Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think mumsnet has become a lot less popular?

166 replies

Duckypoohs · 09/10/2021 03:44

Is it just me who thinks the volume of threads and replies has lessened? It used to be so busy and good, now you can reread a thread and hardly any more replies have been posted.

I'm sad about this, the Internet is becoming more and more condensed. It also seems like the demographic has shrank. Bah, sad times.

OP posts:
NoWordForFluffy · 09/10/2021 07:44

@singlemama91

Is it possible to actually make friends on mumsnet?
Oh yes, I've got a group of friends from a long-running thread on here. You're more likely to get this on the boards for certain things (i.e. antenatal groups) than AIBU / Chat though, where you post over a long time together and build relationships that way. My Facebook had loads of MNers on it.
Scrollonthroughtherain · 09/10/2021 07:43

It's an incredibly unfriendly place these days. Much like most of the internet, it's very difficult to have a discussion because people are SO black or white. You're not allowed to take the middle ground, you have to be either for or against. People will take a little bit of what you say and then run with it out of context to bang whatever drum they're banging. What's the point? Most of the time it makes more sense to talk to a brick wall.

I think the reputation Mumsnet has got for being intolerant is probably deserved.

2Two · 09/10/2021 07:39

You never seem to hear anything about Nethuns these days, do they still exist?

MichelleScarn · 09/10/2021 07:39

@Dragonpox

I think a lot of people switched off when the covid hysteria hit hard. Real life was nothing like as hostile as Mumsnet. It felt bizarrely unsupportive around homeschooling for example - if you complained that you were suffering because overnight you'd become a teacher, a 7yo's best friend, a mother, full time employee, and your house was looking like a squat you were swiftly shut down as a selfish cow killing grandmothers left right and centre.
Agree dragon they'd be posts such as 'DS 4 has fallen and broken his arm, paramedics say compound fracture, handhold while they are in surgery' and there would be posters berating op for calling an ambulance and taking up a bed as they're needed for covid, how selfish!
singlemama91 · 09/10/2021 07:39

Is it possible to actually make friends on mumsnet?

AuntieStella · 09/10/2021 07:38

Oh, and something really need to be done about the ageism

AuntieStella · 09/10/2021 07:37

It's definitely slowed down, in the sense if fewer posts.

It's losing its identity - the distinctive lingo is vanishing, the 'outdated' platform has been tweaked for the sake of being the same across all deceived, which means the things you could see on Active on desktop, like who had posted last on a thread and when, have been removed, taking away a bit of that sense of community, because there's no easy way now to see who's about. And I don't get the idea that because you can't do it on a mobile, it should be gone everywhere.

And of course the amount of trolling is ridiculous, and deleted threads are these days expunged completely sometines - you can't see what happened from your TIO as sometimes they've gone from there too.

MNHQers no longer seem to join in threads from time to time (would we still know who had a crush on which film star?) and seem to exist only to tell us off - sometimes for long-term discussed and approved things for which policy has changed (fair enough) but if no-one tells us we don't know you don't like it any more. That might seem like a petty thing, but it shows a difference in MNHQ towards its content creators, and people don't like being taken for granted and being on the receiving end of uncommunucated changes.

Also, because the levels of trolling us so high, there is a (I think) an expectation that threads are not true. MN was never a safe space (no open Internet site is) but it used to be a place that it was worth taking your problems to. It's nit that any more either.

I'm still here because, despite all that, I still like the place better than many others. But it's a shadow of its former self

AutistAwayWithUrConditionalLuv · 09/10/2021 07:34

I think MN is great for new people and those who need support. I think where it gets "same old" is if you look to it for entertainment.

I also like the interface.

Coffeeonmytoffee · 09/10/2021 07:34

The potential to end up as a story in the daily poxy mail makes me think very carefully about what I post and reply.
That has changed mumsnet for me.

NoWordForFluffy · 09/10/2021 07:32

I agree, Royston. There used to be loads of genuinely funny threads (and people didn't have to label them 'lighthearted' to convey that humour was intended). Now, threads which make me laugh are few and far between.

Why2why · 09/10/2021 07:30

It is not very diverse and can come across as uncaring of ethnic minority women. It only caters for a certain demographic of women.

user6598 · 09/10/2021 07:29

I have only ever started threads in places like Telly Addicts, it's not a place I would start a thread for advice

singlemama91 · 09/10/2021 07:27

Ive only just joined Mumsnet but am becoming quite addicted to it and find it really supportive. I hope that it doesnt shut down or anything

Roystonv · 09/10/2021 07:25

Just doesn't seem as fun to me, of course there will always be the need for the serious topics but has it got a bit worthy everywhere.

user6598 · 09/10/2021 07:24

Covid and Brexit made it much worse, posters try to shoehorn these subjects into a lot of threads making them not very pleasant places to post

HugeAckmansWife · 09/10/2021 07:20

I've been on here over a decade and have used it for advice on so many aspects of child rearing.. Outside of AIBU and Relationships is still quite a nice place. As a single parent I really use it as my interaction with grown ups on the dad I'm not at work. I do dislike the 'oh this again' response to thread topics. OK, I worked out the prevalent MN stance on P&C parking a decade ago, but someone who's just a had a baby won't have and wants to have their say, not just read an old thread. Doesn't matter that the points made are the same.

Hottubtimemachine · 09/10/2021 07:19

The sun made an article out of one of my posts. It was horrible, it ran for days with hundreds of comments on their Facebook page that were judge and nasty. I rarely post now and would never start a thread.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 09/10/2021 07:07

I think it has gone back to how it was when it first started. There was a while when it seemed hostile as hot very cliquey - you got shot down for asking a breastfeeding question as it “had been done before”….not for me I needed help.

Babdoc · 09/10/2021 06:53

Mothers have the “same old” problems they always had, and they still need advice and help. It would be nice if they no longer needed support to leave abusive partners, deal with postnatal depression, cope with breast feeding, get legal advice for workplace bullying, etc etc, but they do - and MN is the place to find it. It’s also one of the few internet fora that have resolutely provided a platform for gender critical feminists to defend women’s and children’s rights to single sex spaces. Long may it continue.

dottiedodah · 09/10/2021 06:51

Name bunny totally agree.struggle with technology .please keep site simple .we are not all whizzes online you know!

Dragonpox · 09/10/2021 06:47

I think a lot of people switched off when the covid hysteria hit hard. Real life was nothing like as hostile as Mumsnet. It felt bizarrely unsupportive around homeschooling for example - if you complained that you were suffering because overnight you'd become a teacher, a 7yo's best friend, a mother, full time employee, and your house was looking like a squat you were swiftly shut down as a selfish cow killing grandmothers left right and centre.

Nightbringer · 09/10/2021 06:42

Posted too soon.

As MN are deleting at ops request, you generally find the same stuff being posted and posted again.

I quite like style and beauty and the property DIY sections. I find stuff.

Oh and the 'we hate wfh' with the same posters saying the same stuff is getting worse.

Best was the poster who does wfh, who also thinks it's morally wrong for people to wfh cause 'won't you think of the coffee shops in Central London!'

Nightbringer · 09/10/2021 06:39

I do think it doesn't seem as busy.

To be fair I took a step back for about a year. The covid threads were just increasingly ridiculous.

Some of MNs new ways of working make the site really boring. There appears to be a handful of posters who post, have it deleted then post again, have it deleted and post the same again. Sometimes changing small details to make people agree with them. Since MN just let people delete threads because 'op requested deletion'

AutistAwayWithUrConditionalLuv · 09/10/2021 06:29

I think it's because threads are roughly same old same old. There's nothing new and topics are rehashed with different details and a bit of a twist here and there. That's why you get a lot of people buzzing on troll threads because trolls know how to bring something new that will get more people interested.

Besides troll threads, it's still the sensationalist threads that get the most traffic. Other times, it's just business as usual, drudgery and same old same old.

Evasmithsghost · 09/10/2021 06:27

I think a lot of it is related to covid, but perhaps like the demise of the high street, covid accelerated what would have happened anyway.