Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you can justify using a woodburner in a city or town

584 replies

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 09:39

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/oct/09/eco-wood-stoves-emit-pollution-hgv-ecodesign?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

New wood burning stoves billed as more environmentally friendly still emit 750 times more tiny particle pollution than a modern HGV truck, a report has shown.

Only stoves that meet the ecodesign standard can be legally sold from the start of 2022 in the UK and EU, but experts said the regulation was shockingly weak.

The report used data on the emissions produced by stoves in perfect laboratory conditions and the pollution could be even higher in everyday use, the researchers said, with older stoves being much worse.

Tiny particle pollution – called PM2.5 – is especially harmful to health as it can pass through the lungs into the bloodstream and then be carried around the body and lodge in organs. At least 40 ,000 early deaths a year are attributed to wood burning in Europe.

Wood burners also triple the level of harmful pollution inside homes and should be sold with a health warning, said the scientist behind a study published in December. The researchers advised that the stoves should not be used around elderly people or children.

The government may have banned the burning of wet wood but has no plans to ban the sale of woodburners, despite the fact that the 8pc of homes that use them are almost entirely in cities and can use power or gas for heating. And are almost entirely fairly wealthy households.

(Those of you who live a "very rural" location, to use a common Mumsnet phrase and are entirely off grid may justifiably need one. But the question was cities and towns).

It worries me so few people know how dangerous PM2.5 emissions are, particularly for pregnant women and children.

YANBU: correct, woodburners should be banned in homes in cities and towns asap

YABU: no, they look pretty and who cares about science and health

OP posts:
Strugglingtodomybest · 09/10/2021 10:29

So I'm interested to know what those of you who have no gas or wood burner/open fire will do when the power goes out?

I will wear layers: wool vests/longjohns, wool jumpers, add on a dressing gown/poncho/blankets in the evening.

But, to be fair, I live in Cornwall. I expect I'd feel differently in I lived up north.

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 10:27

@Babymamamama. Yes, lots of people don't get that it could be "carbon neutral" and yet still polluting.

We're talking here about particulate emissions, not carbon.

It's local air quality, eg in your home, street that this matters most that global change.

It's why saying "well, people fly on holiday so woodfires are not a problem" is irrelevant. That's not causing PM2.5 emissions in my house and street.

(Not saying you should all fly loads either, we can care about both local and global issues at the same time)

OP posts:
Travelledtheworld · 09/10/2021 10:27

I hope you woodburner owners aren't helping yourself to fallen wood from National Trust owned woodlands. The local NT Rangers told me they lose a LOT of fallen timber to locals collecting it for woodburners. The NT have left it there as a habitat for fungi and insects.

TheWholeWorld · 09/10/2021 10:25

They trigger asthma for me now. Which is odd because I grew up in a house with an open fire. Didn't get used all the time, but definitely sometimes in winter.

But I think now we know the damage that particulate emissions causes that the reasons for installing woodburners starts to look less attractive.

I'm house hunting at the minute and mentally including the cost of removing woodburners when I see them installed. I think in the next decade we will see moves to ban or severely restrict their use in towns and cities.

The wood smoke outdoors in winter in a lot of areas now is very unpleasant.

Imohsotired · 09/10/2021 10:23

I had no clue of their impact until we almost purchased two last year. We removed our fire places and planned to put in two stoves. My DH grew up in a rural area and thought I was being ridiculous but he came round after reading the research.

I don’t think it’s well enough publicised at all - I only came across it because I was checking if the stove would irritate my youngest who is prone to chest infections. I explained to the retailer why I was cancelling the order and they acted like it was news to them - not surprising I guess when it’s your business.

Babymamamama · 09/10/2021 10:23

Thavks for the explanations above I did wonder about the carbon neutral issue…..on reflection then I think then the whole idea of carbon neutral is rubbish. Try telling your neighbours your fuel is carbon neutral when you are polluting and stinking out the whole street. In these COVID times with so many people having weakened lungs it’s an issue.

Pinkstegosaurus · 09/10/2021 10:22

Up until recently we had a log burner which was our only source of heat in the winter (bar a plug in heater which was extortionate to run). Lived in a built up area in an annex, husband works in landscaping so we used to save and season any timber from felled trees/branches/untreated wood etc and that did us for the year after. I miss the cosiness of having a log burner but it was a needy beast!

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 10:22

@Sunshineshow

They are a bit naff now aren’t they? Right next to the sign saying ‘live love home’ and the twigs in the pot.
@Sunshineshow. The most damning comment on them so far Grin
OP posts:
Hardbackwriter · 09/10/2021 10:20

YANBU but in general I'm always surprised by how little people care about air pollution, I guess because it's invisible and the effects aren't immediately apparent. I used to live somewhere where every parent I met was obsessed with feeding their child no sugar organic food and with rear-facing in the car until 6 but when I mentioned being concerned about it having some of the worst air quality in the country people looked at me like I had two heads for caring. It was one of the reasons we moved (and deliberately moved to a set up where we could go down to one car used only occasionally). But I think I feel quite emotional about it because I had recurrent miscarriages while living there and was quite devastated when the research showing that air quality like ours increased miscarriage risk as much as smoking does came out.

OddBoots · 09/10/2021 10:20

I don't have one and would never have one but people who do have paid a lot of money for them.

Human nature is a funny thing and when you have paid that much out (plus when it is a part of your home which means another level of emotional attachment) it's normal to find ways to justify it even in the face of massive evidence of harm.

I wonder if alongside stopping more people getting them if more advanced filtering systems can be developed and made compulsory until they fade out from use.

WhoNeedsaManOfTheWorld · 09/10/2021 10:18

I have a multi fuel stove in the sitting room. I have been planning to have it removed for environmental reasons. I'm semi rural so pollution is less of a concern here but it still bothers me
I've only ever used smokeless coal or coffee logs. Any thing else gives me asthma
I'm glad I still have it now due to the rise in gas prices. It means I can hear one room and it does warm the house up through the chimney

duffed · 09/10/2021 10:18

Carbon neutral normally means the damage is being offset somewhere else, so the company who sells them plants so many trees.

I do thing a lot of the scaremongering stats are a bit silly - as its not like gas/electricity is without its dangers. Should we put stats up about how many people die in gas fires, or electric shocks?

I think its great that wood burning stoves will become more eco friendly from next year, but I think life is pretty miserable if you aren't allowed a nice fire to cosy up with. Many elderly rely on fires as a cheap way to heat the whole house. The way a fire heats the bricks always seems to stay a lot longer than radiators.

FourTeaFallOut · 09/10/2021 10:18

I have two log burning hygge bastards on my street. The street is thick with smoke on foggy days and it makes me wheeze and I can't open the windows. Cunts.

TDogsInHats · 09/10/2021 10:17

Mojo moon I think your choice of aibu and yanbu determiners are slanted to provoke a reaction.
Here's my reaction.
I'm not well off and we have a modern log burner that exceeds current environment requirements.
We use it as our sole source of heating in winter, we have a small house well insulated and leave our interior doors open so the heat spreads throughout our home.
I'm dreading the day we can't use it. We've never bought logs for it, we use free properly seasoned wood.

Loveshelly · 09/10/2021 10:17

@MojoMoon
Like no one ever does any research with an agenda. And only people who are evil will want to prove the government haven’t done a good job…
Ok !

bigbluebus · 09/10/2021 10:15

So what is the alternative when the electricity goes off?
When we bought our new build in 1992 we were told that the village suffered from regular power cuts due to all the cabling being overhead wires. As the builders had put a chimney on the plans but weren't planning on lining it or putting a fireplace in, we insisted that they did (other heat source was storage heaters at the time due to there being no gas in the village). There were numerous occasions when we had to light the fire just to heat one room as the power had been off overnight so we were then left with no heating for 24 hrs.

We now have central heating (oil) but it still doesn't work if the power goes off so the fire is used on those occasions that either the power goes off or the boiler breaks (that's happened this year too!).

I'm considering swapping my open fire for a wood burner just for aesthetic reasons but wouldn't consider getting rid completely.

So I'm interested to know what those of you who have no gas or wood burner/open fire will do when the power goes out?

I also grew up in a house with a coal fire and a back boiler so the fire was lit every day. None of my family had/ have asthma and my parents both lived until their late 80s.

Babymamamama · 09/10/2021 10:14

My green-party-supporting friend has an open wood fire hearth and tells me the logs they burn are “carbon neutral”. My tiny mind can’t even understand how that works. It seems counter intuitive. All I know is when I occasionally stay with her I go home with a dry sore throat and sometimes even lose my voice temporarily. In contrast, I’m in an insulated newish build and rarely even put the (gas fired) central heating on -so I think my lungs can’t handle onslaught of the wood fire.

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 10:14

@Loveshelly considered flaw in a study paid for by the association of people who sell woodburning stoves.

Funny they've not put their research paper in for publication in a respected peer-reviewed scientific journal unlike the paper they are criticising Hmm

OP posts:
butterflyze · 09/10/2021 10:13

I live on the edge of a small town, and a neighbour across the road has one. He seems to be burning mostly creosote-soaked broken-up fence panels on his, judging by the blue smoke and appalling smell. I did report it to the council one year, and they came out to have a look. During the day of course, when nobody was at home so the fire wasn't on. Confused

Loveshelly · 09/10/2021 10:11

Very interesting that the data is considered flawed.

Sunshineshow · 09/10/2021 10:09

They are a bit naff now aren’t they? Right next to the sign saying ‘live love home’ and the twigs in the pot.

GoWalkabout · 09/10/2021 10:09

That figure covers other sources of burning too, here's an explanation of how further studies have quantified the problem. www.hetas.co.uk/understanding-the-impact-of-domestic-wood-burning/

LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 09/10/2021 10:08

YABU for making such a silly choice option.

Strugglingtodomybest · 09/10/2021 10:08

I would love an open fire or woodburner, but would never have one for these reasons, so I don't think you're being unreasonable.

Lockheart · 09/10/2021 10:08

On this basis, we could easily conclude smoking cigarettes during pregnancy and around children is fine or drinking alcohol or using lead paint on furniture is fine since it happened a lot in the Olden Days and most of us lived to tell the tale.

I didn't say it was fine, I'm questioning the level of risk which you suggest.