Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think holding children down for “educational” purposes is bad?

305 replies

MakingM2 · 09/10/2021 12:26

I watched “Don’t exclude me” last night and there were some interesting ideas but I’ll cut to the chase.

In one scene, if you haven’t seen it, the teacher is physically restraining a very young boy who clearly has additional needs. They are basically on the floor in the playground. She is holding him down. He is pulling her hair. It’s all fairly horrific. She claims this is “trauma informed practice”.

The deputy head said - it feels wrong when you do it and it feels wrong when someone else does it.

…and my thought is “Sir, that’s because it is wrong”. You are teaching this tiny child that a more powerful person can physically force them to submit to their will - and that this is something that is ok. You may as well get a cane out.

Having been a governor in two primaries and friends with teachers and teacher trainers, I personally can’t imagine many teachers would want to undertake this kind of “behaviour management” even if the children do become more compliant afterwards.

And it occurred to me, given we think that observing violence is bad for children, should we really be doing this type of thing?

So am I being unreasonable to think violence (of any kind, with any justification) has no place in an educational environment?

YABU - nah, this is fine, stop being so precious
YANBU - education should be violence free

OP posts:
Couldhavebeenme3 · 10/10/2021 08:49

@MyCatEatsPrawnCrackers

I agree that Education should be violence free, so if a child is being violent to others then he/she should be stopped. If that means by restraint as a last resort, then so be it.
What's your alternative OP?

Allow a child to be violent to others, or a risk to themselves, or restrained by fully trained professionals as a very last resort? Schools should be a safe place for everyone, and unless you've witnessed such a violent outburst, never mind had to deal with it, then you unfortunately have no insight as to the severity of a situation that has this difficult outcome.

twirlinginthesnow · 10/10/2021 08:48

@Ricekake I agree with you that there is no middle ground currently in most schools. It's either the child is a square peg in a round hole in a mainstream classroom with the teacher doing their best in an impossible situation or it's special school which are nigh on impossible to get a place at.

One local mainstream primary school here has a hub. A separate part of the school for children to access the full curriculum, if they're able, but not in the traditional classroom environment. Much smaller numbers, quiet spaces, movement breaks more readily available. These children don't have learning difficulties usually but they're unable to cope with a 30 child traditional classroom for whatever reason. They children can then, if they want or can, join in with break and lunchtime, assemblies, PE so that they're still part of the school community - ie not excluded.

It's a great success. They had a special grant for it apparently. There's arguments on both sides I think. Some people want inclusion at all costs and if schools had the funding that'd be great but it is not possible to meet all children's needs in a mainstream classroom without lots of staff and space. Which schools don't have and can't pull out of their backsides. Some people want all SEN children in specialist provision so that their own children are never disrupted by them - that's not right either and not necessary. But having a proper additional resource in a mainstream school with properly trained staff who can both teach and work with SEN children is a balanced approach I think.

Unfortunately it's a pipe dream because there is no money for this!

KingsleyShacklebolt · 10/10/2021 08:31

@Thegirlwiththeeagereyes

In my LA, we don't restrain children anymore. We used to have annual training on safe restraint, but not now. The only time I would restrain a child now was if they were about to run out in the road. It is very difficult, and at times means whole classrooms are wrecked, or means I am punched black and blue...but still better than restraining a child - it always made me feel a bit sick when I had to do it.

And yes, schools are dealing with an ever-increasing number and variety of needs, and more funding and training is desperately required.

How can allowing a child to wreck a whole classroom or allowing him/her to punch an adult black and blue be better then restraint? Obviously restraint is a last resort, but come on, however angry a child is, or whatever their needs, they cannot be allowed to trash classrooms and assault staff.

What about the other 29 children in the class?

Ricekake · 10/10/2021 08:30

@ichundich

I think the problem with this child was that he is in a mainstream school, which doesn't have the resources to cater to his needs. It's not fair on him, his classmates or his very inexperienced teacher, who might end up leaving the profession because it's so stressful. My friend's son couldn't walk until he was 6, he is non verbal, unable to be toilet trained. Yet she was initially only offered a place for him at our local primary school (who said that they would not be able to teach him, but only to provide childcare). She had to go to the local press and contact our MP to get him a place at the special needs school.
Yes this is also an issue, it is extremely hard to gain a place and the threshold is really high. I do think there is more of a middle group who don't thrive in mainstream but wouldn't necessarily require attending a special needs school. Not sure on the answer as to how best those children would be supported would be though.
Ricekake · 10/10/2021 08:28

But this is a TV programme edited so the full picture might not be shared.

Yes I agree with this, there could have been previous incidents that led them to take this approach, it still doesn't mean it was the correct one, but it is hard to judge from a heavily edited programme designed to get viewers.

I'm sure it can be agreed that there isn't enough support given to schools to be able to care for and teach every child and their differing needs currently.

ichundich · 10/10/2021 08:19

I think the problem with this child was that he is in a mainstream school, which doesn't have the resources to cater to his needs. It's not fair on him, his classmates or his very inexperienced teacher, who might end up leaving the profession because it's so stressful. My friend's son couldn't walk until he was 6, he is non verbal, unable to be toilet trained. Yet she was initially only offered a place for him at our local primary school (who said that they would not be able to teach him, but only to provide childcare). She had to go to the local press and contact our MP to get him a place at the special needs school.

Elephantsparade · 10/10/2021 08:13

@Spikeyball

Unfortunately some schools use this type of approach with children who have a diagnosis that indicates this approach is the wrong one.
Yes sadly this is true too.
AnotherLauraLou · 10/10/2021 08:10

Sometimes I felt that they overloaded the children such as Oscar with a lot of information when talking to them, we can do this, this, this, this. There wasn’t much time to give them to process. My DC need time to process what is being said, one piece of information at a time. I know all children are different though.

When he gave her a hug at the end, that was lovely.

Spikeyball · 10/10/2021 08:05

Unfortunately some schools use this type of approach with children who have a diagnosis that indicates this approach is the wrong one.

Elephantsparade · 10/10/2021 08:00

She had a great rapport with the children. And there are alternatives to team teach.

Its a failing of the education and health system is that it talks about provision being 'needs led' so therefore you dont end up with a diagnosis or any assessments to find out why a child is behaving like this. it means schools are forced to treat a symptom which could have multiple causes because its so hard to access assessments. Some times the treatment works as they were good techniques for a lot of children with semh. Other times is causes damage like with my son with asd because although the symptom is the same the different cause needed something else. Its very hard when you have a child with ptsd caused by school not feel distressed if you see a child who could also be damaged by the wrong treatment. But this is a TV programme edited so the full picture might not be shared.

Spikeyball · 10/10/2021 07:47

Having looked the expert up her background is entirely in semh. The approach she uses is inappropriate with a child where other difficulties have not been ruled out.

twirlinginthesnow · 10/10/2021 07:45

@Mumofsend That is interesting, thanks for sharing.

Whoever said about it being disapproved of because the lady is black is talking utter bloody nonsense. Race has absolutely zero to do with this discussion. If feel the same whatever race she was!

Mumofsend · 10/10/2021 07:33

Interesting comment from Team Teach :)

AIBU to think holding children down for “educational” purposes is bad?
gogohm · 10/10/2021 07:19

My dd never had to be restrained at school thankfully but certainly did at home, I was taught the correct techniques. She's autistic and sometimes it's the only answer to protect herself and others, I have scars from her. She attended mainstream school because she was bright (a*'s and A's) and the special school provision she was offered do didn't do proper qualifications, only a few btecs. She's at university now

Mumofsend · 10/10/2021 07:10

@User5827372728 absolutely nothing to do with race at all, it would have been am inappropriate use of restraint if she were white too.

Spikeyball · 10/10/2021 07:05

She shouldn't have been using that hold in that situation.

User5827372728 · 10/10/2021 06:46

Typical from MN the black lady isn’t an expert and is patronising! Surprised she’s not been called aggressive yet.

Spikeyball · 10/10/2021 06:42

She is clearly not an expert if she is using that hold in that situation in a school.

Spikeyball · 10/10/2021 06:40

A hold should not have been used in that situation and the hold used was against guidelines. It is not endorsed by team teach.

User5827372728 · 10/10/2021 06:30

@Babyfg

The expert seemed really patronising and I felt she restrained him because she was like don't make a fool of me on the camera. I was thinking go on lad when he said he'd follow her then ran off because I'd have done the same to someone treating me like how she was.

Sorry ranting but it did break my heart a bit.

She’s not being patronising, she’s adjusting hoe she is talking as she is talking to a 6 year old kid, and you know what? It worked!

I purely worked with students who have been excluded numerous times and those on mama he’s transfers and it’s not like the day to day workings of a mainstream school.

She’s an expert, taught the others how to restrain him, and hopefully made a positive change to the kids lives and their families, and the other 29 kids in the class who’s learning was being ruined day in and day out

Nat6999 · 10/10/2021 01:13

There was a boy at ds primary school with ADHD & related behaviour problems, he could kick off at anything, he threw chairs, desks, anything he could get hold of. His class was regularly removed from the classroom when he had a meltdown, the teacher used to lock the classroom door & then go round to unlock the outside door from the classroom to the playground, he would then go outside & run the meltdown off. As he got older he found he could climb the 10 foot fence & escape. He was placed in a SEN school from Y7. The biggest problem in this country is that children with SEN are mostly expected to be in mainstream schools, there aren't many specialist schools & education authorities will do anything to avoid placing a child in a suitable school mainly because of the cost, not because it is best for the child. My brother & sil had to go to tribunal to get my nephew who is severely autistic & has ADHD a place in the school that was named on his EHCP, they had to consider remortgaging their home to pay for the reports, a barrister for the tribunal & the tribunal, they were lucky they could afford to do this. The school is run by the Autistic Society & costs a minimum of £35k a year, he will stay there until he is 19. Parents shouldn't have to fight to get what is a human right, a right to an education in a suitable school.

Thegirlwiththeeagereyes · 10/10/2021 00:36

In my LA, we don't restrain children anymore. We used to have annual training on safe restraint, but not now. The only time I would restrain a child now was if they were about to run out in the road. It is very difficult, and at times means whole classrooms are wrecked, or means I am punched black and blue...but still better than restraining a child - it always made me feel a bit sick when I had to do it.

And yes, schools are dealing with an ever-increasing number and variety of needs, and more funding and training is desperately required.

eeek88 · 09/10/2021 23:49

It’s a tricky one. It should be an absolutely last resort but unfortunately in establishments where physical interventions are allowed, they can become normalised, due to the experiences and temperaments of the staff and children there.

I worked in such a place. I was and still am appalled by the idea of restraining a child and I’d do anything to avoid it. There were times when my reluctance to restrain them may have put them at risk, but there were many other times when I was glad I’d held back because I managed to resolve the situation through other means (ie talking to them or accompanying them as they attempted to do a runner). After I left I looked back on the restraints my colleagues did with horror and felt strongly that it was very wrong.

Some years later I met one of the children I’d looked after, now a young adult. We became good friends. We talked a lot about the establishment and our shared experiences of it, and to my surprise he was very complimentary about it. One day I asked him whether he thought it would have been better without the restraining and he looked at me as if I was mad and said, ‘no, because if it hadn’t restrained kids I wouldn’t have gone there’. He’s right. This place was his only chance of a childhood not spent behind bars. He was able to integrate into the local community, meet local kids, hang out in their homes being fed home cooking by their mums, but on bad days he flipped out and my colleagues restrained him. Afterwards he’d cry, give them a hug, and talk about it. He’s turned into a lovely adult and believes he owes it to this place and the ‘tough love’ he got there (and he truly was loved, but also one of the most difficult kids any of us had ever met).

So yes. It’s complicated.

Babyfg · 09/10/2021 23:32

I've just watched that and that scene made me feel uneasy. If you keep watching when the talk to the male teacher they cut him off as he's talking about it , also when they call the nest woman out you can see how unwilling she is to hold his legs down. When she restrains the boy again the male teacher is sitting on the bench looking really uneasy.

I've taught for 11 years and we've had quite a few children like this boy. From what I saw on camera (obviously they will edit for effect or whatever so you don't see everything like being there). I would have made the area safe and basically acted like I was ignoring the behaviour. Let him rage it out and when he was calm talk to him. I feel it escalated because of being restrained!

Fwiw I thought additional needs too.

The expert seemed really patronising and I felt she restrained him because she was like don't make a fool of me on the camera. I was thinking go on lad when he said he'd follow her then ran off because I'd have done the same to someone treating me like how she was.

Sorry ranting but it did break my heart a bit.

Sockwomble · 09/10/2021 23:15

"And it doesn’t hurt- in the training you have to be “restrained” and fight against it so that you know how it feels."

You don't know how it feels. You are not that child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread