Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you can justify using a woodburner in a city or town

584 replies

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 09:39

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/oct/09/eco-wood-stoves-emit-pollution-hgv-ecodesign?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

New wood burning stoves billed as more environmentally friendly still emit 750 times more tiny particle pollution than a modern HGV truck, a report has shown.

Only stoves that meet the ecodesign standard can be legally sold from the start of 2022 in the UK and EU, but experts said the regulation was shockingly weak.

The report used data on the emissions produced by stoves in perfect laboratory conditions and the pollution could be even higher in everyday use, the researchers said, with older stoves being much worse.

Tiny particle pollution – called PM2.5 – is especially harmful to health as it can pass through the lungs into the bloodstream and then be carried around the body and lodge in organs. At least 40 ,000 early deaths a year are attributed to wood burning in Europe.

Wood burners also triple the level of harmful pollution inside homes and should be sold with a health warning, said the scientist behind a study published in December. The researchers advised that the stoves should not be used around elderly people or children.

The government may have banned the burning of wet wood but has no plans to ban the sale of woodburners, despite the fact that the 8pc of homes that use them are almost entirely in cities and can use power or gas for heating. And are almost entirely fairly wealthy households.

(Those of you who live a "very rural" location, to use a common Mumsnet phrase and are entirely off grid may justifiably need one. But the question was cities and towns).

It worries me so few people know how dangerous PM2.5 emissions are, particularly for pregnant women and children.

YANBU: correct, woodburners should be banned in homes in cities and towns asap

YABU: no, they look pretty and who cares about science and health

OP posts:
GinJeanie · 11/10/2021 03:45

@MojoMoon - I agree, don't like them nowadays and we've got rid of ours due to health concerns (DC have asthma as do I). On one occasion I had to come home and use my inhaler after walking in our local area at dusk. I used to love our burner though so get why others do... it's a shame but I can completely understand why they'll eventually have to be banned ☹.

TheEvilPea · 11/10/2021 02:15

@EvilPea hello my evil friend! 😆😈

It appears that there are many of us. 😁

MojoMoon · 10/10/2021 23:58

Ok, I might rein it in on posting at least a bit since I need to do my actual job tomorrow.

I'm glad this thread has been so active and on the front page so much because it means people have seen it.

I'm really heartened by the posts from people who did not know the risks but now are more aware. That's why I was hoping for. Please spread the word. It's not well known enough.

I know lots of people thought they were being green when they bought it but were unaware of the increased risk to themselves, their children and their neighbours of asthma, cardiac arrest, miscarriage, cancer and dementia posed by exposure to PM2.5 particulates even when using dry seasoned organic foraged wood in an eco stove.

It's been fascinating to see some of the kneejerk arguments against it which echo a lot of early responses to the smoking ban - my nan smokes a pack a day and is fit at 100 years old, the French smoke loads and they live longer than we do, if smoking was so bad, why are there so many old people, alcohol is bad for you too and no one is banning that, what about the tax paid on cigarettes, it's my freedom and right to smoke if I want to etc etc.
Quitting smoking is hard so you can see why people resisted a ban - it's an addiction. Quitting using your woodburner in London is easy. Yes, it may be much harder and maybe even impossible for Rural Folk (I did specify towns and cities in my question though). But being rural doesn't mean the risk of dementia, miscarriage, asthma and cardiac arrest is removed. You really might want to rein it in as much as you can especially in front of your kids and while pregnant.

We are talking here about localised air pollution - not climate change (not that climate change is not important). In London, on days with high levels of PM2.5 particulates (cold days with low cloud), hospitalisations from asthma attacks and cardiac attacks rise and people die. Including children - see Mums for Lungs and the Ella Kissi Debrah Foundation. It also linked to higher rates of dementia with the higher personal and financial costs that imposes
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29897947/

23-31pc of PM2.5 exposure in London is caused by wood burning - that could be knocked out immediately if councils were given the power to ban wood burning stoves. In London, wood burning stoves are not essential sources of heat for homes with no other choice - they're pretty and cosy and atmospheric and most entirely found in large homes in wealthy areas. No one on my estate has one but the Georgian houses in Islington I can see from.my window often do.

If someone posted on AIBU that their neighbour on a London terraced street smoked all day at home in front of their kids and then came round to their house every night and smoked cigarettes in their children's faces (before heading off to do it in all the other houses on the street), they would be told YANBU and also to grow a backbone and tell the CF neighbour to sod off. Maybe even to log it with the police (both a woodburning and Mumsnet joke there)

So if it isn't absolutely vital for you to warm your home with a wood burning stove, then please don't be that smoky CF neighbour for your own health, your kids and everyone else in your neighbourhood.

OP posts:
coachmylife · 10/10/2021 23:14

The fireplace delusion is alive and kicking here on Mumsnet!

As you said, this isn’t about rural areas - but even there, why add 750 HGV-worth of fumes to your and your neighbours’ lungs??

Who remembers the big campaigns for cleaner stoves for poorer countries? Smoke is a killer… can be slow, can be fast.

Bideshi · 10/10/2021 22:59

@cjpark

To me, woodturners are of the 00's! they should be put in room 101 along with glittery slogans written on walls and diamanté furniture. No need - bad the environment when there is plenty of cheaper alternatives.
Big old house out in the sticks. No mains gas or water, frequent power cuts. Roads often closed in winter. So tell me the cheaper alternatives please. We already do the layers of clothing thing. Oh and we live in a wood. We stack and season wood for three years until it goes for burning. Can’t see the point of them in towns though.
MojoMoon · 10/10/2021 22:58

@Roughasabadgersbum

It's great you have a carbon monoxide monitor but that tells you nothing about PM2.5 particulates.

They are also linked to dementia, cancer, cardiac arrest and miscarriage so it's not just asthma

OP posts:
TuftyMarmoset · 10/10/2021 22:56

@CovidDoesNotExistDuh

Because airers work in a cold damp house?

Some kind of heating and airflow is required you berk.

I don't currently live rurally, but I'll be moving back end log burners or dual fuel stoves are the only option in some places.

Yes, they do. As long as the humidity in the house is lower than the moisture content in the clothes stuff will dry. I avoid using heating and everything is dry by the second day at the very latest in the depths of winter (and no it doesn't smell if it's hung properly - unlike clothes which have been around woodsmoke, yuk).
MojoMoon · 10/10/2021 22:55

@Ddot Me? I don't own a car. Got two bicycles though (greedy)

On drying clothes, check out Lakeland's heated airer.
Not having a tumble dryer is pretty normal in a London property - no room for it in my bijou home- so not sure it's a rural issue to dry clothes without one. The lakeland heated airer is excellent - many threads in Mumsnet housekeeping singing its praises.

OP posts:
CovidDoesNotExistDuh · 10/10/2021 22:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Roughasabadgersbum · 10/10/2021 22:43

Thanks for your comment! I have an airer thank you .. no need to be so bloody rude

TuftyMarmoset · 10/10/2021 22:37

We are rural and rely on it to ... dry our washing ( we have no dryer)

Ah yes, it's well known that airers don't work in rural areas like they do here in town...

RIPWalter · 10/10/2021 22:35

YANBU except for suggesting that it is only an urban issue.

I live "very rurally", we are not on mains gas, water or sewerage.

We got rid of our log burner after we had an air source heat pump fitted as it seemed kind of pointless and hypocritical to have a green heating system (we are on a green energy tariff) and then spew loads of particulate into the air.

When our neighbours use their logburner and we are stuck in the clouds, we live up on a mountain side so this is fairly common, it absolutely stinks. They have oil Central heating, so the log burner is a lifestyle choice.

Ddot · 10/10/2021 22:23

What size is your car

Cakeofdoom · 10/10/2021 22:17

The cold will affect my health far more than my stove...nothing will change my mind, zero. Call me selfish but I'm going to struggle to heat my small home without it.

Goldi321 · 10/10/2021 22:16

We live in a tiny village with no mains gas. We have bottled LPG (£250 a month to live in a cold house anyone) which we try to use sparingly. With our log burner we can heat one room, seasoned logs are a cheap way of supplementing our central heating and we had a 24 hour power cut my in the village in January last year that was miserable. So yes , sorry we will keep our only alternative form of heat.

StoneofDestiny · 10/10/2021 22:15

I'm glad I have one and when gas prices short up or power fails it will be lit. We use it rarely as our house is very rarely cold as it's insulated within an inch of its life!

CuteGirlsWatchMeEatEther · 10/10/2021 22:04

It can’t be justified. Some people are just selfish arseholes through and through.

julieca · 10/10/2021 22:02

It isn't about asthma. It is about tiny particles getting into your organs.

Roughasabadgersbum · 10/10/2021 22:00

Definitely not dedicatedGrin

Roughasabadgersbum · 10/10/2021 22:00

Ps I am dedicated not posh and grew up with open fires at home, as did DH and none of our children or us have asthma or any breathing difficulty, we do have a carbon monoxide detector in the rooms as provided by the computer that installed our stove

Roughasabadgersbum · 10/10/2021 21:57

I have a wood burner and I love it. We are rural and rely on it to keep the house warm, cook on, make hot drinks and dry our washing ( we have no dryer)when the electricity fails, which is quite often in winter. We do have oil heating but this is costly and can't always guarantee delivery or the boiler working!
I wouldn't be without my stove. We only burned seasoned wood, not green stuff. We've often all slept downstairs in the front room when it's been bitterly cold outside.

OverTheRubicon · 10/10/2021 21:42

@Ddot

I only burn the correct fuel, its chemical treated wood and painted wood that stinks
Doesn't matter. Still creates particulates.
MojoMoon · 10/10/2021 21:30

@Ddot

Please don't let the Grenfell disaster put your off all external wall insulation. There are many, many types of perfectly safe and effective external wall insulation. Energy Saving Trust can provide lots of info.

In the next few months, the government will announce its policy proposals for decarbonising heating which will include measures to support more insulation (unless the Insulate Britain protest have given it a bad name)

I really hope there is something there that will be financially accessible to you. There definitely are technological solutions to making your home warmer - it needs the government to make them viable and accessible.

And I 100pc agree bonfire night is unnecessary and all bonfires should be banned in urban areas too. Even if it is "tradition". People's health is more important than tradition.

OP posts:
Ddot · 10/10/2021 21:22

Its bonfire night soon, now that's unnecessary

Ddot · 10/10/2021 21:10

Looked into help for new boiler I dont qualify can't insulate walls unless I put something on the outside and we know how that went. Can't afford to move, I wish I had a solution for you I really do but I don't. I'm as green as I can be and try each day to save our lovely planet. I use less chemicals than most even my toothpaste is chemical free.