Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wedding present fiasco AIBU?

385 replies

Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 09:42

My partner and I got married 2 years ago. On our wedding day our very close relative member said that as our wedding present they would purchase us something of the value of £1000. We thought that was very generous of them and as we had just got a house we would use it towards that. However 2 YEARS after the wedding and we have never received said gift. We have never made it a big deal because I suppose it’s the thought that counts, however it’s very annoying having that member of family repeat to people how much of a generous gift they’ve offered us. Now we will never claim that money from them because it’s so out of character for us, how would it work we buy a tv and ask them to pay for it, what if their financial situation has changed since they offered etc etc. They would even joke that “I know you guys will never ask for it so I will keep nagging for you to take it” well then why not just chuck it in a envelope and pass it over?

However, this relative family member has recently gotten married. My partner and I decided that we would not give them a wedding present, because as far as we’re concerned we never got a wedding present off them. We thought this is very reasonable however this has caused a war in the family now. Honestly it was also a petty way for them to realise it’s been 2 years since our wedding and we don’t want to hear about this bloody present that we will never receive again.

Lots of members of family are saying we are selfish because we were gifted £1000 and we gifted nothing. We did try and explain that we’ve never received that money for 2 years so never received a gift. However apparently we were the issue by not asking for it. Again we never expect a gift from anyone but this member likes to show off infront of people that they’ve offered us this gift.

So were we unreasonable to not get them a gift? AIBU for not claiming the money and this is my fault.

OP posts:
MiddleClassProblem · 09/10/2021 14:54

[quote Henryhoover12]@HarrisonStickle using this analogy you can see that I in the company of that person looked at the goods that they had told me they wanted me to get with this money. I had selected which one I wanted went to pay and looked at them in which they just stared blankly. I payed for it myself and when it arrived they said “oh I was meant to get you a fridge/oven I would of got that for you”. There was nothing to stop them from getting that for me apart from them reaching their hand in their pocket to get their money, which is literally the only issue here that they don’t or never intended on actually paying for the item.[/quote]
You’re changing the narrative now from you mentioning multiple things to you physically shopping online during a group situation.

With no warning that today might be the day they have to pay for something. Even if they have the money it might be in a different account. You find it crass to ask them if you could accept their offer on a particular item yet you are happy to shop in front of everyone and expect them to handover their card? Don’t say you didn’t expect it because this is the only scenario where you have presented an opportunity to pay for something plus say they could have handed over their card.

This is so loco 🤣

MiddlesexGirl · 09/10/2021 14:54

You say 'we gave them £1000 - how is that not a generous gift?'.

Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 14:53

@MiddleClassProblem it is a hill im willing to die on that a gift is not something that has to be begged for cap in hand.

OP posts:
Rainbowheart1 · 09/10/2021 14:53

If he was going get that for you why didn’t he give you the money afterwards so he did buy it for you, instead of saying “oh well you’ve got it now”

He obviously was never gonna give it to you, or would have paid for it

MiddleClassProblem · 09/10/2021 14:49

It’s a bit like someone saying “let me know what you’d like for your birthday” and then you in group situations talking about things your thinking of buying then being annoyed that they don’t get it for you. Except this comes with a high price caveat so they cant just buy you anything and hope you like it.

We can’t judge if they were bullshitting or not as that was never really tested. Regardless, you offered nothing and gave nothing. Low road taken. And you say you think you should of but now are still arguing that you were justified because they gave you nothing. This shows that despite your attempts to be rational, you are still holding in to the bad feeling and think tit for tat was justified.

Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 14:49

@HarrisonStickle using this analogy you can see that I in the company of that person looked at the goods that they had told me they wanted me to get with this money. I had selected which one I wanted went to pay and looked at them in which they just stared blankly. I payed for it myself and when it arrived they said “oh I was meant to get you a fridge/oven I would of got that for you”. There was nothing to stop them from getting that for me apart from them reaching their hand in their pocket to get their money, which is literally the only issue here that they don’t or never intended on actually paying for the item.

OP posts:
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 09/10/2021 14:49

You don’t ask for gifts.
Only megalomaniacs would expect someone to come to them and ask for the gift they had been promised.

Rainbowheart1 · 09/10/2021 14:47

You don’t ask for a gift either, they gift the gift, you was never gonna get it

Rainbowheart1 · 09/10/2021 14:46

Anyone can say they will gift something and not do it.

I’ll gift you my 5k car Op, I’m getting married next week, dm me for my address as I expect a present back as I’m giving you a car (that you will never see)

HarrisonStickle · 09/10/2021 14:43

[quote Henryhoover12]**@nomoneytreehere* *“You have behaved really poorly too, you don’t give to receive or vice versa but it is really unkind to get nothing”

But surely it’s unkind I got nothing, because I did get nothing?

If I went around telling everyone I was to gift them a yacht they just need to tell me which one but never deliver on the yacht then it’s quite clear I never intended to. How frustrating it must be for them aswell when I tell everyone all the time I have got them a yacht when in fact I’ve got them nothing[/quote]
Using this analogy OP, you have never said to them, "This is the yacht I'd like you to get." You've just looked at yachts in their company, mentioned yachts you're going to buy.

PetticoatSoldier · 09/10/2021 14:42

YANBU. On what planet do you have to ASK for a gift?** Absolute no sense. You have not been given a wedding gift and until the money/item is in your hand all this person is doing is grandstanding bullshit.

Totally agree you should do what @coconutpie said and set the family straight:

"No, X never gave us a present. They have talked about this present for 2 years and told everybody about it but they haven't given it to us. They have fooled you all. We have assumed that we will never receive the gift and have decided that it's better to just draw a line in the sand and not give them a wedding present either."

Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 14:41

@HarrisonStickle which I did multiple times, I made clear what I want but never made clear they need to pass their bank card over because I find that very rude.

Matter of fact is that I made clear what I want but I don’t ask people for money which that person knows and relies on so as to not pay the gift that was promised. It’s all great you saying well I would of just demanded the money, I’m not like that. Whether wrongly or rightly that is who I am and that is who the person knows me to be. So why then when you know I will never ask for money not offer to pay? Unless they never actually intended to pay for it

OP posts:
lonelyapple · 09/10/2021 14:40

Why don't you just retort back that you have offered to give them a gift but they have never taken you up on the offer. And if they do ask you directly just ask them directly for your gift. Just play them at the same game.

HarrisonStickle · 09/10/2021 14:39

@Choccyaddict4eva

If someone says they’re going to give you a gift then why should you ask for it?! It’s ridiculous. Good on you for not getting them anything. It’s almost as if they wanted you to ‘beg’ for the money.
Because the gift was something the OP had to stipulate!
Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 14:39

A promise of a gift is surely not a gift if it’s never gifted in this lifetime 🤣

OP posts:
Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 14:39

@nomoneytreehere **“You have behaved really poorly too, you don’t give to receive or vice versa but it is really unkind to get nothing”

But surely it’s unkind I got nothing, because I did get nothing?

If I went around telling everyone I was to gift them a yacht they just need to tell me which one but never deliver on the yacht then it’s quite clear I never intended to. How frustrating it must be for them aswell when I tell everyone all the time I have got them a yacht when in fact I’ve got them nothing

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 09/10/2021 14:28

@Henryhoover12

I’m confused why people think hinting wasn’t enough for them to realise that I wanted them to pay for it using the gift they promised. Considering no gathering goes by without them mentioning the gift then it’s very much at the forefront of their mind !
I don’t understand why you didn’t ever call this person out. ‘Well it was a nice offer, but we don’t have anything as of yet” then escalate etc.
1forAll74 · 09/10/2021 14:21

I would maybe get them a small gift, and stop thinking about how they dealt with you for your wedding, I hate any tit for tat stuff. Other people should just butt out with their opinions, nothing worse than other people, and their stupid opinions. I would just forget the loss of what your were supposed to be receiving, it's in the past now.

The people who were going to gift you, may well feel bad about their broken promises now, who knows. too late in the day to bother now.

Andylion · 09/10/2021 14:20

They have probably been sat waiting to find out what they were supposed to buy you.

A few posters have suggested that this i what was going on, but the says "They would even joke that “I know you guys will never ask for it so I will keep nagging for you to take it”

They are being dicks. OP, do they comment on how generous they are in front of others? I would be tempted to call them on it. "Ah yes, the mythical £1000 gift" and roll my eyes.

seaandsandcastles · 09/10/2021 14:16

Yep, YABU. You should have asked, not hinted and expected them to understand.

It’s as simple as this:
“Hey X, we would like to buy this oven with the money you gifted us. Please can you send it over?”

You’re complaining about an issue you won’t solve.

Choccyaddict4eva · 09/10/2021 14:15

If someone says they’re going to give you a gift then why should you ask for it?! It’s ridiculous. Good on you for not getting them anything. It’s almost as if they wanted you to ‘beg’ for the money.

Gemma2019 · 09/10/2021 14:11

They are the ones in the wrong here. I hate people who publicly promise stuff like help with kids, money or gifts and then expect you go cap in hand for it, knowing full well you won't.

I have given a large amount of money to very close relatives as a wedding present. I wrote a cheque, put it inside the wedding card and handed it over. I received a thank you message shortly afterwards telling me what they had bought with the money. If someone wants you to have something they will hand it to you and not expect you to ask, while pretending to others that they are Lord Bountiful.

Not buying them a wedding present was definitely a mistake and your idea of speaking to them and calling it quits with wedding gifts is a good one.

PleasantFucker · 09/10/2021 14:10

Good idea about 'gifting' them the hypothetical £1000 back.
I haven't read all 9 pages only your replies but yanbu about not giving them money for their wedding either. I'd have done it too, petty or not.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 09/10/2021 14:09

It would make me incredibly uncomfortable to go to someone and tell them what to buy me. I wouldn’t have done it either.
If someone wants to give you money to help, they should just give the money. Trying to maintain control over the money by forcing the recipient to come cap in hand, showing the the item and getting their approval, comes across as a bit domineering.
Horrible dynamic.

SillyLittleBiscuit · 09/10/2021 14:00

Just say you were going to gift you 1k so why don’t we both keep our own money and call it quits.

Swipe left for the next trending thread