Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Regretting Children

166 replies

ClementBatley · 08/10/2021 23:58

DP and I have a DD aged 1. DP a great dad, active, hands on, clearly loves her to bits. Does his fair share of childcare and household stuff, and he’s great with her too, DD really loves him. He’s a bit more laid back about some things than I am but broadly speaking we’re both on the same page.

We were recently watching something on TV and someone on the show said that he was 50/50 about whether he wanted to have children. DP commented that the advice he would give anyone in that situation is that if they’re not sure then don’t have them.

Something about the way he said it led me to ask him whether he regretted having DD. I’ve always had a suspicion that he had a child just for me, rather than because he particularly wanted to, so perhaps it was that which prompted my question.

He replied that he didn’t regret her, that she was brilliant and he wouldn’t be without her. However, if he had his time again, knowing what he knows now about the impact children have on your life, he might make a different choice. He also said that he preferred his lifestyle before children (we had a great social life), but accepted that had, in the main, gone and was happy to crack on with family life. He also said he would never, ever, make her feel like she wasn’t wanted.

I feel really upset by what he said. On one hand it seems perfectly reasonable and he was just being honest. On the other he’s saying he’s effectively saying he’s trapped in a lifestyle he doesn’t want.

AIBU? Or is he out of order?

OP posts:
MoiraRose4 · 09/10/2021 07:47

He’s not BU at all. I completely agree with him. I don’t regret my children at all, but if I had my time again, I think I’d choose a child-free life.

hesterstanhope · 09/10/2021 07:43

Also worth remembering that life moves on regardless, who’s to say if you didn’t have the child he’d skill be living his old life.
And certainly, he never experienced life as a lonely older person with no living relatives.
It’s a modern construct that life is a series of discrete choices.

ohfook · 09/10/2021 07:38

Also you obviously have a good relationship if he felt like he could say that to you. You should be pleased you can be so honest with each other.

I once tried to explain to my husband that having kids had really cemented my belief in access to abortion. I didn't want to retroactively abort my kids - I was trying to explain that despite really wanting them and loving themI found some aspects (torn arsehole, sleep deprivation, being skint, no social life, having to listen to shit about trains for 12 hours a day) hard so I thought it was horrific to enforce it on someone who didn't actually want any of this. He absolutely went off it with me, couldn't believe I'd think such a thing etc. It caused a huge row for what was me essentially trying to talk to him about the less than perfect bits.

HollyGoLoudly1 · 09/10/2021 07:36

[quote RussianSpy101]@FloconDeNeige you still can. My DC (except the youngest) have skied, scuba dived, been on speedboats & jet skies, been on camel rides and have travelled to many countries.[/quote]
Which is lovely but will be beyond the budget of most families, especially once you are in the school years and paying inflated prices for holidays while still paying wrap round care and have more than one child.

ittakes2 · 09/10/2021 07:35

I think this advice to others is very sensible.

ohfook · 09/10/2021 07:31

He's pretty much summed up how I felt about a year in to parenthood too. I love my kids and wouldn't be without them but god my life was good before I had them and there's times I miss that a lot.

HarrisMcCoo · 09/10/2021 07:31

@Tickly

Think that is pretty normal with a 1yo first child tbh. It's a massive shock to the system how much freedom you lose. It does get easier though.
No it doesn't! I have a teenager 😂
bozzabollix · 09/10/2021 07:30

I don’t think he’s been unreasonable, when kids are that age it’s such hard work. My youngest is now seven and it’s way easier.

When you say you had a great social life it sounds like that’s in the past. Do you not socialise now? I know some parents choose a route so child centred that it doesn’t allow for their needs. If that’s you maybe give yourselves a bit of a breather, invite friends over, see if grandparents can take over for a night whilst you go out. It might feel less like life as you knew it is over.

HollyGoLoudly1 · 09/10/2021 07:30

I can distinguish between my feelings for him and how I feel about motherhood in general (which is not dissimilar to how your DH feels)

This is how I feel. My DS is my sun and moon but equally I feel quite trapped by motherhood. I couldn't live without him now but at the same time I know I would have had a perfectly happy life without children.

But you can't have both (children and freedom) and you can't even really have any kind of middle ground compromise either (unless you have squillions of money and can outsource everything). Like a PP said, in for a penny in for a pound so if you're going to do it you need to just do it. Doesn't mean he can't miss his old life or wonder about what else might have been sometimes. I know I do!

Tirediam · 09/10/2021 07:28

@JasonMomoasgirlfriend 🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼 Or it’s gin every day for me!!

RussianSpy101 · 09/10/2021 07:26

@FloconDeNeige you still can. My DC (except the youngest) have skied, scuba dived, been on speedboats & jet skies, been on camel rides and have travelled to many countries.

MitheringMytryl · 09/10/2021 07:24

I think it's a very positive sign that he was so honest with you. That's part of a healthy marriage, and some couples stop communicating after they have kids.

You have a 1yo. That can be a very tough time. I had days with my first where I thought "I love you, but I wish I could go back in time to before I had you". By the time she was 2 I felt completely differently, and have happily had more children.

JasonMomoasgirlfriend · 09/10/2021 07:24

@Tirediam

My son is 2.5.. if I had to do it again I wouldn’t but it doesn’t mean I don’t love every cell of his being. Life is hard, so hard with a baby/toddler. I’m sure it will get easier as he gets older.
This is what I'm hoping
Rhubarbcrumblerules · 09/10/2021 07:22

As much as I love my two children more than anything, I feel I have been treading water for the last 21 years and am only just finding myself again.

Tirediam · 09/10/2021 07:21

My son is 2.5.. if I had to do it again I wouldn’t but it doesn’t mean I don’t love every cell of his being. Life is hard, so hard with a baby/toddler. I’m sure it will get easier as he gets older.

CarryOnNurse20 · 09/10/2021 07:17

I mean I had more confidence and knowledge obviously rather than having a super brainy self confident newborn 😂 hope that’s makes sense!

Lanareyrey · 09/10/2021 07:17

YABU. I feel exactly the same as he does after having 2. Gets harder as they get older to. Love them to bits though.

CarryOnNurse20 · 09/10/2021 07:16

@Evasmithsghost @mistermagpie I guess it’s a bit in for a penny in for a pound! I’ve actually enjoyed having children far more since having 2- having a baby with a bit more confidence and knowledge was a far happier experience and watching the two kids interact and play has solidified to me how wonderful they are and how grateful I am to have had them.

However- I look at my friends who don’t have kids (most planning on them in future) and have pangs of envy. The sleep ins, the holidays, the free time, the money!! I loved our life before kids and we had them earlier than I expected so sometimes feel it was cut short. But I adore my kids and 5 years and 2 kids in it knees deep in parents life and enjoy it. But it’s ok to have what ifs! I do with kids, jobs, where we live! Always considering moving abroad.. I’m not dissatisfied I love my life but I love considering ‘options’.

onelittlefrog · 09/10/2021 07:15

It sounds like good advice that he would give, to be honest. I agree that anyone on the fence or not sure about having children probably shouldn't have them. It's such a massive life change and we don't need more unwanted children in this world.

I think it's OK to miss his previous life too, and to say he might have done things differently if he had his time over again. It doesn't mean that he doesn't love or want his daughter (or any future children). It's just that parenthood is a hard slog especially in the first year.

ArtichokeAardvark · 09/10/2021 07:15

I'm with your DH to an extent. I hugely miss my old life pre children and think wistfully about how wonderful it was at least once a day. Usually at 5am when I'm so desperately tired I could cry, but they are up and bouncing off the walls. My kids are 3 and 1, so not dissimilar situation to you. However, missing my old life doesn't mean I regret having my kids.

Wineandroses3 · 09/10/2021 07:15

Your DH clearly loves his daughter but has given a realistic answer as everyone whose ever had a one year old know sometimes it’s very very difficult, tiring and relentless. I wouldn’t worry about what he said at all, he still loves his daughter

Thatsplentyjack · 09/10/2021 07:14

I think most people feel like that. Kids are hard work, and even if you get a couple of nights away without them, they are on your mind so you never get to completely relax.

WeDidntMeanToGoToSea · 09/10/2021 07:14

*deciding what they did when, not 'then'

WeDidntMeanToGoToSea · 09/10/2021 07:13

I think a PP makes a great point about assumptions that this feeling is permanent and/or linear. I've been a parent for 16 years and there haven't been any stand-out 'difficult' or 'easy' phases - it's been a mix of joys and worries all through - but certainly as my older two have hit the teens there are moments of thinking how much easier/less worry life would be without them. There's a proverb in the country I live in - 'little children, little worries; big children, big worries' and sometimes I find myself half-humorously agreeing with it. That doesn't mean I 'regret' them. It means I'm beginning to realise, in a way I didn't when they were small, just how much of a risk (iyswim) having children is, particularly when you see them turning into their own people and developing aspects to their personalities that are foreign to you and which you worry will make their lives harder for them going forward. (And I would add we don't have any serious problems with them - it's on the 'coasting, mediocre grades, minor rudeness, excessive screen time' level. But the worry of them .'going rogue' is very much present). I can see a parallel to the baby-stage 'regret' (which I never had) in that both of these stages represent a loss of control for the parent over something they were used to controlling - one's own life and schedule for babies, the children themselves ('control' in the sense that influencing them and deciding what they did then was a much more realistic proposition previously) for teens. People hate not being in control of things. Most do adapt.

I do think the more able we feel to talk with nuance about any experience - including having children - without aspersions being cast on anything that isn't complete enthusiasm, the better it is overall for our individual and societal mental health.

Cherryana · 09/10/2021 07:12

Committed