Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you can justify using a woodburner in a city or town

584 replies

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 09:39

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/oct/09/eco-wood-stoves-emit-pollution-hgv-ecodesign?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

New wood burning stoves billed as more environmentally friendly still emit 750 times more tiny particle pollution than a modern HGV truck, a report has shown.

Only stoves that meet the ecodesign standard can be legally sold from the start of 2022 in the UK and EU, but experts said the regulation was shockingly weak.

The report used data on the emissions produced by stoves in perfect laboratory conditions and the pollution could be even higher in everyday use, the researchers said, with older stoves being much worse.

Tiny particle pollution – called PM2.5 – is especially harmful to health as it can pass through the lungs into the bloodstream and then be carried around the body and lodge in organs. At least 40 ,000 early deaths a year are attributed to wood burning in Europe.

Wood burners also triple the level of harmful pollution inside homes and should be sold with a health warning, said the scientist behind a study published in December. The researchers advised that the stoves should not be used around elderly people or children.

The government may have banned the burning of wet wood but has no plans to ban the sale of woodburners, despite the fact that the 8pc of homes that use them are almost entirely in cities and can use power or gas for heating. And are almost entirely fairly wealthy households.

(Those of you who live a "very rural" location, to use a common Mumsnet phrase and are entirely off grid may justifiably need one. But the question was cities and towns).

It worries me so few people know how dangerous PM2.5 emissions are, particularly for pregnant women and children.

YANBU: correct, woodburners should be banned in homes in cities and towns asap

YABU: no, they look pretty and who cares about science and health

OP posts:
TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 09/10/2021 13:10

I'd look at the authors of the report and the amount of wood they burnt to get their results. They are assessing 140kg of wood used as the main source of heating (so assume this is for the entire cold season).

They've massaged the data according to their message. Fake news, anyone?

elbea · 09/10/2021 13:09

I lived in a very rural location in Cumbria that operated on electric storage heaters and single glazed sash windows. It was pretty well insulated as the walls were about half a meter thick. My open fire was absolutely essential in the very cold winters, I did ensure to use smokeless coal though.

I can’t really see the point of one in the middle of a city though.

ejhhhhh · 09/10/2021 13:07

@icedcoffees that's something that could be solved relatively easily if there was the political will. We could tax polluting "luxury" behaviours very highly, and subsidise cleaner forms of heating using the proceeds. Insulating poor quality housing would be a massive step in the right direction, so the homes of those in fuel poverty just need much less fuel to heat. We've had politicians tinkering about the edges with policies on this for decades, but they're made very little progress because there just hasn't been political will. It COULD be done, your average wealthy person lives in a well insulated house, but those who can't afford to do it themselves, or don't own their home so can't, need much more government intervention.

Energy4You · 09/10/2021 13:07

@MojoMoon

For those "very rural" people asking about power cuts and the need for back up.

Ok, how about you are banned from using them unless the local council waives the ban for a day if you have a power cut? If there is a widespread long lasting power cut, each day the local council can issue a proclamation saying that it's ok today.

Sorted.

Still no reason for them to exist in big cities

You are not going to spend £thousands in a wood burner plus having the wood there, all dried etc… if you need it a few times in the year. Once the wood burner is installed, it’s going to be used.
KeflavikAirport · 09/10/2021 13:04

Incinerating it is just wasting the embedded energy though, unless you capture the heat.

Ibelieveinghosts · 09/10/2021 13:02

Probably justify it in the same way people justify having more than one child, a car, buying clothes that they don’t strictly need, eating meat and dairy, wearing leather, flying....,,,

DdraigGoch · 09/10/2021 12:59

@GermioneHranger

I think the issue is if they are banned in towns and cities, how would this work? We have one as we are rural (several miles from the local town) however we have the local towns name on our address. Without it, we'd have no heating in some areas of the house - if they banned it in towns then how would it be policed? I think it would be quite hard!

It's cold up north 🥶

Same applies to me. Define "town". The nearest town is on my address, I am represented by Town Councillors in the town but there are a few fields and a hill separating my village from the town.
RavingAnnie · 09/10/2021 12:59

@EddieVeddersfoxymop

I absolutely detest these stoves and the huge rise in garden fire pits. I am surrounded by people that like to burn things all the time........I have 2 medical conditions triggered by smoke and so sometimes actually have to leave my house and go out when my neighbour starts burning. I can't use my own garden, can't open windows, hang washing or even stay at home because someone close by decides to burn shit. I contacted the council who basically shrugged their shoulders, saying they can do nothing. Meanwhile I'm left unable to use my home or garden because of the frequency of local burning. Hate these things- they shouldn't be allowed in villages or towns. No neighbours for miles, then crack on but in close proximity it just shouldn't happen. I appreciate I have a bit of a bee in my bonnet about it, but it's so wearing day after day - and because its different people each time I cannot get any help.
I think you need to start badgering your MP. Explain the impact on your health. I think we all need to start doing that. They need to know if public opinion is turning and then they might do something.
BungleandGeorge · 09/10/2021 12:59

@MojoMoon but a large percentage of our electricity comes from burning fossil fuels! And some of our ‘eco’ options are extremely inefficient.

Datafan55 · 09/10/2021 12:59

@MojoMoon ^For those "very rural" people asking about power cuts and the need for back up.
Ok, how about you are banned from using them unless the local council waives the ban for a day if you have a power cut? If there is a widespread long lasting power cut, each day the local council can issue a proclamation saying that it's ok today^.

Maybe, although you'd still have to be allowed to install them, or not.
They'd have to be used occasionally to keep them working/ready for if needed.

You also have to buy fuel in advance (enough, just in case)... And then it's there rotting or simply filling a shed if it's not used.

MapleMay11 · 09/10/2021 12:57

Wood pellets are made from waste wood from industry (when you cut up a log, you basically lose as much as 50% of it). That waste wood would otherwise be incinerated. Turning it into pellets is obviously not a zeo-carbon process but it does make a more efficient combustible. It's a complicated equation and I would not like to be the person in charge of deciding which area gets the pollution, the incinerator in the poor area on the edge of town or the middle-class suburbs.

Nitrogen oxide levels are higher in some suburban areas than city centres (certainly in London) so pollution levels are already very high there, with serious consequences for respiratory health.

ejhhhhh · 09/10/2021 12:57

In rural areas, air pollution isn't really that much of a concern. If the population burning is spread out enough, and the levels of traffic low, it's not too much of a concern. It's when particulates from wood/coal burning mix with traffic fumes that it's really harmful to health, so I've no real problem with enforcing smoke free zones in urban areas only. We already have them, but they're not enforced so they're just ignored, and the legislation needs to be tightened up to include all burning.

RavingAnnie · 09/10/2021 12:56

@NautaOcts

I’d also be interested to know how the harm from domestic woodburners compares to that from people having bonfires to burn garden waste as I feel more impacted by that.
I think both should be banned.
Auroreforet · 09/10/2021 12:56

Unfortunately in very cold weather air source heat pumps are not good enough to heat the house properly.
So when you need them most they may not work.

The big problem is retrospective energy proofing homes and that’s what the government should be focusing on.

WhoIsBernieBrown · 09/10/2021 12:56

Eek. DP has always coveted a log burner and we are hoping to move to an area where there are loads in the future. Massively rethinking this now. I don't want my wee ones to be surrounded by smoke constantly. Thanks for this thread, it's genuinely really useful and definitely something people need to hear. Air pollution really isn't spoken about in the same way as CO2 emissions.

UsedUpUsername · 09/10/2021 12:55

@KeflavikAirport

The fourth has been pretty roundly debunked, from manufacturing to CO2 and PM2.5 intensity.

Wood pellets are made from waste wood from industry (when you cut up a log, you basically lose as much as 50% of it). That waste wood would otherwise be incinerated. Turning it into pellets is obviously not a zeo-carbon process but it does make a more efficient combustible. It's a complicated equation and I would not like to be the person in charge of deciding which area gets the pollution, the incinerator in the poor area on the edge of town or the middle-class suburbs.

Waste wood being incinerated onsite is better, no? Keeps particulates outside of residential areas. Makes local air quality better
bob1985 · 09/10/2021 12:53

If you do the maths on it you would need to run the average wood burner for approx 730 years to match the output of a HGV

(assuming you ran the burner for 90 days per year , and the HGV had a working life of around 12-15 years)

icedcoffees · 09/10/2021 12:53

People burning unsuitable wood, with too wet, not sufficiently seasoned or treated wood adds massively to the pollution.

I don't disagree but many people can't afford to heat their homes any other way. Treated wood is expensive. Smokeless fuel is expensive. Central heating, electric and oil radiators are all expensive.

People shouldn't be using woodburners if they can afford other options but many people can't. They shouldn't be penalised for being poor.

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 12:51

@ChargingBuck my question literally says "in towns and cities"

Yes, that is urban centric. It's in the headline!

OP posts:
user1493494961 · 09/10/2021 12:51

We've just lit ours.

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 12:50

For those "very rural" people asking about power cuts and the need for back up.

Ok, how about you are banned from using them unless the local council waives the ban for a day if you have a power cut? If there is a widespread long lasting power cut, each day the local council can issue a proclamation saying that it's ok today.

Sorted.

Still no reason for them to exist in big cities

OP posts:
ChargingBuck · 09/10/2021 12:50

And are almost entirely fairly wealthy households.

Ah, the standard urban-centric MN bubble.

Tell that to the hundreds of thousands living in fuel poverty rurally.
Some of us can't afford the oil, or worse, bottled gas that are the only modern heating option in many remote houses.
We can lash out a tenner on a bag of coal a couple of times a week though. Or save for a £50 dumpy bag of logs from a local farmer.

Without those options, many rural houses would be literally freezing. Unless you've lived in a gaff where the back door ices over & you can only afford to heat a single room, you might not understand that.

RavingAnnie · 09/10/2021 12:49

I agree completely OP. I used to have an open fire in my last house and wanted to fit a wood burner in this one. However we have opted not to when I find out how much they pollute your local and indoor environment. I can't wait until they are banned. My whole village absolutely stinks of wood smoke throughout winter. So much so that it can be difficult to breathe walking up my road some days when the air pressure isn't right. I dread to think what it's like for poor people with asthma and COPD etc.

Please keep spreading the word. I don't think most people understand how bad they are.

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 12:48

Re heating with electricity - about half of your electricity bill is made of various taxes and levies. Only half of it is the cost of electricity itself.

Electric heating can be made much cheaper by moving those taxes onto more environmentally damaging fuels. When power was generated by more coal, it made sense but now the power system is increasingly clean and will become even more so in the next decade, so it doesn't make sense to tax the consumption of it so heavily but not tax the consumption of damaging fuels like gas, oil, wood.

Those fuels cause damage that we then all pay for - in healthcare for asthma, miscarriages, dementia, all of which have been linked to higher rates of particulates exposure. And that is aside from the tragedy of early deaths like Ella Kissa-Debrah.

These externalities should be reflected in the tax treatment of those fuels.

And then electricity will be cheaper. Air source heat pumps, infrared radiators etc can also help improve the efficiency of using it for heating, not like the old fashioned electric heaters.

OP posts:
MrsRobbieHart · 09/10/2021 12:47

Thanks @JassyRadlett, @ejhhhhh and @TuftyMarmoset.

Swipe left for the next trending thread