Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think mumsnet has become a lot less popular?

166 replies

Duckypoohs · 09/10/2021 03:44

Is it just me who thinks the volume of threads and replies has lessened? It used to be so busy and good, now you can reread a thread and hardly any more replies have been posted.

I'm sad about this, the Internet is becoming more and more condensed. It also seems like the demographic has shrank. Bah, sad times.

OP posts:
grownup2 · 09/10/2021 18:04

@YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators

I don't recognise this impression at all. As a PP said, perhaps it is slow if you are looking for entertainment? I still find MN a great place for seeking advice and reflecting on issues brought to the forum's attention by other posters, on any number of fascinating topics. The wealth of information, advice and anecdotal evidence is phenomenal; you don't even need to start your own thread about most things, you can literally search any obscure, niche predicament, and learn that others have trodden that path before you, which is, in itself, reassuring. I find MN as a community a place of generosity and mutual respect, and failing that, at least good humour. The kindness of strangers who take the time to support, encourage and commisserate with others in need is heart-warming. The only place where people tend to come unstuck is climate related discussions, where climate sceptics tend to behave as they do in all other corners of the internet.
Me too actually. MN is my first port of call for good advice (or at least a bunch of thoughtful perspectives).
5catsonthedesk · 09/10/2021 17:46

I think there’s a small group of posters who are very, very anti-SAHMs. Very bitter people. They blatantly arrive on every thread with their thinly-veiled agenda. They are belligerent and spiteful, but claim to be ‘concerned.’ They make MN - which is after all a parenting site for mums - into a joke.

Tal45 · 09/10/2021 17:14

I came over from netmums which has slowly gone more and more downhill since it was taken over in 2011 by a French group. NM used to be much easier to navigate than MN. The thing I dislike most about this site though is the number of times I write a long reply to a post just to find the thread has been taken down. It's so annoying. I don't even care if the threads are fake, as long as they're not scamming people does it matter? It's still interesting to read other people's advice on different situations or what they'd do if they were in that situation.

sospspsp · 09/10/2021 17:07

@Coffeeonmytoffee

The potential to end up as a story in the daily poxy mail makes me think very carefully about what I post and reply. That has changed mumsnet for me.
Yes this has scared a lot of people off. I'm not sure what can be done about it, and it must drive traffic to MN.

The genuinely funny threads there used to be so many off have definitely disappeared, maybe to Twitter?

I love MN though, the Feminist and the Relationship boards make fascinating reading and have changed me as a person through being able to quietly educate myself on lots of issues that impact my life.

I would say I owe my happiness to MN as I learnt to leave a really unhappy relationship and not fear the future and to have pride and confidence in myself.

Moonface123 · 09/10/2021 16:58

Utter

Moonface123 · 09/10/2021 16:58

Fear, and victim mentality dominates MN.
l think it's a shame that a forum created for women and mainly used by women is so full of uttat nonsense.
A lot of the threads here are fake, surely ?

Scardanelli · 09/10/2021 16:29

I had a long break during Covid because I found myself getting so riled by the Covid fanatics and their self-imposed status as rule-monitors.

I had another long break about 10 years ago because it was just pissing me off and so many people couldn't spell.

I use it intermittently now for a bit of a chat when illness keeps me at home.

I would hate it if it went all high-tech. I'm a 50 yr old who has been here since the start, and I don't use any other social media. I don't even have a phone! So I just wouldn't bother with it any more if it changed in that way.

Hont1986 · 09/10/2021 16:28

Back in the 'old days' using a forum was more of a niche interest. Now everyone and their nan has got an iPad and can post all day. There's less cliques but it's all more anonymous and geared towards one-off interesting interactions rather than thread-long back and forths.

And to anyone not using the site, the reputation is terrible. I actually wouldn't want people to know I post here.

Vulpius · 09/10/2021 16:25

@MyCatDribbles

Re Queen Bees: It was like being the uncool girl in the school playground when everyone else is in on a joke, and you're not. And when you try to join in, they take the piss out of you as a gang.

KateF · 09/10/2021 16:20

I came to MN in 2000 looking for recommendations for double buggies. Those children are now 21 and 20 and MN has seen me through toddlers and teenagers (on the last one now, thank goodness!), divorce from an abuser, SN parenting, lone parenting and so much more. I agree some people are aggressive and unwilling to debate reasonably. It's also got many more users which has good and bad points.

These days I use it to keep up with the views of younger parents as I work in childcare. I love the book and gardening topics and the low carb bootcamp people have been amazing. I think there's something for everyone but you need to pick and choose and remember it's not real life. That said I feel I've learned a lot about how others live which is good as my area isn't very diverse.

CarlaH · 09/10/2021 16:16

[quote AdaColeman]@CarlaH

TIO ~ Threads I’m On…. A quick way to navigate the site.[/quote]
Thanks.

RedRiverShore · 09/10/2021 14:15

Maybe people have just thought instead of speaking to randoms on the internet, I'll read a book or watch a film, places like MN will maybe die a natural death for chat and become more of an information type place like MSE

notimagain · 09/10/2021 12:55

Be interesting to see actual stats but FWIW there’s much the same debate (traffic decreasing) on at least a couple of other forums I lurk on.

General feeling there is many people had moved to specialist groups facilitated by faceache (though after last weeks events…..???), plus in the last year or two what appears to be an increase in plain nastiness and intolerance which some people seem to manage shoehorn into any thread on any topic at the first opportunity.

Given the uncertainty many people have suffered, and in some cases continue to suffer, since early last year the. maybe it is the way some people respond to stress?

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 09/10/2021 12:48

NicOgJul, I hear you. Most of society does not see its inherent racism, and posters here are no exception, mainly by virtue of operating from a place of privilege. I was going to say it is a terrible format for approaching discussion about racism, but I half take that back, as I feel like I've learnt a lot from the sharing of women of colour on MN. But it's also an easy place to indulge in feeling offended or defensive and flounce off without really reflecting more deeply when one's prejudice is challenged. It is a shame, because it could also be a really safe place to acknowledge and confront our unconscious bias; it is an anonymous forum after all.

tiredanddangerous · 09/10/2021 12:38

Too many trolls these days I think. You can pretty much guarantee that anything that runs past one thread in length is complete bullshit.

Plus there's a collective of posters who seem to exist to belittle and just be generally nasty to the OP.

It ain't like it used to be.

Sallycinnamum · 09/10/2021 12:38

I still love MN and spend too much time on here but the covid-19 threads really put me off coming on here for a while.

Clearly I'm a masochist as I do venture over to the dark side ie the covid board now and again and it does seem to have calmed down a bit but the doom mongering and catastrophising really were a sight to behold.

thatsnotmyzoo · 09/10/2021 12:36

It’s aggressive and contrary; people post reasonable questions or describe reasonable situations and posters pile on to tell them they are wrong. Covid sent this into the stratosphere. I wouldn’t start a thread and even though I do visit I find it a very negative place.

I also wouldn’t want anyone to know I post on here really. A bit embarrassing.

Viviennemary · 09/10/2021 12:24

On a thread with Queen Bees you certainly couldn't speak unless spoken to. Or if you were lucky and not ignored you'd be told MN wasnt the place for you if you disagreed.

BrilloPaddy · 09/10/2021 12:24

It's a good site, and you need to take it at face value. The doghouse has been invaluable for me, and the health boards at times.

I did take a very long break though in the height of the pandemic - there is a very high proportion of users with health anxiety, who all still seem determined that life should be put on hold still to appease them.

daisychain01 · 09/10/2021 12:20

Like most stuff in life, I tend to take away the good bits on here (support, information, general chat) and discard the rest (Covid and Brexit fury, feminism board - too opinionated to get snarled up in). I glance at some threads for some take-it-or-leave it info and then form my own opinion privately, who cares what I think anyway, that's why I don't bother with Twitter!

daisychain01 · 09/10/2021 12:14

@MyCatDribbles

What was it like with Queen Bees?

It was the anointed few, MN Royalty who, when they grace a thread with their presence, would have everyone 'billing-and-cooing' at their every word. Or if they started a thread it was full of cliquey obtuse in-jokes that some people knew about (or pretended to know), designed to exclude. I, as an uncool, occasional poster, made the mistake from time to time, trying to find out what all the 'fun' was, maybe post a comment to try and connect, but there was an obvious attempt to ignore anyone getting in on the in-jokes. A bit childish so I quickly realised it was best to ignore and not bother getting involved. Why waste energy (a bit like RL Smile )

The ringleaders must have eventually got bored, or finally grew up, or drifted off elsewhere.

Ijustknowitstimetogo · 09/10/2021 11:32

There appears to be a handful of posters who post, have it deleted then post again, have it deleted and post the same again. Sometimes changing small details to make people agree with them.

Why would someone want to keep posting the same thing over and over again tbough? What are they getting out of it?

Energy4You · 09/10/2021 11:28

I actually agree about it being racist. Often from a I haven’t a clue and refuse to put myself in question position too.

The views are extremely polarised and often, once a few posters have gone down a certain route, everyone piles in wo thinking for themselves (or at least it feels like it).

I think that is becoming more and more pronounced, which is a réflexion of what happens on other platforms. Plus there wa also being proud of not being like netmum (does it still exist?)and ‘telling it like it is’ which has one overboard imo.

However, over the years, I’ve learnt a lot from MN. Not from asking for help as such. I’ve done it a few times and it rarely has been as helpful as it could have been, esp in the last few years. But I’ve learnt from people expressing different pov, pointing behaviours (abusive, not abusive etc…) etc…. There isn’t a lot of places where you can have discussion on how to leave a partner/get support for an SEN child etc… (The SN board is amazing for example)

Mercurial123 · 09/10/2021 11:13

I've posted for years and it's got increasingly right wing and intolerant. The middle class posts are a joke.

NicOgJul · 09/10/2021 11:08

@Why2why

It is not very diverse and can come across as uncaring of ethnic minority women. It only caters for a certain demographic of women.
Mumsnet is implacably and irredeemably racist to the point that I feel I could never post anything from my experience that might in any way make a white person feel at all challenged without being met by hostile rage. A case study in white fragility.