Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Regretting Children

166 replies

ClementBatley · 08/10/2021 23:58

DP and I have a DD aged 1. DP a great dad, active, hands on, clearly loves her to bits. Does his fair share of childcare and household stuff, and he’s great with her too, DD really loves him. He’s a bit more laid back about some things than I am but broadly speaking we’re both on the same page.

We were recently watching something on TV and someone on the show said that he was 50/50 about whether he wanted to have children. DP commented that the advice he would give anyone in that situation is that if they’re not sure then don’t have them.

Something about the way he said it led me to ask him whether he regretted having DD. I’ve always had a suspicion that he had a child just for me, rather than because he particularly wanted to, so perhaps it was that which prompted my question.

He replied that he didn’t regret her, that she was brilliant and he wouldn’t be without her. However, if he had his time again, knowing what he knows now about the impact children have on your life, he might make a different choice. He also said that he preferred his lifestyle before children (we had a great social life), but accepted that had, in the main, gone and was happy to crack on with family life. He also said he would never, ever, make her feel like she wasn’t wanted.

I feel really upset by what he said. On one hand it seems perfectly reasonable and he was just being honest. On the other he’s saying he’s effectively saying he’s trapped in a lifestyle he doesn’t want.

AIBU? Or is he out of order?

OP posts:
Cherryana · 09/10/2021 07:11

It is holding conflicting and contradictory views that makes us human. Social media and culture tend to channel people to completely one view or another - but your husband sounds intelligent, reflective and commuted to you both.

AnyOldPrion · 09/10/2021 07:10

@Ijustknowitstimetogo

He won’t feel like that for ever though. One day when he’s older his life will partly revolve round her and any grandchildren, but in a different way to how it does now. He’ll be saying it’s one of the most important/ precious things he’s ever done.
I love this post.

I’m at the other end. Two of mine have left home and the other is in the process of leaving. They all seem to be progressing towards fully independent lives and I’m very proud of them. It’s not surprising he feels this way. Mixed feelings about the enormous change a baby brings are normal. I thought I was more prepared than most, as I had a career that was very tying and involved a lot of sleepless nights, but even I felt shocked by the twenty-four seven responsibility. If he’s a good father, which you say he is, make the most of him.

JasonMomoasgirlfriend · 09/10/2021 07:10

I think he's being realistic and that's what I would tell someone as well if they weren't sure.

Etherealhedgehog · 09/10/2021 07:08

He's just honestly articulating how a lot of people feel, and the world would be a happier place if everyone did that without fear of being considered 'out of line'

mistermagpie · 09/10/2021 07:04

I don't regret having my children. I have three aged 6 and under so it can be really really challenging, but I think one way of coping with it is just to sort of lower your expectations about what your life is going to look like. Holidays aren't really fun for me and DH now and we got to places we wouldn't really choose to, meals out with all the kids are so stressful that we don't even really bother with it now, etc etc. But I'm alright with all that, it's just part of life.

It sounds like your husband is the same really, just getting on with it. But I can't imagine saying anything like wondering whether I should have had them... maybe it's just not something I allow myself to think about and he's just being honest though?

I wouldn't get massively hung up on it, he sounds like a good dad and that's what matters. Age 1 is a bit of a shit show to be honest (have one myself) and it's my least favourite age, has been with all my kids, so that will be influencing what he says.

ThirdElephant · 09/10/2021 07:02

@Evasmithsghost

See so I don’t want to sound contentious but then why have two?

I do miss aspects of my old life (like lie ins!) but if I really regretted DS I wouldn’t be thinking of having another child in the future.

Because he loves his DD, even though overall he preferred his life pre-kids, and since he can't return to his pre-kid lifestyle figures he'd like another?

Also, having a second to entertain the first can reduce the time pressures on parents.

Immaculatemisconception · 09/10/2021 07:02

I think what he said was quite fair and understandable. There’s nothing there to be upset about. 💐

JapanJetplane · 09/10/2021 07:00

I think that’s a pretty normal way to feel in year one. I have lots of conflicted feelings about this. I love my son more than anything and would never not have him now. But my life was objectively easier and in lots of ways more enjoyable before I had him. I feel like there are other compensations for that (the overwhelming love, the value of motherhood, the new perspective on purpose etc) that make up for that, but it’s still a fact.

Things are easier now but we had a seriously rocky first few months and there were many times that I felt that if I had my time again without knowing my son I wouldn’t choose children. I don’t feel that way at the moment but I have done, and I may again.

Basically, I think it’s complex. You can love your children beyond measure and be unable to imagine life without them and still yearn for the life you had and miss the child-free alternative you gave up. And I think that’s especially true in the first year when it’s so hard and you’re still adjusting.

mistermagpie · 09/10/2021 06:58

@Cominghome1230

I have two children and I feel like your husband.

As wonderful as they are, I do miss my old life and would have been perfectly happy not to have children.

I also wonder why you had the second one?
Evasmithsghost · 09/10/2021 06:55

See so I don’t want to sound contentious but then why have two?

I do miss aspects of my old life (like lie ins!) but if I really regretted DS I wouldn’t be thinking of having another child in the future.

Cominghome1230 · 09/10/2021 06:48

I have two children and I feel like your husband.

As wonderful as they are, I do miss my old life and would have been perfectly happy not to have children.

Hattie765 · 09/10/2021 06:37

I wouldn't be upset by that, I think a lot of parents feel the same, I know I do in some respects x

ClementBatley · 09/10/2021 06:36

Thanks all. I agree, he’s not out of order and he’s actually just being honest. And there are times when I feel “what have we done” but they soon pass. He was just being honest.

OP posts:
Runnyrose · 09/10/2021 06:35

I have a 1 year old DD just like you. I have a wonderful DH who is an incredible father to our DD, just like yours. And I agree 100% with your DH. I worship my DD but I do very much miss my old life; it was wonderful and even though DD was planned and I knew my life would change, I was in no way prepared for just how hard living that change every single day would actually be when putting it into practice and I do greatly miss the ease of my pre-child days. That doesn't mean I don't love my DD more than anything in the world and doesn't mean I would ever do anything that would have her taken away from me. And I'm also confident that it doesn't make me any less of a mother. Cut your DH some slack. If you can honestly, hand on heart say that you experience no hint of regret or longing for your former life before your DD came along then you are incredibly lucky, so be kind to your DH as he's obviously not quite there yet. As others have said, I'm sure he'll get there, I'm sure I will too. For me personally, I'm already so much better this year being back at work and having that time to be me again and not just Mama when I was last year on maternity leave and I can see how the older DD gets, the more freedom I can regain bit by bit so I'm not worried at all about my feelings. But if you are already in the place where you are completely happy and satisfied then be kind to your DH because he's obviously just not quite there at this time and he's working very hard to still be an amazing Daddy and show up for your DD every day.

Icecreamsoda99 · 09/10/2021 06:31

I think being honest with people about the realities of children is very sensible. I don't regret our child and I'll do it all over again but we're stopping at one because we've found it so hard. Were you more keen on having a baby than him? I was and then I feel guilty which makes me irrationally and unfairly cross when my DH is grumpy and complains because I worry he regrets the decision I pushed for, but that's my issue not his!

Fdksyihfd · 09/10/2021 06:30

He’s not out of order; it’s the way he feels. But it’s also understandable that you’re upset.
I also think he’s right that if you’re not sure then don’t until you’re sure as it’s bloody hard even when you 100% wanted to have DC.
Life is ever changing with DC; even in a year things will feel completely different.

Evasmithsghost · 09/10/2021 06:22

I don’t know to be honest.

It’s very common and I’d go as far as to say encouraged on MN to say you regret having children but while I think it’s definitely normal to grieve aspects of your own life, I’d never make a choice that meant I didn’t have DS. Ever.

I’m not sure honesty is always the best in these cases.

mynameiscalypso · 09/10/2021 06:18

I also think there's a big difference between 'children' as a sort of concept and your feelings towards your own child. I love my DS more than I can say and he's the most amazing person in the world but I can distinguish between my feelings for him and how I feel about motherhood in general (which is not dissimilar to how your DH feels)

ThirdElephant · 09/10/2021 06:07

Don't ask questions you don't want to know the answer to, OP.

YABU

ChrissyPlummer · 09/10/2021 06:00

I said this the other day on a different thread. I’m sure most men and it usually is men are ambivalent about having DC. It’s ALWAYS trotted out that “You had HIS baby” or “What would he do if he were (insert scenario)” as though the woman has done the man a huge favour. When, probably the bloke would rather not have bothered. Obviously NAMALT and all that.

Aquamarine1029 · 09/10/2021 04:05

You've never had mixed emotions about anything in your life? He loves your child and he did not say he's trapped. He was just reflecting on things and being honest. You're being very unreasonable and very unfair.

seaandsandcastles · 09/10/2021 04:02

YABU. He’s not out of order. You’re being oversensitive and putting words in his mouth.

Ireolu · 09/10/2021 03:48

At least he is being honest. A lot of what he said will ring true with many people too.

Hankunamatata · 09/10/2021 00:56

He sounds like a very practical person who gave you a logical reply. Ad he told you he loves her bit does mourn his pre child life. I also found hat my dh found the first couple of years as my focus shifted entirely to the baby and we had zero social.life

BrendaBubbles · 09/10/2021 00:56

Well I was reading your post and thought what a kind and considerate answer he had given and that he was a keeper, but was then shocked when you said you were offended by it!