Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Regretting Children

166 replies

ClementBatley · 08/10/2021 23:58

DP and I have a DD aged 1. DP a great dad, active, hands on, clearly loves her to bits. Does his fair share of childcare and household stuff, and he’s great with her too, DD really loves him. He’s a bit more laid back about some things than I am but broadly speaking we’re both on the same page.

We were recently watching something on TV and someone on the show said that he was 50/50 about whether he wanted to have children. DP commented that the advice he would give anyone in that situation is that if they’re not sure then don’t have them.

Something about the way he said it led me to ask him whether he regretted having DD. I’ve always had a suspicion that he had a child just for me, rather than because he particularly wanted to, so perhaps it was that which prompted my question.

He replied that he didn’t regret her, that she was brilliant and he wouldn’t be without her. However, if he had his time again, knowing what he knows now about the impact children have on your life, he might make a different choice. He also said that he preferred his lifestyle before children (we had a great social life), but accepted that had, in the main, gone and was happy to crack on with family life. He also said he would never, ever, make her feel like she wasn’t wanted.

I feel really upset by what he said. On one hand it seems perfectly reasonable and he was just being honest. On the other he’s saying he’s effectively saying he’s trapped in a lifestyle he doesn’t want.

AIBU? Or is he out of order?

OP posts:
JasonMomoasgirlfriend · 09/10/2021 09:43

Or you never had to deal with it and then you've been lucky and had an easy ride..

JasonMomoasgirlfriend · 09/10/2021 09:43

@RussianSpy101 and @FrauleinSchweiger yeh I've not had so much joy being met with a Noddy 2yr old who had a face like thunder and was trying to bat me away when I went to get him from his cot this morning. Then for him to have removed his nappy, refused another, refused all clothes, ripped the best off I managed to get over his head.
Sat downstairs peeing on the carpet three time, getting kicked and hit when trying to get nappy and vest on again.
It's very very tiring. Where is the "joy" in that?
I think you've forgotten how hard work toddlers are.

GettingUntrapped · 09/10/2021 09:42

Maybe it depends on what kind of life you had before children? Mine was full - travel, excitement, career, me feeling like I was moving forward with self development etc.
Having children can put a stop to all of that, and I've found that incredibly difficult.
As for the joys, plenty in the first years, but the self sacrifice (which is very real and lived every day) drudgery, frustration, boredom and tedium is too big a price to pay in my opinion.
It's not the fault of the children, but our culture which doesn't support parents, especially mothers, enough.

JoyPeaceHope · 09/10/2021 09:42

I also think it's really good if you can discuss these things openly as a couple. Like oh my goodness, what did we used to do with our time! And it brings you together to cope with the hard times of you can be honest to one another.

The first year is an absolute slog. It gets better once they get a bit older and dad can take them swimming, mini golf, movies, lunches out, camping etc...

TableFlowerss · 09/10/2021 09:41

YABU.

You asked him a question, he answered honestly. I think many men are easy either way whether they have DC. They go with the flow, because ultimately the choice isn’t down to them. If a woman wants a baby, she’ll have a baby. You just have to look at the other boards where the woman says ‘DH doesn’t want to keep the baby’, the advice is always ‘have the baby, it’s not up to him… you’re body your choice etc’

Some men will want their partner to be happy and if she wants a baby then he’ll go along with it. Some men absolutely want them from day dot, some might decide they want them later on… there’s lots of variables and nothing is right or wrong.

Your DH sounds like a great dad and DD is clearly very loved, it’s not reflection of his love.

Nightbringer · 09/10/2021 09:40

These threads always make me feel like I don't belong on MN as it seems to be assumed that "most parents" feel like this. Believe it or not some of us don't. That is not said to sound smug but I do wonder if people reading these threads think that everyone regrets having had children and yearns for their child free life.

That doesn't even make sense.

Even if people believed most parents feel this way, most doesn't mean all. So by default, saying most feel this way you are acknowledging some don't.

I wouldn't have had my kids in the same circumstances I did. I honestly think, anyone who says they never miss their child free life, even for a second in the middle of the night when their 6 week old still hasn't slept, is just good at forgetting.

Its not unfashionable to say you don't regret your kids.

For years and years, women especially had to pretend everything was perfect. People didn't talk about the difficult side, the side they found difficult, the problems etc.

People feel more comfortable being honest , not sure why that makes you feel put out and like you don't belong? That's quite dramatic, based on your own view of your life.

Tal45 · 09/10/2021 09:38

I felt much worse than that having a 1 year old, spent at least the first two years wondering what the hell I'd done! Kids are not easy but it will get more fun and rewarding as she gets older and there will be more you can do together that's fun as she grows up. We have a teen now and can go anywhere and do pretty much anything, no regrets at all, we've done so much together - and so much that we wouldn't have done without a child.
I don't think you have any need to be upset by what he said at all, having a child is a HUGE adjustment x

CorianderAndCream · 09/10/2021 09:35

I think lots of people feel like that. He's right, it's a massive and difficult change. I don't think you should be upset

RussianSpy101 · 09/10/2021 09:35

@FrauleinSchweiger I feel the same as you. My DC bring us so much joy and we have a brilliant life with them. I would imagine life without them incredibly dull.

FrauleinSchweiger · 09/10/2021 09:33

Well as I read it quite a few people said that if they had their time over again they wouldn't have them. Apologies if I got it wrong but there seem to be so many of these threads these days. As I said, maybe MM isn't the place for me anymore.Sad

JasonMomoasgirlfriend · 09/10/2021 09:29

No one had said they regret their children, have they?

The thread is titled "regret" but the OPs DH specifically said he did NOT regret their child.

FrauleinSchweiger · 09/10/2021 09:26

These threads always make me feel like I don't belong on MN as it seems to be assumed that "most parents" feel like this. Believe it or not some of us don't. That is not said to sound smug but I do wonder if people reading these threads think that everyone regrets having had children and yearns for their child free life.

I think it seems increasingly unfashionable to say that you have never regretted having children and that evenings out, holidays, new cars etc do not compare to the joy that children can bring. And before anyone piles on, I am not doubting that it's bloody hard work. My DH was initially unsure about having kids and the only thing that he ever said after having them was "we should have done it years ago". I don't say this to upset or aggravate anyone, not to diminish their experience but merely to add some balance. Apologies to anyone whom I have offended.

madamovaries · 09/10/2021 09:22

A friend described children as “the most wonderful way to ruin your life”.
It is gruelling. I think your partner’s response is totally normal and good for him for being honest.
One thing I’ve thought a lot since having a baby is that mothers tend to get a bit more out of the first few months (though obviously can have it so, so much harder than fathers too) — and that’s been exacerbated during the pandemic. My husband wasn’t allowed to go to my scans, wasn’t allowed to stay in the hospital with us etc. So when I eventually took my son home, it felt like my son and I were a team and my husband had to slot his way in. Plus because I breastfed, my son and I had loads of time to bond that his father wasn’t part of. Oh and of course I’d been carrying him around in utero.
As your daughter gets older, I reckon your partner will get more from it, while hopefully it will get a bit easier to resume a social life (it does get easier, right...?!!!)

SallyDoTheDishes · 09/10/2021 09:12

My children are now 18 and 15 and honestly when you are in the thick of it with baby or toddler years it does feel restrictive and overwhelming. Everything shifts to being about them, considering them in decisions about going out and holidays etc.

He clearly loves his child and dotes on her, but right now she is a lot of work because she is just a baby. It gets easier or at least it should, no more nappy changes because they use the toilet, no constantly having to entertain them because they learn to entertain themselves. Think how much she has changed from a newborn.

I think you should appreciate his honesty about it.

AliasGrape · 09/10/2021 09:09

I suspect my DH might feel similarly sometimes, we also have a 1 year old. He’s a great dad, does his share of parenting, loves DD to bits but I think he finds it harder than me. I don’t think it helps that DD is very very much all about me still, she loves her dad but will still pick me every time and kicks off if it’s him putting her to bed or trying to give her a cuddle or whatever. She likes to play running around shrieking games with him and will take him toys/ books to look at but all the extra cute snuggly stuff gets reserved for me right now which I think is hard on him.

I get more of the grunt work as I’m a mostly SAHM for now ( bit of freelance stuff done around DD) and I do tend for ease to just deal with the nighttime’s as I know she’ll settle quicker for me although I know it’s making a rod for my own back. Physically I’m knackered and objectively my life is harder, more restricted and more repetitive than before. But I don’t regret her for a second and if I could go back I’d choose to have her again and again a hundred times over. Like I say though, I think it’s been more of an eye opener for DH and I’m not sure he’d say the same - I don’t blame him for that, he adores DD and is a good dad so that’s all that counts.

Prokupatuscrakedatus · 09/10/2021 09:09

Your DP gave a considered and honest answer and showed himself to be an adult.

Your reaction on the other hand...

Livelovebehappy · 09/10/2021 09:06

Think these days it is easier to make the decision not to have children, as there’s not the pressure there used to be. Going back just 30 years ago, it was just an expectation that once married, children would follow, and people who chose not to have children were looked on as odd. I suspect lots of parents with adult children now felt that back in the day they knew they didn’t want children but had them to keep other people happy. These days I work alongside women who have decided they don’t want want children, and society doesn’t look at them differently for making that choice. So YABU, your DH is just voicing out loud what some will think.

JustJustWhy · 09/10/2021 09:04

I think it's excellent advice.

I tend to shy away from giving advice about potentially life-changing decisions, but not this one. I have a dear friend who is on the fence but certainly not desperate to have children. I've advised her that if you're looking to make a choice, you should only have children if you really, really want them. You're not having a baby, you're making a person. There will be challenges ahead, potentially heart-breaking ones and it's the love you have for that person that keeps you going.

I wouldn't change my child for the world but if I hadn't chosen to have them and if I hadn't therefore loved them from day 1 then I wouldn't have been able to face the recent and very long-term challenges we have just faced and I would also have failed them as a parent.

DaphneduM · 09/10/2021 09:00

I think your husband gave you a very reasonable, thoughtful and honest account of his feelings of parenthood. It's challenging and no matter how much you love your children, it can be very draining. But the joys, when they come, are wonderful. I've been watching my darling daughter and son-in-law face all the challenges of having a toddler through the pandemic. No toddler clubs for him and life is only just getting back to normal. Also they have the worry of feeling there is no medical help easily available. This is all for another thread, but the delays in accessing GP services with long delays have been very worrying for them.

I love being a Granny - hands-on - looking after our grandson and it's the culmination of everything I could have ever wanted. But being a parent was very hard and stressful at times, but always there was that background of love for her. I have friends who are similar age to me who don't have children and are now widowed. They have everything they could ever want materially and can go on amazing holidays and have the absolute best of everything, big houses, etc. etc. but I wonder how it must feel to be essentially alone and have no emotional investment in the future, which our children and grandchildren give us I can remember thinking when my daughter was little, please let me just have half an hour to read a book.

It's tough and so honest of him to admit it. You're fortunate to have an emotionally intelligent husband.

Nillynally · 09/10/2021 09:00

My husband feels the same. No offence to our toddler, she's amazing but he did enjoy his life more before her. He could spend his money on what he wanted, drive fast cars, go out and do all his hobbies, lie in, go to work dos, go on nice holidays. I feel my life is more enriched by having her, it's different but I prefer it. I don't blame him, at least he's honest. I think it's a common thing to think. He IS right though, if you're not sure than dont- too many children in this world resented, unwanted and unloved.

In4mation · 09/10/2021 08:58

Just because you love your new life, doesn’t mean you can’t miss your old life.

Ideally I’d have liked to have kept both. Obviously that’s not possible.

GettingUntrapped · 09/10/2021 08:58

Maybe by the time they are older we can be so worn down, broke and have lost ourselves so much that we just accept that is how things are. No point complaining anymore. Sorry, I know that sounds grim. I don't believe that giving up so much of yourself for so long is natural, it's a culturally imposed mate-guarding system. Childcare should be much more communal.

HailAdrian · 09/10/2021 08:56

Hmm I was pregnant at 16 and have essentially warned my now 15yo not to do the same. I don't regret them but it's so difficult.

mydogisthebest · 09/10/2021 08:49

@Ijustknowitstimetogo

He won’t feel like that for ever though. One day when he’s older his life will partly revolve round her and any grandchildren, but in a different way to how it does now. He’ll be saying it’s one of the most important/ precious things he’s ever done.
That's not always true. Quite a few of my friends have grandchildren but still say if they could go back in time they would not have children.
RussianSpy101 · 09/10/2021 08:39

@Scrollonthroughtherain the PP I was replying to said she did all these things previous to having her child and can’t do them now. I was pointing out she can.