Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you can justify using a woodburner in a city or town

584 replies

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 09:39

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/oct/09/eco-wood-stoves-emit-pollution-hgv-ecodesign?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

New wood burning stoves billed as more environmentally friendly still emit 750 times more tiny particle pollution than a modern HGV truck, a report has shown.

Only stoves that meet the ecodesign standard can be legally sold from the start of 2022 in the UK and EU, but experts said the regulation was shockingly weak.

The report used data on the emissions produced by stoves in perfect laboratory conditions and the pollution could be even higher in everyday use, the researchers said, with older stoves being much worse.

Tiny particle pollution – called PM2.5 – is especially harmful to health as it can pass through the lungs into the bloodstream and then be carried around the body and lodge in organs. At least 40 ,000 early deaths a year are attributed to wood burning in Europe.

Wood burners also triple the level of harmful pollution inside homes and should be sold with a health warning, said the scientist behind a study published in December. The researchers advised that the stoves should not be used around elderly people or children.

The government may have banned the burning of wet wood but has no plans to ban the sale of woodburners, despite the fact that the 8pc of homes that use them are almost entirely in cities and can use power or gas for heating. And are almost entirely fairly wealthy households.

(Those of you who live a "very rural" location, to use a common Mumsnet phrase and are entirely off grid may justifiably need one. But the question was cities and towns).

It worries me so few people know how dangerous PM2.5 emissions are, particularly for pregnant women and children.

YANBU: correct, woodburners should be banned in homes in cities and towns asap

YABU: no, they look pretty and who cares about science and health

OP posts:
EvilPea · 10/10/2021 21:08

@TheEvilPea

This has reminded me: I need to order some logs. Thanks!
Shock Two evil peas in a pod!!?
LidlMiddleLover · 10/10/2021 21:06

Get real there are a lot worse things than woodburners Being cold for example

NotMeNoNo · 10/10/2021 21:04

"my little (indulgence of your choice) won't make a blind bit of difference" is what got us into this mess. Half a million people are all making the same excuse.

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/feb/16/home-wood-burning-biggest-cause-particle-pollution-fires. All the stats linked here.

Your lovely top of the range burner burning beautiful dry wood is still polluting your neighborhood, if you live in anywhere bigger than a village you shouldn't use it.

The only reason they aren't outright banned is probably (like Aga's) they are mostly owned by posh people including a large number of MP's.

TheEvilPea · 10/10/2021 20:59

This has reminded me: I need to order some logs. Thanks!

MojoMoon · 10/10/2021 20:45

@Ddot

Those are all great things to do for carbon emissions and climate change.

But wood burning is about local air pollution, not climate change. It is about particulates, not carbon.

No I don't want you to freeze. But neither do I want you to be poisoning yourself, your family and your neighbours, increasing your risk and their risk of respiratory diseases, dementia, miscarriage and cancer.

I'm not Being Mean To WoodBurning Fans for fun. I'd just rather you, your family and neighbours had a lower risk of dying early, miscarrying or ending up with dementia

As I said, I think more support for low income homes to improve efficiency and insulation is vital too. There are schemes in many local areas already and although it means some disruption, I would strongly suggest taking a look

The Energy Saving Trust is a great starting point for advice.

OP posts:
Porridgeislife · 10/10/2021 20:45

Wood fires don’t significantly contribute to climate change. Why you should be concerned is particulates, and the health of your family. If you wouldn’t allow a diesel car to discharge its exhaust into your living room, you shouldn’t have a wood fire.

The particulates from wood burning fires contribute to significantly shortening the lives of women in sub Saharan Africa due to women cooking over open fires as they are so very bad for your health. I couldn’t, in good conscience, have one in the house with children.

DreamTheMoors · 10/10/2021 20:35

@HeronLanyon

Yes - the loss of all flora & fauna is tragic.
Carmel and Santa Barbara are two of my very favorite places - my auntie lived in SB so I spent a great deal of time there as a child.
We are very regulated here, but it’s not like there’s the “fireplace police” running around every night during the winter handling out tickets - it’s more the honor system, but people are pretty good about it.
And now, the western US is experiencing a 1000-year drought. It’s frightening how lakes and rivers are drying up and farmers’ wells have run dry. Farmers and wine growers are having to make tough decisions about whether to plant or not plant. Rationing water is right around the corner.
You stay safe and well too.

UsedUpUsername · 10/10/2021 20:34

The 2 aren't a million miles apart!

Actually they are. Carbon emissions can’t hurt you, but particulates can. Prematurely kills thousands of people annually but whatever

generalh · 10/10/2021 20:31

We make sure the wood is dry. Plus I live next to a steelworks so my little woodburner won't make a blind bit of difference

Ddot · 10/10/2021 20:31

I dont eat meat, I don't fly, I buy most of my clothes second hand, I grow my own vegetables but I'm not willing to freeze sorry not sorry. Are you without sin

JassyRadlett · 10/10/2021 20:31

The 2 aren't a million miles apart!

In terms of what can be done to mitigate them there are some commonalities.

In terms of their impacts, they’re pretty different.

Lumping them together is a bit daft.

And you won’t get disagreement from me that institutions (business, govt) need to be the ones transforming the food system, the transport system, the energy system our housing stock and most importantly the financial sector to tackle climate change in particular.

Air quality is much more local. Some solutions will be common to both - don’t have coal-fired power stations in built up areas (or at all), get rid of ICE cars.

But there are things that have a big local impact on air quality that are much more marginal from a carbon perspective. Domestic burning is one of them.

Trying to conflate them muddies the waters at best.

Hopeisnotastrategy · 10/10/2021 20:30

Newsflash.

None of us need to justify ourselves to you, You have delusions of grandeur.

daisyjgrey · 10/10/2021 20:28

There is a very big space between "towns" and "off grid".

You are being a berk.

ANameChangeAgain · 10/10/2021 20:25

I know the question was aimed at City dwellers, but they aren't for the wealthy in rural areas, as we have free fuel. Power stations don't have to be running to heat my home, just a fallen tree or branch from the wood, dry stored for 12 months.

Ddot · 10/10/2021 20:25

I agree their not ideal but like I said my home is bloody freezing. I only use when I cant get the house above 14 it's not cheap to run but I dont want to be ill and I get alot of pain when cold.

ShipwreckSunset · 10/10/2021 20:21

We are in rural location and have two multi fuels burners. We got for aesthetic reasons, not really considering the health and environmental impacts but I’m not so keen on using now.

MojoMoon · 10/10/2021 20:19

It's not about the smell. Or the look of smoke.

@Ddot PM2.5 particulates are released by all wood. Read the study cited in the article by the Guardian - they got those results using dry seasoned wood in best burning practices and state that in real life, people probably don't use best practice all the time so the real life results are worse.

I don't deny that for some rural homes, it may be complicated or hard to replace. It's literally stated in the original post. I think the government should offer much more generous support for insulating and cutting energy demand in homes. There are many things that can be done to improve efficiency even in period homes.

But in towns and cities, there are other options for heating (gas or power and no evidence of regular power cuts) and it's a more densely populated area so more concentration of particulates (particularly when weather is still) . We recognise that exposing children and other people to an individual's choice to smoke cigarettes is unacceptable and banned smoking in public places. Why should we treat this any different?

I don't get quite why all the Very Rural people are so outraged by this post. It literally is not about you.

For what it's worth, my proposed law would be that local councils are given the power to ban them. Currently they don't have the right too. Therefore London councils could ban them immediately with stringent fines (several have already issued pleas not to use them but have no rights to ban) and other areas can do as they wish reflecting their local needs.
Even at low estimates of them producing 23pc of London particulates, it would make a massive difference over night to everyone's health if they could ban them.

OP posts:
Mrsjamin · 10/10/2021 20:14

@MojoMoon thank you for this AIBU - YANBU! It's such an important topic that people have no idea about and are sticking their heads in the sand about. I'd never have any source of fire indoors and have removed them from houses in the past. I think connected to this we should not have bonfires or fireworks either. Our air quality is so fragile, especially in cities, we need to take more collective responsibility for it.

NotMeNoNo · 10/10/2021 20:12

Even worse we have an open fire. We are keeping it in case of power cuts but are in a smokeless zone. We were thinking of replacing it with a stove but now considering more sustainable alternatives such as solar panels and a little electric stove.

OverTheRubicon · 10/10/2021 20:09

@Hardbackwriter

When people say 'target corporations instead' what they actually mean is 'do something about it, but something that affects me in no way' but that's not possible - there isn't this line between businesses, consumers and people that those that say this seem to be imagining.
Absolutely agree. I always wonder what people like @FreedomFaith think that corporations are actually doing - burning fuel for the sake of it? ALL pollution ultimately comes back to human consumption, so it's every single one of us responsible, not some magical 'big corporation'.
Ddot · 10/10/2021 20:01

I only burn the correct fuel, its chemical treated wood and painted wood that stinks

Hardbackwriter · 10/10/2021 20:00

When people say 'target corporations instead' what they actually mean is 'do something about it, but something that affects me in no way' but that's not possible - there isn't this line between businesses, consumers and people that those that say this seem to be imagining.

OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 10/10/2021 19:57

I love a fire, you can't beat it. But I do acknowledge the problems and pollutants that wood and coal use bring. My village isn't on mains gas. It isn't hugely rural at all but still, no gas. So a lot of homes are still on solid fuel or use oil or lpg and supplement with solid fuel because lpg is bloody expensive. You can smell the difference at a certain point of the afternoon when everyone gets their stoves going for the heat and water. We're lucky enough to have lpg now but were on solid fuel for a long time so from September to March/April had a fire going 24/7. Now we use it sparingly just for the occasional cosy up.

justasking111 · 10/10/2021 19:56

Wood an old farm neighbour told us heats you three times

1 chopping the wood into logs, 2 splitting them for kindling. 3 burning them

AmberLynn1536 · 10/10/2021 19:56

@Loveshelly

What’s going to happen now. No more open fires in pubs. This is all fucking bullshit. They’re really for aesthetic reasons these days, on in winter only. Not pumping out 24hours a day in slums. People really need to take a long hard look at what is really killing people. And it’s not Judith in number 23 who uses a wood burner 10 times a year
Absolutely this!! Well said.