Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think holding children down for “educational” purposes is bad?

305 replies

MakingM2 · 09/10/2021 12:26

I watched “Don’t exclude me” last night and there were some interesting ideas but I’ll cut to the chase.

In one scene, if you haven’t seen it, the teacher is physically restraining a very young boy who clearly has additional needs. They are basically on the floor in the playground. She is holding him down. He is pulling her hair. It’s all fairly horrific. She claims this is “trauma informed practice”.

The deputy head said - it feels wrong when you do it and it feels wrong when someone else does it.

…and my thought is “Sir, that’s because it is wrong”. You are teaching this tiny child that a more powerful person can physically force them to submit to their will - and that this is something that is ok. You may as well get a cane out.

Having been a governor in two primaries and friends with teachers and teacher trainers, I personally can’t imagine many teachers would want to undertake this kind of “behaviour management” even if the children do become more compliant afterwards.

And it occurred to me, given we think that observing violence is bad for children, should we really be doing this type of thing?

So am I being unreasonable to think violence (of any kind, with any justification) has no place in an educational environment?

YABU - nah, this is fine, stop being so precious
YANBU - education should be violence free

OP posts:
parrotonmyshoulder · 10/10/2021 14:12

@Mumofsend

‘They receive 26k EHCP funding. 1.3k PP. 4k bums on seats for her. So over 30k for her.’

I’m not doubting you, but utterly amazed at the difference between this and what is available as an absolute maximum in my area. I wonder if this sort of difference is why we are all at loggerheads on this thread, as well as the differences between individual schools. What I could do with that amount of money! I honestly cannot get anything like that.

FuckingFabulous · 10/10/2021 14:06

My daughter had this awful technique used on her by a PE teacher who was oddly thrilled to do so. His reasoning was that she was getting anxious and he feared she may harm herself! She was getting anxious because he was shouting in her face to calm down when she was coughing and spluttering after going underwater at swimming and unable to get out. So this massive man pinned my nine year old daughter first to the wall and then to the cold floor with her arms at her sides, just wearing a soaking wet swimming costume and utterly terrified, in front of her whole class. There was no reason to do it and there was never any discussion that these techniques would be used at this little village mainstream primary. All students were shocked and frightened. The parent helper said he seemed to genuinely relish his power over my little girl. It was she who insisted the school call me immediately to explain what had taken place. The first time in my life I felt sheer nuclear anger.

How long do you reckon he kept his job?

Spoiler alert- he was on leave by the end of the day.

Even when working with children who can and do harm themselves and others, is wrong to do this when there are so many other distraction and de-escalation methods. Knowing these in a job role made me even more disgusted at what that man did to my daughter. Ground holds are an advanced team teach method and the use of them is prohibited in most situations.

5zeds · 10/10/2021 14:03

Disabled people have the right to be educated just like anyone else. Give us local schools that provide an education at least as good as that available in MS and I’m sure far fewer parents will opt to have their children treated this way to scrabble for the crumbs of education they might get in mainstream,

ForPingsSake · 10/10/2021 13:21

While I agree that children who need this kind of intervention may not be best-suited to a mainstream environment, the reality is that is where a lot of them are and they have to be managed somehow. IME children end up in mainstream (when they possibly shouldn't be) either because it is really hard to get through the process of diagnosis and proof that they actually need a specialist placement* OR because the parents refuse to acknowledge that their child needs specialist provision and insist that they stay in mainstream. Sadly, I have seen several children who only ended up getting the help they needed after being permanently excluded from mainstream school.

*even when it is obvious to every adult in the school that deals with them and even then it can be hard to get a place for them.

ArianaDumbledore · 10/10/2021 13:12

I did think MG seemed to immediately pick up that Olivia was a very confused little girl, I would be interested to know what the 1:1 sessions were but can totally understand the need to respect Olivia's privacy. Olivia did seem genuinely baffled by her teacher's reaction to her (when the teacher said she was giving attitude with how she talking and looking at her etc). I do think it was a genuine difficulty in reading social situations being misinterpreted as being cheeky etc

Stormsy · 10/10/2021 12:56

@ArianaDumbledore

Team Teach has responded, MG is not trained by them. I think a lot of schools use TT
Yet despite what TT have said, people will still pile in here saying it was reasonable to use restraint - when they haven't even watched the clip in question!
AccidentallyOnPurpose · 10/10/2021 10:17

As a parent and school staff I've learned that:

Some schools/SLT/teachers can be unbelievably crap.

Some parents can be crap.

The education system, the DFE and especially the government are totally crap and don't give a crap about the staff,the kids or their parents. Especially when it comes to our most vulnerable(for whatever reason) children.

They are continuously cutting funding from schools and other places of support , as well as shutting them down. Then they shrug and wonder why the numbers don't look good. And it's all about the numbers, not the kids.

Hercisback · 10/10/2021 10:13

It shouldn’t really take thirty minutes, assuming not NQT/ECT.

Secondary specialist in maths here with many years experience. Some EHCP requirements do need 30+ minutes daily planning. Visual reminders, printed timelines, different coloured paper, sentences to fill, faded activities, TA filled in on lesson.

Differentiated work is an expectation, but realistic expectations of workload have to come into it too.

drspouse · 10/10/2021 10:05

@Planningspringflowers

To be fair, differentiated work is an expectation of teaching.

If a child can’t access the curriculum it is the teachers role to help him access it. It shouldn’t really take thirty minutes, assuming not NQT/ECT.

I've been told my DS needs "an individualised curriculum" like this was a bad thing and no child should ever need this.
drspouse · 10/10/2021 09:57

I haven't read all the posts but Team Teach who trained this school say this was completely inappropriate for the situation, and a dangerous hold.
I know my DS was held by 4 adults in his previous school when other children could have been moved instead. I can't watch.

Maybebaby8 · 10/10/2021 09:54

I've had to restrain a child, and i was the last resort, after having chair's thrown at me, being spat at, punched etc. No level of talking would have calmed them down in that state, he even ripped plastic cable covering off and smacked me across the face with it. Needless to say we had to restrain him, to then move him to a safe place to calm down. No it's not nice for anyone but sometimes it's necessary.

Mumofsend · 10/10/2021 09:53

I would also argue my DD's specification is largely actually something that more requires one off periods of preparation. She really benefits from flashcards with the word and the picture on and she builds sentences with them which is what we've just used for her to do homework this week.

ArianaDumbledore · 10/10/2021 09:52

I would say special schools aren't always the answer, as they can be more rigid than mainstream with some things.

There was a NAS school that closed and staff were over using restraint and seclusion. And there's been other safeguarding for a large group too.

Ds3 is doing much better in his school but he does now swear like a docker(!)

Mumofsend · 10/10/2021 09:49

@Hercisback my DD can do the content but is most likely severely dyslexic (Nearly 7 so still a bit young for the diagnosis). She has a TA read/scribe for her and she shows she can do the content fairly easily so she doesn't need an entirely different lesson. Her EHCP specifies a high level of visual supports within her learning. Her EHCP also specifies planning time to allow these to be prepared.

@accidentallyonpurpose and this is the dilemma I had with my DD. Except she isn't violent, she had a couple of small isolated incidents and the one the school were entirely to blame. Her choices are a specialist that the oldest children aren't doing the level of work she's doing, a specialist for extremely violent children or staying here she is and I will just continue being a PITA parent ensuring her ehcp is adhered to.

pinkwoolymammoth · 10/10/2021 09:46

Depends on the situation although I think there are too many dc being forced through mainstream school that shouldn't be which is bad for al dc.

When I was at primary school in the 90's there were two boys that were extremely disruptive to our class: I don't remember being traumatised whatsoever when a teacher made efforts to restrain a dc if they were about to kick off. Only relieved as it meant they wouldn't hurt us. One time a teacher locked a boy in the cupboard within our class room as he'd started to lash out and kick the teacher. Over time they knew exactly when to restrain him before someone else got hurt. It meant 30 other dc got an education instead of witnessing or even experience violence.

I do wish there were more special schools though more able to deal with such dc.

Planningspringflowers · 10/10/2021 09:35

To be fair, differentiated work is an expectation of teaching.

If a child can’t access the curriculum it is the teachers role to help him access it. It shouldn’t really take thirty minutes, assuming not NQT/ECT.

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 10/10/2021 09:33

The issue is there is no alternative provision . Our local SEN school serves 3 boroughs, it's massively over subscribed and it's harder and harder to get a space. They don't have the space (or staff) to take in more children and still keep numbers low in the classroom.

DD's (mainstream)school is brilliant for SEN , but that means the LEA just dumps kids that are severely struggling or excluded from other mainstreams on them. There's no recourse . Then if the school can't manage (like they've warned and documented before the child started) they need to show they've tried everything, then implement whatever new suggestions, document again for a while, prove they've done it and it's still not working and so on before the LEA finally relents or a space becomes available at the SEN school. In the meantime that child has already spent years in an unsuitable environment through no fault of their own, their parents or staff.

My school is similar, we have classes with over 10 children on the SEN register, 3/4 EHCP's , medical needs etc. The funding is scarce and the LEA are dragging their feet, but somehow in a class of 30 we have to provide various 1:1 support to 3 children but there's just me and the teacher .

And there is absolutely no place to go for children who are academically very able but with severe behavioural/emotional /MH issues, leaving parents with a really shitty choice where their child loses out anyways. Either academically in a SEN school(which are mostly geared towards SLD) , or in a mainstream school that doesn't suit their needs.

Hercisback · 10/10/2021 09:32

What do you mean by appropriately differentiated work? What does this look like to you?

I ask because when people say this, they usually want either a completely different lesson planning, or a different resource. Both of these things take time to plan (over and above regular lesson planning). 1:1 TA funding is usually school hours only so no time for them to plan. Teachers are limited in their time too (2 hours PPA a week on average). Legally the responsibility falls with the classroom teacher to differentiate and ime the majority work their hardest to do everything possible. But we are humans with our own time limits too. Spending 30 mins a day planning a resource for one child isn't sustainable.

donquixotedelamancha · 10/10/2021 09:27

I've had to restrain kids in school to break up fights and even restrain my own child at home because she was very violent.

It's not nice but no-one does it for fun. It's an adults duty to prevent kids in their care being hurt. I've seen a kid injured after other teachers froze and didn't intervene in a fight.

Mumofsend · 10/10/2021 09:21

@boobsonthemoon @Elephantsparade

My DD's school are going the same way.

They receive 26k EHCP funding. 1.3k PP. 4k bums on seats for her. So over 30k for her. Yet they refuse to provide her appropriately differentiated work so they can show she can't keep up.

She has never trashed a classroom, hurt another child etc. She had one lashing out at a teacher incident when they had her cornered. Her biggest is she is a flight risk but her flight is run and find a small hidey hole for 5-10 minutes and she calms down. We had an incident this time last year where she was restrained. Why was she restrained? Because she was in her EHCP specified den organising her colours because she had been overwhelmed by a fire alarm. She was in the den 7 minutes and the teacher decided it was work time. DD went from ok in the den organising to self calm to having a shed load of you must do x, y and z immediately by no less than 5 members of staff. She was 5 years old. So then she got upset and loud so she was restrained as she was disrupting the other children learning.

The whole incident escalated because of her ehcp being ignored and completely needlessly. She is still scared of the member of staff.

She isn't a violent child at all.

ArianaDumbledore · 10/10/2021 09:20

DS3 was disruptive in mainstream, the school supported the LA for the tribunal! but fortunately we won and he's now in a specialist. He has ASD ADHD and sensory difficulties

Whenever school messed up (and they admitted so) they were "only human" but when my son did it was "unacceptable" and he needed consequences.

The tribunal process was so stressful and it really isn't easy. The fees and travel for DS3 are eye-watering.

I have seen in some of my SEN groups that some parents of the DC featured have said child/ren do have a diagnosis but the program didn't want to focus on that? But I've not seen the comments myself so it's a bit of "my friend's neighbour's aunt's dog walker said..." situation

ArianaDumbledore · 10/10/2021 09:09

Team Teach has responded, MG is not trained by them. I think a lot of schools use TT

AIBU to think holding children down for “educational” purposes is bad?
AIBU to think holding children down for “educational” purposes is bad?
Emmelina · 10/10/2021 09:02

All schools will have a restraint policy. I can only assume OP has never been around a child so out of control they are likely to harm themselves and those around them.
What to do in this situation? Let them do it? What do you say to the parents of the other children injured? And those of the child who hurt themselves- “we saw it escalating but didn’t want to appear violent to passers by so let him tear out the teachers hair and scratch up another child’s face before allowing him to bounce his own head off the playground”
That would go down REALLY well.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/use-of-reasonable-force-in-schools

childlawadvice.org.uk/information-pages/discipline-within-school/

forfucksakenett · 10/10/2021 09:01

It was BBC2 so not the usually Benefit Street type nonsense.

Interesting comment. And by interesting I mean classist and shitty.

BoobsOnTheMoon · 10/10/2021 08:55

[quote Elephantsparade]@DoubleShotEspresso my sons last school got 32k to have him in for 45 mins 3 times a week for the whole academic year. Id love to know what they did with it. Theres zero accountability[/quote]
This! My child was at a school for 18 months with funding for a full time 1-1, funding for the staff to have training in various strategies and therapeutic approaches to use with him, funding for specialist equipment... and for most of that time he attended for less than 2 hours a day. The school basically stole from a disabled child. The money wasn't spent on him, but nobody holds them to account over it. It's disgusting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread