Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think holding children down for “educational” purposes is bad?

305 replies

MakingM2 · 09/10/2021 12:26

I watched “Don’t exclude me” last night and there were some interesting ideas but I’ll cut to the chase.

In one scene, if you haven’t seen it, the teacher is physically restraining a very young boy who clearly has additional needs. They are basically on the floor in the playground. She is holding him down. He is pulling her hair. It’s all fairly horrific. She claims this is “trauma informed practice”.

The deputy head said - it feels wrong when you do it and it feels wrong when someone else does it.

…and my thought is “Sir, that’s because it is wrong”. You are teaching this tiny child that a more powerful person can physically force them to submit to their will - and that this is something that is ok. You may as well get a cane out.

Having been a governor in two primaries and friends with teachers and teacher trainers, I personally can’t imagine many teachers would want to undertake this kind of “behaviour management” even if the children do become more compliant afterwards.

And it occurred to me, given we think that observing violence is bad for children, should we really be doing this type of thing?

So am I being unreasonable to think violence (of any kind, with any justification) has no place in an educational environment?

YABU - nah, this is fine, stop being so precious
YANBU - education should be violence free

OP posts:
AnotherLauraLou · 09/10/2021 12:32

I watched the same episode and have a child who is autistic, I can’t imagine anyone holding him down and the thought of it upsets me. It wasn’t nice to watch. However I don’t know a lot about it either. I don’t agree with exclusion though, how does that benefit a primary aged child? It doesn’t mean anything. It is very hard to get any help or understanding for children with additional needs in main stream school.

She mentioned she had previously worked with other children, what was her background as I missed other episodes?

Feenie · 09/10/2021 12:31

It's about stopping a child from being violent and hurting themselves and others, and absolutely should only be done by trained professionals. Of course it isn't violent. And yes, it's horrible to have to do, but the alternative (child hurting others/themselves) is worse.

What would you prefer?

MichelleScarn · 09/10/2021 12:30

What was the context OP?

Evasmithsghost · 09/10/2021 12:29

I’ve only ever had to physically restrain a child once, in eighteen years of teaching. But I haven’t seen the programme so can’t comment on the context.

MoiraRose4 · 09/10/2021 12:29

Sometimes children have to be held for their own safety and the safety of others. I didn’t see what you’re referring to, so can’t comment on that. But if a child is being violent, to others or to themselves, what would you propose?

Swipe left for the next trending thread