Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you can justify using a woodburner in a city or town

584 replies

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 09:39

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/oct/09/eco-wood-stoves-emit-pollution-hgv-ecodesign?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

New wood burning stoves billed as more environmentally friendly still emit 750 times more tiny particle pollution than a modern HGV truck, a report has shown.

Only stoves that meet the ecodesign standard can be legally sold from the start of 2022 in the UK and EU, but experts said the regulation was shockingly weak.

The report used data on the emissions produced by stoves in perfect laboratory conditions and the pollution could be even higher in everyday use, the researchers said, with older stoves being much worse.

Tiny particle pollution – called PM2.5 – is especially harmful to health as it can pass through the lungs into the bloodstream and then be carried around the body and lodge in organs. At least 40 ,000 early deaths a year are attributed to wood burning in Europe.

Wood burners also triple the level of harmful pollution inside homes and should be sold with a health warning, said the scientist behind a study published in December. The researchers advised that the stoves should not be used around elderly people or children.

The government may have banned the burning of wet wood but has no plans to ban the sale of woodburners, despite the fact that the 8pc of homes that use them are almost entirely in cities and can use power or gas for heating. And are almost entirely fairly wealthy households.

(Those of you who live a "very rural" location, to use a common Mumsnet phrase and are entirely off grid may justifiably need one. But the question was cities and towns).

It worries me so few people know how dangerous PM2.5 emissions are, particularly for pregnant women and children.

YANBU: correct, woodburners should be banned in homes in cities and towns asap

YABU: no, they look pretty and who cares about science and health

OP posts:
HeronLanyon · 10/10/2021 19:55

dream what drama ! I have family in Carmel and Santa Barbara so have been keeping up very vaguely with California happenings.
Here we are a little less organised - farmers stubble burning has guidance but our own garden fires (most right on top of neighbours are only regulated by loose local authority guidance). Even this year which was very dry March-may and other very dry spells it was only ever guidance about no ipen fires despite tinder dry conditions some places.
Always as well as fear for humans it’s always heartbreaking to think of the flora and fauna affected.
Stay well !

MojoMoon · 10/10/2021 19:54

It's quite fascinating that a lot of people say "well, the environment is damaged by lots of things so what does this matter" but seem to miss the point that particulates, particularly PM2.5, damage your health, the health of your children and family and neighbours.

It's more like CIGARETTE SMOKING (albeit smoking so much that it gets into your neighbours house too) than CLIMATE CHANGE.

Asthma, respiratory disease, miscarriage, dementia

www.mumsforlungs.org/our-campaigns/wood-burning

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29897947/
Results: The emission of PM2.5 from local residential wood burning was associated with dementia incidence with a hazard ratio of 1.55 for a 1 μg/m3 increase in PM2.5 (95% Confidence Interval (CI): 1.00-2.41, p-value 0.05). Study participants with an address in an area with the highest quartile of PM2.5 from residential wood burning and who also had a wood-burning stove were more likely to develop dementia than those in the lower three quartiles without a wood-burning stove with hazard ratios of 1.74 (CI: 1.10-2.75, p-value 0.018).

OP posts:
BluebellsGreenbells · 10/10/2021 19:52

I wonder how power station affect the air quality of their neighbors?

DecadentlyDecisive · 10/10/2021 19:52

@JassyRadlett

Stopping all the wood burners in the world being used would produce a very small effect on climate change.

It’s about air quality, not climate change.

Potatoes, Potatoes......

The 2 aren't a million miles apart!

Individuals are easier targets than businesses and always will be.....

MojoMoon · 10/10/2021 19:49

@FreedomFaith

It's about local air pollution NOT climate change

It's the particulates damaging your health, the health of anyone in your home and your neighbours. Particulates stay in your local area. Burning wood in China doesn't make a difference to your local air quality and vice versa.

It has nothing to do with climate change or the actions of Big Guns or whatever.

(Climate change is still very important and we need to make radical changes but it's a different issue)

OP posts:
Mamabear2020 · 10/10/2021 19:48

We have a multifuel burner. I won't lie, it is pretty, but we have it for practical purposes! Already this year our gas bill has gone through the roof and we probably won't be able to afford to turn the heating much extra this winter, so we will rely heavily on our burner as a 'free' way to heat the house, day and night.

I wish there were some magical solution to heating our house that wasn't going to harm the environment or stop us paying the mortgage but this is where we are currently!

JassyRadlett · 10/10/2021 19:45

Stopping all the wood burners in the world being used would produce a very small effect on climate change.

It’s about air quality, not climate change.

FreedomFaith · 10/10/2021 19:38

@BluebellsGreenbells

I have one and installed it due to power cuts and out boiler broke one Christmas and I will never suffer minus temperatures over winter again!

Our hose has a lot of insulation and the fire is lit occasionally when extremely cold -

I don’t need to justify it

Yes again people are penalized not businesses

Your last sentence - exactly.

Aim your environmental anger at the companies producing pollution and ruining the air quality far more than a few wood burners. Stopping all the wood burners in the world being used would produce a very small effect on climate change. Focus On on the big guns, not the small ones.

DreamTheMoors · 10/10/2021 19:36

@HeronLanyon

dream that’s interesting. So the default is ‘no burn days’ ? Guessing this is as much to do with fire risk as anything else ?
@HeronLanyon

Oh gosh, Heron - We were high up in the Sierras a couple of weeks ago at a friend’s cabin and the National Park Service all of a sudden came and we were evacuated - so scary. The KNP Fire was some distance away but another fire had broken out near us so we had to run. It’s okay now, though. However, many Giant Sequoias have been lost and that’s tragic. Heartbreaking.

The “no burn days” are mainly for air quality and pollution. The agricultural burning this time of year is usually out in the middle of empty fields and consists of old vines or fruit trees that the farmers have pulled out some time ago and pushed into large piles — the smoke is quite terrible, but it’s also far out in the country.
We live in the San Joaquin Valley, which provides the USA an enormous amount of its fruit and vegetables and cotton, etc.

Galdos · 10/10/2021 19:33

One of my jobs when young was hauling coal from the cellar and making up the coal fired kitchen boiler. I don't suppose I did it a lot, but it left me with a lifelong dislike of open fires, woodburners ...

Our predecessors in our house had open fires. When we bought, we had a loft extension, and knowing that some folks were crazy about real fires we had the chimneys extended so this would still be possible. Now, a complete waste of money in having kept the chimneys open (they are capped at the top, removable though).

Not sure about legally banning the damned things, but I ain't ever going to have a woodburner (and living in London, sourcing wood to burn could be awks anyway). I'd rather wear two pullovers!

On a related theme, but separate, I wonder if the heating crisis looming will lead to a trend away from huge live-in kitchens across the back of so many houses? Much easier to heat smaller rooms ...

justasking111 · 10/10/2021 19:28

I have asthma no problems with fires open or closed style. What sets me off are scented candles. It's embarrassing because I have to leave the room/house I am visiting to stop the cough and sometimes resort to my inhaler

DecadentlyDecisive · 10/10/2021 19:24

People are penalized because people are polluting residential areas.

Ironically, in the countryside people are using them less than in the past due to central heating etc. being more common & available than 75 years ago...

It's only because city dwellers don't like the smell, particles etc in their overcrowded little domains that they think there's a national issue & want to force change on everyone.

The same citydwellers who moan about the traffic on the roads next the houses they bought (next to the roads)... Hmm

BookishKitten · 10/10/2021 19:18

I forgot to clarify something:

Just because you’re burning “carbon neutral wood” (as it’s often advertised) this doesn’t mean that you’re not sending up harmful particles into the atmosphere!

I know that this happens if I have to use the woodburner, but sometimes needs must.

Overall we should all strive to be as carbon neutral as possible and avoid sending harmful particles into the atmosphere!

Rugsofhonour · 10/10/2021 19:05

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

BookishKitten · 10/10/2021 19:05

Our house had a woodburner and I grew up abroad in houses with and without woodburners.
There is no denying the impact of burning wood and especially wood that is wet, green or even (!!!) chemically treated. Burning wood other than properly seasoned wood should just be heavily fined and woodburner removed from properties that do this.

However, I am grateful to have a fall back option for when the boiler breaks as has happened - we lit the woodburner and it made the whole house warm in a very short period of time. I like the flexibility it provides, and I would be upset if I had to remove it.

Those living in older houses that are not insulated to 21st century standards know this well.

I prefer to eat vegetarian meals more frequently, not drink alcohol, and not driving a car. That said, the woodburner does not get used regularly.

HeronLanyon · 10/10/2021 18:55

dream that’s interesting. So the default is ‘no burn days’ ? Guessing this is as much to do with fire risk as anything else ?

DreamTheMoors · 10/10/2021 18:52

In my *very rural” area of California, and in fact all over the state, we have “burn days” — depending on air quality. They announce it on tv and in the print media online which days are acceptable for wood burners or agricultural fires.
Works pretty well and has for well over 20 years.

Ddot · 10/10/2021 18:46

My house is freezing, no cavity insulation because no cavity. My boiler is old and I can't afford to replace. I manage with hot water bottles, heated blanket and the occasional use of my wood burner. My home in the worst weather gets down to 14 with the central heating on, live like that and then tell me not to use my burner.

Roxy69 · 10/10/2021 18:34

Ha! Tell that to the French and see what they say about it. I think you might anticipate the response.

Strugglingtodomybest · 10/10/2021 18:17

Those who worry about air quality and their children - do you also avoid scented candles, cleaning products, plug in air fresheners etc? Even new fabrics emit unpleasant irritant chemicals. Air qaulity within homes is frequently very poor.

Yes

grasstreeleaf · 10/10/2021 18:05

I think they are one of those household items that were seen as really covetable a few years ago. They became a bit of a status symbol. It might be connected to Scandinavia decor being fashionable, although burning wood there doesn't necessarily have the exactly the same environmental impact as someone in a town or city here.

Years ago we had a Victorian house with open fires. We lit them occasionally but they made me wheeze and gave out lots of embers which put me off so didn't make a fire again. We had pretty good central heating anyway. In our current house we have no proper chimneys, just a gas flew. We got the gas fire cut off because we don't light it and it just was getting dusty which meant it required servicing every time before we wanted to light it otherwise it wouldn't burn properly.

Ddot · 10/10/2021 18:02

So if I'm rich and live in the country then its fine. I can also hunt not pay the right tax and numerous other crap that those working class must abide by

takenforgrantednana · 10/10/2021 17:56

@Loveshelly

I think the positives out weigh the negatives for fires in general. I spend a lot of time camping and will only go to places that allow fires. Learning to cook on one as a child. We had a wood burner as a child it was so amazing The hearth is the heart of the home.

Really of all the things to worry about in terms of the environment this isn’t it. A few people having something nice in their home.

and i do a lot of camping/caravanning and willl only go to places that BAN them! i have enough t o put up with when at home because of our neighbour and his constant fires ever night smoking out my house, strange how i have developed copd in the last 18 months isnt it? yes i blame him for it! he burns all his old fencing business waste and it goes directly into my bedroom
Poptasmagorical · 10/10/2021 17:52

The environmental factors are really important to me and I would never have one, but I also really hate the smell of woodsmoke, mostly because I'm allergic to practically everything, so I can't even dry my clothes outside because of my bloody neighbours. We live in a fairly large town and I know they have central heating because it took for-bloody-ever to noisily instal when I had a new baby.

Davygran · 10/10/2021 17:51

I hate them with a passion. I was born & raised in a coal mining area & I was very small when the whole place was made a smoke free zone. You HAD to burn clean coal, the chimneys didn’t smoke and it didn’t smell. Now I’ve moved away and there’s a pub near me & even worse a wood-fired pizza oven takeaway 2 streets away and they both stink as soon as they light the fires/oven. They are filthy and a health hazard. You are absolutely not being unreasonable.
I should not be able to smell these bonfires 2 streets away!