Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think mumsnet has become a lot less popular?

166 replies

Duckypoohs · 09/10/2021 03:44

Is it just me who thinks the volume of threads and replies has lessened? It used to be so busy and good, now you can reread a thread and hardly any more replies have been posted.

I'm sad about this, the Internet is becoming more and more condensed. It also seems like the demographic has shrank. Bah, sad times.

OP posts:
bestsoupintown · 10/10/2021 10:17

@daisychain01

It doesn't help having an antiquated user interface that hasn't moved with the times and expectations of a feature-rich modern forum. It's increasingly clunky. I know they're planning to sort that out, hopefully sooner rather than later.

On the plus side it is a lot less cliquey than it used to be, there aren't the queen bees, they've all buzzed off.

Yes, it's absolutely terrible. I was on forums 10 years ago with better platforms.

I also think it's got much much nastier and the endless trans threads have got extremely tedious.

MarshaBradyo · 10/10/2021 10:07

I like the simplicity and don’t want that to change

But the level of aggression is rising imo if you post against the tide. Means people are less likely to bother.

GetDrunkWithMe · 10/10/2021 10:05

Daily Fail ruined it. Taking threads off here for excusing their bullshit journalism skills.

bumblingbovine49 · 10/10/2021 10:03

@Namebunny

I really like the simplicity of the way it’s laid out and works. Everything else seems to get meow whizz bang and you have to learn more and more stuff. Exhausting! I like that this at least is easy and reassuring and that it’s like an old friend. Please don’t change!
This
TheBullfinch · 10/10/2021 09:52

@puddlebubble

about 2/3 weeks ago there was a poster who in their thread title used the word 'palava'. The word isn't used that much on here and was spelt wrong ... i.e. palaver. 2 hours later there was a second totally unrelated thread using the same word with the same misspelling. People are hired to put threads on here. Very obvious when particular posters have the same posting style and when OP's don't answer questions.
Yes, Ive noticed this too.

Ive been here for over a decade and noticed that now, the interaction just doesnt seem genuine. So many threads are started along the lines of ... "Oh, problem, problem, hope it's ok." "Tell me about your experiences with this problem..." and they never engage with the thread again or if they do, its a one-off, limited 'no response' response. My suspicious mind makes me think its for data gathering or advert promotion. It's annoying.

Aside from the above, its become dominated by Brexit talk, Covid talk, Lefty nonsense and all the trans stuff and all the highly educated, funny, witty people seem to have gone elsewhere. I believe a lot went to the nappy valley forum a few years ago but thats dead too now. I suspect its also the threat of The Daily Mail picking up threads.

Youglue · 10/10/2021 09:37

Once you’ve disagreed with posters on the feminism board, particularly if you’ve been supportive of transgender people you get tracked all over the site, ostracised and completely ignored.

SomethingOnce · 10/10/2021 09:32

Mumsnet has given me a terrible impression of British women and in particular white women.

Please do elaborate.

TwinsandTrifle · 10/10/2021 09:21

I use MN a lot to ask about recommendations. It's really useful for that.

It used to be a lot more edgy and honest. I think it's become a bit sad and undermines the whole point of some threads, by the over policing and the type of posters who have appeared in volume recently.

Most AIBU tend to be:

OP: "Hi I'm being completely unreasonable, but I'm not looking for opinions or advice, just validation for my unreasonable actions.

Flurry of MN: "Er, OP.... Yabu"

OP: "well you're all nasty and like to kick people who are down (oh I'm such a victim)"

MN: "OP, you have become aggressive with anyone who doesn't agree with you. No one has been nasty.

Torrent of new style posters then suddenly appear: "Wow. Some real nastiness on this thread. OP ignore all this, you're brilliant" (having clearly not rtft and glossing over that it's the OP who's attacked people)

MN: "have you rtft??"

New posters and OP (thrilled with the validation that they provide): "yes, it's these 95% of posters all saying the same thing who are clearly bitter and clueless. We're brilliant, however. And will declare that our 5% is "most people" on this thread, so therefore we're right too.

MN: "no, sorry, that's not on. Firstly, yabu. Also, you are rude, defensive, attacking PP, intolerant of opinions, 95% of the thread tells you this" (and essentially gets called out)

OP: (can not wriggle out of being called out. major tantrum. major, major tantrum at not getting the thread and validation she wanted)

MNHQ: "hi everyone, this thread has been deleted at OPs request, due to her concerns she may be identified.

Yeahhhhh.

This is quite common now. Oh and the people who deliberately find one word in a post and troll relentlessly. For example, an OP might be wondering whether to buy a male or female puppy. And they try and derail a whole thread with their "did you mean to say gender OP, are you trying to offend OP, do you need a bit of educating OP?". Ugh. Have a day off.

vivainsomnia · 10/10/2021 09:05

Mumsnet has given me a terrible impression of British women and in particular white women
Please do not think MN represent women in the UK. It really doesn't. Oy a small sub group that happens to be very vocal.

My RL is nothing at all what it appears as on MN.

Thekolschisonme · 10/10/2021 08:55

The thread about Angela Rayner was awful. I was shocked at some of the appalling comments about her accent, dress sense and parenting skills. Totally superfluous and misogynistic.
I've been here since 2005. In the early days I would say it was politically central but debate was measured and thoughtful. Now I take many of the comments with a pinch of salt. A thread about Johnson or the government usually attracts a pile on of supporters and you start wondering whether you actually live in the same country. Putting my tin foil hat on I think that the site is definitely targeted by political parties of all hues who want to nudge public opinion. Happened during lockdown and the last GE.

lnsufficientFuns · 10/10/2021 08:45

@Needspace21

I think it's way more policed. People get cancelled if they say anything remotely controversial.
Agree

MN can’t even advocate for women so what’s the point? I blame the heavy reliance on advertising and pissing off menz

beigebrownblue · 10/10/2021 08:39

Yes I like the simplicity of it too. And you do get replies fairly quickly.
People can be brutal and horrible on here quite frankly,
but if you have a genuine emergency or really need some help as a mum, in my experience mumsnetters rally. So thanks everyone.

I'm aware that I am not based in London. So it is also interesting to hear from those who are. I am South West.

Why2why · 10/10/2021 08:04

Mumsnet has given me a terrible impression of British women and in particular white women.

Geamhradh · 10/10/2021 07:31

@RampantIvy- the same posters bleating on about not wanting to follow Covid regulations to save someone who had reached their life expectancy figure anyway. They don't just hate women who wear Seasalt. They hate women. Older ones. And older men of course. Who might say "hello" (as neighbours) if they meet them coming out of their house.
The ageism on MN is some of the most disgusting I've seen.

Geamhradh · 10/10/2021 07:28

@WhatAShilohPitt

I personally am sick of shitrags like the sun and the Mail posting women’s problems in their papers like sensational news, making it very difficult for those people with nobody IRL to turn to post on here for advice. It’s much more likely they’ll be recognised. I have various problems that I now won’t post on here. Gutter journalism.
In fairness almost every story lifted by the press from here has "troll" written all over it.
RampantIvy · 10/10/2021 00:19

@DarlingFell

For a site that is supposedly in support of women, it’s frighteningly full of hatred, bitterness, contempt and mockery of said women Confused
I agree, especially the ageism on the Style and Beauty threads.
WhatAShilohPitt · 09/10/2021 23:48

I personally am sick of shitrags like the sun and the Mail posting women’s problems in their papers like sensational news, making it very difficult for those people with nobody IRL to turn to post on here for advice. It’s much more likely they’ll be recognised. I have various problems that I now won’t post on here. Gutter journalism.

Marguerite2000 · 09/10/2021 21:29

Many forums are declining in popularity. I don't think this one is any different.
I think people just outgrow forums as time goes on. There's only a certain number of things you can talk about.

DarlingFell · 09/10/2021 21:00

For a site that is supposedly in support of women, it’s frighteningly full of hatred, bitterness, contempt and mockery of said women Confused

Nightbringer · 09/10/2021 20:30

@JustAnotherPoster00

Slowly becoming Parler for middle class white women
To be fair, people have been saying that for at least 10 years.

In the last few days I have seen 'mn is full of sahms that think they are morally superior'

And

'Mn is full of high earning women who dislike sahms'

'Mn is like the opression/poor olympics'

'Mners must lie about their income because most seem to be high earners'.

I think certain things stick out to certain people and we can think mn is full of that demographic.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 09/10/2021 18:52

Slowly becoming Parler for middle class white women

amazeandastonish · 09/10/2021 18:51

I was just thinking today, if we had no MN, where else would we go?

I've been here under various names for about 14 years now and at times I do feel a bit irritated seeing the same "my boyfriend is a dick but I am blind to it" posts or the "is this a line" posts

Needspace21 · 09/10/2021 18:19

I think it's way more policed. People get cancelled if they say anything remotely controversial.

LoveFall · 09/10/2021 18:17

I think the more witty and interesting posts seem to be declining.

People talk about racism but other "isms" seem ok. For example, a poster on a recent thread about what you are sick and tired of said "baby boomers." It is also ok to refer to old and fat people in a negative or stereotyping way.

It could be a case of simple ageism and the younger generations feeling they know the answers, which has been ever thus. "Every generation blames the one before." (Mike and the Mechanics)

I am not American but the amount of anti-American comments really surprised me.

But overall I stay because I learn about what matters in the UK and gain understanding of the place where close family live. And DH who was born in London during WWII. The UK is also the place where a good number of my ancestors came from, mostly via the US and then to Canada as United Empire Loyalists.

Nancydrawn · 09/10/2021 18:16

A lot of the wit has gone. The feminist boards have become a self-congratulatory echo chamber. And the only way a lot of people have heard about MN is either from the tabloids stealing stories or from the reputation (earned or unearned, as you see it) as deeply hostile to trans people.

That said, it's a place that can offer stunning support for women who need it, particularly on the relationships page. And there are still posts that make me laugh out loud. Plus property is great.