one scene, if you haven’t seen it, the teacher is physically restraining a very young boy who clearly has additional needs. They are basically on the floor in the playground. She is holding him down. He is pulling her hair. It’s all fairly horrific. She claims this is “trauma informed practice”.

The deputy head said - it feels wrong when you do it and it feels wrong when someone else does it.

…and my thought is “Sir, that’s because it is wrong”. You are teaching this tiny child that a more powerful person can physically force them to submit to their will - and that this is something that is ok. You may as well get a cane out.

Having been a governor in two primaries and friends with teachers and teacher trainers, I personally can’t imagine many teachers would want to undertake this kind of “behaviour management” even if the children do become more compliant afterwards.

And it occurred to me, given we think that observing violence is bad for children, should we really be doing this type of thing?

So am I being unreasonable to think violence (of any kind, with any justification) has no place in an educational environment?

YABU - nah, this is fine, stop being so precious
YANBU - education should be violence free

OP posts:
muddyford · 09/10/2021 15:47

I worked in a residential school for difficult teenagers (some arsonists, some having sex with their parents, that level of problem) with learning issues. We were trained in appropriate restraint to protect the child, to protect other children and to protect staff. Don't judge until you have been in that situation.

TaylorsSwimShorts · 09/10/2021 15:44

Watching this now....Oscar is my ds 6 years ago...identical behaviour, my ds has a diagnosis of ADHD, ODD /conduct disorder, he was kicked out of 3 primary schools, his behaviour was even more extreme and dangerous and at times he had to be restrained to stop him getting out of a window/onto the school roof, this wasn't even always successful...as much as I hated him being restrained, it was definitely needed, he is 12 now, and though different, he is still unable to attend school, I know that if he was in the special school recommended, he would be restrained again and as he is much bigger/stronger and aggressive, this would end badly for everyone, currently not in school 😞

Ozanj · 09/10/2021 15:40

Trauma Informed practice prevents a child from getting hurt. That restraint technique is just one; you could also restrain a child by hugging them. Honestly OP until you have seen a child with additional needs so worked up, so frustrated, that the only way they can make sense of things is by banging ten kinds of shit out of their heads then you can judge

callingon · 09/10/2021 15:34

I think if I saw a hold like that at my school I’d actually be obliged to report it; it’s outside what we are trained to do and the situation wasn’t dangerous enough to justify doing anything outside of our training (which it might be if you were eg having to prevent a child from jumping into a road, in which case you are permitted to essentially just grab them and pull them back).

MrsCherrytree · 09/10/2021 15:32

I work with children with challenging behaviours, honestly before you judge maybe you should spend a day in a school like that? And not form your opinions based on a programme quite possibly edited to make it look a certain way.

Restraint is used as a last resort and unfortunately it is sometimes necessary.

Lesserspottedmama · 09/10/2021 15:28

It’s a terrible thing for everyone involved and of course it feels wrong but... once I was at an after school club chatting to other mums while waiting for DC to get changed and a boy, maybe about 5yrs old and definitely (on reflection) with additional needs, flew at my youngest DD (aged 18 months) from behind and began trying to bite her and pull her hair.. he dug his fingers into her face and was snarling like an animal! It was horrific and his mother was utterly useless - standing their asking and pleading him to stop while myself and thankfully two other amazing women there pried him off. It took me hours to stop shaking, it was like he wanted to kill her. Even after he’d been pulled off he kept trying to fling himself on her again and again. It’s a sad fact of life that there are disturbed or incapacitated children that other children need to be protected from. I never went to that group again but I heard on the grapevine the boy was later asked to leave due to other serious incidents. I hope he is getting the help he needs.

callingon · 09/10/2021 15:27

Have seen the hold in question now and yeaaaaaah it wasn’t great and I can see why OP would be shocked by it. Wouldn’t be allowed in my school and I also don’t see why they went into it, no immediate risk to safety especially as he’s done the dangerous bit ie. slip on the tennis balls. I would like to see the rest of the programme but on that tiny snippet I wasn’t super impressed.

It’s at 26:00 mins in in episode two for those who want to find it.

LadyMuckington · 09/10/2021 15:16

I was also referred to the PRU by CAMHS and I think my Mum had to sign something saying she understood that the teachers were trained in graded holds (meaning the type of restraint was graded on proportion to the action) and she accepted that.

LadyMuckington · 09/10/2021 15:07

I went to a PRU between the ages of 13-16 and graded holds were a standard there. My school had pupils aged between 4-18 with all kinds of additional needs, health conditions and pregnant girls.

It was a shock to watch at first (I have a chronic illness which is why I was there so was never restrained) but they are often needed. Some kids need restraining not only for their own safety but the safety of others. I remember seeing a 15 year old boy being restrained by a teacher as he was flailing around and spitting in his face. It was horrible but he had a tendency for harming himself.

A knife went missing from the school kitchen once and three teachers had to restrain a boy whilst they prized it out of his pocket. Teachers are trained in these holds for a very good reason.

itsgettingwierd · 09/10/2021 15:06

The dfe use of reasonable force in schools says it's up to schools to decide how they log serious incidents. It also says about deciding how to report.

It's no longer a requirement to use a bound and numbered book although I don't like this. I would like a national reporting online system for use of force personally. Most schools now use cpoms.

If you think a student has been restrained and it not reported then ask for the report. Ask for it redacted as they can't provide names of third parties.

I'm a send parent myself and I don't recognise any schools not recording incidents. I do know they've not been reported before and I don't always agree with this in some cases.

spanieleyes · 09/10/2021 14:57

There aren't always " plenty of warning signs" that a meltdown is going to occur, a previous poster mentioned turning a page in a book and the child reacting immediately to a picture of a frog, we have a child who dislikes being looked at, if he thinks someone is looking at him he will lunge straight at the child in question or, if he can't get to them, throw a chair at the adult who intervenes, the TA I mentioned has commented that the boy she supports goes from zero to ten in 2 seconds flat with no foreseeable reason.

TreeWizard · 09/10/2021 14:55

Totally agree with @JanetandJohn500's comments. Watching the programme, the restraint used looked very much like a basket hold which is simply not safe, especially when the person being held is so much smaller abs lighter than the adult. The little boy looked to be at risk of positional asphyxia as his head was pushed so far forward.

Stormsy · 09/10/2021 14:52

@itsgettingwierd

Yet oddly there is no law to say parents must be told when their child has been restrained which naturally makes you question why? DfE guidance also only says schools should consider how to best record it. Some simply don't bother.

Restrained must be recorded. It is recommended as good practice to inform parents but it's not law because for some children (for example those who have extreme behaviour due to homelife) can be placed at greater risk if their parents are informed. It's very unusual to not inform a parent.

So why aren't all schools recording it? If you think it's only used where necessary and done properly and always recorded, there are plenty of send parents who will tell you that unfortunately this is not always the case.

Which law says it must be recorded?

Stormsy · 09/10/2021 14:49

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m0010cx8/dont-exclude-me-series-1-episode-2 26 mins in

I am 99.9% sure they have cut this before placing it on Iplayer. She was restraining the child before he started pulling her hair, which we no longer see here. It appears it's been edited out since airing so it now looks like she only starts restraining him after he starts pulling her hair. The fact they've edited it after people have starting questioning how necessary the restraint was speaks for itself Hmm

MoodyMooTutu · 09/10/2021 14:46

Eduction should be violence free but if it’s the child who is displaying violent behaviour what’s a teacher meant to do?
The child needs to be stopped from inflicting violence or unacceptable behaviour to other children.
Other than exclusion I’m not sure there is much else you can do if you have tried adjustments and none have worked.

Mumofsend · 09/10/2021 14:42

It came across to me that they jumped into using restraint far too quickly. It should be a last resort and I don't think with context at that stage it was appropriate.

My child was restrained once and she's still petrified of the member of staff.

itsgettingwierd · 09/10/2021 14:42

Yet oddly there is no law to say parents must be told when their child has been restrained which naturally makes you question why? DfE guidance also only says schools should consider how to best record it. Some simply don't bother.

Restrained must be recorded. It is recommended as good practice to inform parents but it's not law because for some children (for example those who have extreme behaviour due to homelife) can be placed at greater risk if their parents are informed. It's very unusual to not inform a parent.

HopeClearwater · 09/10/2021 14:41

@CaptainCallisto I have worked with many TAs in your position and you are all extremely poorly paid for the frankly dangerous work that you do.

As pp have said, the electorate have voted not to fund decent specialist provision and many children are going through school either without the support they need or having to watch extremely violent and frightening behaviour.

itsgettingwierd · 09/10/2021 14:40

Stormsy where I have said what he was doing was very dangerous Confused I'm not sure what your getting at with your response? I said I agree restraint has its place but didn't like the position she restrained him in or the fact she asked someone to hold his legs.

Upsielazy · 09/10/2021 14:38

You'd be more comfortable with removing from mainstream so that others don't have to wonder if x will be restrained today? Confused do you think this isn't used as a tool in specialist schools?

godmum56 · 09/10/2021 14:38

[quote Stormsy]@godmum56 did you watch it? We saw the whole incident. It did not require restraint, not by a long stretch. And the person restraining was someone who has been popping into school to give advice. They were not a teacher and certainly wouldn't know the child well on the limited contact they'd had.[/quote]
no I didn't which is why my comments have been general.

1forAll74 · 09/10/2021 14:36

It was fairly common place in the oldie days of teaching, and it used to work well with somewhat wayward children who were naughty. It wasn't violence in any way, just restraining a child. Some children seemingly did not have any normal discipline at home, but came to school causing havoc to one and all, which cant be tolerated in a class, with other kids, and a teacher, trying to do their jobs.

PutYourBackIntoit · 09/10/2021 14:35

There are real alternatives that cost the same as (or in my daughters case, less than) the cost of mainstream schools. My daughters mainstream school recieves £28/day and they redirect this to a farm provision that costs £23/day.

What needs to happen is for all parents to push their mps/LA'S/schools to utilise these provisions, and quickly rather than waiting for an EHCP which takes too long.

SEN families need a larger collective voice, as all of our children disbenefit from not utilising what exists.

DeepaBeesKit · 09/10/2021 14:33

I think many people agree that what was shown on tv may not have been a good example. It doesnt mean there are not situations where careful, trained restraint is the best or only way to keep everyone safe.

MummyGummy · 09/10/2021 14:33

The children in that programme clearly have undiagnosed conditions such as autism or ADHD so in that context it is cruel to be using physical restraint on a young child that has had a meltdown because their needs have not been recognised or supported adequately.

It should never reach the point of needing to physically restrain a child, there will be plenty of warning signs that the child is heading towards a meltdown and staff should be trained to recognise these and equipped with a range of options to help calm them before they are completely out of control of themselves.

Swipe left for the next trending thread