Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sell small property to invest the money instead? Stupid? Dh says its ridiculous and to keep it and it won't get as much.

65 replies

Alpacinoshoohaa · 08/10/2021 19:55

Small property gets about 7 grand a year after taxes etc.

Property worth around 100,00 maybe a little more maybe a little less.
I'm wondering about investing it instead in stocks and shares funds and removing the human aspect of this type of investment. I've spent a lot of money on it in recent years and something always seems to go wrong eg I paid for new doors and there were issues, paid for new windows and also issues.

It's commercial not housing.

I'm thinking about selling and putting some into a sipp and some into stocks and shares isa (drip it in)
Silly idea or sensible?

OP posts:
Alpacinoshoohaa · 10/10/2021 09:44

@LostButtons

I've just found him on Spotify. It looks very interesting there are tons of episodes though.

OP posts:
YankeeDad · 09/10/2021 20:21

It would be optimistic to assume an average 10pct return over the long term from stocks and shares. Something around 6-7pct is probably more realistic, or 5-6 pct after fees.

Stocks and shares may provide a dividend yield on the order of 2-3pct depending on the type of stocks and funds chosen, and that may be before fees, which could easily eat up half of that. Any further cash from the portfolio would have to be gotten by selling some shares, so needing a distribution rate of 5-7pct for living expenses would put you in a position of having to sell into a market downturn.

That does not mean that it’s a bad idea to buy stocks and shares, just that it’s imprudent to assume 10pct returns and 5-7pct withdrawal rates.

An important input to your decision would be to work out how much cash you’ve cleared from the property, net of ALL expenses, and then compare that vs what you think you might get elsewhere.

GenderApostatemk2 · 09/10/2021 20:15

You could go for income funds, best yielding ones seem to be around the 4/5% range. Safe withdrawal would be JUST the natural yield, otherwise you may sacrifice growth by taking more.
Otherwise a cheap passive tracker like a Vanguard lifestyle, the VLS60 is 60% equity / 40% bonds for example.

I would keep 2/3 years of income in cash so you don’t have to sell funds in a downturn.

Alpacinoshoohaa · 09/10/2021 20:10

The hate.

It's not a house?

And I'm really surprised you wrote that you sold an asset and have since been on your arse.

This property is my barrier to stop me from ending up on my arse and this is what scares me having previously been very much on my arse and no safety net.

OP posts:
TheHateIsNotGood · 09/10/2021 19:44

Sell it - to a local buyer, Council or Housing Trust and invest it in something else. You shouldn't 'lose' any Capital so why not? I have done similar many years ago and have never regretted it, even though I have since been on my arse.

Be just a little part in helping mitigate our housing crisis and if others do too, then those little actions add up.

LostButtons · 09/10/2021 19:42

I'd recommend reading or listening to How to own the world by Andrew Craig as he addresses the negatives/positives of keeping your money in property versus investing. Very easy/read listen and might help you. You've got plenty of time to make the decision.

PigletJohn · 09/10/2021 19:31

[quote Alpacinoshoohaa]@Viviennemary

Why, please Grin

Re stocks I'm fairly confident to just stay with long term investing and staying with index funds.

What I'm not clear about is how I get that income from the stocks.

I wouldn't necessarily want it yet, but my income form the property goes back into the property at the moment.

Or am I being spoilt...[/quote]
I have a SIPP that I currently draw income from, at the rate of about 3%. This is a bit less than it generates in dividends so I reinvest the left overs.

It holds about a half a dozen different funds and shares, with a European and International bias. My funds are Income versions.

You can get higher yielding funds or shares, but they may not have the same long term growth prospects.

I wouldn't recommend something volatile, you're better off getting a low-cost tracker, and I am moving that way myself.

It is sometimes said that if you withdraw 4% p.a. from a mixed portfolio, it will not diminish, because growth and income will tend to equal or exceed what you draw out.

If you have decided that you will die in, say, 20 years or 10 years, you could choose to take more with the intention of using it all up.

Income from the SIPP is taxable, so if I have any high-yielders, I put them in an ISA which is not taxed.

greenflower1 · 09/10/2021 19:12

I would find a consultant who could teach you about crypto and get you invested in that as well as regular stocks.

PattiPritell · 09/10/2021 18:24

Some funds are income funds - not sure if it's dividends or growth in value.

Viviennemary · 09/10/2021 15:37

Because you'd be hard pushed to get 7% return on a safe investment. Property usually = steady rental income plus capital growth. Invest the rental income if you want to invest.

Alpacinoshoohaa · 09/10/2021 15:28

@Viviennemary

Why, please Grin

Re stocks I'm fairly confident to just stay with long term investing and staying with index funds.

What I'm not clear about is how I get that income from the stocks.

I wouldn't necessarily want it yet, but my income form the property goes back into the property at the moment.

Or am I being spoilt...

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 09/10/2021 14:30

It would be utter madness.

RandomLondoner · 09/10/2021 14:26

@Kitfish

I recommend you don't try and pick the stocks yourself but go to a good financial advisor. You want a balanced portfolio over a wide range of stocks/funds that reflects your risk profile. I have a very good financial advisor, who I would recommend. DM and I'll give you his contact details.
People who've ever read any books on investing will know that the consensus is that financial advice reduces your returns by the amount you pay the advisor.
Alpacinoshoohaa · 09/10/2021 14:06

Piglet John, I don't spend much time there as its a long way away.
However the mental worry and not easily being able to sort things out gets me, esp as every issue I've had with the tenant is not clear cut the lease has been no good.

I'm not a high earner at all and unlikely to be.
I'd probably put some into sipp and try and get bulk into an isa.

OP posts:
PigletJohn · 09/10/2021 12:09

@HotChoc10

If it's your main pension you could put it into a SIPP (over a few years as the max you can contribute in one year is £40k, I think?) and claim the tax relief
to get the tax rebate, you are not allowed to contribute more to your pension in one tax year, than your taxable earnings in that tax year. There is a small exemption for low-earners or no-earners.

But if you have a fat wedge to invest, you can put another £20k per year into your ISA.

Pensions get tax relief when you put the money in

ISAs are tax free when you take the money out.

If you pay higher tax rate in your contributing years than in your drawing years, pensions have an advantage. Otherwise, not much in it, and ISAs are more flexible. But pensions can avoid inheritance tax if you have a fund remaining when you peg out, and have an estate exceeding £325,000.

HotChoc10 · 09/10/2021 10:18

If it's your main pension you could put it into a SIPP (over a few years as the max you can contribute in one year is £40k, I think?) and claim the tax relief

PattiPritell · 09/10/2021 09:34

A financial advisor will ask how safe you want your investment to be - usually safe investment means v slow and steady so less profits. But the initial sum should still be there at the end.
High profit usually means more risk.

Amboseli · 08/10/2021 21:58

We have property which I agree is a huge hassle because of the people factor. But we have had a steady rental income from them month after month for 20+ years as well as the capital growth.

We are now starting to invest in s+s ISAs but I know we probably won't see any significant returns for at least 5 years.

I think the best option is to have both. Keep the property but also put some money into shares/investment funds although the problem with these is that there is no guarantee of a set level of income every month.

workwoes123 · 08/10/2021 21:46

We have both property and index tracker funds. The latter have given us a better return over the last 15 years than the properties have tbh and, unlike the properties, does not require constant attention and financial input 🙄. The only thing that works in our favour with the properties is that we don’t have a mortgage and they are city centre in an expensive city, so the capital value increases steadily.

If you do go for an index tracker you need to be investing over the long term to see the benefits - 5-10 years minimum.

PigletJohn · 08/10/2021 21:36

How many hours a year do you you spend on chasing rent, dealing with complaints, arranging plumber, decorator, roof repair, tax return, agent?

What do you value your time at?

Do you already own a house?

If so, what percentage of your wealth is in residential property?

Alpacinoshoohaa · 08/10/2021 20:36

Mrs Worcester and svarve petty,

Yes that's what I am also thinking, it's not in a boom area I think there is more of ceiling than elsewhere.

My capital lump sum should also rise in value.

The tax side is a huge issue, do you pay tax when selling it?

OP posts:
Alpacinoshoohaa · 08/10/2021 20:31

Ok 40s and this would be my pension as I don't have one.

If I keep the property its my pension as well but its the worry of it that weighs me down.

OP posts:
Alpacinoshoohaa · 08/10/2021 20:30

Lease is up next year.
Not sure if tenant wants to carry on but I suspect its a yes.

Stocks for me would definitely be long term and I wouldn't intend to touch the money but I'd like to see what it yields.

So if I was able to get index funds of average 10% a year would that be 500 a month?

I've already got an isa with a small amount in it and a sipp with a small amount in it.

I'm mostly invested in vanguard but have what I call my gambling funds like fundsmith.
I don't think I'd put the sale money into gamble funds.

OP posts:
Kitfish · 08/10/2021 20:23

Hi @Alpacinoshoohaa

It sounds like you're making close to zero return on the property once maintanance costs have been taken into account and having the hassle factor of dealing with a tenant.

The thing about stocks and shares is that you can't guarantee (or really estimate) the return. You really need to be in a position to let the money sit there for a suitably long period and - over time - it should grow.

You mentioned in your original post that you were thinking of investing some in a SIPP. That is definitely a long term investment - you wouldn't be able to get the money out under any circumstances until you were 55. However, depending on your marginal tax rate, you would get a 25% to 67% uplift on the amount you invested as a tax rebate. Helps increase teh return but provides no monthly income. It all depends on what you want from your investment...

ThinWomansBrain · 08/10/2021 20:22

if it's causing a lot of hassle with repairs and maintenance, may be more trouble than it's worth. Is the £7k after the costof R&M, or before?
And do you have tenants, or need to find some? If it's currently empty, could well depend on how attractive the property is in the current market.

Swipe left for the next trending thread