Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you can justify using a woodburner in a city or town

584 replies

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 09:39

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/oct/09/eco-wood-stoves-emit-pollution-hgv-ecodesign?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

New wood burning stoves billed as more environmentally friendly still emit 750 times more tiny particle pollution than a modern HGV truck, a report has shown.

Only stoves that meet the ecodesign standard can be legally sold from the start of 2022 in the UK and EU, but experts said the regulation was shockingly weak.

The report used data on the emissions produced by stoves in perfect laboratory conditions and the pollution could be even higher in everyday use, the researchers said, with older stoves being much worse.

Tiny particle pollution – called PM2.5 – is especially harmful to health as it can pass through the lungs into the bloodstream and then be carried around the body and lodge in organs. At least 40 ,000 early deaths a year are attributed to wood burning in Europe.

Wood burners also triple the level of harmful pollution inside homes and should be sold with a health warning, said the scientist behind a study published in December. The researchers advised that the stoves should not be used around elderly people or children.

The government may have banned the burning of wet wood but has no plans to ban the sale of woodburners, despite the fact that the 8pc of homes that use them are almost entirely in cities and can use power or gas for heating. And are almost entirely fairly wealthy households.

(Those of you who live a "very rural" location, to use a common Mumsnet phrase and are entirely off grid may justifiably need one. But the question was cities and towns).

It worries me so few people know how dangerous PM2.5 emissions are, particularly for pregnant women and children.

YANBU: correct, woodburners should be banned in homes in cities and towns asap

YABU: no, they look pretty and who cares about science and health

OP posts:
lescompagnonsdeloue · 09/10/2021 17:21

@tiredandmardy

Our open fire is so cosy now the nights are drawing in…I love it and so does the rest of the family.

As others on MN have told me in my time -“you do you and I’ll do me” Wink

And many of us will also judge you harshly. But you do you. Hmm
MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 17:19

@XingMing
I'd recommend finding a local qualified person for personal advice - anyone has completed the Heatgeek training is worth trying so perhaps look here for someone to survey your home

www.heatgeek.com/find-a-heat-geek/

Firstly the advice is going to be to do as much as you can to address the draughty house. A house can be improved, even old period homes. They may not be perfect but they can be much better. Windows, doors, loft insulation, floor insulation, insulated internal plaster board, external render, cavity wall insulation etc may be options depending on your home.

In terms of heating - ground or air source heat pumps are probably the most environmentally sound source. The right system designed for your specific needs can be used even at very low temperatures (they are common in Scandinavia and it gets cold there). Bad ones poorly designed for your situation will be bad
They will work best if your house can be improved but they can work in less than perfectly insulated homes - they just need to be bigger.
If you have the land, ground source heat pumps are the best option in terms of efficiency. So if you are rural with a sizeable garden, that's what I would be most tempted to do.

If you live somewhere rural that really does have regular, long lasting power cuts after storms, then perhaps a biofuel stove for backup heating/cooking/boiling water would be an idea but would be best restricted only to emergencies.

Perhaps also install a battery and charge it during cheap over night rates to cover lighting etc if power cuts are very common.

The government will soon announce its new subsidy system for air and ground source heat pumps plus likely also a new range of schemes to help finance home insulation improvements because it knows we have to reduce the carbon footprint and local air pollution caused by domestic heating in order to meet our climate change goals AND reduce the immediate damage done by local and indoor air pollution. So please don't assume that nothing is affordable.

(Carbon and particulates are two separate issues, one is global, one is very local)

OP posts:
lescompagnonsdeloue · 09/10/2021 17:16

@Lockheart

People on favour of having woodburners - does it not concern you re your children's or fetus' health?

Given how standard open fires were 30 or 40 odd years ago, I think we can safely say they're not that damaging at a population level. Certainly the 30- and 40-somethings I know are not crippled with asthma etc compared to their younger peers. My brother and I were born and raised in a house with an open fire and neither of us have any health issues or allergies.

Don't be ridiculous, 40 years ago virtually nobody had open fires anymore. Prior to that, things were so bad they brought in the clean air act.
Loveshelly · 09/10/2021 17:07

Actually that defra study mentioned that break pads are also a considerable problem.

The article is framed that the only thing that kills are PM
But actually it’s much much more complex than that.

They’ll be banning pets next

FangsForTheMemory · 09/10/2021 17:05

when I was househunting, three things made me reject properties without a second thought:

  • if they were listed
  • if they were thatched
  • if they had woodburners.

I cannot understand why people install the things, other than because they think they have snob value.

CovidCorvid · 09/10/2021 17:04

Yes, the house needs to be well insulated so you would also need to invest in that too

But I can’t make a cavity wall…..there’s no gap. I can’t demolish my house and build another one. 🤷‍♀️ I have double glazing and plenty of loft insulation but from what i read that isn’t enough. You need a decent cavity wall so if you have solid walls it won’t be effective.

XingMing · 09/10/2021 17:02

I'd like suggestions for alternative heating methods for people without mains gas supply, or space for an oil tank, living in an old and draughty house. The venerable night store heaters were about as much use as a chocolate teapot by late afternoon. And power outages are not uncommon after winter storms.

KeflavikAirport · 09/10/2021 16:49

For balance (not the Daily Mail): www.woodheatassociation.org.uk/is-biomass-heating-causing-urban-air-pollution/

AlphabetAerobics · 09/10/2021 16:38

@julieca Picture my bitter disappointment upon learning that despite 30 years on the tabs, my CO levels remain below those of a non-smoker living in London.

All that money spent and I’ve not even been doing it right!

Some of you lot need to learn that shades of grey ain’t just a mucky book.

As for the faux “power cuts? In the uk? I’ve never heard of such a thing” innocence. Slip some extra virgin olive oil up there and your head will slip straight out.

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 16:37

@BungleandGeorge

Because while gas is still the single largest source, the rising share of Renewables (and nuclear if Hinkley ever gets finished) means that the average carbon intensity of using electricity to heat your home or cook on is less than using gas. And the amount of new offshore wind farms that are being built will only reduce this carbon intensity further.
So that is carbon for global warming and we should transfer more tax burden on to it away from relatively clean electricity

If we switch to looking at particulates for local air pollution, gas is still damaging (less than burning wood and coal though)

Research suggests gas cooking produces about twice as much PM2.5 as electric

www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2020/5/7/21247602/gas-stove-cooking-indoor-air-pollution-health-risks

So again, this creates negative health outcomes and we should transfer tax burden away from elec and towards gas.

Gradually, starting now and over the next ten years incrementally

OP posts:
Yerroblemom1923 · 09/10/2021 16:35

Gas and leccy prices going up, surely I'm allowed to heat my home with wood?! We are rural and the houses are v old so have existing fire places etc and fake fires look tacky as hell

MapleMay11 · 09/10/2021 16:31

@CovidCorvid

Good quality heat pumps work perfectly. I've lived in two houses with them, including the one I'm currently in. They're not cheap to purchase but 'unknown unreliability' is ridiculous.

I might be wrong but I read they only work perfectly if you live in a well insulated house? So possibly not in my 150yo house with no cavity wall?

Yes, the house needs to be well insulated so you would also need to invest in that too.
OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 09/10/2021 16:28

[quote ejhhhhh]@BungleandGeorge electricity is vastly less polluting than burning wood because we're talking about particulate pollution not CO2 emissions. And burning wood still produces CO2 emissions. Generating electricity produces very little particulate pollution because we no longer have a working power station burning coal, and even if we did, they're not in urban areas where it's that much of an issue (although I'm sure if you lived next door to one it would be a concern). Most electricity comes from burning gas, which does not produce particulate pollution.[/quote]
The comment was in reply to OP saying electricity should be taxed less than ‘consumption of damaging fuels like gas, oil, wood.’ Just pointing out that the majority of our electricity comes from burning those, especially gas. I’m not sure why you’d tax someone more for using gas directly for their heating than someone using electricity which has been made from burning it (and high is a less efficient process)?

MasterGland · 09/10/2021 16:25

I am becoming very suspicious about the motives of whoever at the Guardian is pushing this narrative about Woodburners. The piece they ran in December was deliberately misleading. I think someone has an axe to grind (or investments in gas).
Particulates are produced from any form of combustion. The greatest concentration in the home are usually found in kitchens. Particularly around toasters and when frying on the hob.
Cars also produce particulates, not just carbon dioxide. As do gas boilers etc.
Every time you press the break on you car, small particles of break pad dust are generated. Particulates are everywhere.
I wonder why the Guardian are so obsessed with Woodburners Hmm

SciFiScream · 09/10/2021 16:17

@HermioneAndRoger

I have wanted a woodburner for years but we live in suburbs and it wouldn't be justifiable. Since various MN threads on the topic I now covet a mini Everhot for my sitting room on the day when we take out the awful gas fire.
No I covet a mini everhot! I'd also love a bioethanol indoor fire thingy. Anyone know about the particulate production of that?

I've never lived with an indoor fire of any sort. I'd love a wood burner but have decided against it.

Do you think that if (by some magic) all the other pollution went away wood burners abs such like would be useable, perhaps in some sort of rationed form?

DdraigGoch · 09/10/2021 16:07

@Loveshelly

608 children died in car accidents and 91,000 were injured. Should we ban cars. Won’t someone think of the children!
I wish someone would do something about cars. Awful things, they kill many both directly and indirectly. Also very antisocial, with everyone tucked into their air-conditioned little box.
FatBettyintheCoop · 09/10/2021 15:43

I love lighting our wood burner in winter.

We get free wood from a farmer friend in exchange for other services and we’re burning wood that’s been allowed to dry out for at least 3 years. We live about 6 miles from the nearest town and we’re on the coast.

DH has emphysema but he’s not noticeably affected by the stove during the winter months, so I’m not planning to get rid of it anytime soon.

MojoMoon · 09/10/2021 15:36

On biofuels: there is less research. It definitely is better for particulates than wood but there are some concerns raised over other air pollutants and it also assumes using a high quality fuel

Ethanol fireplaces: The underestimated risk
www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/09/140903091728.htm

There has been a bit more done on biofuels in car engines and the impact on air quality

Biodiesel fuel use is estimated to reduce
several precursors to PM (e.g., PM, SO2, and VOC) and increase others (NOx). Thus, the net
affect of biodiesel fuel use on ambient PM levels is unclear based on analyzing changes in
emissions alone, so it as assessed using air quality modeling.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3622266/

OP posts:
TDogsInHats · 09/10/2021 15:35

@DGRossetti

New wood burning stoves billed as more environmentally friendly still emit 750 times more tiny particle pollution than a modern HGV truck, a report has shown.

Well, yes. But since the shortage of HGVs, it must be OK, surely ?

(I may not be taking this as seriously as some).

Grin oh dear. I think we'll be in for some stern words. You for not taking it seriously enough. And me for showing grinning face at your comment.Confused
elfycat · 09/10/2021 15:33

We had a woodburner fitted when we had an extension some years ago, when they were considered an OK option for heating because you're not adding to greenhouse gases by burning renewable wood supplies.

We deliberately got a DEFRA approved model that is still currently allowed by the regulations. We burn wood that has been seasoned for 2-3 years, and then dried in a covered shelter for the whole summer before the burn year (DH bought a whole felled tree on ebay 3 years ago - shifting it was fun). The pieces are so incredibly light I guarantee there's nothing green-wood about them.

It's not on often. The room has underfloor heating and great insulation but it can take a while to respond to a change in temperature as it needs to get through inches of screed but stays stable once up to temp If the evening is cold we light the burner and burn a few pieces of wood (the burner has stone sides/top which also act like storage heaters so once warm we let the fire go out). But if it's bitter and we've got on jumpers and a blanket over our legs and we're still cold then I will light it and I'm not apologising for it.

That's how I justify it. Thanks for asking.

JudgeJ · 09/10/2021 15:29

@TheyWentToSeaInASieve

I'd look at the authors of the report and the amount of wood they burnt to get their results. They are assessing 140kg of wood used as the main source of heating (so assume this is for the entire cold season).

They've massaged the data according to their message. Fake news, anyone?

When I see anything like this piece in the Gruniard of the type 'I have an agenda and I'll massage the figures to prove it' I am always reminded of Darryl Huff's How To Lie WIth Statistics. Tell me what you want to 'prove' and I'll find the figures to 'prove it'.
julieca · 09/10/2021 15:28

@cantkeepawayforever its worse

cantkeepawayforever · 09/10/2021 15:28

It's also worth saying that I never refuel - I light the fire when I come in, it burns itself out and I clean it out the following day. So it is essentially run as a closed fire throughout.

Swipe left for the next trending thread