Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Changing in classroom - AIBU?

88 replies

Meatbadger · 09/10/2021 10:18

Year 3 DD came home upset yesterday as she got told off for being slow to get changed for PE. She was trying to do it while crouching behind her chair as she felt uncomfortable stripping off in front of the boys.

There have been several issues in the past with boys trying to look at the girls’ pants etc. They’re only 7/8 but AIBU to think mixed changing is probably not appropriate, especially if there are boys waiting to tease the girls about being naked?

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 09/10/2021 13:39

@ImInStealthMode

When I was in primary school the girls changed in the classroom and the boys in the PE hall, or vice versa. Appreciate most primaries haven't got changing rooms but surely all have the room they're about to do the PE in, along with the classroom they're about to vacate?
Our hall is the other side of the school building meaning that those getting changed in there would be totally unsupervised.

Every other lesson, PE is held outside on the playground as well, so they can’t really get changed there!

Clara91 · 09/10/2021 13:38

I'm surprised they have to get fully changed in class. At my son's school they wear joggers/leggings and a polo shirt or white tee on PE days. Just remove jumper/skirt/pinafore and go.

glitterelf · 09/10/2021 13:35

Our school have removed the covid measures of coming in with PE kit on but I've dug my heels in and I'm sending my DD in her PE kit on the specified days much to the annoyance of the Head Teacher but there are several reasons why it's such a good idea and I'll continue to keep sending her in ready.

StrawBeretMoose · 09/10/2021 13:34

@ImInStealthMode

When I was in primary school the girls changed in the classroom and the boys in the PE hall, or vice versa. Appreciate most primaries haven't got changing rooms but surely all have the room they're about to do the PE in, along with the classroom they're about to vacate?
The PE Hall could well still be in use by the previous class and the teachers are telling the children to get changed ready for the start of their slot.

I think coming in wearing PE gear is the best solution if no changing area available.

I've never been in a primary school with changing rooms.

Coffeepants · 09/10/2021 13:22

I have asked for my children to change separately from reception. Spent ages teaching them about privacy, safeguarding, etc only for the school to say it normal for all children to change together. Our school have accommodated the request.

catsandhens · 09/10/2021 13:17

@2bazookas

they are hardly NAKED. At most, down to vest and pants.

You are happy stripping down to a vest and pants in front of your colleagues then? No? Then children shouldn't have to be either

LaBellina · 09/10/2021 13:15

No this definitely isn’t normal and if I had a DD I would speak to the school and demand they provide separate changing space for the girls or my DD wouldn’t participate in PE classes all together. This is a safe guarding issue, I wouldn’t allow my DD to be made up her privacy and feel uncomfortable even at such a young age. Girls need to learn they don’t have to undress in front of anyone they’re not comfortable with. That would be a hill I’d be willing to die on.

nosyupnorth · 09/10/2021 13:14

It's difficult, twenty years ago this would have been fine but various lifestyle changes etc have meant that some children are hitting puberty far earlier, but most schools were built before that was a problem and don't have the capacity for seperate changing nor do they have the spare teachers to supervise changing seperately. But if the school adressed the boy's behavior that would also solve the problem.

BurntO · 09/10/2021 13:13

I can’t believe anyone could vote YABU. If she is uncomfortable changing infront of others how on earth is that unreasonable? Because she is a child? Hmm she is uncomfortable with it and no one should ever be made to undress in a place they feel uncomfortable. I would absolutely speak with the school.

ImInStealthMode · 09/10/2021 13:12

When I was in primary school the girls changed in the classroom and the boys in the PE hall, or vice versa. Appreciate most primaries haven't got changing rooms but surely all have the room they're about to do the PE in, along with the classroom they're about to vacate?

MargaretThursday · 09/10/2021 13:07

It's also a matter of staffing. With the form splitting there may be no one to be in with half the form.

Dd had that in year 6. The girls got dressed in one room, the boys got dressed in the form room (male teacher), so no one with the girls. There was a group of girls who took it upon themselves to comment (unfavourably) on other's figures/pants/bra/lack of bra etc and she frequently came home upset. She and another girl asked if they could change with the boys, and that was much better.

Meatbadger · 09/10/2021 13:06

Thanks for the comments. For those suggesting a vest - yes we will do this when the weather gets colder but currently it’s too warm and DD is quite a hot person anyway.

I do appreciate the space issue in primary schools; ours is certainly not equipped with changing rooms or a lot of classroom space. I think DD was particularly cross that she’d been told to come out from behind her chair and hurry up though when she was just trying to get changed discreetly.

And to pp who said she’s not technically naked - well no she kept her pants on but no way of hiding her top half (unless vest obviously as above).

I will definitely speak to the teacher and see if a solution can be found.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 09/10/2021 13:05

they are hardly NAKED. At most, down to vest and pants.

TamponSupport · 09/10/2021 13:01

DD has started to feel this way too, we have got her some of the short style pants and vests so she is covered up when changing.
This is a good idea for the short term, definitely let her wear a vest on PE days. Make sure she's changing by halves rather than all at once. Speak to the teacher.
Why should the girls have to change in the toilets just because the boys toilets are generally more revolting than the girls? Maybe it would improve the cleanliness of the boys toilets if they knew that had to get changed in there!

RaraRachael · 09/10/2021 12:55

At our school up to age 7 the children all get changed in the class. After that, the girls go to the toilets to change and the boys stay in the classroom.

Why would the children be naked whilst changing for PE? Surely they would only get down to vests and knickers in order to put on their PE kit?

Howshouldibehave · 09/10/2021 12:42

Most schools have changing rooms

They really don’t!

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 09/10/2021 12:40

DD has started to feel this way too, we have got her some of the short style pants and vests so she is covered up when changing.

This style www.next.co.uk/style/st766523/841505#841505

She feels much more comfortable now than she did when wearing normal knickers and having a bare chest.

NerrSnerr · 09/10/2021 12:37

*Most schools have changing rooms.

In the infants changed in class as a time saver only because it took so long - the P5/6/7s used the changing rooms.*

None of the primary schools we looked around had changing rooms (all state schools) so they're not usual around my area.

SirenSays · 09/10/2021 12:35

Have you thought about asking if they can get changed in the toilets, they allow this in my neices school.

When I was in year one, I accidentally went commando one day. We had to changed for PE in our classroom infront of everyone. I still remember trying to hide behind the chairs to change 😳

toomuchlaundry · 09/10/2021 12:35

Many new builds for Primary Schools I have been in have the pegs in the classroom, so no cloakroom as such

TirednWorried · 09/10/2021 12:32

Year 3 is too old to be changing together. No school i hae had any involvement with has had mixed sex changing after Y1. One sex in te classroom, the other in the cloakroom or toilets

Pinkchocolate · 09/10/2021 12:20

As the mother of a son that age and a teacher this is definitely an issue with the boys behaviour. I would be mortified if my son behaved like that! Do the parents know? Has it been addressed with the children? In my experience it tends to be around Y4/5 that children change separately, at my school the TA takes boys outside while the girls change and vice versa. In younger classes I’ve had a TA take individual children to a different area to change (larger or more developed children tend to be conscious, others can still be quite oblivious at that age). You need to speak to the teacher and explain how your daughter is feeling and see what they can put in place.

toomuchlaundry · 09/10/2021 12:13

@PlasticOrchid I have read the OFSTED report on peer on peer abuse in schools. And it is made very clear that Primary Schools don’t just think it is a Secondary School issue. It is horrifying reading.

Boys will be boys culture and banter are specifically mentioned in safeguarding guidance. Schools need to action if but we as parents have a huge role to play too

YetAnotherSpartacus · 09/10/2021 12:13

I cannot believe that people have voted YABU.

PlasticOrchid · 09/10/2021 12:06

[quote catsandhens]@PlasticOrchid that was in response to comments about the girls having to change in the toilets because of the boys behaviour, and I was suggesting that it was the boys who were making the girls uncomfortable not necessarily all of them

Honestly though I think that posters saying the children should just come in in PE kit have the right answer, solves all these issues and saves time for the teachers[/quote]
Wrote a reply and lost it!

I was one of those pp and PE kits worn to school on PE days has certainly made a big difference.

On the 'boys will be boys' issue, peer on peer sexual abuse is a big deal in safeguarding right now, as it should be, and we know that the roots of it lie in primary school. In my school, any misogynistic behaviour is addressed and recorded.