Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wedding present fiasco AIBU?

385 replies

Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 09:42

My partner and I got married 2 years ago. On our wedding day our very close relative member said that as our wedding present they would purchase us something of the value of £1000. We thought that was very generous of them and as we had just got a house we would use it towards that. However 2 YEARS after the wedding and we have never received said gift. We have never made it a big deal because I suppose it’s the thought that counts, however it’s very annoying having that member of family repeat to people how much of a generous gift they’ve offered us. Now we will never claim that money from them because it’s so out of character for us, how would it work we buy a tv and ask them to pay for it, what if their financial situation has changed since they offered etc etc. They would even joke that “I know you guys will never ask for it so I will keep nagging for you to take it” well then why not just chuck it in a envelope and pass it over?

However, this relative family member has recently gotten married. My partner and I decided that we would not give them a wedding present, because as far as we’re concerned we never got a wedding present off them. We thought this is very reasonable however this has caused a war in the family now. Honestly it was also a petty way for them to realise it’s been 2 years since our wedding and we don’t want to hear about this bloody present that we will never receive again.

Lots of members of family are saying we are selfish because we were gifted £1000 and we gifted nothing. We did try and explain that we’ve never received that money for 2 years so never received a gift. However apparently we were the issue by not asking for it. Again we never expect a gift from anyone but this member likes to show off infront of people that they’ve offered us this gift.

So were we unreasonable to not get them a gift? AIBU for not claiming the money and this is my fault.

OP posts:
vajingleberry · 09/10/2021 15:26

[quote Henryhoover12]@HarrisonStickle your cracking me up, so they very publicly all the time can mention the generous gift they’ve given me but when it comes to paying for it has to be private lmao 🤣🤣[/quote]
So when they mention this generous gift in front of other people what do you say

Do you say "but you have never given us this money so I'm not sure what you are talking about" In which case, what is their reply?

Or do you stare blankly which seems to be the preferred option in your family. Can none of you actually speak?

Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 15:25

@HarrisonStickle oh so the person is able to click what the hint was when the product arrives but not able to click the hint when it comes to them paying for it?

@Cavagirl when ever their generosity gets brought up by other family members or by that person themself it is well known that the item has never been brought. However the family members believe that the offer itself is sufficient amount of generousity without questioning it’s been two years.

Family member: oh is this fridge what x has brought you
Me: no I got that myself
X: yes im still waiting for her to ask, but we all know henryhoover will never ask because she’s uncomfortable with asking for money
Family member: oh x it was such a generous offer.

OP posts:
ThreeLittleDots · 09/10/2021 15:24

YANBU. I think 'close family member' sounds like a complete twat and they've got exactly what they deserved.

3luckystars · 09/10/2021 15:24

What do you say at family gatherings when they mention the gift?

Have you told everyone that you have received no gift?

HarrisonStickle · 09/10/2021 15:20

BTW, Op, my suggestion about emailing the person was just one way to be direct.

Since you've said you regularly spend time together ordering stuff, here's another.

You: I've been thinking about your gift, and there's something I'd really like
Them: Lovely, what is it?
You: It's this (You show them what it is onscreen.) Shall I quickly send you over the link to order it?

No demanding. No begging.

Cavagirl · 09/10/2021 15:15

OP I don't think anyone on this thread will ever know if it's a communication issue or they never intended to give the gift at all, because no one is there to see how these "hints" have played out in reality. From what you've said I suspect you're right in that they never planned to give it to you but you probably could have handled this better to bring it to a close far sooner than 2 years.

What I'm really intrigued by is the dynamic with the wider family. You say they are boasting about their gift, when you bought something new eg oven, other family members are saying "oh is that what X got you?" At this point, do you not say "no, we haven't received the present yet". When they are going on about it their own generosity, have you not had any opportunity to politely point out that no gift has yet been received?

It's hard not to get the impression that you have been silently seething about this for years without talking to anyone about it (parents??) so it's not unreasonable that other family members wrongly have the impression your brother(?) gave you £1000 and you gave him nothing...

HarrisonStickle · 09/10/2021 15:14

[quote AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken]@HarrisonStickle

Whhaattttt??? So not only does she have to ASK for her own gift, she has to navigate when it might be convenient to bring it up, without inconveniencing the gifter.
Just give the gift (in cheque or cash or voucher form) or don’t! You can’t expect people to do a little performance for you to receive their own gift.[/quote]
No, she just has to tell the person the specific thing she'd like as a gift, not be in the middle of ordering something online then just look at the person and expect them to know!

The person later on clicks and says, oh I could have got this, but at the time OP remains silent and expects the other person to know what she's thinking.

Completely nuts.

Robin233 · 09/10/2021 15:13

Why don't your other close family members not believe you when you say other close family members (sibling / cousins ) DID NOT buy me / give me a wedding present/ £1000.
Not giving them a 'token' wedding present was passive aggressive.
I can understand why you didn't.
But it would have been nicer to say ti close family member. 'Look as we've not actually had a present from yourself fir our wedding and you're getting married - instead of us getting you a present, shall we just not get you a present and call it quits ?

MolyHolyGuacamole · 09/10/2021 15:12

@Bananarama21

The fact you couldn't pop 20 quid or a nice bottle of wine is petty.
Your suggestion is petty. £20?! I'd rather nothing
MiddleClassProblem · 09/10/2021 15:10

[quote Henryhoover12]@MiddleClassProblem maybe your struggling to read the whole thread and love to jump to conclusions. I have repeatedly said it’s a close member of family so us sitting together on our computers online shopping isn’t out of the ordinary 🤣 your the one saying I should demand they pay for it there and then but I’ve said I never have demanded for them paying explicitly because what if there financial situation has changed (which after an expensive wedding could be the case) Whilst it potentially has changed and they no longer intend of gifting the gift then they should stop bragging about it still surely ?

Gosh would hate to have Christmas in your family, everyone down on their knees begging for gifts that’s have been offered to them or demanding they get their online banking up.[/quote]
Yeah, I never said demand, that’s your word. I wouldn’t do what they did nor does anyone beg. I said you expected it in the last post where it seems like that was the only opportunity you got close to asking them for an item. Like if I was going to happen it would have been then. That’s from your own words:

“I had selected which one I wanted went to pay and looked at them in which they just stared blankly. I payed for it myself and when it arrived they said “oh I was meant to get you a fridge/oven I would of got that for you”. There was nothing to stop them from getting that for me apart from them reaching their hand in their pocket to get their money”

You keep using beg and demand. You seem to have some weird power balance.

You have made it sound like this was in a group situation so yeah I find that odd.

Personally I like buying gifts and don’t measure them against anything I get or don’t get. Christmas at my house is bloody lovely with no weird competitive gift giving or passive aggressive non giving.

Because you are now fictionalise about the way I do things and the continual dramatic language and slight nips and tucks each time you tell the story I can see why there is an issue.

FYI, staring at someone when you are shopping to drop a hint isn’t clear. Deciding to buying it there and then and not taking the opportunity to speak to them one on one isn’t clear, even if that one on one convo wasn’t asking.

HarrisonStickle · 09/10/2021 15:08

[quote Henryhoover12]@HarrisonStickle your cracking me up, so they very publicly all the time can mention the generous gift they’ve given me but when it comes to paying for it has to be private lmao 🤣🤣[/quote]
You're the one who, two years on, has not solved this issue OP.

😆

ShuddaBeenMe · 09/10/2021 15:08

So when they next bring it up like the always do according to your posts, why don't you say oh yes! That reminds me we would like x please.

Merely Hinting at something is a bit silly.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 09/10/2021 15:06

@HarrisonStickle

Whhaattttt??? So not only does she have to ASK for her own gift, she has to navigate when it might be convenient to bring it up, without inconveniencing the gifter.
Just give the gift (in cheque or cash or voucher form) or don’t! You can’t expect people to do a little performance for you to receive their own gift.

Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 15:05

@seaandsandcastles perhaps you’ve failed to read the 10 other pages whereby people were very helpful and realise a gift is not something that needs to be asked for. I’m not stomping my feet at all, I’ve been very open and agreed that not gifting them anything was wrong and upon the advice of the majority have decided to gift them an imaginary £1000. .

OP posts:
HarrisonStickle · 09/10/2021 15:04

[quote Henryhoover12]**@MiddleClassProblem* @HarrisonStickle* but this member of family knows that I find it rude and/or would never ask for money from them or anyone. So perhaps them suggesting a gift like this in which I would have to claim it by doing the one thing I would never do (to ask for money) was to ensure this gift would never be claimed. So this is there way of looking great to the family whilst never being out of pocket.[/quote]
You wouldn't be asking for money! You'd be sending them details of the specific thing you wanted and thanking them for their offer to buy it for you as a wedding gift.

Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 15:03

@HarrisonStickle your cracking me up, so they very publicly all the time can mention the generous gift they’ve given me but when it comes to paying for it has to be private lmao 🤣🤣

OP posts:
HarrisonStickle · 09/10/2021 15:02

[quote Henryhoover12]@HarrisonStickle using this analogy you can see that I in the company of that person looked at the goods that they had told me they wanted me to get with this money. I had selected which one I wanted went to pay and looked at them in which they just stared blankly. I payed for it myself and when it arrived they said “oh I was meant to get you a fridge/oven I would of got that for you”. There was nothing to stop them from getting that for me apart from them reaching their hand in their pocket to get their money, which is literally the only issue here that they don’t or never intended on actually paying for the item.[/quote]
Whoa! That is so rude OP! Ordering something in front of someone then expecting them there and then to get their card out and pay for it!

I'd have decided there and then you were getting nothing.

"Apart from them reaching their hand in their pocket to get their money." 😲

Maybe they wanted to privately buy the thing and have it delivered to you, not be used as a cash machine.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 09/10/2021 15:02

You don’t ask for gifts

seaandsandcastles · 09/10/2021 15:01

There’s little point replying to this thread because OP is stamping her feet and won’t admit she should have just grown some balls and asked 🙄

Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 15:01

@MiddleClassProblem @HarrisonStickle but this member of family knows that I find it rude and/or would never ask for money from them or anyone. So perhaps them suggesting a gift like this in which I would have to claim it by doing the one thing I would never do (to ask for money) was to ensure this gift would never be claimed. So this is there way of looking great to the family whilst never being out of pocket.

OP posts:
Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 14:58

@MiddleClassProblem maybe your struggling to read the whole thread and love to jump to conclusions. I have repeatedly said it’s a close member of family so us sitting together on our computers online shopping isn’t out of the ordinary 🤣 your the one saying I should demand they pay for it there and then but I’ve said I never have demanded for them paying explicitly because what if there financial situation has changed (which after an expensive wedding could be the case) Whilst it potentially has changed and they no longer intend of gifting the gift then they should stop bragging about it still surely ?

Gosh would hate to have Christmas in your family, everyone down on their knees begging for gifts that’s have been offered to them or demanding they get their online banking up.

OP posts:
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 09/10/2021 14:56

@Rainbowheart1

If he was going get that for you why didn’t he give you the money afterwards so he did buy it for you, instead of saying “oh well you’ve got it now”

He obviously was never gonna give it to you, or would have paid for it

Absolutely
MiddleClassProblem · 09/10/2021 14:55

[quote Henryhoover12]@MiddleClassProblem it is a hill im willing to die on that a gift is not something that has to be begged for cap in hand.[/quote]
Yup and no one is asking you to beg or demand or whatever other extreme terminology you wish to use. They just want you to let them know.

HarrisonStickle · 09/10/2021 14:55

[quote Henryhoover12]@HarrisonStickle which I did multiple times, I made clear what I want but never made clear they need to pass their bank card over because I find that very rude.

Matter of fact is that I made clear what I want but I don’t ask people for money which that person knows and relies on so as to not pay the gift that was promised. It’s all great you saying well I would of just demanded the money, I’m not like that. Whether wrongly or rightly that is who I am and that is who the person knows me to be. So why then when you know I will never ask for money not offer to pay? Unless they never actually intended to pay for it[/quote]
I did not say I expected them to hand over their card, nor did I say you should have demanded the money.

What I said was that it's not enough to hint at things or mention things in their company.

There's a big difference between hints and saying to someone "Thank you very much for your offer to buy a gift, this is the item I'd like, shall I email the details to you?" There's also a big difference between doing that and asking for someone's card or for the money itself.

You seem to think it's either ineffective hints or rude demands for their card/cash.

Henryhoover12 · 09/10/2021 14:54

@Rainbowheart1 exactly!! The stipulation was it would be something for the house. Well this scenario happened multiple times, at one point when you run out of things to buy for the house does the person gifting to oh well let me chuck it on a gift card for you to spend how you wish.

OP posts: