Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think holding children down for “educational” purposes is bad?

305 replies

MakingM2 · 09/10/2021 12:26

I watched “Don’t exclude me” last night and there were some interesting ideas but I’ll cut to the chase.

In one scene, if you haven’t seen it, the teacher is physically restraining a very young boy who clearly has additional needs. They are basically on the floor in the playground. She is holding him down. He is pulling her hair. It’s all fairly horrific. She claims this is “trauma informed practice”.

The deputy head said - it feels wrong when you do it and it feels wrong when someone else does it.

…and my thought is “Sir, that’s because it is wrong”. You are teaching this tiny child that a more powerful person can physically force them to submit to their will - and that this is something that is ok. You may as well get a cane out.

Having been a governor in two primaries and friends with teachers and teacher trainers, I personally can’t imagine many teachers would want to undertake this kind of “behaviour management” even if the children do become more compliant afterwards.

And it occurred to me, given we think that observing violence is bad for children, should we really be doing this type of thing?

So am I being unreasonable to think violence (of any kind, with any justification) has no place in an educational environment?

YABU - nah, this is fine, stop being so precious
YANBU - education should be violence free

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ArianaDumbledore · 12/10/2021 14:49

there is a charity that can help with funding reports for parents in certain circumstances. There are restrictions and they do have limited capacity, but worth a mention.

www.parentsinneed.org/

Whatsitbeen · 12/10/2021 14:16

My son has complex needs and has been restrained at school. He is now in a different school as he could not cope in the previous school at all. The restraints and seclusion only made the situation worse, to the point he hated school. He is now in a much more suitable school where they focus on what his needs are, rather than the behaviour.

That restraint on the show was completely unnecessary and dangerous. She was holding that child in a potentially dangerous position and there was no need for the restraint in the first place as he was not a danger. She was shouting at him about bad choices and blaming him for tripping over the balls, exacerbating the situation. If that was my child there would be absolute hell to pay.

drspouse · 12/10/2021 14:01

The SENDO at the LEA thinks we should source our own OT and the "Inclusion manager" thinks he shouldn't have OT "until he's more motivated". It's in his EHCP.
If you are also in the NW mum do PM me!

Mumofsend · 12/10/2021 13:51

But we do have an abundance of OTs here! Typical

Mumofsend · 12/10/2021 13:51

Things on the EP front have drastically declined in a very short space of time. My DD's school had similar to described by @drspouse in 2019 and no longer can. Its hideous the situation.

drspouse · 12/10/2021 13:50

[quote Whyarewehardofthinking]@drspouse please tell me where they are. I'm in Manchester and have 9 students in year 7 alone waiting. One is dangerously close to PEX already due to the injuries staff and other students are sustaining. We as a staff would have a whip around to pay for an EP if we could get one here sooner than next June.[/quote]
We are also in the NW and some of the ones that work in our area are based in Lancashire (i.e. not in your county but should be within commuting distance). I'm surprised TBH - though as I say it's possible there has been a backlog since we saw the last EP in about March.
Would a specialist school lend you one? Some of them have a full time one on staff but if they are 0.8 they might do private work the other day?

In contrast the PRU has been trying since April (how hard, I do not know) to find an OT to see DS weekly (again, NW) and claim they cannot find one.

Whyarewehardofthinking · 12/10/2021 13:42

@drspouse please tell me where they are. I'm in Manchester and have 9 students in year 7 alone waiting. One is dangerously close to PEX already due to the injuries staff and other students are sustaining. We as a staff would have a whip around to pay for an EP if we could get one here sooner than next June.

drspouse · 12/10/2021 10:49

@Hercisback

😂 Good luck finding a school that will fund a private one.
All of my DS schools (two mainstream and one PRU) have private ones they use. One of the mainstream schools also called in the LEA one but they usually use the private one.

The PRU has a private one they often use who came at quite short notice (though for a few different pupils and just gave advice rather than seeing DS) and that was during the pandemic. I accept that some areas may be busier and/or things may have backed up even more this school year.

Mumofsend · 12/10/2021 10:28

@drspouse there really are not at the moment. Plus schools can't afford to. Generally EPs are now only available for ECHNA.

Hercisback · 12/10/2021 09:42

😂 Good luck finding a school that will fund a private one.

Sirzy · 12/10/2021 08:33

Even the private ones locally are booked up massively because of the shortage. Local authorities are using them to meet their requirements for EHCNA

drspouse · 12/10/2021 08:25

[quote Hercisback]@drspouse 2 year wait to get an EP in school at the moment.[/quote]
They can pay a private one. Loads about.

Sleepyblueocean · 12/10/2021 08:19

Waiting for an ED psych is a major hold up and if a parent is fortunate enough to have some money available to spend on getting support and provision, that is where I would spend it. The LA may choose to ignore the report but a tribunal won't. There is a wait for independent EP but it is not nearly as bad and they are 'allowed' not to be vague.

Ricekake · 12/10/2021 08:14

Sadly there just aren't the qualified staff to up the provision and shorten waiting lists. Even if millions and millions was thrown at the system, the staffing gaps would still be a huge issue preventing much improvement. Not sure what the answer is, but retention is a real issue and as usual, the government is not doing anything to address the underlying issues. It's so sad children and their families are waiting so long for assessments to be able to access the support they need.

Mumofsend · 12/10/2021 08:00

Really worryingly @sirzy is a lot of areas recently haven't had Ed Psychs even for EHCNAs, there's a major crisis with availability at the moment. Even independents are 6+ plus :(

Sirzy · 12/10/2021 07:43

In a lot of areas now the only realistic way of getting an ED psych in is via the EHCP process.

Mumofsend · 12/10/2021 06:33

@CheshireChat it took 3 years of mostly waiting lists for my obvious DD to be diagnosed. She started her first year at school and diagnosis came at 5.5

Both of my DC got their EHCPs pre diagnosis and both of of EHCPs identified their individual needs rather than diagnosis. The EPs and SALT and OT etc are trained to identified the needs.

If they need extra support and need an ehcp do not let lack of diagnosis put you off.

GinJeanie · 12/10/2021 06:19

I've not seen this yet but will take a look. Working in an SEN school it does happen occasionally and we have a lot of training which is reviewed annually. It's very much seen as a last resort and there are detailed debriefs afterwards. However, we never use the term "restraint" opting for "holding". Also, no child is ever held down on the floor. We're told this is dangerous and if a child drops to the floor you stand back. A hold is usually done in twos, walking to a safe area, standing or sitting on a chair for the shortest possible time. As pp have said, it's only when a child is likely to really hurt themselves or others. E.g I've had to do it when a lad was going to wallop another with a tree branch outside. Years ago a colleague had to rescue another member of staff who was being strangled by a teen with SEN. That was far more drastic and his legs were kicked from under him. Incredibly rare (and sad) situation though!

Hercisback · 12/10/2021 06:05

@drspouse 2 year wait to get an EP in school at the moment.

drspouse · 12/10/2021 05:03

The school can (and should) buy in EP services and you can also access OT without a diagnosis. An EHCP goes on need, not diagnosis.
There is very little support after diagnosis.

CheshireChat · 11/10/2021 23:59

Can I also add just how long it takes for a diagnosis and how little help there is available without it?

I was told it'll be 18-24 months before my son will be assessed and that was before Covid.

But in the meantime he needs support at school and neither me, nor his teacher are quite sure what would actually work and I can't access anything locally as he isn't actually diagnosed so we're stuck in a rather vicious circle.

Sunshineandalltherainbows · 11/10/2021 22:36

I've had to restrain 2 children before in mainstream primary.
I would never do this lightly.
Always exhaust every deescslation technique available.
However, the 2 times I have used I know it was the right thing to do. Both times I have a warning, "make yourself safe or I will need to help you be safe".
But I am not going to allow a child to physically attack another child (first case involved child who had kicked another child in the head and wanted to continue.
Or risk the safety of the class (throwing tables, chairs and other objects whilst I was evacuating my classroom.
Behaviour in mainstream primary schools is getting a lot worse.

PutYourBackIntoit · 11/10/2021 19:26

My child's sendco has said that she won't apply for an echp for my dd.
We have done it ourselves now, but would much rather have done it with the support of school.

The sendco also said that dd can't have dyslexia because she doesn't complain of letters moving, and she can't have adhd because she's so well behaved.

At primary school the sendco blocked an Ed Psych doing an assessment as 'it would open the floodgates'.

My child has not been to school since March, she has school based ptsd, barely leaves tge house and in her worst weeks stops communicating with us and stops eating. We are on an 8 month camhs waiting list.

I understand there's probably tons of great sendcos out there. Sadly in our experience, we are yet to meet one! I am so fed up of being let down by those whose jobs it is to help my dd.

Sleepyblueocean · 11/10/2021 17:52

"These are not the SENCO's decisions. 🤦🏽‍♀️ They are instructed by their LA on what they need in terms of evidence etc."

All schools do not behave in the same way so some of it does come down to the schools choice. Insisting a child only attends for 2 hours a day for months on end and even then often sending them home after 30 mins because they are having a bad day is a pretty clear indication that the school can't meet needs. This was not my child. It was a family I supported through tribunal. I come from a background in education so I knew very early on when my child was being treated unlawfully.

AllWaxedOut · 11/10/2021 17:23

AccidentallyOnPurpose

I'm not doubting what you're saying and I know people can only speak from their own experience, it's just the sweeping statements that are jarring.

I've appreciated and learnt from the comments of SEN parents that have responded on this thread and it's definitely good to see things from different prospectives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread