Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you can justify using a woodburner in a city or town

584 replies

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 09:39

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/oct/09/eco-wood-stoves-emit-pollution-hgv-ecodesign?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

New wood burning stoves billed as more environmentally friendly still emit 750 times more tiny particle pollution than a modern HGV truck, a report has shown.

Only stoves that meet the ecodesign standard can be legally sold from the start of 2022 in the UK and EU, but experts said the regulation was shockingly weak.

The report used data on the emissions produced by stoves in perfect laboratory conditions and the pollution could be even higher in everyday use, the researchers said, with older stoves being much worse.

Tiny particle pollution – called PM2.5 – is especially harmful to health as it can pass through the lungs into the bloodstream and then be carried around the body and lodge in organs. At least 40 ,000 early deaths a year are attributed to wood burning in Europe.

Wood burners also triple the level of harmful pollution inside homes and should be sold with a health warning, said the scientist behind a study published in December. The researchers advised that the stoves should not be used around elderly people or children.

The government may have banned the burning of wet wood but has no plans to ban the sale of woodburners, despite the fact that the 8pc of homes that use them are almost entirely in cities and can use power or gas for heating. And are almost entirely fairly wealthy households.

(Those of you who live a "very rural" location, to use a common Mumsnet phrase and are entirely off grid may justifiably need one. But the question was cities and towns).

It worries me so few people know how dangerous PM2.5 emissions are, particularly for pregnant women and children.

YANBU: correct, woodburners should be banned in homes in cities and towns asap

YABU: no, they look pretty and who cares about science and health

OP posts:
OverTheRubicon · 11/10/2021 14:59

@CauliflowerBalti

Rather than vilifying users in false binary questions, more needs to be done to educate stove owners on how to burn more responsibly and safely - like this, in New Zealand: www.warmercheaper.co.nz/

With the price of gas so utterly ridiculous, there's gonna be a lot more people using their stoves this year.

You've missed the point that in any built up area there is more or less safe, but no 'safe' level.

If we followed this advice, we'd be focussing on advising smokers with kids to just smoke outside the back door as opposed to actually stopping.

The vast majority of urban stove and fire earners are on middle to high incomes. It's ridiculous they're even on sale or allowed to be installed inside major cities.

CauliflowerBalti · 11/10/2021 13:46

Rather than vilifying users in false binary questions, more needs to be done to educate stove owners on how to burn more responsibly and safely - like this, in New Zealand: www.warmercheaper.co.nz/

With the price of gas so utterly ridiculous, there's gonna be a lot more people using their stoves this year.

LemonSwan · 11/10/2021 12:16

We previously lived in a single skin 1930s standard semi. Had double glazing & loft insulation. You could not for the love of you get that place warm. You just couldn't.

And I am not someone who does 'warm' - I work outside in the cold all weathers, and I had just come out of student accommodation so my levels for cold/heat are pretty generous - so the house was certainly not overheated.

So we got a log burner, and my god the issue was instantly solved!Its just a different type of heat. Its like it warms the actual building, the bricks, its nothing like a radiator.

After the house was warmed up and had a residual heat the radiators could keep on top of it. My gas bill was triple UK average in the first year and below average after the log burner.

And we only used it on very cold evenings. About 5-10 times a year in winter depending on the year.

So I am pro log burners.

I have just moved into a 2000ft single skin renovation project and first on the list is central heating and log burners. From previous experience I know there is no point trying to heat this house with central heating alone until its warm and 'dry' because humidity lowers temperatures.

So YABU

WalkingOnTheCracks · 11/10/2021 11:40

I’d be a lot more inclined to vote on this one if the phrasing of the options weren’t so loaded.

EKGEMS · 11/10/2021 11:35

Ever heard of a wood pellet stove? They burn the pieces of wood that are otherwise wasted from using in construction or paper making-we had two in the house we lived in a few years back-much cheaper than electric heat. Made an older house with high cathedral ceilings warm in blizzards and everyday heat needs.

Ddot · 11/10/2021 10:57

Mine is a stove I use coke and wood but only if I'm bloody froze.

SomethingOnce · 11/10/2021 10:10

What if you want a barbacue?

🤦‍♀️

daisyjgrey · 11/10/2021 10:04

@mustlovegin

House coal sales are being banned from May 2023

What if you want a barbacue?

That's charcoal, different thing. As is anthracite, which is what a lot of solid fuel reliant houses use now, it's smokeless.

Hardbackwriter · 11/10/2021 09:44

People always instinctively think that air pollution is an outdoor problem. I've also seen lots of people on MN say that they wouldn't have their child in a cycle trailer because of car exhausts, even though you're actually breathing in more fumes in the car than you are next to it. People think cars and houses are little hermetically sealed bubbles that don't let this stuff in but they're not - but they do slow down its dispersal.

MojoMoon · 11/10/2021 09:16

@JinglingHellsBells

What your source for saying people are more exposed to air pollution in their street than indoors?

This UK study says the opposite - ultrafine particulate exposure is higher indoors

www.globalactionplan.org.uk/news/revealed-indoor-air-pollution-3-5-times-worse-than-outdoor-air-pollution

A new study from Clean Air Day reveals that ultrafine particle pollution is on average 3.5 times higher inside the home than outside - and in one case peaked at 560 times higher than outdoors.

We commissioned air quality testing experts NAQTS to study four properties around the UK and found remarkably similar patterns of ultrafine particle pollution.

Our data showed that outdoor air pollution adds to indoor air pollution, building up in the home, and taking longer than outdoors to disperse.

OP posts:
Porridgeislife · 11/10/2021 09:14

@mustlovegin

House coal sales are being banned from May 2023

What if you want a barbacue?

House coal is not the same product as charcoal. You’d be in for a very disappointing (and toxic) BBQ if you tried house coal in your grill.
mustlovegin · 11/10/2021 09:08

House coal sales are being banned from May 2023

What if you want a barbacue?

FreedomFaith · 11/10/2021 08:59

@OverTheRubicon

Ok since you don't understand my point about the 'magical big corporation' as you put it, I'll explain.

People want to stop people buying meat, milk, plastic 'tat', etc. That's all well and good, but asking people to stop buying it won't stop the production. And people are easily manipulated, if it's available, they'll buy it. You might stop one person buying, but others will just buy more. It won't decrease production, which is part of the overall problem.

Your solution to wood burners is asking people to stop buying or using them. The real solution is stop making them. And then probably ban the use as well, but that likely won't happen unless boris or one of his cronies falls ill.

Eleganz · 11/10/2021 08:47

It seems we can't, as a population, hold the idea that we need to reduce global CO2 emissions and also do so in a way that does not wreck localised air quality.

There have clearly been a lot of wood burners installed around me (neighbours at the back have just had one installed as part of an extension). You can really smell them in the evenings and PM2.5 is a know health hazard and commercial units over a certain size have to have particulate control systems fitted. Domestic has always lagged behind.

Of course gas boilers have their own issues with NOx and actually a combination of wood and gas burning in urban areas is going to be worse than either alone as it will increase the likelihood of smog formation.

JinglingHellsBells · 11/10/2021 08:43

@MojoMoon Not ALL diesel is equal. Some of the best modern diesel engines are very different to the old ones that belch out fumes.

I see your point, but don't see how a government ban on open fires or woodburners is practical or possible.

Unless every open fireplace or chimney in the country is blocked up, it's not going to happen. Ditto solid fuel Agas etc.

I was brought up in a home where the only source of heating and hot water was an open fire. Lived like that till I was 16 when CH was installed.

I think the issue around particulates is more complex and grey than you make out. Most people are exposed to more pollution on the streets than in their homes.

KeflavikAirport · 11/10/2021 08:40

Yes I know, which is why pellets should be made either from fast-growing coppiced species or waste wood that would otherwise be incinerated.

Porridgeislife · 11/10/2021 08:37

@KeflavikAirport the issue with burning pellets is that wood is a carbon sink; burning it releases that carbon back into the atmosphere which then has to be reabsorbed, which currently it can’t do.

Putting it back into the ground isn’t actually a bad option from an environmental perspective.

KeflavikAirport · 11/10/2021 08:32

Thenka @Mojomoon. The reason I ask is because I worked in the sector back in the mid-90s before particulates were a concern. I'm wholly ready to admit my knowledge is out of date but I do think the case for wood pellets made using either coppiced and waste wood is better than you've painted once you take into account what would happen to the waste wood otherwise: I remember several municipalities using them successfully for collective heating in council housing (not in the UK).

Porridgeislife · 11/10/2021 08:29

This argument is only coming to light from those aggrieved that as the energy costs rise, they have no alternative to electric or gas.

I have a fireplace (installed before we moved in), certainly no fuel poverty and yet I can still understand it’s a serious public health issue.

House coal is thankfully being phased out.

www.gov.uk/government/news/restrictions-on-sale-of-coal-and-wet-wood-for-home-burning-begin

Wife2Frog · 11/10/2021 08:14

This comment also stood out to me. Can’t help but sense resentment being the catalyst to this argument. Whilst I don’t have a wood burner I burn wood & house coal in my open fire. I burn mostly on the weekends & during the evening when the temperatures drop & I have my chimney professionally cleaned at least one a year, a vital additional cost. This argument is only coming to light from those aggrieved that as the energy costs rise, they have no alternative to electric or gas.

MojoMoon · 11/10/2021 08:11

@KeflavikAirport
Unlike the scientific research they are criticising, the wood heat association's "research" has not been published in a respected peer reviewed scientific journal.

Their conclusion is "more research is needed" - clearly they've take a leaf out of the tobacco industry playbook. Tobacco executives knew in the 1950s that cigarettes caused cancer but successfully delayed any attempt to require them to highlight this by requiring information on packets or to ban smoking in public by fifty years, often by producing research that said "more research is needed".

Much like, despite the fact some people whined relentlessly, it turned out you can ban smoking in public places without causing riots, closing all pubs or forcing people into lives of relentless misery.

Using a wood burner in London could be banned tomorrow with equally as little problem as banning smoking in restaurants. Using a wood burner in London is not in anyway essential, it is a life style choice.

The wood heat association doesn't quite have the balls to say "our products don't cause dementia, cancer, asthma and miscarriage" because the scientists can't quite bring themselves to entirely ignore the science. They can just say "more research needed" into exactly how much of air pollution in London is caused by wood burning.

The thing is - whether particulates from wood burning make up 15pc or 20pc or 30pc of PM2.5 exposure in London doesn't matter. Even at the low end of estimates, banning them would lead to a sizeable improvement in air quality.

Are they the sole or biggest source of particulate exposure in London? No. The wood burning association can attempt to delay action by doing research pointing out that other things cause it too and saying we should do "more research" on that.

We also need to reduce car usage (even EVs produce particulates from brakes and tyres) and ban the use of diesel in London more rapidly. We should also ban garden bonfires and provide waste collection instead.
But even as a cyclist, I know that at least some car and lorry usage in London is inevitable and vital. So we can't just ban all traffic or diesel vehicles overnight.

Likewise, particulate exposure from frying over gas etc means stricter rules should be in place over renting properties without proper extractor fans. But it would take time to replace them all and is complex - it should be done but it cannot be done by tomorrow

But banning woodstoves in London is simple. It's low hanging fruit that would instantly reduce harm to people.
And the only damage would be to someone's hygge vibes.

Rural folk, please note I am specifically talking about London.

OP posts:
Porridgeislife · 11/10/2021 07:49

@KeflavikAirport

OP did you see the link i posted upthread from the wood heat association dusagreeing with you and the Guardian? Obvioudly they have both expertise and a vested interest so i was wondering if you could comment on thrir argument.
They are extremely clear in their own report that the issue is open fires and older stoves. They are more interested in “saving” biomass boilers using wood chips/pellets, which is fairly novel in urban centres. There is a weak environmental rationale for biomass boilers, but ultimately releasing the carbon trapped in wood into the atmosphere via burning wood isn’t great for the environment.

The other issue is that wood burning stoves are long lasting household appliances. No one is upgrading their stove every 5 (or even 10) years to meet modern requirements, even if that stove is pumping particulates into their living room.

DEFRA are very clear that 38% of the UK’s PM2.5 emissions came from domestic combustion, and that most of this is from wood burning stoves & open fires. This is the largest source, more than manufacturing and transport.

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/emissions-of-air-pollutants/emissions-of-air-pollutants-in-the-uk-particulate-matter-pm10-and-pm25

KeflavikAirport · 11/10/2021 06:42

OP did you see the link i posted upthread from the wood heat association dusagreeing with you and the Guardian? Obvioudly they have both expertise and a vested interest so i was wondering if you could comment on thrir argument.

UsedUpUsername · 11/10/2021 06:36

•I try to be green, yes you said it's a different thing but I think you will admit everything we do or eat affects the air we breath

Unironically the less ‘green’ option of natural gas is better for your health.

Although even those release nitrogen dioxide though … but not nearly to the extent of wood burners.

We’re really seeing a naturalistic fallacy at play here

Ddot · 11/10/2021 06:03

So you live in london with transport everywhere, where I live we have buses that dont really follow time table, plus expensive, you can wait over an hour then give up. No tube here. We have train station but limited to where it goes. Sorry about car comment but was tired. I have a small petrol car which I need. I try to be green, yes you said it's a different thing but I think you will admit everything we do or eat affects the air we breath. Everything has to be reared or manufactured which causes air pollution. If we all did something extra that would be a start