Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you can justify using a woodburner in a city or town

584 replies

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 09:39

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/oct/09/eco-wood-stoves-emit-pollution-hgv-ecodesign?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

New wood burning stoves billed as more environmentally friendly still emit 750 times more tiny particle pollution than a modern HGV truck, a report has shown.

Only stoves that meet the ecodesign standard can be legally sold from the start of 2022 in the UK and EU, but experts said the regulation was shockingly weak.

The report used data on the emissions produced by stoves in perfect laboratory conditions and the pollution could be even higher in everyday use, the researchers said, with older stoves being much worse.

Tiny particle pollution – called PM2.5 – is especially harmful to health as it can pass through the lungs into the bloodstream and then be carried around the body and lodge in organs. At least 40 ,000 early deaths a year are attributed to wood burning in Europe.

Wood burners also triple the level of harmful pollution inside homes and should be sold with a health warning, said the scientist behind a study published in December. The researchers advised that the stoves should not be used around elderly people or children.

The government may have banned the burning of wet wood but has no plans to ban the sale of woodburners, despite the fact that the 8pc of homes that use them are almost entirely in cities and can use power or gas for heating. And are almost entirely fairly wealthy households.

(Those of you who live a "very rural" location, to use a common Mumsnet phrase and are entirely off grid may justifiably need one. But the question was cities and towns).

It worries me so few people know how dangerous PM2.5 emissions are, particularly for pregnant women and children.

YANBU: correct, woodburners should be banned in homes in cities and towns asap

YABU: no, they look pretty and who cares about science and health

OP posts:
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 10/10/2021 17:08

That’s very interesting.
I feel exactly like his friends. Fires are important to me. I can’t imagine life without them.

MojoMoon · 10/10/2021 16:57

samharris.org/the-fireplace-delusion/

This is a fantastic essay on why people cling so hard to fireplaces (much like people find comfort in religious beliefs, conspiracy theories or any other irrational beliefs)

It finishes with:

I have discovered that when I make this case, even to highly intelligent and health-conscious men and women, a psychological truth quickly becomes as visible as a pair of clenched fists: They do not want to believe any of it. Most people I meet want to live in a world in which wood smoke is harmless. Indeed, they seem committed to living in such a world, regardless of the facts. To try to convince them that burning wood is harmful—and has always been so—is somehow offensive. The ritual of burning wood is simply too comforting and too familiar to be reconsidered, its consolation so ancient and ubiquitous that it has to be benign. The alternative—burning gas over fake logs—seems a sacrilege.

And yet, the reality of our situation is scientifically unambiguous: If you care about your family’s health and that of your neighbors, the sight of a glowing hearth should be about as comforting as the sight of a diesel engine idling in your living room. It is time to break the spell and burn gas—or burn nothing at all.

Of course, if you are anything like my friends, you will refuse to believe this. And that should give you some sense of what we are up against whenever we confront religion.

OP posts:
PickleASturgeon · 10/10/2021 16:22

Wonder if the people in Lebanon have woodburners.

MasterGland · 10/10/2021 14:57

@ozgirl75 you will have been (and continue to be) exposed to a variety of carcinogens throughout your life. Alcohol and red meat, for instance, are proven class 1 carcinogens. Chemicals in furniture, toxic metals and pesticides accumulating in the food chain etc. There is a heavy weight of evidence that all these things are killing us. If you have made it to your 40s, I would suggest you have escaped the wrath the woodburner. If you want to try to have as long a life as possible, evidence would suggest that giving up red meat and alcohol, not smoking, and staying in a healthy weight range are the best decisions you can make.

OhGiveUp · 10/10/2021 14:48

@KittyBurrito I use bio ethenol so it's perfectly safe and environmentally friendly. It's fume and emission free, hence you don't need a chimney.
Yes, it's open flame but your pets will be safe, my dogs have never got close enough to burn themselves due to the heat. You could use a fire guard if you're concerned though.
Take a look at them on Amazon, I think you will be surprised at the choice. I also order my bio from Amazon too.

KittyBurrito · 10/10/2021 11:52

@OhGiveUp thanks - I will look into it! How does it stack up in terms of emissions? Is it an open fire or enclosed? (We have pets and floofy tails and open flames don't really go together)

OhGiveUp · 10/10/2021 10:58

@KittyBurrito I have an ethenol fire which I use in late spring, early autumn evenings when it's not really cold enough to light the parkray.
It looks lovely and gives out loads of heat, could you consider one of those? No fireplace or chimney required.

UsedUpUsername · 10/10/2021 10:51

This is an ex communist county. Wages are low food costs high and without the traditional wood heating most would freeze in winter. But the air quality is far above London and I bet even with the wood heating their carbon footprint is a fraction of your average Londoners

It’s not about their carbon footprint, it’s about the air quality within their home and within their neighbourhood.

Hopefully they’ve got decent ventilation, burning wood indoors is not good for respiratory health, but it seems they have no alternative because of poor infrastructure.

Most in the UK do have alternatives so that’s what the post is addressing.

Biker47 · 10/10/2021 10:06

The way gas prices are going, and being at the whim of countries that can just turn off the tap, or hike the price if their needs are deemed more important, I might get a wood burning stove as backup. I'm already planning to buy a spare gas boiler before they go off sale.

Toolchest13 · 10/10/2021 09:48

@MojoMoon
Thanks for bringing my attention to this. I won’t be using mine any more.

Ozgirl75 · 10/10/2021 09:36

I’m interested in the health damage issues too - I grew up in that house heated solely by wood burners. I don’t have any health issues at all (mid 40s now) and didn’t as a child either and neither do my parents who have lived in their house for nearly 40 years.

Would the health issues have made themselves known by now? Genuine question.

Lockheart · 10/10/2021 09:35

@Barkinginthedistance

Are the wood pellet stoves safe? Really concerned about Dd, 3’s health now. We have no central heating where we are and use a small electric heater in the bedroom, which costs us a fortune. What other option do we have??
Don't worry too much. Yes, there is a risk, but millions of people in the UK (more around the world) have grown up with this sort of heating and the vast, vast majority have no ill side effects.
Ozgirl75 · 10/10/2021 09:30

My parents have two wood burners (one in living room, one in dining room) in their 300 year old cottage. They don’t have any other heating apart from a small electric heater in the bedrooms. Their house is listed and doesn’t have cavity walls and there is no gas in their village (they’re not even they rural to be honest, just the Sussex countryside).
I presume that there would always be an exemption for houses like that as you couldn’t fit any other type of heater anyway.

MojoMoon · 10/10/2021 09:21

@Barkinginthedistance

Afraid wood pellets are not a fix - combustion of any wood releases particulates.

I'd suggest looking here for well trained people who can advise on all sorts of options

www.heatgeek.com/find-a-heat-geek/

OP posts:
KittyBurrito · 10/10/2021 09:09

YANBU. I absolutely love how cosy they are (in Scotland here, so winter nights are long, dark and bloody cold). We thought of getting one installed, read up on the air pollution aspects of ECO ones, and couldn't justify it. Whichever way you cut it, it creates a major environmental problem. We installed lots of low golden lights and big thick rugs to snuggle under instead, to get that cosy feeling.

Barkinginthedistance · 10/10/2021 09:04

Are the wood pellet stoves safe? Really concerned about Dd, 3’s health now. We have no central heating where we are and use a small electric heater in the bedroom, which costs us a fortune. What other option do we have??

Branster · 10/10/2021 08:45

@CovidCorvid

Just been talking about this to dh who works as an engineer in the energy sec/power stations and has done for nearly 40 years. He’s adamant as things currently stand if people stopped using gas central heating (and to a lesser extent log burners) and switched to heat source pumps there is not currently enough capacity in the National grid to run all the heat source pumps which would be needed. So sounds like there’s some way to go yet.
Not just that, but installing a ground source heat pump, for example, is not suitable for all sites and not everyone has the available land for this.
MurielSpriggs · 10/10/2021 08:42

We've wanted one for a while, and the ban on gas boilers and the shift towards heat-pump boilers means we'll get one of the new types of wood-burning stove put in our living room. In older houses heat-pumps are ok for background heat, but they don't really get your house warm. You need another heat source for that.

(Incidentally, not too worried about justifying it.)

OhGiveUp · 10/10/2021 08:05

I have Parkray ( coal ) central heating which also heats the water. I would never get rid of it. I sometimes burn wood on it too, along with fruit and veg peelings etc.
It's also great for cooking things or boiling water on if there's a power cut. Potatoes wrapped in foil and placed in the ash pan to bake are gorgeous.
No way would i have it changed to anything else.

ejhhhhh · 10/10/2021 07:44

The thread is about woodburners in urban areas in in the UK. Where there's lots of traffic, so where particulate pollution mixes with traffic fumes and is harmful to health. If you live elsewhere where those circumstances don't collide, crack on with your wood burner if you want.

DoctorSnortles · 10/10/2021 07:42

I want to have one installed. We live in the sticks and the cost of our non-mains gas has always been astronomical and is set to become more expensive. I don't want to rely on electricity as a heating source in an area prone to power cuts.

If it boils down to a choice between keeping my family warm in the winter or occasionally creating air pollution, I'm going to go for the former.

Proudboomer · 10/10/2021 06:50

@UsedUpUsername

I don’t know how I have grown used to it when I only arrived 5 hours ago

Then you have really no basis to speak on this. Wait until you have a really cold morning with no wind and heavy cloud cover.

You are making too many assumptions. First that I have been here for ages Second that I am new to the area and it is the first time experiencing it.

Both wrong. I don’t live here but it is not my first time here. I know the weather and in few months the snow will be a few inches thick on the ground. The outdoor kitchens will be left in favour of cooking on the indoor wood burner and every house in the village will be burning wood as it’s main source of heat.
This morning the dogs have woken me barking. It is wet and overcast but the area doesn’t stink of burning.
This is a more natural way to live. No one burns nicely chopped up new logs. All the wood is seasoned, bought during the summer when it is cheaper and left out during the hot summer to dry. Most people grow a lot of their own food. Chicken wander around until someone fancies on for diner, rabbits are kept and eaten. Pretty much ever man has a still and produces their own booze out of whatever they have a gut of in the garden but usually plums.
This is an ex communist county. Wages are low food costs high and without the traditional wood heating most would freeze in winter. But the air quality is far above London and I bet even with the wood heating their carbon footprint is a fraction of your average Londoners.

UsedUpUsername · 10/10/2021 04:35

I don’t know how I have grown used to it when I only arrived 5 hours ago

Then you have really no basis to speak on this. Wait until you have a really cold morning with no wind and heavy cloud cover.

Gothichouse40 · 10/10/2021 02:05

There is
absolutely no thought given to asthmatics or people with respiratory illness. The slightest smoke and Im coughing for days. I would ban the lot. What is the point in banning coal, petrol, diesel etc, then be subjected to the godawful stink and particles that get into your airways with these and no people do not burn the appropriate wood, they burn anything and don't give a jot for the effect it has on others.

BreadInCaptivity · 10/10/2021 01:58

YANBU

My neighbours have one. They have a wood store and use seasoned wood.

It still stinks. We can tell when they use it and it's really unpleasant. It exacerbates my DH's asthma and means we have to keep the windows shut.

We are semi rural ie not in a town/suburbs but also not in the back of beyond and have a gas supply.

I can totally understand people wanting a "back up" to electricity and why in very rural areas an open fire/wood burner is not only attractive but essential (and I'm against banning them outright for that reason).

Beyond that I think if you have access to an alternative (we have a very realistic gas "wood burner") it's a very selfish choice.