Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sell small property to invest the money instead? Stupid? Dh says its ridiculous and to keep it and it won't get as much.

65 replies

Alpacinoshoohaa · 08/10/2021 19:55

Small property gets about 7 grand a year after taxes etc.

Property worth around 100,00 maybe a little more maybe a little less.
I'm wondering about investing it instead in stocks and shares funds and removing the human aspect of this type of investment. I've spent a lot of money on it in recent years and something always seems to go wrong eg I paid for new doors and there were issues, paid for new windows and also issues.

It's commercial not housing.

I'm thinking about selling and putting some into a sipp and some into stocks and shares isa (drip it in)
Silly idea or sensible?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Valeriekat · 12/10/2021 09:28

You have income AND capital growth...hard to beat that!

user1471464702 · 12/10/2021 06:26

Hi there - it’s tricky as I bought an investment property that has already gone up in value by 30k in two years however unlikely to make more until another 5 years passed rental yields approx 5 % and stocks and shares average 12-15% a year so having money makes money if invest wisely with specialist advice go for it

CatSnores · 12/10/2021 06:18

Could you convert your shop to residential?

Maskless · 12/10/2021 05:41

I was in the same situation. I had two letting properties that were a total pain in the butt and giving me so much stress!

I sold them both. Used the money to pay off my mortgage (after just 7 years) which saved me a huge amount of money.

The remainder I put into a stocks and shares ISA and a SIPP and a Fund and Share Account.

All of these are with Hargreaves Lansdown. They are managed by fund managers.

Overall, in 7 years the money I invested has grown 40 percent.

I thought I would lose during the pandemic but I gained even more. Some of the funds I am invested in have made over 50%.

My worst fund made 11%.

Bythemillpond · 12/10/2021 04:59

Also I set aside money from my salary for tax

Surely tax would come out of your income from the rent rather than your salary?

OnceUponAThread · 11/10/2021 20:56

[quote Alpacinoshoohaa]@jimmyhill

That was my intention to invest the rent but, as I mentioned previously unfortunately, I can't seem to get ahead because of works needing doing.

@OnceUponAThread

I don't really need the cash right now but I'm in minimum wage.
Dh is not a high earner, so ideally yes I'd love to use the rent but whatever I save gets eaten up by works.
Also I set aside money from my salary for tax.
I wouldn't have to do this if I was able to get the sale proceeds into an isa.[/quote]
Sounds like a decent plan then (IMO). I guess the other consideration is whether you'll have to pay Capital Gains Tax on the property and how much.

To me it sounds like:

  • the property isn't actually making anything like 7% once repairs, tax etc are in play. So you're not making great returns or benefitting from the income.
  • there's a lot of unwanted faff with the human element that's annoying an unwanted.

I think a well diversified, cheap on fees, stock portfolio makes loads of sense. Depending on how old you are, I'd consider flowing it into a mix of an S&S ISA, possibly and S&S Lisa (nutmeg do one), and your Vanguard pension. Maybe with a buffer in the highest interest rate savings account you can find (say £5k) for emergencies.

I'd set your risk levels, and then I would try really hard not to look at your investments, especially in the early days. But I would divide the total amount you're putting in over a year and transfer it monthly (to spread out the risk of little bumps).

(I maxed my ISA right before Covid, and it halved overnight which was a scary moment. Made it all back and more within the year, of course, and it steadily grows now. But it was really bad timing. My other S&S ISA which has a monthly direct debit was much smoother).

Alpacinoshoohaa · 11/10/2021 17:40
  • I agree stock picking mugs game, I just buy index funds but have one or two smaller funds that I call my gamble funds
OP posts:
PigletJohn · 11/10/2021 17:39

@jimmyhill

Fair enough, but supposing you'd invested just five years earlier, in 2006...?
8.55%
Alpacinoshoohaa · 11/10/2021 17:38

@jimmyhill

That was my intention to invest the rent but, as I mentioned previously unfortunately, I can't seem to get ahead because of works needing doing.

@OnceUponAThread

I don't really need the cash right now but I'm in minimum wage.
Dh is not a high earner, so ideally yes I'd love to use the rent but whatever I save gets eaten up by works.
Also I set aside money from my salary for tax.
I wouldn't have to do this if I was able to get the sale proceeds into an isa.

OP posts:
OnceUponAThread · 11/10/2021 17:17

@PhillMcCann

Silly I think.

Extremely volatile times at the moment, I wouldn't be sinking my entire savings into any stock at present.

I'd keep the house.

Not sure why you think a well-balances, diversified portfolio (which covers equities, bonds, real estate, infrastructure etc) is more silly than having all eggs in a property basket.

What if Op can't get a tenant for six months? What if the property market corrects and the cost of the house falls substantially? What if the roof gets damaged and she needs to fix it.

@Alpacinoshoohaa - my Stocks and Shares ISA has made 16.66% on average (been open for four years). (NB I just one of the robo-wealth platforms for this, so I set the risk level and they do the best. I think stock-picking yourself is a mug's game akin to gambling).

My private pension (also invested) is on 14.89% (this one's been running for two years). So you definitely can beat the property returns with investments. (This is in a default fund so the pension manager does all the hard work, and a lot of it is passive trackers).

The thing that strikes me though is whether you need the income. The best thing with investments is to leave them for five years plus so you get cumulative interest as profits are reinvested.

Obviously with the house you're getting income in the form of rent payments. If you need that cash-flow then you want to look at income investing, for which I'd consider an IFA.

NotDavidTennant · 11/10/2021 17:17

Also, you need to consider what you want this investment for.

If it's for a pension then you wouldn't generally expect to take any income out until you're retired. If it's for an income now then it might be difficult to accumulate enough to become a worthwhile pension.

NotDavidTennant · 11/10/2021 17:14

It's commercial not housing.

Why do people never bother to read the OP properly!?

What kind of commercial is it? A lot of people here are assuming that if you hold on to the property you'll make money through capital gains but that might not be the case for some kinds of commercial property. If it's a shop for instance it's probably not going to increase in value much in the current retail climate.

Bythemillpond · 11/10/2021 17:04

If it is a commercial property, I thought the tenant is responsible for any repairs and maintenance

jimmyhill · 11/10/2021 16:59

Fair enough, but supposing you'd invested just five years earlier, in 2006...?

PigletJohn · 11/10/2021 13:37

@jimmyhill

I struggle to imagine an investment where you could safely and reliably get a 7% return (though how much of that has to be put by for maintenance etc?)

What about investing the profits from the property and hanging onto the asset for now

I just checked the return on my main pension between 08/10/2011 and 08/10/2021 (with strong European and International bias since before the Brexit referendum).

Annualised growth is 11.6% (no income taken)

Doesn't sound spectactular but I am very satisfied with it.

YMMV

That is in nominal pounds, not adjusted for inflation, and includes the CV crash and partial recovery.

The FTSE 100 appears to have done worse but does not include reinvested income which would push up the return in a low-cost tracker.

Alpacinoshoohaa · 10/10/2021 22:01

@TheHateIsNotGood

It's not, I repeat not... A residential property. There is no way I'm going selling it for half it's value Grin.

I find your post odd sorry. Patronising and strange.

Saucy 99

10% on average on long term investment.

That smooths out the rough years on index funds.

I don't think tyere is that much head way in capital appreciation.

OP posts:
suggestionsplease1 · 10/10/2021 21:59

Presumably you will have capital gains tax when you sell the property so there is that to consider - it's not like you will be able to straight swap the value straight into investments.

I would have thought if you have spent a lot on major maintenance recently then this expense should not be so great going forward as you will have sorted a lot of the big jobs, and you should be able to achieve better overall profit in the future.

I would keep the property in your situation I think.

Saucy99 · 10/10/2021 21:31

If you think that stocks and shares will net you 12% per year you shouldn't be investing. 7% I a fantastic return and you also have the possibility of capital appreciation. Keep the house.

TheHateIsNotGood · 10/10/2021 21:19

Alpaca life changes, I sold and assigned the Lease to a local person for half the market price many years ago, since been on my arse but not now. Many years later I'm still happy with that decision.

Yes, making the most out of 'investments' is good for the investor, unless things 'change'. There is always a choice about how, where and what an 'invesor' places their money in.

An investor can choose to invest ethically and given the 'housing crisis' currently experienced by those on low incomes for renting and those on middle-incomes that can't even buy...just ask yourself about your part in this. Sell the property and invest in something else to make money.

PigletJohn · 10/10/2021 11:56

@PattiPritell

All the advice I've read about finances says spread your money so some in ISAs some in property, some in funds Then if something tanks due to a disaster eg covid when I think most shares fell in value you have other stuff safe eg property going up. Shares have recovered now.
Remember that the UK still has a lot of homeowners, and homes are expensive.

So it would not be unusual for a family to have (say)

£250,000 in the family house
£50,000 in pension funds
£1,000 in premium bonds
£500 in a the bank

You can see that some 80% of their "wealth" is invested in domestic property

so for a balanced portfolio, the last thing they need is to buy more.

Alpacinoshoohaa · 10/10/2021 11:09

Within the isa I mostly have vanguard stuff which is a little of everything and vanguards life strategy fund.

OP posts:
Alpacinoshoohaa · 10/10/2021 11:08

Yankee dad thanks

I have a small stocks and shares isa and a smaller sipp.

The rent was supposed to boost these but I can't seem to get ahead with it, ie expensive work needing to be done on the property, then if the tenant does stay next year that's another grand on a new lease.
More ££ on checking electrics and all that stuff. If the tenant stays I'm going to have to pay to get someone to run through the lease with her and what her responsibilities are.

I don't pay for management but I'm thinking of it but it's extra cost.

I'd prefer to consolidate it all.

OP posts:
YankeeDad · 10/10/2021 10:43

@PattiPritell

All the advice I've read about finances says spread your money so some in ISAs some in property, some in funds Then if something tanks due to a disaster eg covid when I think most shares fell in value you have other stuff safe eg property going up. Shares have recovered now.
Spreading your money ie "diversification" among different investment types makes sense, but one challenge is that real property is "lumpy": either you own one or you don't. You cannot easily sell half of a property, and I think the OP has to be either 100% property or 0% property.

Also in reading language about ISAs, funds, SIPPs, stocks and shares, etc. it is important to distinguish between containers and contents. Funds and ISAs are both more like types of containers than contents.

An ISA is a type of container that is designed to deliver certain tax benefits: after-tax money goes into it, but earnings within the container are tax free and money can generally be taken out when you need it. A SIPP is a different type of tax-related container: pre-tax money goes into it, but access is very restricted and the money including earnings gets taxed upon withdrawal.

A fund is yet a different type of container that is designed to hold a basket of assets, often stocks or bonds, so that an individual investor can invest more easily and with more diversification than if they bought individual stocks or bonds. A fund can be purchased within an ISA, or a SIPP.

Diversification is worth having in the sense of having different types of contents, so for example some stocks, but not everything in stocks. In normal times you'd also want some bonds, but currently bonds yield next to nothing so it might be better to have stocks and cash and skip the bonds.
Whether that is best done within ISA, SIPP, normal taxable account, or a mix of the three, depends on the person's tax circumstances. But "diversifying" among ISA / SIPP / taxable account does not really make sense, and more importantly, it is possible to have a poorly diversified portfolio while holding all three of those or while holding many different funds. What matters is what's contained inside the funds / ISA / SIPP / taxable account.

Going back to the original question, having investment property in a diversified portfolio, is a good idea in general, but in the OPs case, as
I read it, it's either 100% investment property or a mix of stocks and bonds, but not both, because the OP would have to sell 100% of the property in order to buy any liquid financial investments (which include stocks and bonds).

PattiPritell · 10/10/2021 10:04

All the advice I've read about finances says spread your money so some in ISAs some in property, some in funds Then if something tanks due to a disaster eg covid when I think most shares fell in value you have other stuff safe eg property going up. Shares have recovered now.

LostButtons · 10/10/2021 09:46

[quote Alpacinoshoohaa]@LostButtons

I've just found him on Spotify. It looks very interesting there are tons of episodes though.[/quote]
I actually meant his original book which I linked to rather than the podacasts, that would give you the basics to his approach. And I've found very useful in my own approach to finances.

Swipe left for the next trending thread