Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you can justify using a woodburner in a city or town

584 replies

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 09:39

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/oct/09/eco-wood-stoves-emit-pollution-hgv-ecodesign?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

New wood burning stoves billed as more environmentally friendly still emit 750 times more tiny particle pollution than a modern HGV truck, a report has shown.

Only stoves that meet the ecodesign standard can be legally sold from the start of 2022 in the UK and EU, but experts said the regulation was shockingly weak.

The report used data on the emissions produced by stoves in perfect laboratory conditions and the pollution could be even higher in everyday use, the researchers said, with older stoves being much worse.

Tiny particle pollution – called PM2.5 – is especially harmful to health as it can pass through the lungs into the bloodstream and then be carried around the body and lodge in organs. At least 40 ,000 early deaths a year are attributed to wood burning in Europe.

Wood burners also triple the level of harmful pollution inside homes and should be sold with a health warning, said the scientist behind a study published in December. The researchers advised that the stoves should not be used around elderly people or children.

The government may have banned the burning of wet wood but has no plans to ban the sale of woodburners, despite the fact that the 8pc of homes that use them are almost entirely in cities and can use power or gas for heating. And are almost entirely fairly wealthy households.

(Those of you who live a "very rural" location, to use a common Mumsnet phrase and are entirely off grid may justifiably need one. But the question was cities and towns).

It worries me so few people know how dangerous PM2.5 emissions are, particularly for pregnant women and children.

YANBU: correct, woodburners should be banned in homes in cities and towns asap

YABU: no, they look pretty and who cares about science and health

OP posts:
userabc · 09/10/2021 14:56

So no agenda in OP at all then Hmm

Would also be interested to know about the OP's

  • use of car (even electric cars use masses of fossil fuels in steel manufacture, smelting etc)
  • use of air travel
  • indirect use of fossil fuels in purchase of any goods that require transportation in e.g. a ship, plane, HGV

I am willing to bet OP is a massive hypocrite with a niggle on single issue that they are blemish-free on.

CovidCorvid · 09/10/2021 14:54

@JassyRadlett that sounds great and when it’s all up and running and the cost of energy has fallen I’ll revisit my house heating options. In the mean time it’s significantly cheaper to put a couple of logs on the log burner than turn the central heating on.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 09/10/2021 14:52

I absolutely hate them. We're semi rural and since we've moved in, I'm constantly coughing and the house is full of smoke from neighbours' wood burners.
There were 2 in our house and we ripped them both out (they were condemned anyway). There's also one in the outbuilding that we don't use.

We're on LPG so costs a lot to heat the house, but I couldn't justify adding to the smoke surrounding our house by putting a fire back in. We also took out the gas fire as can't afford the LPG to run it.
All our neighbours are loaded so it's clearly not a financial issue why they aren't removing their bloody awful wood burners.

EarlGreywithLemon · 09/10/2021 14:51

I love the smell, I love what it looks like and would love to have one. In fact we could have one fitted, but won’t for exactly this reason.

julieca · 09/10/2021 14:51

[quote dailily]@julieca isn't gas mains on its way out too?![/quote]
Eventually. But banning wood burning stoves for people who have other ways to heat their house, is such an easy way to reduce pollution.

julieca · 09/10/2021 14:49

@LowlandLucky no one is asking you to justify it. But the advice is not to use a wood burner stove around children. It emits tony particles that gets into the bloodstream and over time can cause damage. It is way more damaging to children's health than smoking in a room with your children.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 09/10/2021 14:49

I've not RTFT, but why is it that people are SO resistant to the idea that something they enjoy might be causing harm?
Honestly. I don't get it. I learn about new things all the time, things I've previously enjoyed but are now found to be detrimental to health or harmful to the environment. I feel disappointed for a while and then work out how to not do the thing or do much less of the thing that is harmful. Including decommissioning my supposedly clean burning wood burning stove.
What I don't do is minimise or discredit good science or engage in endless whataboutery.

JassyRadlett · 09/10/2021 14:49

@CovidCorvid

I have one. I am rural ish but we have gas so yes don’t need it. I didn’t know about the pollution (nobody talked about it ten years ago) when we fitted it. I mean obviously I knew that burning wood would cause some particles, etc but nobody spoke about it like they do now back then. Not sure I’d have had it fitted if I knew.

Saying that I will still use it….cost me 5k so I’m not having it as decoration. We’ve had two extended periods of time when I’ve been so glad we’ve had it. Once our boiler broke and it was a week to fix, in winter so no central heating…was a life saver. Another time the gas pipe to our village broke and nobody had any gas for two weeks. Again was very glad we had it.

Also with rising fuel bills I prefer to put the fire on….working my way through the pile of logs knowing how much I have left. Rather than putting the heating on and worrying how much it’s going to cost.

Plus how clean is the gas/electricity we get? There’s an environmental cost to everything. 🤷‍♀️

Well, mostly free of coal now which is great. Gas to be phased out by 2035, which suggests large expansion of non-intermittent power (batteries, nuclear, tidal, hydro) alongside wind and solar. Suspect a mix will come into play and tidal and battery storage will become a lot cheaper, and grid balancing will get a lot smarter to reduce relative demand (as overall demand increases due to electrification of heat.)
CovidCorvid · 09/10/2021 14:48

Good quality heat pumps work perfectly. I've lived in two houses with them, including the one I'm currently in. They're not cheap to purchase but 'unknown unreliability' is ridiculous.

I might be wrong but I read they only work perfectly if you live in a well insulated house? So possibly not in my 150yo house with no cavity wall?

dailily · 09/10/2021 14:47

@julieca isn't gas mains on its way out too?!

JassyRadlett · 09/10/2021 14:45

There’s a brilliant water-source heat pump system at a newish large apartment/hotel development in Kingston, which draws water from the Thames (not a notoriously warm body of water) to provide a district heating system for the whole development.

Cakeofdoom · 09/10/2021 14:41

Sorry, meant to quote MapleMay and heat source pumps...

JassyRadlett · 09/10/2021 14:41

Well what's the use of forcing us to use hydrogen? I don't have a clean cheap reliable source of that either, not any heater that runs off it. It's like how they keep touting 'heat pumps' as if everybody can spend thousands to have a hole ripped into their house to install a device with unknown reliability which is going to pump in the 'heat' from outside - all -5 degrees of it in winter which I'm sure will keep me nice and toasty.

You know it’s not just moving air from the outdoor, right? There’s refrigerant liquid and a compressor involved.

Wait until I tell you about a crazy heat-exchange device called a ‘fridge’. It’ll blow your mind.

Cakeofdoom · 09/10/2021 14:40

The initial outlay is beyond the reach of most. I've costed this for my mum in case her oil boiler dies. In excess of 20k and the solid floor needs to come out...she'll struggle to do that on pension credit 🤔

CovidCorvid · 09/10/2021 14:38

I have one. I am rural ish but we have gas so yes don’t need it. I didn’t know about the pollution (nobody talked about it ten years ago) when we fitted it. I mean obviously I knew that burning wood would cause some particles, etc but nobody spoke about it like they do now back then. Not sure I’d have had it fitted if I knew.

Saying that I will still use it….cost me 5k so I’m not having it as decoration. We’ve had two extended periods of time when I’ve been so glad we’ve had it. Once our boiler broke and it was a week to fix, in winter so no central heating…was a life saver. Another time the gas pipe to our village broke and nobody had any gas for two weeks. Again was very glad we had it.

Also with rising fuel bills I prefer to put the fire on….working my way through the pile of logs knowing how much I have left. Rather than putting the heating on and worrying how much it’s going to cost.

Plus how clean is the gas/electricity we get? There’s an environmental cost to everything. 🤷‍♀️

AnotherThingToDo · 09/10/2021 14:36

I genuinely didn’t know they were as bad as this! We’re renovating a new home and planned to put one in but I don’t think I could justify it now

MapleMay11 · 09/10/2021 14:35

@nosyupnorth

They are looking at other options - e.g. using clean hydrogen instead of gas, etc.

Well what's the use of forcing us to use hydrogen? I don't have a clean cheap reliable source of that either, not any heater that runs off it. It's like how they keep touting 'heat pumps' as if everybody can spend thousands to have a hole ripped into their house to install a device with unknown reliability which is going to pump in the 'heat' from outside - all -5 degrees of it in winter which I'm sure will keep me nice and toasty.

I wonder if everybody crying about the health risks of air particles has even bothered to compare to the well known health risks of damp and underheated homes.

Good quality heat pumps work perfectly. I've lived in two houses with them, including the one I'm currently in. They're not cheap to purchase but 'unknown unreliability' is ridiculous.
EvilPea · 09/10/2021 14:32

@NiceTwin

I live off grid, we have a wood burner but we rarely use the room it is in. We use the room with the open fire. We live in a smokeless zone and the goal merchant won't sell us house coal, even though they do stock it.
This may have changed but if I remember rightly canal boats can still use ‘house coal’ they are exempt.

Can’t imagine the number of them makes that much difference though

Cakeofdoom · 09/10/2021 14:32

Best avoid those naice woodfired pizzas in Waitrose and barbeques in the Summer then... 🤔

godmum56 · 09/10/2021 14:30

[quote MojoMoon]@MinesAPintOfTea

House coal sales are being banned from May 2023 fyi

www.gov.uk/guidance/selling-coal-for-domestic-use-in-england[/quote]
but that's coal, not coke.

FourTeaFallOut · 09/10/2021 14:30

*It’s not about carbon emissions, it’s about the air quality in your home and your immediate surroundings.

Why can’t people understand this?*

Because they aren't wheezing and dying now they think that air pollution is a worry for other people. The silent risk of the pm in their own air on their own risks of poor lung health, dementia and cancer in the long term don't hit the radar.

KeflavikAirport · 09/10/2021 14:30

Tbf it is a huge problem in the third world. Caroline Criado Perez has a good section on it in her book.

Hardbackwriter · 09/10/2021 14:30

@Loveshelly

608 children died in car accidents and 91,000 were injured. Should we ban cars. Won’t someone think of the children!
By your logic - there's no point doing anything if you're not going to eradicate all causes of death entirely - people might as well go around stabbing children until we ban cars because hey, some kids will die anyway. But that's really very stupid, isn't it?
EvilPea · 09/10/2021 14:29

[quote JasonMomoasgirlfriend]@Elphame yeh I think lots of people still use candles and harsh chemical products that are really not nice for our bodies.
Candles are carcinogenic arent they?
Although, what isn't I suppose.

I went to buy a new vacuum cleaner the other day and the guy in the appliance shop was saying all tumble dryers with heating elements will be banned in 5 years time. He said they will all be heat pumps going forward[/quote]
Hopefully heat pump prices come down in that time or that will be another thing only for the wealthy

Cakeofdoom · 09/10/2021 14:28

@Hardbackwriter

Funny how I feel the need to NC in order to say that I have far bigger things to worry about than woodburners.

Woodburners are contributing to the premature deaths of many people each year, including children. What do you have to worry about that's more important than the deaths of children?

Stats please ?