Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you can justify using a woodburner in a city or town

584 replies

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 09:39

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/oct/09/eco-wood-stoves-emit-pollution-hgv-ecodesign?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

New wood burning stoves billed as more environmentally friendly still emit 750 times more tiny particle pollution than a modern HGV truck, a report has shown.

Only stoves that meet the ecodesign standard can be legally sold from the start of 2022 in the UK and EU, but experts said the regulation was shockingly weak.

The report used data on the emissions produced by stoves in perfect laboratory conditions and the pollution could be even higher in everyday use, the researchers said, with older stoves being much worse.

Tiny particle pollution – called PM2.5 – is especially harmful to health as it can pass through the lungs into the bloodstream and then be carried around the body and lodge in organs. At least 40 ,000 early deaths a year are attributed to wood burning in Europe.

Wood burners also triple the level of harmful pollution inside homes and should be sold with a health warning, said the scientist behind a study published in December. The researchers advised that the stoves should not be used around elderly people or children.

The government may have banned the burning of wet wood but has no plans to ban the sale of woodburners, despite the fact that the 8pc of homes that use them are almost entirely in cities and can use power or gas for heating. And are almost entirely fairly wealthy households.

(Those of you who live a "very rural" location, to use a common Mumsnet phrase and are entirely off grid may justifiably need one. But the question was cities and towns).

It worries me so few people know how dangerous PM2.5 emissions are, particularly for pregnant women and children.

YANBU: correct, woodburners should be banned in homes in cities and towns asap

YABU: no, they look pretty and who cares about science and health

OP posts:
ejhhhhh · 09/10/2021 12:46

@Datafan55 noone should be encouraging fire pits either. If it gives out smoke when it burns, stop burning it. We should ban all unnecessary burning that gives out smoke. That's one easy way of cutting air pollution. No fire pits, no woodburners, no bonfires, no coal BBQs, no candles (although candles are arguably quite small fry compare to the others!). I think the resistance to all that is that people haven't quite woken up to just how much our lifestyles are going to have to change for environmental reasons. But it will change, either quite gradually, or with an screeching painful about turn if we fail to act quickly enough.

KeflavikAirport · 09/10/2021 12:43

The fourth has been pretty roundly debunked, from manufacturing to CO2 and PM2.5 intensity.

Wood pellets are made from waste wood from industry (when you cut up a log, you basically lose as much as 50% of it). That waste wood would otherwise be incinerated. Turning it into pellets is obviously not a zeo-carbon process but it does make a more efficient combustible. It's a complicated equation and I would not like to be the person in charge of deciding which area gets the pollution, the incinerator in the poor area on the edge of town or the middle-class suburbs.

cjpark · 09/10/2021 12:40

To me, woodturners are of the 00's! they should be put in room 101 along with glittery slogans written on walls and diamanté furniture. No need - bad the environment when there is plenty of cheaper alternatives.

TuftyMarmoset · 09/10/2021 12:40

@BluebellsGreenbells most radiators have valves on them which control the heat. Turn down/off the ones in the rooms you don't want to heat. You can also get smart systems to do it for you.

@MrsRobbieHart the reason is because of the government's commitment to net zero. Although it's better than oil, gas is still a fossil fuel that results in carbon dioxide emissions when burnt. After 2025 new build homes will not be built with gas boilers and at some point in the 2030s new gas boilers won't be installed in other homes (but they won't take away existing gas boilers that still work, it's for when you need a new one). Heat pumps are the main alternative but they're looking at hydrogen boilers as well.

JassyRadlett · 09/10/2021 12:40

It’s a good question! I guess because it’s needed now, and gas phase out will take many years? Gas is certainly less harmful than some other forms of heating eg oil, so it may be it’s being looked at as a transitional fuel.

ejhhhhh · 09/10/2021 12:40

Because gas boilers add up to quite a significant proportion of CO2 emissions in this country, so there's a push to replace with less polluting means of heating (like solar, air source heat pumps). That's different to burning wood though, with wood it's the particulate pollution that's a concern, as well as CO2, and gas boilers give out very little particulate pollution so in that regard they're much cleaner. We need to phase out both, both are harmful, but in different ways. Imo wood burners could go immediately, they're of no use they're just ornaments, whereas phasing out gas boilers would be much more difficult and would need a viable, reasonably priced alternative, which we don't yet really have. We have a good alternative to a wood burner already, it's called a gas boiler, if you have one of those you should stop using your wood burner immediately and just use your boiler. They may not be the best ever technology in terms of CO2 emissions, but they're a damn site better overall than woodburners.

MrsRobbieHart · 09/10/2021 12:37

@JassyRadlett

What is the reason gas is being phased out?

Emissions. Household heating is a huge source of CO2 emissions.

There are still debates on what the long term solution will be but in the medium term heat pumps seem to be the preferred option.

Thanks @JassyRadlett. So I wonder why in the hell phoenix gas are being allowed to dig up the whole country here in NI to install their pipes when it’s being phased out elsewhere.
MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 12:37

@CounsellorTroi

I don’t think there’s any way of getting away from the fact that burning things releases toxins and carcinogens.

This includes candles in the home especially scented ones.

Very true. Scented candles release a lot of particulates too (but drift outside your home less I suppose? So you just damage yourself and your kids perhaps. And you probably don't have them on eight hours a day)

Going to rile a whole new demographic with that!

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 09/10/2021 12:36

I live in a 4 bedroomed house, why would I need to heat the whole house when I can hear one room?

You can do that with central heating.

Datafan55 · 09/10/2021 12:36

Firepits really are trendy these days too... Should we be encouraging one and talking about banning another?

Datafan55 · 09/10/2021 12:35

Lots of interesting debate here. Noting down re fuels etc.

As a PP said, just wearing thermals and multiple jumpers and gloves and dressing gowns over the top instead of heating even for a few days is not a good option - I cough and wheeze and have aching joints most of each winter due to lack of money for heating/from the cold. With the current worry about fuel pries and about the actual gas and electric supply, I would relish some kind of independent, back-up, cheap fuel burning option.

My parents installed a woodburner as - like @bigbluebus and other rural posters eg @meadowbleu- the power lines are overhead in their village, there is no gas, only oil, and the power goes out enough for them to need an alternative for heat and hot water. They buy wood responsibly (supporting a local business and having some rare human interaction to boot). The rest of the time, their house is well-insulated (loft, good windows, thick blinds and curtains, etc) and warm from the oil/radiators.

I would be looking into any 'good' options if I am ever lucky enough to buy a house with a fireplace etc... Particularly if I’m buying somewhere rural.

However I have a few neighbours here in this built up area who I suspect not only pick up random/wet wood from the small nearby park, which smokes horribly over the whole street, but possibly cut it OFF trees. I've never seen them do it, but I suspect (it’s on the list of issues, along with loud music and a maniac dog which poos).

Can you ban house fires if you can’t be sure that the centralised supply will never fail? or if you are rich enough to afford gas at whatever price, or heat pumps, but others are not? or if you live in Westminster but others are in far more rural places?

Auroreforet · 09/10/2021 12:34

We use a wood burner as our only alternative would be electricity and we simply couldn’t afford it.
We’ve just bought new more economical radiators for the bedrooms.

The dust from our wood burner is dreadful and I do worry about our health but it’s that or freeze.

JassyRadlett · 09/10/2021 12:34

What is the reason gas is being phased out?

Emissions. Household heating is a huge source of CO2 emissions.

There are still debates on what the long term solution will be but in the medium term heat pumps seem to be the preferred option.

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 12:33

@longtompot

Surely if you're going to ban wood burners, then any open fire needs to be banned. I would have thought there are more emissions from an open fire than a wood burner. We have a wood burner, which we installed last year. We chose the most efficient eco model we could afford. Oh, and we aren't rich and didn't install it for it's looks. There are no live, love, home signs here either. It really helps not only keep our house warm, but it helps my dd who has a chronic pain condition and has bad circulation in her feet (they are like ice all the time) and this is the only thing that has actually made her feet warm. So for her health, we will be keeping ours.

I do wonder if hgvs having such a low level for particle emissions is because they are so many many more of those than there are wood burners in the country?

Open fires have long been banned in London and I think in some other cities too (feel like maybe Brum?)
OP posts:
ejhhhhh · 09/10/2021 12:33

You're right OP, it's not justifiable. In towns/cities, with centrally heated houses, it's just selfish. An 8 year old died in London from an asthma attack a few years ago. After an inquest, the coroner has rules air pollution as the cause of death. If that, and all the other direct and indirect deaths (because it won't be the first or last, just the first officially recorded) aren't enough to stop people burning wood in their homes just because they like it, I don't know what will, we're a morally bankrupt. They should really be banned, I've no idea why they haven't been. If they were banned in towns and cities it would make sod all difference to people's lives because noone actually needs one.

MrsRobbieHart · 09/10/2021 12:31

It worries me to hear lots of people on MN saying gas boilers are being phased out. Here in NI there has been a massive push to install gas infrastructure all over the place. People are spending lots of money to convert from oil to gas. What is the reason gas is being phased out?

CounsellorTroi · 09/10/2021 12:28

I don’t think there’s any way of getting away from the fact that burning things releases toxins and carcinogens.

This includes candles in the home especially scented ones.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 09/10/2021 12:26

I hope the height of the chimney does make a difference, because I am in a small town but at the top of a hill and live in a tall Georgian house with insanely tall chimneys, so if the particulates blow away it might be fine but not if they fall down.
The wood burner makes a huge difference to the comfort of our (very cold, listed) house in the winter and I love open fires but I am not particularly comfortable about harming other people!

I once stayed at a big, crowded campsite with fire pits at every pitch and it was striking how once hundreds of campers had their fires going you could see the pall of smoke that hung over the valley.

meadowbleu · 09/10/2021 12:25

@nestoftables

I think there is a market for getting wood burning stoves converted somehow to electric. There must be a way to do this with some sort of heating element, without people having to get rid of nice stoves (which would be an environmental issue itself due to all the waste).
There often seems to be a snide tone towards posters who say they live in a rural area, some of us really do with all the pros and cons it brings. We have mains fresh water and electricity, but private drainage and oil for heating., there's no gas, but then gas boilers are supposed to be phased out. Where we live there is no public transport route, no pavements and no street lighting. We've struggled to get a delivery of oil during the fuel crisis, you can't buy and store more than the tank allows and if they can't deliver, you're utterly without. Some areas really do have a need for alternative sources of heat.

Our multi fuel flat topped stove is a godsend during frequent power cuts, or when the oil's run out, or boiler broken down, as it's more efficient than an open fire and we can heat water or soup or do scrambled eggs on top of it to get by. Converting to electricity would make it useless.

We use wood on a rotation, it's two years seasoned in a barn when we receive it and we keep it another year under cover, this supplements the main fuel source which is Eco briquettes. These are mechanically pressed offcuts and sawdust from the local sawmill.

Our nearest air quality reading is at Level 1 and we have no light pollution here either. We do lots of things to try and live responsibly as we can.

I do agree they should be used as responsibly as possible and that in towns and homes where the main source of heating is reliable, they're mostly a decorative object.

BungleandGeorge · 09/10/2021 12:24

I don’t think there’s any way of getting away from the fact that burning things releases toxins and carcinogens. There’s 2 groups though, those who want a wood burner but have other options and those who don’t have other options. The availability of gas is probably a moot point as gas boilers are being phased out too. I’d be very happy to switch to an eco friendly option but the cost is unaffordable. The government don’t want to subsidise people to switch over, thus why they’re not really tackling the problem of chimney smoke.

KeflavikAirport · 09/10/2021 12:23

Pellets made from waste wood are pretty green. Several towns use them for collective heating. You can get home pellet burners too.

BluebellsGreenbells · 09/10/2021 12:22

I agree , if you have central heating i cant see the need for them

I live in a 4 bedroomed house, why would I need to heat the whole house when I can hear one room?

What happens when the central heating fails?

chaosrabbitland · 09/10/2021 12:19

i agree , if you have central heating i cant see the need for them , in my old private rent house we had the original victorian fire , but i never was tempted to use it .

my ex husband who lives on a canal boat uses one , but then thats a bit different ,as its the only way to heat the boat and keep it warm , but it does give off a wee bit of a smokey smell that probably would give me a headache if i breathed it in for too long ,

TuftyMarmoset · 09/10/2021 12:18

BBQ, bonfires etc are also bad in terms of releasing particulate but they don't tend to be in quite as regular use (at least not bonfires). I have an allotment and the council asked us not to have bonfires during the pandemic because the pollution was harming people who were ill, and worsening people's chronic conditions.

longtompot · 09/10/2021 12:17

Surely if you're going to ban wood burners, then any open fire needs to be banned. I would have thought there are more emissions from an open fire than a wood burner.
We have a wood burner, which we installed last year. We chose the most efficient eco model we could afford. Oh, and we aren't rich and didn't install it for it's looks. There are no live, love, home signs here either.
It really helps not only keep our house warm, but it helps my dd who has a chronic pain condition and has bad circulation in her feet (they are like ice all the time) and this is the only thing that has actually made her feet warm. So for her health, we will be keeping ours.

I do wonder if hgvs having such a low level for particle emissions is because they are so many many more of those than there are wood burners in the country?