Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Changing in classroom - AIBU?

88 replies

Meatbadger · 09/10/2021 10:18

Year 3 DD came home upset yesterday as she got told off for being slow to get changed for PE. She was trying to do it while crouching behind her chair as she felt uncomfortable stripping off in front of the boys.

There have been several issues in the past with boys trying to look at the girls’ pants etc. They’re only 7/8 but AIBU to think mixed changing is probably not appropriate, especially if there are boys waiting to tease the girls about being naked?

OP posts:
thirdfiddle · 09/10/2021 12:02

There's a boys' behaviour issue for sure; but there's also that whatever the trigger, your DD has got to the stage that she feels like she would like privacy and that should be respected.

I think time to speak to the teachers, say she feels uncomfortable, try to find a solution together. Everyone going to school in kit on PE days is so much easier (and the kit gets washed more than once a half term too, definitely a win with puberty approaching).

If nothing else possible, maybe she could wear a vest and boxers style underwear so she feels less undressed when changing. But it shouldn't be on her to change how she dresses, she should have privacy if she wants it.

Wheresmrpenguin · 09/10/2021 12:02

I wouldn't be happy with this either. I always had seperate changing areas in primary school at all ages. I was very aware of my body at that age, I also started puberty early and was wearing my first bra from 9 years old.

CheeseCrackersAndChutney · 09/10/2021 11:59

Oh pants I was trying to quote someone from upthread 🤣🤣🤣

CheeseCrackersAndChutney · 09/10/2021 11:58

They absolutely don’t. I’ve never worked in a school where there were changing facilities. Secondary schools yes. Primary, no.

MintyGreenDream · 09/10/2021 11:54

The kids at ds school wear their p.e on the day so no changing needed

Stompythedinosaur · 09/10/2021 11:51

My 8yo dd still is expected to change in a classroom with the his and doesn't really like it either. She asked if I could get her some crop tops to wear on pe day which seems to have helped a bit.

Howshouldibehave · 09/10/2021 11:51

Our classes don’t have PE across a year group due to staffing and space constraints, so it wouldn’t be possible to have boys in one classroom and girls in the other as the partner class would be using the room. We have coats on a trolly in the corner of the room so there’s no cloa room and only two toilets per classroom.

Coming in wearing PE kit on those days would be one solution.

catsandhens · 09/10/2021 11:50

@PlasticOrchid that was in response to comments about the girls having to change in the toilets because of the boys behaviour, and I was suggesting that it was the boys who were making the girls uncomfortable not necessarily all of them

Honestly though I think that posters saying the children should just come in in PE kit have the right answer, solves all these issues and saves time for the teachers

TheMadGardener · 09/10/2021 11:50

Our school has kept the Covid measure of children wearing sports clothes to school on the two days a week they have PE. Staff love it - no more cloakrooms full of PE bags, lost plimsolls and nameless PE shorts, no more wasting loads of PE time waiting for the slowest changers. As staff we begged the HT to keep the Covid PE clothes rule!

toomuchlaundry · 09/10/2021 11:48

Problem with moving the boys to the toilets to change is that many of them will misbehave there too. The problem we have is a boys will be boys culture, and I say this as a mother of a son. Schools should be trying to stamp this out but so should parents.

Remember an instance at DS’s Primary School where a group of boys caused havoc in the toilets with large amounts of toilet roll, blocking the loos, flicking wet toilet paper up the walls to see how far it would stick. They were punished with having to picking up litter duty and other things. Parents were incensed, saying it was just a joke and boys will be boys. No thought of the poor person who had to clean it all up.

I bet if these boys were given some form of punishment for looking at the girls whilst they were changing, some parents would be mortified by their son’s behaviour, others would be complaining that it was just boys being boys.

Mummyoflittledragon · 09/10/2021 11:48

My dd got changed separately from yr4. The boy’s behaviour needs to be addressed pdq. If there are a minimum 2 classes in a year, the easiest is for the children to be separated by sex.

SecretGardenn · 09/10/2021 11:46

In my school it was mixed until year 5, the girls had to get changed in the shared corridor / open space for years 5 &6, same corridor for heads office. The boys from 3 other classes just had to look out the window into the corridor and they could see. The boys from our class couldn't see, the blinds were closed ffor their privacy... Was awful. In year 6, the girls could go to the toilets.
I'd make it clear there is a behaviour issue with the boys that needs addressing and potentially the boys removed. They should absolutely have the right to get changed with privacy and dignity. It's disgraceful. Make sure the girls do not get the short end of the straw. These boys need a serious talking to! Maybe they can take the boys out and talk to them about respecting boundaries and the girls it's okay to have boundaries and kick up a fuss if that line is crossed.

Something needs to be done in school to tackle this behaviour.

qualitygirl · 09/10/2021 11:43

I could never understand this about the U.K. Irish children just wear their PE tracksuit in on PE days. No changing necessary...what's waste of time Confused

PlasticOrchid · 09/10/2021 11:42

[quote catsandhens]@NichyNoo

The boys behaviour needs to be challenged and stopped. Avoiding the issue by taking the girls out of the room just normalises the boys behaviour and teaches the girls that they should be the ones taking evasive action.

Whilst I understand and in a lot of ways agree with what you are saying, I dont think girls should have to put up with being made to feel uncomfortable for the purposes of teaching boys how to behave. Much better would be to take the boys out of the room to the toilets to change because they cant be trusted etc[/quote]
Have you ever seen the boys' toilets in a primary school? You really do not want your child getting changed in there. Plus the fact that there is only room for about 3 children at a time.

HermioneAndRoger · 09/10/2021 11:41

It's unusual for primary schools in the UK to have changing facilities.

I'm surprised more schools haven't retained what was originally the Covid measure of primary-age children wearing their PE kit on PE days. It was very popular with parents at our school and they have retained it.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 09/10/2021 11:39

Personally I think the best solution would be for Primary uniform to always be 'pe ready'... joggers/leggings/shorts, polo/t shirt and jumper... no more shirt and tie stuff.

catsandhens · 09/10/2021 11:34

@NichyNoo

The boys behaviour needs to be challenged and stopped. Avoiding the issue by taking the girls out of the room just normalises the boys behaviour and teaches the girls that they should be the ones taking evasive action.

Whilst I understand and in a lot of ways agree with what you are saying, I dont think girls should have to put up with being made to feel uncomfortable for the purposes of teaching boys how to behave. Much better would be to take the boys out of the room to the toilets to change because they cant be trusted etc

frazzledali · 09/10/2021 11:34

@Mantlemoose

We always had seperate male/female at school. But that was in the good old days e.g. 70's where males and females were respected. I wouldn't have been comfortable if it wasn't but I was lucky, my mum would just have gone to the school and told them I wasn't doing it. She was never backwards at coming forwards.
Snorting at the 70s being the good old days where women were respected.
catsandhens · 09/10/2021 11:32

I think 7-8 is a little old to be changing together personally. A small proportion of girls will start their periods at 8 and that would be unpleasant for them to be in mixed changing rooms at that point.

Regardless of that you need to bring it up with the school if the boys are making the girls feel uncomfortable. I think its a really off situation if girls are being told off for basically not stripping quickly enough in front of boys who are teasing them about it, and not being given the opportunity for privacy, its not a good message.

thevassal · 09/10/2021 11:32

Deja vu...I remember my first big bust up on MN was about this very same topic, at least five years ago! There were teachers/TAs kicking off about how nobody understood how little space there was in classrooms, how kids can't be trusted to change in toilets alone, how none of their students had ever said they felt uncomfortable etc, but people have already in this thread given examples about how easy it would be to make the changes.

Schools need to accept that kids are hitting puberty much earlier now than they were even 20 years ago. It doesn't make sense to me that we separate by sex in public changing rooms like swimming pools, toilets etc by7/8 as the absolute maximum but we expect children to change together, and in front of an opposite sex teacher, up to 11. Plus all the safeguarding teaching about private areas, not seeing your underwear etc and then have classmates doing exactly that!

Children should feel safe and not embarrassed in schools and if that can be easily achieved by letting them come in in PE kit or swapping 1 lesson a week around so boys and girls do it separately, why not?

TeenMinusTests · 09/10/2021 11:32

Thinking more about this, the children should be spoken to about being respectful etc etc and then bad behaviour jumped on.
If boys aren't 'trained' to behave well around girls then it will only deteriorate later.
The school should be receptive to hearing this given current news stories.

NichyNoo · 09/10/2021 11:31

The boys behaviour needs to be challenged and stopped. Avoiding the issue by taking the girls out of the room just normalises the boys behaviour and teaches the girls that they should be the ones taking evasive action.

Tee20x · 09/10/2021 11:31

We had mixed changing but from what I can remember we were separated in that girls were at the back and boys were at the front

HikingforScenery · 09/10/2021 11:30

This is one of the reasons why children going to school on their PE days is a good idea.
Mine always did wear a vest at that age so that helped .

Mantlemoose · 09/10/2021 11:29

We always had seperate male/female at school. But that was in the good old days e.g. 70's where males and females were respected. I wouldn't have been comfortable if it wasn't but I was lucky, my mum would just have gone to the school and told them I wasn't doing it. She was never backwards at coming forwards.