Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how would you manage your money with dh if you were us?

170 replies

SnowWhitesSM · 08/10/2021 21:23

Me and DH - I earn 30k and DH has his own business but has approximately the same monthly earnings as me. I have two teens full time and he has dss 8 50/50.

We've been putting our bill money in one account and paying 50/50 but argue over food shopping money and treats. I think dh doesn't see how much I spend (especially on him food wise) and he thinks the same. I suggested upping our monthly contributions towards bills and using that for treats and food shopping but dh doesn't want to. I also suggested putting all of our bills together inc phone contracts, car insurance ect and keeping £500 a month to ourselves in our banks but he doesn't want to do that either. His suggestion is he buys food for him and dss and I buy for me and mine but I cant complain about him coming home with treats that aren't for me either. I just don't get it, why would you buy yourself a chocolate bar (yes we're arguing over a chocolate bar) and not buy me one. Apparently it makes him resentful that he can't just buy a bar of chocolate without worrying about me wanting one.

My dc don't eat us out of house and home. They have a decent school dinner and have cheese and crackers/pitta breads and houmous/soup/fish finger sandwiches for dinner as they have their main meal in school. Dh eats a lot and where the majority of the food money goes.

What is fair? I grew up with parents that had a joint bank account and everything was family money. In my wider family it's the same. Dh didn't grow up like that and feels his money is his. I want to share! I don't feel like we're a proper team when we argue over money that technically is marriage money. I don't feel he sees what I do and he says the same. Surely we should be working towards bettering our financial future together?

OP posts:
Beekindbeehumble · 09/10/2021 09:37

Does he do 50% of all cleaning?
Does he wash his and DSS clothes, iron and out away?

If he is so against sharing money and food, then literally he cannot have it both ways!

I would for a month separate everything - he has to buy his own washing up liquid, and wash up, washing powder and do laundry, toilet rolls, cleaning products etc. Don’t buy any food he eats and certainly don’t cook it. If he wasn’t a hit meal, he cooks it, washes up.

As that is how he is treating you!

Sn0tnose · 09/10/2021 09:29

I took ages to post and missed the update. I think your marriage is fucked. How did he respond when you told him you didn’t think the marriage would last without counselling?

Iggly · 09/10/2021 09:28

@SnowWhitesSM

I don't want to do that *@Chloemol* we tried that a couple of months ago and dss got very upset at the separateness. He saw my dc with their treats and wanted them.

@SunshineCake1 hope you're ok now. Foster care is very hard.

We've also tried counselling. We had two sessions but I needed a new car and the loft needs to be finished for ds and dss to have their own rooms. I felt the car and counselling was the priority but dh felt the loft was. I have told dh that by the time the loft is finished we'll be lucky if we're still together as I felt we needed the counselling more. I want to go back to counselling and I'm happy to go 50/50 on the cost but dh isn't.

The arguing over chocolate bars is a symptom. It sounds like you’ve got some serious differences and money is exacerbating it.

It all sounds so energy sapping (dividing up ice lollies ffs) and I wonder if he has issues from childhood which make him effectively hoard food.

Who has the time to mentally keep tabs on treats and who buys what for whom. Just one family shop would make sense and I wonder if there are other things which demonstrate that you both are not really a blended family.

It sounds like you’re flatmates. You can’t even agree to split the cost for the counselling?

If I were you, I’d have counselling alone. And work through why you think you want to stay married.

SnowWhitesSM · 09/10/2021 09:27

I'm not drip feeding I'm answering a couple of posters who said about counselling. I don't want the post to be about everything else wrong in our relationship I just want to know peoples opinions on how to share money in our situation.

OP posts:
Sn0tnose · 09/10/2021 09:26

I’m struggling to get my head around this set up. It is beyond weird. Separate cupboards is insane for anyone other than housemates. What’s next? Will you have to go and buy another fridge/freezer? DH and I only have a joint savings account because we never got around to setting up joint current accounts. I pay some bills, he pays others. We both buy shopping, pay for meals out etc, and neither of us keep track because we’re married; it’s our money. If he’s skint one month, he has full access to everything I have, and vice versa. We know the pins for each other’s cards and both make sure that the other is ok for spending money.

In your circumstances, I would consider my marriage to be in serious trouble. I’d like to think that I’d be sensible, try and work on the marriage and push for counselling from someone who specialises in blended families, but I’m petty, so would probably agree to separate shopping for a trial month, then refuse to give him access to anything he hadn’t paid for, (soap, washing up liquid, soap powder etc) just to show him how ridiculous he’s being. I also think that this would start to kill my feelings for him.

He is saying he already feels resentful that he can't just buy himself a chocolate bar on the way home from work and come home and sit next to me and eat it without buying me one That is so incredibly selfish. It’s not like you’ll only eat ethically sourced cocoa beans from the mountains of Peru. He’s standing right next to the Mars Bars. How much effort would it take to pick up two instead of one? It’s such a tiny, inconsequential thing to do to make you happy and he’s telling you it’s too much trouble for him and he doesn’t want to do it.

NoSquirrels · 09/10/2021 09:23

The counselling is a big drip feed, OP! It’s not just about groceries, then?

NoSquirrels · 09/10/2021 09:22

I'm not trying to make my DH (yes we're definitely married) spend more on my dc. I've tried to write this from both our points of view and not to garner sympathy. I was going to show dh this thread but I can't now as he will jump on to that.

If you’ve tried to write from both POV and not elicit sympathy why can’t you show him the thread?

SnowWhitesSM · 09/10/2021 09:21

I don't want to do that @Chloemol we tried that a couple of months ago and dss got very upset at the separateness. He saw my dc with their treats and wanted them.

@SunshineCake1 hope you're ok now. Foster care is very hard.

We've also tried counselling. We had two sessions but I needed a new car and the loft needs to be finished for ds and dss to have their own rooms. I felt the car and counselling was the priority but dh felt the loft was. I have told dh that by the time the loft is finished we'll be lucky if we're still together as I felt we needed the counselling more. I want to go back to counselling and I'm happy to go 50/50 on the cost but dh isn't.

OP posts:
SMabbutt · 09/10/2021 09:20

@SnowWhitesSM

Me and DH - I earn 30k and DH has his own business but has approximately the same monthly earnings as me. I have two teens full time and he has dss 8 50/50.

We've been putting our bill money in one account and paying 50/50 but argue over food shopping money and treats. I think dh doesn't see how much I spend (especially on him food wise) and he thinks the same. I suggested upping our monthly contributions towards bills and using that for treats and food shopping but dh doesn't want to. I also suggested putting all of our bills together inc phone contracts, car insurance ect and keeping £500 a month to ourselves in our banks but he doesn't want to do that either. His suggestion is he buys food for him and dss and I buy for me and mine but I cant complain about him coming home with treats that aren't for me either. I just don't get it, why would you buy yourself a chocolate bar (yes we're arguing over a chocolate bar) and not buy me one. Apparently it makes him resentful that he can't just buy a bar of chocolate without worrying about me wanting one.

My dc don't eat us out of house and home. They have a decent school dinner and have cheese and crackers/pitta breads and houmous/soup/fish finger sandwiches for dinner as they have their main meal in school. Dh eats a lot and where the majority of the food money goes.

What is fair? I grew up with parents that had a joint bank account and everything was family money. In my wider family it's the same. Dh didn't grow up like that and feels his money is his. I want to share! I don't feel like we're a proper team when we argue over money that technically is marriage money. I don't feel he sees what I do and he says the same. Surely we should be working towards bettering our financial future together?

I've never had a separate pot of money for food or bills but my grandparents did. I don't think I would be happy with his attitude at all.

It seems as if he has a particular issue with food because he doesn't think you are both contributing equally in terms of what you use. Would it be worth keeping all receipts for a few weeks to see what you are both actually spending or agreeing to do it his way for 2 weeks or 1 month, cooking separately and keeping all receipts for everything. At the end you can see what the actual split is financially and if you are right he will see he is being ridiculous. Having to manage his way will be a real pain for him as well so he will hopefully realise he's better off with the status quo and stop whinging.

NoSquirrels · 09/10/2021 09:20

If your DC and you don’t eat more of the food (& I do still refuse to believe that 2 teens don’t cost more than a couple of pittas and hummus a night) then what’s the issue, really? If they never touch ‘his’ food, why is it an issue to him?

Tell him to get ALL the food shopping & groceries for a month, and you’ll reimburse him at the end of the month 50%.

If he doesn’t feed you and the DC - all the DC - equally at that point, treats and all, then there’s a problem.

But I don’t really understand what you want. You want him to buy you treats sometimes but not always - because you don’t want to binge on junk like him.

Sundancerintherain · 09/10/2021 09:17

@Fireflygal has got it spot on.
He is a selfish twat.

Chloemol · 09/10/2021 09:07

Tell you what I would do certainly for a month

I would buy stuff just for you and your teens. Put it all in your cupboard. That also includes washing powder and anything else

Dh would then be left to purchase his own, and cook his and DSS meals, and do respective washing, not using your washing powder. You may end up having to do all cleaning, but I simply wouldn’t do anything else. And if there is anything else you can hive off then I would do that

If at the end of the month he hasn’t changed his mind, then that would continue

SnowWhitesSM · 09/10/2021 09:06

But me and my DC don't eat a hefty amount of the food - which I buy more of. Dh binge eats although is fairly slim. My dc had 2 pitta breads (45p) a pot of homous (£1.50) cucumber and tomatoes (£1) and went to youth club where they probably bought themselves sweets from the tuckshop with their pocket money. That's a typical evening for them as they both have their main meal in school.

Dh buys a chocolate bar, a chocolate marshmallow bar, fruit, ice cream and cake or biscuits for his evening snacks. I don't even want to eat half of that as I'd be huge.

I'm not trying to make my DH (yes we're definitely married) spend more on my dc. I've tried to write this from both our points of view and not to garner sympathy. I was going to show dh this thread but I can't now as he will jump on to that.

I also think - and I might be wrong so tell me if I am - that when you're married the money you earn whilst married is both of yours legally? I don't want him to spend all of what he earns on me and my dc. I just think arguing over chocolate bars and who paid for what is ridiculous. I don't want my dc to eat all of the food he buys for himself, I'd hate to buy something and it wasn't there to eat when I wanted it, I just think he takes it to an extreme.

OP posts:
CornishTiger · 09/10/2021 09:02

@SunshineCake1 that’s just awful. Your foster carers were awful.

CornishTiger · 09/10/2021 09:01

Does he have any redeeming qualities?

I find his selfishness around food and money so ugly. I couldn’t be friends with him let alone married.

Fireflygal · 09/10/2021 08:54

@junebirthdaygirl, I think in your case you say your Dp knows you don't want a treat so makes sense.

Op, this isn't about food, he is resentful and or selfish. He is telling you that he doesn't want to have to have to consider your dc needs. He wants to treat them as separate, as that's how he feels and food is a way to highlight that message.

We normally use food and sharing of food to bring people together- he is doing the opposite.

I think we all relate to having one or 2 treats that is for individuals in the house but that's not going on here.

How long have you been married? I imagine it can't be too long if his son is 8. I suspect he had these selfish traits with his ex as well.

hettie · 09/10/2021 08:54

My best advice is to find a good couples or family therapist...make sure they have experience working with blended families and have systemic training....

FreakinFrankNFurter · 09/10/2021 08:52

He is saying he already feels resentful that he can't just buy himself a chocolate bar on the way home from work and come home and sit next to me and eatit without buying me one.

There"s something about this which suggests a much bigger picture, that he's not happy in the marriage or he is just an entirely selfish man.

blueballetshoes · 09/10/2021 08:50

@SnowWhitesSM

This is a tough situation, it saddens me that he doesn't see your children as his and all of you including his child is just one big family unit. He sounds incredibly selfish and quite childish.

I would give anything to be able to get it all and then have £500 a month each spare. Me and DH do this but have £100 each spare.

I think you need seriously decide whether there are some more deep rooted issues in your marriage and whether this masking it. Organisations like Relate might be able to help?

In all honesty I don't think I could remain married to someone like that he really does sound awful. Thanks

Orla1970 · 09/10/2021 08:47

@SunshineCake1

Hell never see your children as his. When I was fostered the parents would buy their kids and ice cream, never me. I just stood there trying not to cry. Lots of other examples like that. They never classed me as a family member.
Sunshine this made me want to cry. These people would have been paid well to look after you yet they singled you out and didn’t treat you the same as their own children. The money they spent on their children was prob the foster payment for you. Rotten mean bastards. I hope when you got old enough you reported their behaviour and they are not still abusing children in their charge. Absolute fuckers xxx
JuneOsborne · 09/10/2021 08:39

But is it really about money, or about his selfishness?

He is resentful that he can't stop at a shop, on the way home and buy just one chocolate bar, get in and eat it in front of you? That's so bizarre. What effort does it take to pick up a second chocolate bar? Why doesn't he want to buy you one? What is with this? Why does he want to eat it on his own? And why, when there's a cupboard already full of treats.

But, he's happy for you to buy the loo roll? I'd tell him I was resentful of him every time he goes for a shit. That I want to just buy loo roll for me and my kids. That you just want to buy enough loo roll and he is spoiling that.

Lessthanaballpark · 09/10/2021 08:35

Why did you move this man in with your children?

I’m guessing she didn’t know this about him before?

billyt · 09/10/2021 08:34

The OPs comment that her OP begrudges buying her a bar of chocolate when he has one and he resents this.[ANGRY]

He's a selfish fucker, isn't he?

We've always had a joint bank account. I earn more but I'm glad that this increases our household income. I don't see buying treats etc is based on our individual incomes. If I ever got to the stage of resenting buying anyone a bar of chocolate in my family I'd think I'd seriously lost the plot.

One of my BILs has the same attitude though. He'll have a packet of biscuits in the shopping every week (they buy the same items religiously weekly) and they are his. SIL mustn't touch them, they're his. He's a selfish cunt as well. He's also the sort to stela sweets off of kids when he's visiting somewhere. We had to stop leaving anything edible out.

I hate selfish bastards.

Orla1970 · 09/10/2021 08:32

So he would rather horde food in his own cupboard and let it go off than share it with his step sons? He sounds like a right wanker. I feel sorry for your boys. He doesn’t want to buy treats for them. Clearly resents them. They must feel this. Your husband thinks he is in a student flat share. My husband wolves down whole packets of biscuits and I go to have one and just find the crumbs Grin so I have said to him. Do not eat all of the biscuits/chocolate if you want to remain alive Grin.

He doesn’t seem to get any pleasure of buying treats for you, your sons. Things he knows you like. If either my husband or I are shopping we routinely pick up other stuff.

I know others are saying you should pay more as you have 2 kids and they’re there full time but I’d feel uncomfortable about that too. He knew you came as 3. Surely you just split the costs equally as it’s a partnership x

silkience · 09/10/2021 08:30

@SunshineCake1 that is awful, I'm so sorry

Swipe left for the next trending thread